Bal Mukund Sharma@Balmukund Chaudhry son of Rama Nand Sharma, R/O
Village-Gobindpur, P.S. Sogrampur, Distt-Monghyr, at present residing at village-
Koul, P.S. Amarpur, Distt-Bhagalpur.
.... .... Appellant/s
Versus
The State of Bihar
.... .... Respondent/s
with
Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 225 of 1990
===========================================================
1. Mahendra Rai son of Mahadeo Rai @ Sidheshwar Rai
2. Ashoke Rai son of Mahendra Rai
3. Kishore Rai son of Mahendra Rai all residents of village Kole, P.S. Amarpur,
Distt-Bhagalpur
.... .... Appellant/s
Versus
The State of Bihar
.... .... Respondent/s
with
Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 239 of 1990
===========================================================
1. Brahmdeo Chaudhary son of late Shri Pradip Chaudhary.
2. Kapildeo Chaudhary son of Late Ramdhari Chaudhary.
3. Babula Chaudhary son of Brahmdeo Chaudhary.
4. Anil Chaudhary son of Kapildeo Chaudhary.
5. Sunil Chaudhary son of Kapildeo Chaudhary.
6. Bhavesh Chaudhary son of Rash Bihari Chaudhary.
7. Mani Chaudhary son of late Chandradeo Chaudhary.
8. Pankaj Chaudhary son of Brahmdeo Chaudhary.
9. Sanjay Chaudhary son of Brahmdeo Chaudhary.
10. Manoj Chaudhary son of Suresh Chaudhary.
11. Sadanand Chaudhary son of Daroga Chaudhary, all residents of village, Kole,
P.S. Amarpur, Distt-Bhagalpur.
.... .... Appellant/s
Versus
State Of Bihar
.... .... Respondent/s
===========================================================
Appearance :
(In CR. APP (DB) No. 221 of 1990)
(In CR. APP (DB) No. 225 of 1990)
(In CR. APP (DB) No. 239 of 1990)
For the Appellant/s : Mr. Ram Suresh Roy, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Uma Kant Prasad, Adv.
===========================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MIHIR KUMAR JHA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR TRIVEDI
CAV JUDGMENT
(Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR TRIVEDI)
Date: 23-05-2013
Appellants Brahamdeo Chaudhry, Babulal Chaudhry, Anil
Chaudhry, Sunil Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry, Mani Chaudhry,
Pankaj Chaudhry, Sanjay Chaudhry, Manoj Chaudhry, Sadanand
Chaudhry, Bal Mukund Sharma@Balmukund Chaudhry, Mahendra
Rai, Ashok Rai, Kishore Rai along with Kapildeo Chaudhry (since
dead during pendency of instant appeal and on account thereof the
appeal to the extent of his interest has been found abated) have
assailed judgment of conviction dated 11.06.1990 and sentence dated
12.06.1990 by 7th Additional Sessions Judge, Bhagalpur whereby and
whereunder appellant Brahamdeo Chaudhry has been found guilty for
an offence punishable under Sections 302, 436/149, 148 IPC as well
as 27 of the Arms Act and accordingly has been directed to undergo
R.I. for life under Section 302 IPC, R.I. for five years for an offence
punishable under Sections 436/149 IPC, R.I. for two years for an
offence punishable under Section 148 of the IPC and R.I. for four
years under Section 27 of the Arms Act respectively. In likewise
manner appellant, Kapildeo Chaudhry (since dead) has been found
guilty for an offence punishable under Sections 302/149, 436/149, 148
IPC as well as 27 of the Arms Act and accordingly has been directed
to undergo R.I. for life under Sections 302/149 IPC, R.I. for five years
under Sections 436/149 IPC, R.I. for two years under Section 148 of
the IPC, R.I. for four years under Section 27 of the Arms Act.
