AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Rule 4.60 of the Punjab Motor Vehicles Rules, 1940.
  • section 95(1)(b) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Rule 4.60 of the Punjab Motor Vehicles Rules, 1940.
  • section 95(1)(b) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939,
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — D.V. Sehgal, J. (FAO Nos. 519 & 558 of 1982)

Factual and Procedural Background

Surinder Kumar (aged about 26/27), employed as a cook in the Punjab Police, was travelling on 21.4.1981 in Truck No. PNH-7191 driven by Sohan Singh (respondent No. 1) and owned by Shri Munshi Ram (respondent No. 2). The truck, insured with Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. (respondent No. 3), struck a Sheesham tree near village Samundra at about 10:45 P.M., and Surinder Kumar sustained serious injuries from which he died.

Two claim applications were filed before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Hoshiarpur: Claims Case No. 7 (8.5.1981) by the widow Smt. Usha Rani and two minor daughters (claiming Rs. 1,50,000/-), and Claim Case No. 8 (13.5.1981) by the parents Bansi Lal and Smt. Krishna (claiming Rs. 80,000/-). The respondents opposed the claims. The Tribunal consolidated the claims, framed five issues and adjudicated liability and quantum. The Tribunal held the driver negligent, made respondent No.1 (driver) liable, and declined to hold the owner and insurer liable; it awarded specified sums to the widow, children and parents with interest at 6% per annum. These appeals challenge parts of that award.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the death of Surinder Kumar occurred in the accident due to the rashness or negligence or both of Sohan Singh (respondent No.1)?
  2. If issue No.1 is proved, to what amount of compensation the claimants in both the claim applications are entitled and from which of the respondents?
  3. Whether at the time of the accident the truck was not being driven by an authorised person holding a valid licence and if so, what is its effect?
  4. Whether there has been any breach of the condition of the Insurance Policy and if so, what is its effect?
  5. Relief.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants (widow, children and parents) claimed compensation for the death of Surinder Kumar caused by the accident and contended that the award by the Tribunal was inadequate (specifically on quantum).
  • On quantum the appellants argued that Surinder Kumar's income and dependency should support a higher multiplier/award (details on income and dependency were adduced in evidence and relied upon in appeal).

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent No.1 (driver) pleaded that the deceased boarded the truck without his permission and that he was driving at a moderate speed; the accident occurred for reasons beyond his control.
  • Respondent No.2 (owner) raised similar defenses as to not being liable (as set out in the Tribunal's pleadings).
  • Respondent No.3 (insurer) denied rash/negligent driving, asserted the vehicle was a goods carrier and that the deceased was not authorised to be carried; therefore the insurance policy did not cover liability for the death. It also pleaded that the truck was being driven by a person not holding a valid driving licence, denying its liability under the policy.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jiwan Dass Roshan Lal v. Karnail Singh (1980 A.C.J. 445) Division Bench decision relied upon by the Tribunal regarding owner liability (used by the Tribunal to absolve owner). The Court noted the Tribunal based its decision on this authority but observed it has since been overruled by a Full Bench; therefore the Tribunal's reliance on it could not be sustained.
Pirthi Singh v. Shri Binda Ram (1986-2 90 PLR 162) — Full Bench Held that the determining factor for owner liability is whether the driver acted in the course of his employment; owner liable even if driver acted contrary to express instructions or statutory rules. The Court applied this Full Bench holding to reverse the Tribunal's finding and hold the owner (respondent No.2) vicariously liable because the driver was acting in the course of employment on the back journey.
Oriental Fire & Gen. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Gurdev Kaur (1967 A.C.J. 158) Interpreted proviso to section 95(1)(b) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, holding insurer not liable in case of death/injury to passengers in a goods carrier unless policy required cover. The Court relied on this Full Bench discussion to uphold the Tribunal's finding that the insurer (respondent No.3) was not liable for the death of a passenger being carried in a goods vehicle, applying the statutory proviso and the policy term.
Miss Ballu Gaur v. Mrs. R.P. Randhawa (1985-2 88 PLR 135) Authority cited in support of applying a multiplier in assessing dependency/compensation. The Court cited this decision as supporting the use of multiplier 20 in computing compensation for the deceased's dependants.
Rajinder Singh v. Urmil (1986-1 89 PLR 647) Authority cited in support of the multiplier and approach to computing dependency. The Court cited this decision as additional support for applying the chosen multiplier to calculate compensation.
Smt. Sushhila v. Delhi Union Territory through Chief Secretary Delhi (1987-1 91 PLR 50) Authority cited in support of the multiplier/compensation methodology. The Court cited this decision as further support for the multiplier and method used to compute the enhanced award.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reappraised the evidence and proceeded through the following analytical steps (as stated in the opinion):

  1. Findings on Negligence and Licence: The Court affirmed the Tribunal's finding that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of respondent No.1 (Sohan Singh) and noted that the licence of respondent No.1 was not questioned, thereby upholding the Tribunal's conclusions on issues Nos. 1 and 3.
  2. Owner's (Respondent No.2) Vicarious Liability: The Tribunal had absolved the owner based on a Division Bench decision (Jiwan Dass Roshan Lal). The Court observed that the Division Bench authority had been overruled by a Full Bench in Pirthi Singh v. Shri Binda Ram, which established that the key test for owner liability is whether the driver acted in the course of employment. The Court analysed the facts: the truck, after unloading goods, was being driven on the return (back) journey; such plying constituted the course of employment. The Court therefore reversed the Tribunal and held the owner liable.
  3. Insurer's (Respondent No.3) Liability: The Court examined the proviso to section 95(1)(b) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 and applied the Full Bench decision in Oriental Fire & Gen. Ins. Co. Ltd. v. Gurdev Kaur. That authority and the statutory proviso indicate that where a passenger is carried in a goods vehicle (not requiring policy cover for such passengers), the insurer is not liable for death or bodily injury to such passenger. The Court also noted the specific policy provision (Exhibit R.1) aligned with the statute. Accordingly, the Court affirmed the Tribunal's conclusion that the insurer is not liable.
  4. Quantum of Compensation: The Court addressed the appellants' contention that the Tribunal's award was inadequate. Evidence in the record established the deceased's monthly salary at Rs. 350/-, with testimony that personal expenses were approximately Rs. 50/-, leaving a monthly dependency of Rs. 300/-. The Court calculated annual dependency at Rs. 3,600 and applied a multiplier of 20 (supported by cited precedents). This produced a total compensation figure of Rs. 72,000. The Court concluded that Bansi Lal (the father) was not entitled to any share. The total was to be divided equally among the mother (Shrimati Krishna), the widow (Smt. Usha Rani), and the two daughters (Miss Sonia and Miss Seema).
  5. Modification of Tribunal Award: On that basis, the Court modified the Tribunal's award—allocating amounts to the appellants, increasing the rate of interest to 12% per annum from the date of the respective claim applications, ordering costs for the appellants (Rs. 500), and holding respondents Nos.1 and 2 jointly and severally liable for payment.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appeals were allowed in part. The Court reversed the Tribunal's exoneration of the owner and held the owner (respondent No.2) vicariously liable; the insurer (respondent No.3) was held not liable. The Court enhanced and reallocated the compensation awards and interest.

Direct consequences and remedial orders (as stated in the opinion):

  • The appeals were allowed and the Tribunal's award was modified.
  • The total compensation computed on the basis of annual dependency Rs. 3,600 and multiplier 20 equals Rs. 72,000. This sum was divided equally among Shrimati Krishna (mother), Smt. Usha Rani (widow), Miss Sonia and Miss Seema (daughters).
  • The Court specified the enhanced awards: appellants in F.A.O. No. 558 (widow and two daughters) receive Rs. 54,000 in aggregate (as set out by the Court), and Shrimati Krishna in F.A.O. No. 519 receives Rs. 18,000. Bansi Lal (father) is not awarded any compensation.
  • Interest on the amounts awarded is fixed at 12% per annum from the date of the respective claim applications.
  • Respondents Nos. 1 (driver) and 2 (owner) are held jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation and interest. Respondent No. 3 (insurer) is held not liable; appeals against the insurer are dismissed with no order as to costs.
  • Costs of these appeals to the successful appellants were fixed at Rs. 500.

Broader implications: The Court applied existing Full Bench authority (Pirthi Singh) concerning vicarious liability of owners and relied on established statutory interpretation (section 95(1)(b) proviso) and precedent (Oriental Fire v. Gurdev Kaur) on insurer non-liability for passengers in goods carriers. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new precedent; it applies and reconciles existing authorities to the facts of this case.

Disposition: Appeals allowed (as above).

    Bansi Lal And Another v. Sohan Singh And Others .

    D.V Sehgal, J.:— This judgment will dispose of F.A.O No. 519 and 558 of 1982 as both of them are directed against the award dated 10-5-1982 of the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Hoshiarpur (for short ‘the Tribunal’).