Furthermore, both the above named appellants namely, Brahamdeo
Chaudhry and Kapildeo Chaudhry have also been found guilty for an
offence punishable under Sections 307/134 and were directed to
undergo R.I. for seven years. Remaining appellants namely, Babulal
Chaudhry, Anil Chaudhry, Sunil Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry, Mani
Chaudhry, Pankaj Chaudhry, Sanjay Chaudhry, Manoj Chaudhry,
Sadanand Chaudhry, Bal Mukund Sharma@Balmukund Chaudhry,
Mahendra Rai, Ashok Rai, Kishore Rai have been found guilty for an
offence punishable under Sections 302, 436/149, 148 IPC and further
they have been directed undergo R.I. for life under Sections 302/149
of the IPC, R.I. for five years under Section 436/149 and R.I. for two
years under Section 148 of the IPC. Furthermore, appellants Anil
Chaudhry, Bhavesh Chaudhry, Babulal Chaudhry and Mahendra Rai
have been found guilty for an offence punishable under Sections
323/34 of the IPC and have been directed to undergo R.I. for one year.
All the sentences have been directed to run concurrently.
2. The prosecution case in nut shell is that Meghu Pandit
(PW-2) had given his Fardbeyan on 18.01.1986 at his Darwaza at
about 11:15 a.m. alleging inter alia that on the same day at about 7:00
a.m. while he was carrying soil after digging from a Gairmajarua land
lying north to his house for the purpose of manufacturing earthen
pots, Brahamdeo Chaudhry armed with gun, Babulal Chaudhry armed
with sword, Sanjay Chaudhry armed with Lathi, Pankaj Chaudhry
armed with Lathi, Anil Chaudhry armed with Bhala, Sunil Chaudhry
armed with Lathi, Mani Chaudhry armed with Bhala, Mahendra
Chaudhry armed with Lathi, Ashok Rai armed with sword, Kishore
Rai armed with Lathi, Kapildeo Chaudhry with pistol, Bhavesh
Chaudhry with Bhala, son-in-law of Bal Mukund Sharma
@Balmukund Chaudhry armed with Bhala, Sadanand Chaudhry, servant
of Brhamdeo Chaudhry armed with Lathi, Manoj Chaudhry armed
with Bhala along with 10 to 15 others variously armed arrived over
there at 9:00 a.m and had tried to intercept PW-2 and thus he along
with his wife out of fear had run away towards their house but he was
still chased even up to his house where Brahamdeo Chaudhry had
repeatedly fired three rounds and had also threatened the villagers
challenging that whoever would come forward to rescue the informant
would also be done to death.
3. The informant PW-2 had further stated that he (PW 2)
along with his wife had hidden in their house and had also closed the
door whereafter the aforesaid members of the unlawful assembly had
put part of his house i.e. Baithka on fire and they also unsuccessfully
tried to enter into his house after breaking open the door but could not
succeed in their such efforts. It is claimed by the informant that
thereafter, they all had caught hold of his nephew, Ambika Pandit
who was working in his field and took him away dragging to another
field lying east where Brahamdeo Chaudhry had shot at Ambika
Pandit causing his instantaneous death at the spot. According to
informant he had seen the occurrence after coming out from his house
and when on hearing hue and cry the villagers had rushed, Brahamdeo
Chaudhry and Kapildeo Chaudhry had opened fire from their gun as
well as pistol on account of which Shanti Devi, Subhash Sao, Wakil
Yadav, Kokai Sao had also sustained injuries on their persons. It has
also been alleged by the informant that PW 2 Brahamdeo Chaudhry
with the help of other members of the aforesaid unlawful assembly
had dragged the dead body of Ambika Pandit to his Basa (out house)
and in order to make out a case they had also put their own Basa on
fire as also had scattered bundle of paddy hither and thither.
4. According to informant Govind Pandit, Baidnath Pandit,
Raghunath Pandit along with aforesaid injured persons as well as
others had witnessed the aforesaid occurrence. The motive for such
occurrence according to informant was taking of settlement of a pond
by him from Fishermen‟s Co-operative Society.
5. On the basis of the aforesaid Fardbeyan Amarpur P.S.
Case No. 10/1986 was registered under Section 147, 148, 149, 324,
323, 452, 436, 307, 302 IPC and 27 of the Arms Act whereupon the
police having conducted investigation had submitted its charge-sheet
leading to trial which ultimately concluded by convicting and
sentencing the accused persons which is the subject matter of this
appeal.
6. The defence case as is evident from mode of cross-
examination as well as statement of the accused recorded under
Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. is one of their innocence as well as
complete denial of the occurrence. A plea of alibi was also taken on
behalf of the appellant/accused, Bal Mukund Sharma @ Balmukund
Chaudhry and to support the same two DWs have been examined.
There has also been evasive plea of alibi on behalf of the
appellant/accused, Mahendra Rai, Ashok Rai and Kishore Rai.
7. While assailing the judgment of conviction and sentence
rendered by the trial court, Mr. Ram Suresh Roy, Senior Advocate
followed by Mr. Uma Kant Prasad, Advocate the learned counsels for
the appellants have made elaborate argument suggesting that the trial
court had adopted a wholly mechanical approach while scrutinizing
the evidence of PWs. Stressing furthermore on this very aspect it has
been also argued that when the evidence of PWs is brought under
judicious scrutiny, it gives a clear indication that none of the PWs
including the injured ones are eyewitnesses to occurrence or they had
actually sustained injury on their persons during course of
commission of the occurrence as alleged rather they had sustained
such injuries on their persons in a different manner and on that very
score their testimonies are fit to be altogether rejected.
8. It has been submitted that all the witnesses are also inter-
related, partisan as also interested and they also had a motive in
falsely implicating the appellants in the background of admitted fact
that for the murder of Pradeep Chaudhry, one of the brother of
deceased, Ambika Pandit along with his father were accused.
9. It has further been submitted that apart from having
inconsistency and contradiction persisting in the evidence of PWs on
the factum of genesis as well as manner of occurrence, the same also
happens to be wholly inconsistent with the medical evidence. To
elaborate this aspect, it has been argued that medical evidence in fact
completely rules out the manner of occurrence as suggested by the
ocular evidence. In the aforesaid background, it has further been
argued that though there has been no counter case but then right from
Fardbeyan there is an admission on the part of the prosecution itself
that Baithka of Brahamdeo was burnt and though for the same they
levelled allegation against the appellants the same cannot be believed
in the facts and circumstance of the case.
10. Not only this, it has further been submitted that there
happens to be also utter failure on the part of the I.O. to place his
positive objective findings regarding the actual place of occurrence
inasmuch as presence of blood stains at different places as found by
the I.O. is itself suggestive of the fact that occurrence had not been
committed in the manner as suggested by the prosecution. Last but not
the least, it has also been argued that all the appellants are resident of
different villages and from cross-examination of the PWs it is evident
that there happens to be some sort of difference and suspicion over
proper identification of appellants.
11. With regard to motive, it has further been submitted
that there is not an iota of evidence to suggest that appellants had ever
raised objection or claimed the pond which was claimed by the
informant to have been taken on settlement for a period of three years
from the Fishermen‟s Co-operative Society.
12. On these grounds, it has been submitted by both the
learned counsels for the appellants that the prosecution has failed to
substantiate its case beyond all reasonable doubt and on account
thereof the judgment of conviction and sentence rendered by the trial
court is unsustainable both on facts and in law.
13. Per contra, A.P.P has submitted that from the evidence
it has come to light that the accused persons had committed the
offence in hand due to vengeance arising out of the fact that father and
brother of the deceased, Ambika Pandit had been exonerated in a
murder trial which was conducted for causing death of Pradeep
Chaudhry, the father of the main assailant of this case namely,
Brahmadeo Choudhary. It has further been submitted that there
happens to be consistent evidence on record with regard to presence
of these appellants at the boundary of the land of prosecution party
and so there was also no question of mistaken identification of the
appellants. With regard to genesis of occurrence, it has been sought to
be clarified by the learned A.P.P that the appellants were actually
aiming to eliminate the informant who was engaged in digging the
earth and bringing the soil to his place for manufacturing of earthen
pot and has canvassed that the factum of occurrence as it took place
on account of hiding of the informant in his house with the bolted
doors and the appellants in retaliation picking up the deceased
working in his field has been established from the evidence led by
prosecution without any improvement or embellishment and the
witnesses including those who had received injuries on their persons
in the same occurrence in the hands of the appellants had given a true
account of the entire manner of assault.