    2. Surinder Kumar, aged about 26/27 years was serving as a cook in the Punjab Police. On 21.4.1981 he was travelling in Truck No. PNH-7191 driven by Sohan Singh, respondent No. 1 and owned by Shri Munshi Ram, Contractor, respondent No. 2. It was insured with the Oriental Fire and General Insurance Company Ltd. respondent No. 3. The truck was going from Garhshankar to village Samundra. It met with an accident in the revenue limits of village Samundra at about 10.45 P.M It struck against a Sheesham tree on its right side. Surinder Kumar received serious” injuries in this accident and died as a result thereof. Smt. Usha Rani widow of the deceased and his two minor daughters, namely, Miss Sonia aged 4 years and Miss Sheem, aged 10 months, filed claim application before the Tribunal which was registered as Claims Case No. 7 of 8.5.1981 They claimed compensation to the tune of Rs. 1,50,000/- on account of the death of Surinder Kumar, stating that the accident took place due to rash and negligent driving of the vehicle by respondent No. 1. Another claim application No. 8 of 13.5.1981 was filed by Bansi Lal and Smt. Krishna, father and mother of Surinder Kumar before the Tribunal, claiming compensation of Rs. 80,000/-. Both the claim applications were opposed by the respondents. It was pleaded by respondent No. 1 that the deceased boarded the truck of his own accord and without his permission; that he was driving the truck at a very moderate speed with all care and caution and that the accident took place for reasons beyond his control. Respondent No. 2 also raised similar pleas in his defence. The Insurance Company, respondent No. 3, besides denying the fact that the accident was the result of rash and negligent driving of the vehicle by respondent No. 1, further stated that the vehicle was a goods carrier, Surinder Kumar, deceased, was not authorised to be carried in the truck. The policy of insurance of the truck did not cover the liability in respect of the death of Surinder Kumar. It was further pleaded that the truck was being driven by a person not holding a valid driving licence. Thus, respondent No. 3, denied its liability. The learned Tribunal consolidated both the claim applications and on the basis of the pleadings of the parties framed the following issues:—

    1. Whether the death of Surinder Kumar occurred in the accident due to the rashness or negligence or both of Sohan Singh respondent? OPA.

    2. If issue No. 1 is proved, to what amount of compensation the claimants in both the claim applications are entitled and from which of the respondent? OPA.

    3. Whether at the time of the accident the truck, involved in the accident, was not being driven by an authorised person holding a valid licence and if so, what is its effect? OPR No. 3.

    4. Whether there has been any breach of the condition of the Insurance Policy and if so, what is its effect? OPR No. 3.

    5. Relief.

    3. Issue No. 1 was decided in favour of the appellants. It was held that the accident took place due to the rashness and negligence of Sohan Singh, driver, respondent No. 1 which resulted in the death of Surinder Kumar. Issue No. 3 was decided against respondent No. 3. Issues No. 2 and 4 were decided together. It was held that the owner of the vehicle respondent No. 2 and the Insurance Company, respondent No. 3, were not liable for payment of any compensation. Respondent No. 1 was, however, held liable. The quantum of compensation payable to Smt. Usha Rani widow and two minor daughters of the deceaed, namely, Miss Sonia and Miss Seema, who are appellants in F.A.O No. 558 of 1982 was determined at Rs. 30,000/-, Rs. 10,000/- and Rs. 12,000/- respectively. Respondent No. 1 was also held liable for payment of compensation amounting to Rs. 7,000/- and Rs. 10,000/- respectively to Bansi Lal and Smt. Krishna, father and mother of the deceased who are appellants in F.A.O No. 519 of 1982. Interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum from the date of the filing of the application was also awarded.

    4. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties. The findings on issues Nos. 1 and 3 as returned by the learned Tribunal were not seriously assailed before me. Even otherwise on reappraisal of the evidence, I find that the accident had resulted because of rash and negligent driving of the truck by respondent No. 1 which caused the death of Surinder Kumar other fact that respondent No. 1 held a valid licence was not questioned by the learned counsel for respondent No. 3. Hence, the finding of the learned Tribunal on both these issues is affirmed.