14. Learned counsel for the State in this regard has further
submitted that the trial court had meticulously scrutinized the
evidence of each and every PW and had arrived at its finding holding
the appellants guilty which is fully supported with the materials
available on the record. She has also submitted that there is no
inconsistency amongst the evidence of the PWs nor there happens to
be any sort of variance in between ocular as well as medical evidence
and thus according to her, these appeals are fit to be dismissed.
15. Before scanning the evidence on record it has to be
noted that prosecution had examined altogether 16 witnesses out of
whom PW-1 is Gobind Pandit, PW-2 is Meghu Pandit, PW-3 is Shanti
Devi, PW-4 is Kokai Sah, PW-5 is Subhas Sah, PW-6 is Wakil
Yadav, PW-7 is Jugali Devi, PW-8 is Raghunath Pandit, PW-9 is
Baijnath Pandit, PW-10 is Dasrath Tatwa, PW-11 is Dr. Kashi Nath
Jha, PW-12 is Bishan Harijan, PW-13 is B.N.Z Haider, PW-14 is
Mohammad Safique, PW-15 is Amar Nath Singh and PW-16 is
Arvind Kumar Singh. Amongst them, PW-8, Raghunath Pandit and
PW-12, Bishan Harijan have been tendered while PW-13, B.N.Z
Haider and PW-15, Amar Nath Singh are formal in nature. PW-10,
Dashrath Tatwa is the village Chaukidar who has supported the first
part of occurrence as an eyewitness. PW-11, Dr. Kashi Nath Jha and
14, Mohammad Safique are the two doctors respectively while PW-3,
PW-4, PW-5 and PW-6 are injured eyewitnesses in addition to the
informant (PW-2) his wife, Jugali Devi PW-7 as also PW-9 Baijnath
Pandit, the father of the deceased who have deposed as eyewitnesses.
PW-16 Arivind Kumar Singh is the Investigating Officer.
16. The prosecution had also exhibited Ext-1, settlement
receipt, Ext-2 series, injury report, Ext-3 postmortem report, Ext-4,
Fardbeyan, Ext-5 series, endorsement made over Fardbeyan, Ext-6,
inquest report, Ext-7 series, carbon copy of injury report, Ext-8 series,
seizure list, Ext-9, statement of informant under Section 164 Cr.P.C as
well as had also exhibited material exhibit- (i)/iv, half burnt 5 pieces
of bamboo (ii) ash, (iii) blood stained earth.
17. The defence had also examined DW-1, Shailendra Kr.
Singh and DW-2 Chandra Shekhar Pd. Sinha but did not adduce any
documentary evidence.
18. Before we would analyze the aforesaid ocular evidence,
it is appropriate for us to examine medical evidence. Autopsy over
dead body of deceased, Ambika Pandit was conducted by the then
Deputy Superintendent of Banka, Amarpur namely, Dr. Shyam
Nandan Prasad Singh and through evidence of B.N.Z Haidar PW-13
the prosecution had brought on record the fact regarding death of
aforesaid Dr. Shyam Nandan Prasad Singh and by such evidence had
succeeded in bringing postmortem report as Ext-3 on the record. As
per postmortem report (Ext-3) the following ante mortem injuries
have been found over the dead body of deceased Ambika Pandit:-
1) Fire arm wound:- There was only wound of
entrance and not exit.
It had hit the left eye ball and the whole eye ball was
completely lacerated. On further dissection irregular
fracture of frontal bone near the eye-brow and it had pierced
the brain matter even up to the base of brain causing much
damage to the brain matter. Intracerebral liquid blood and
blood clots towards the vertebral column inspite of best
effort the shot could not be found out and recovered as the
same had taken circuitous course once it entered into the
body.
The deceased died due to haemorrhage and shock
from above mentioned injuries.
19. Thus it is beyond controversy that the cause of death of
deceased Ambika Pandit was fire arm injury as is sought to be
established in ocular evidence of the prosecution.
20. Dr. Kashi Nath Jha PW-11 had examined the injured
PW-3, Shanti Devi, PW-6, Wakil Yadav and had in his deposition had
stated about the following injuries on their person:-
1. On 18.01.1986 I was posted as Medical Officer,
Amarpur Block. On that day at 12.40 P.M. I examined
Srimati Shanti Devi W/O Suresh Pandit resident of village
Kashpur, P.S. Amarpur within district Bhagalpur, and I
found the following injury on the persons:
A lacerated wound 1/4" in diameter on the right
thigh. It was simple in nature. It was caused by pellet of
fire-arm. It was possible by gun-shot. The age of the injury
was within 6 hours of the examination.
2. This injury report of Srimati Shanti Devi is in my
pen and bears my signature.(This report is markes Exhibit
2).
3. On the same day at 12.30 P.M. I examined Sri
Wakil Yadav S/O Sri Tarni Yadav, resident of village
Kashpur. P.S. Amarpur within district Bhagalpur, and I
found the following injuries on his person:-
1) Two lacerated wounds 1"x 1/2"x1/4" upon the
back of the both right and left elbow joints. There was one
lacerated wound on each elbow joint.
2) Lacerated wound 1"x1/2"x1/4" upon the back.
Both the injuries were simple in nature and were
caused by fire-arm such as gun-shot or pistol shot. The age
of the injuries were within 6 hours of the examination. This
injury report is in my pen and bears my signature. (This
report is marked exhibit ½).
21. Dr. Md. Safique PW-14, had examined the injured
PW-5, Subhas Sah as well as PW-4 Kokai Sah, on being referred
from Primary Health Center, Amarpur and had stated about them in
his evidence in court in the following terms:-
1). On 18.01.1986 I was posted in Bhagalpur
Medical College Hospital, Bhagalpur, as Surgical
Registrar. On that day, Subhash Sao son of Kokai
Sah resident of village Kashpur, P.S. Amarpur, Distt-
Bhagalpur, was referred to me for examination and
treatment by doctor of Primary Health Centre,
Amarpur. On the same day at 3.05 PM. I examined
said Subhash Sao in Bhagalpur Medical College
Hospital. He was admitted in the unit of Dr.B.Jha and
thereafter his examination was done by me. He was
discharged from the hospital on 23.1.1986. I had
found the following injuries on the person of said
Subhash Sao:-
(1) One circular lacerated wound .5 centimeter
in diameter on right lateral aspect of chest over
anterior axillary line 5" above coastal margin with
charring of margin. This was the wound of entry.
(2) One circular and lacerated wound .05
centimeter in diameter on left lateral aspect of chest
over mid axillary line above coastal margin. This was
the wound of exit.
(3) Incised wound 2"x2"x skin deep on back of
left forearm middle part.
(4) One circular lacerated wound .05
centimeter in diameter on medial aspect of left arm
5" above elbow. This was the wound of reentry.
(5) One circular lacerated wound .05"
centimeter in diameter on right gluteal region. This
was wound of entry.
(6) Swelling 4"x3" on front of right thigh
middle part.
(7) Abrasion 1/2"x1/4" on back of middle
phalanx of right index finger.
(8) One lacerated wound 1/4"x1/4"x skin deep
on back of terminal phalanx of right middle finger.
(9) Loss of distal part of nail of right ring
finger with abrasion of nail bed 1/4"x1/4".