    5. Learned counsel for the appellants assailed the decision of the learned Tribunal to the effect that respondent Nos. 2 and 3, that is, the owner and the insurer of the vehicle were not liable for payment of compensation. As regards the liabilty of the owner, respondent No. 2, I find that decision of the learned Tribunal cannot be sustained. It based its decision on a Division Bench judgment of this Court reported as Jiwan Dass Roshan Lal v. Karnail Singh . 1980 A.C.J 445., which had since been overruled by a Full Bench of this Court in Pirthi Singh v. Shri Binda Ram . 1986-2 90 PLR 162.. It has been held therein that the determining factor so far the liability of the owner is concerned is whether the act was committed by the driver in the course of his employment or not. If the driver was acting in the course of his employment then the owner would be liable even though he acted against the express instructions of the ower or in violation of the rules framed under the statute. The owner of the truck cannot be absolved of his vicarious liability simply because the driver, his employee, carried the deceased passanger in the truck in contravention of the provision of Rule 4.60 of the Punjab Motor Vehicles Rules, 1940. Besides, the view taken by the learned Tribunal that since the truck was returning from Garhshankar after unloading the goods, it was not being driven by respondent No. 1 in the course of his employment as a driver with respondent No. 2, is erroeous. The truck was deployed to transport the goods. After unloading the goods when it was being driven to village Samundra on back journey by the driver, the plying of the truck by him was definitely in the course of his employment with respondent No. 2. I, therefore, reverse the decision of the learned Tribunal on this aspect and hold that respondent No. 2 is liable for payment of compensation on account of the death of Surinder Kumar.

    6. As regards the liability of the Insurance Company, respondent No. 3, I am of the view that the decision of the learned Tribunal is unassailable. The proviso to section 95(1)(b) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, inter alia, provides that a policy shall not be required except where the vehicle is a vehicle in which passangers are carried for hire or reward or by reason of or in pursuance of a contract of employment, to cover liability in respect of the death or of bodily injury to person being carried in or upon or entering or alighting from the vehicle at the time of the occurrence of the event out of which a claim arises. A full Bench of this Court in Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Gurdev Kaur . 1967 A.C.J 158., has elaborately discussed this provision in the statute and held that in the case of death of or bodily injury to a passenger in a goods carrier, as in the present case, the insurance company is not liable. The learned counsel for respondent No. 3 also brought to my notice the specific provision contained in the policy of insurance, Exhibit R.1, which is in conformity with the above provisions of the statute. I have, therefore, no hesitation to upheld the decision of the learned Tribunal that respondent No. 3 is not liable for payment of compensation on the death of Surinder Kumar.

    7. Now coming to the quantum of compensation, the learned counsel for the appellans contended that what has been awarded to is grossly inadequate. The decased was employed as a cook in the Punjab Police drawing a salary of Rs. 350/- per month Smt. Usha, while in the witness box, has stated that he used to have his meals in Police Station Talwara and was handing over the entire salary to her for house-held expenses. I am of the view that his personal expenses in this situation would not be more than Rs. 50/- month. Thus, he would have been paying Rs. 300/- per month for maintaining his mother, widow and the two minor children. The deceased was 26/27 years of age. It has been so stated on oath by his father Bansi Lal and his widow Shrimati Usha Rani. These statements have not been questioned in cross-examination. His mother Shrimati Krishna was 45 years of age while the widow was 23 years of age. The minor children were four years and 10 months of age. He was a Government servant and would have continued in the employment for a period nearly 32 years had his life not been cut short by the accident, I, therefore, find it appropriate that multiplier of 20 should be applied. I find support for this view from Miss Ballu Gaur v. Mrs. R.P Randhawa . 1985-2 88 PLR 135., Rajinder Singh v. Urmil . 1986-1 89 PLR 647. and Smt. Sushhila v. Delhi Union Territory through Chief Secretary Delhi . 1987-1 91 PLR 50.. Dependency of mother, widow and the children of the deceased being Rs. 300/- per month, the amount of compensation per annum comes to Rs. 3600/-. On applying multiplier of 20 it works out to Rs. 72,000/-. In my view Bansi Lal, father of the deceased is not entitled to any amount out of compensation. However, the amount of compensation as determined above shall be shared equally by Shrimati Krishna, Smt. Usha, Miss Sonia and Miss Seema, mother, widow and the daughters respectively of the deceased Surinder Kumar.

    8. I, therefore, allow these appeals, modify the award of the learned Tribunal and enhance the amount of compensation payable to the appellants in F.A.O No. 558 of 1982 to Rs. 54,000/- and the amount payable to Shrimati Krishna, appellant No. 2, in F.A.O No. 519 of 1982 Rs. 18,000/-. Bansi Lal, appellant No. 1, shall, however, not get any amount of compensation. The appellants who have been held so entitled to payment of compensation shall also get interest on the amount of compensation at the rate of 12 per cent per annum from the date their respective claim applications. They shall also get costs of these appeals which are assessed at Rs. 500/- Respondents Nos. 1 and 2 are held jointly and severally liable for payment of the amount of compensation and interest thereon. Respondent No. 3, however, is held not liable to payment of any amount of compensation. So, the appeals against it are dismissed with no order as to costs.

    R.M.S
    Appeals allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bansi Lal And Another v. Sohan Singh And Others .
    (Jan 30, 1987)