Above injury nos. 4 and 5 were x-rayed and
evidence of metallic substance were found in the
wounds. I gave my opinion in this regard after
looking into the x-ray plate. Injury nos. 1,2,4 and 5
were caused by fire-arm, such as, gun or pistol. Injury
no.3 was caused by sharp weapon. This injury was
possible by sword or bhala blow. Injury nos. 3 to 9
were caused by hard and blunt substance, such as,
lathi. Injury nos. 1 and 2 were grievous in nature.
Injury nos. 3 to 9 were simple in nature. The age of
all the injuries was within six hours of the medical
examination. This is the approximate age of the
injuries.
2) This injury report is in my handwriting and
bears my signature. It is the carbon copy. I had
prepared it with the corresponding original report in
the same process by placing a carbon. The carbon
copy of the injury report is marked exhibit 2/2.
3) On 18.01.1986 Kokai Sao s/o Biranchi Sao
resident of village Kashpur, P.S. Amarpur, Distt-
Bhagalpur, was referred by Amarpur Primary Health
Centre to Bhagalpur Medical College Hospital. He
was admitted in the unit of Dr.S.D. Mishra in
Bhagalpur Medical College Hospital and on the same
day I examined him at about 3.20 P.M. and I found
the following injuries on his person:-
1)Lacerated wound 1"x1/2"x skin deep on shin
of right tibia in the middle part.
2)Lacerated wound 1"x1/4"x1/4" on front of
right knee. This injury was X-rayed and report by
radiologist showed evidence of fracture of right
patella.
(3)Lacerated wound ½"x1/4"x skin deep on
front of right thigh lower third.
4)Lacerated wound ½"x1/4"x skin deep on
front of left leg middle third.
5) Lacerated wound 1"x1/2"x1/4" on back of
left forearm upper third .
6) Two bruises, each 2"x1" on back of right
shoulder.
7) Swelling 3"x3" on back of left shoulder.
All the injuries were caused by hard and blunt
substance. These injuries were possible by both blunt
portion of bhala, blunt portion of sword and butt of
gun. The age of the injuries was within six hours of
the examination. Injury no.2 was grievous in nature
and the remaining injuries were simple in nature.
This carbon copy of the injury report is in my
handwriting and bears my signature. I had prepared
it with the corresponding original report in the same
process by placing a carbon. The carbon copy of the
injury report is marked exhibit 2/3.
22. From the cross-examination of Dr. Kashi Nath Jha PW-
11, it is evident from para-5 that all the injuries found over the person
of Wakil Yadav(PW 6) had blackening mark at the edge of entrance.
From para-6 the Doctor had estimated distance in between the victim
as well as appellant in between 5 to 10 feet. With regard to injury of
Shanti Devi (PW 3) at para-9 the Doctor had opined that lacerated
wound found on her person was also possible by pointed arrow or
pointed weapon having diameter of 1/4".
23. With regard to injury of Subhas (PW 5) and Kokai (PW
4), it is evident from the evidence of Dr. Md. Shafique PW-14 that
both the injured must have been examined by the Doctor B.Jha, the
referring Doctor of Primary Health Center, Amarpur and in likewise
manner had divulged that Kokai (PW 4) was admitted under the unit
of Dr. S.D. Mishra who also must have examined Kokai Sah.
24. Thus from the medical evidence regarding injures on
PW-3, PW-4, PW-5 and PW-6 there is nothing to discredit the version
of the two doctors that all of them had sustained fire arm injures on
their person. It however has to be recorded here that the learned
counsel for the appellants have made elaborate submission to raise
doubt over the medical evidence regarding injuries on Shanti Devi
(PW-3), Subhas Sah (PW-5) and Kokai Sah (PW-4) and in this regard
it has been emphasized that no foreign particle was ever found in the
injuries of Shanti Devi (PW 3) and the Doctor according to his
opinion had described it as a gun-shot injury only on the factum of
measurement of the injury having 1/4" in diameter for its being held
to be caused by gun-shot injury is not at all permissible and
acceptable. It is on this premise that they have proceeded to submit
that the evidence of PW-3 with regard to her presence at the place of
occurrence has been doubted in the background of the fact that there
also happens to be no evidence on record to suggest that Shanti Devi
had sustained injury caused by sharp cutting weapon. In likewise
manner it has been submitted that neither Dr. B.Jha nor Dr. S.D.
Mishra had been examined nor the injury report issued by them
respectively have been brought on record which would amount to
suppression of material evidence and in turn would adversely affect
the prosecution version.
25. We however do not find any merit in such submissions.
From the evidence of Shanti Devi (PW-3), Subhas Sah (PW-5) and
Kokai Sah (PW-4) it is evident that they are consistent with regard to
assault on their persons. Mere absence of foreign particle in the body
of Shanti Devi (PW-3) can not ruin her entire testimony as eyewitness
to the occurrence specially when the defence had not controverted or
challenged her version with regard to sustaining of fire arm injury. In
likewise manner, the defence had also failed to challenged the finding
recorded by PW-14 with regard to injuries sustained by Subhas (PW-
5) as well as Kokai (PW-4). The defence had also failed to cross-
examine these two witnesses on this very point and in likewise
manner also failed to cross-examine the I.O., PW-16 to extract
anything from his end as with regard to issuance of injury reports by
Dr.B.Jha or Dr. S.D. Mishra. Thus such hypothetical submissions of
learned counsel for the appellants cannot be taken into consideration
unless and until the same is supported with factual aspect. Therefore,
on this score we do not see any infirmity in propriety/genuineness of
respective injury reports of injured eye witnesses namely, PW-3, PW-
4, PW-5 and PW-6.
26. Now stepping ahead towards the scrutiny of oral
evidence, the first of all the evidence of informant Meghu Pandit
(PW-2) along with his wife Jugali Devi (PW-7) needs be taken into
consideration by us. PW-7, Jugali Devi had not named Kishore Rai,
Ashok Rai, Bal Mukund Sharma @ Balmukund Chaudhry, Sadanand
Chaudhry, Manoj Chaudhry as members of the unlawful assembly but
then she had categorically stated that when the members of unlawful
assembly had rushed towards her husband for assaulting him, she
along with her husband had fled away from there while being chased
by the member of unlawful assembly up to their house but they could
save themselves from being assaulted as they had bolted the door
from inside. She had also stated that accused persons unsuccessfully
attempted to break the door but could not succeed, and thus they had
put her Baithka (out house) on fire and from there they had gone to
the field of Ambika Pandit. She has also stated, she along with her
husband later on came out from her house and had seen the whole
occurrence in which the deceased was done to death as well as Shanti
Devi, Subhas Sah, Wakil Yadav, Kokai Sah were shot at/assaulted.
Though she has been cross-examined at length on this score in para-
21, 23, 24 but her aforesaid disclosure in the examination in chief had
remained undisturbed and consequently proved her presence at the
place of occurrence. While recording this Court is not unmindful that
in paragraph 26 of her cross-examination she had disclosed that at the
time when Shanti Devi, Subhas Sah, and Kokai Sah and Vakil Yadav
had sustained injuries, they were at a distance of 4 to 5 hands away
from her but her disclosure of such distance has to be viewed from the
angle that she is a rustic village lady who had by and large remained
firm in supporting prosecution case.
27. PW-2, Meghu Pandit is the informant and had
reiterated his earlier version whatever he had divulged in his
Fardbeyan. He had also named all the accused persons being variously
armed with full specification. He had also stated that the armed
persons including the appellants had reached at the place where he
was engaged in digging earth and seeing them he with his wife PW-7,
Jugali Devi had run away to their house and were chased by the
members of unlawful assembly up to their house. He has also stated
that when he and his wife had taken shelter in their house by bolting
the door from inside the members of unlawful assembly having failed
to nab them had put his Baithka on fire and then had gone towards the
field of Ambika where he was irrigating the crop and from there he
was dragged by the accused persons to the field of Brahamdeo
Chaudhry where he was given fatal gun shot injury on his person. He
had also explained that the villagers were also attacked by appellant
Brahamdeo Chaudhry as well as appellant Kapildeo Chaudhry with
gun and pistol as well as had assaulted Kokai Sah with the butt
portion of gun, sword, Bhala and Lathi. He had also disclosed that the
accused persons took away the dead body of Ambika to their Basa
and then had also put their own basa on fire. PW-2 the informant had
further reiterated he had given his Fardbeyan before the police which
had come to his place.
28. He had further disclosed that prior to settlement of
pond in his favour by Fishermen‟s Co-operative Society, the accused
persons were in its possession and were enjoying its usufruct. During
cross-examination, he had however admitted under para-34 that there
was no dispute amongst the parties relating to the aforesaid pond. In
para-40 he had further explained that the villagers as a whole had
made complaint against appellant Brahamdeo Chaudhry and his
father Pradeep Chaudhary and his other henchmen as with regard to
the fact that they had illegally encroached upon Gairmajarua land as
well as pond and had got them amalgamated with their land. In para-
50, he with regard to manner of occurrence had stated that when the
accused persons from his house had proceeded towards eastern
direction he came out from his house and then had gone towards the
place of occurrence i.e. the field of the deceased. In para-62 and 63 of
his cross-examination, he had given a detailed account of the accused
persons taking away Ambika Pandit, the deceased from his field. In
para-68, he had said that he had seen appellant Brahamdeo Chaudhry
to have shot at Ambika Pandit the deceased and had specified that it
was appellant Brahamdeo who had fired from eastern side on Ambika
Pandit the deceased from a distance of 2 to 3 hands. He had further
given a detailed version of the subsequent conduct of the accused
persons in para-69 and 71 and in para-75, he had stated as to how the
police force came to his place through the Basa of Brahamdeo
Chaudhry .
29. From a bare reading of his evidence it would become
clear that tough he had been cross-examined at length by the defence
but could not be shaken in any manner to disbelieve him as an
eyewitness to the occurrence. In fact his conduct of running away
from the field to his house with his wife PW-7 with a view to save
their life and the accused persons‟ retaliation on account of their
failure to nab informant by grabbing the deceased in his field and
killing him after dragging him to their own field is full established by
him. Thus there is no reason for us to accept the submission of learned
counsel for the appellants that PW-2 informant is not a reliable
eyewitness.
30. PW-3, Shanti Devi an injured witness had said that
after hearing hulla she had gone towards north of her house, and had
also reached at the Darwaja of Ambika Pandit and since Darwaja of
Meghu Pandit (PW-2) was by the side of Ambika Pandit the deceased,
she could also see that 15 to 20 persons having assembled at the
Darwaja of Meghu Pandit had already put the Baithka of Meghu
Pandit on fire. According to her the members of unlawful assembly
were variously armed out of whom she had claimed identification of
only two persons, namely appllant Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapo
Chaudhry @ Kapildeo Chaudhry. She had also stated that the accused
persons had gone towards east from the Baithka of Meghu Pandit
(PW-2) informant to the field of Ambika Pandit the deceased where
they had caught hold of Ambika and had dragged him to the adjacent
field of Brahamdeo Chaudhry where they had thrown Ambika Pandit
on the ground and thereafter appellant Brahamdeo Chaudhry had fired
from his gun on the person of the deceased causing his instantaneous
death at the spot. She had further stated that on hearing the sound of
firing of gun the villagers had assembled there and appellant
Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapo Chaudhry had also fired on the
villagers in which she had also sustained gun-shot injury which was
fired by Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Wakil (PW-6) and Subhas (PW-5)
also became injured by such indiscriminate firing. She had claimed
that immediately after receiving gun-shot injury, she had fled away
from there and was subsequently taken for her treatment at Amarpur
State Dispensary. She had identified only appellant Brahamdeo
Chaudhry and Kapo Chaudhry (since dead) in the court.
31. During her cross-examination in para-10, she had
categorically stated that she had not seen that who had put the Baithka
of Meghu Pandit on fire. She had further narrated in para-13 that she
had seen the occurrence from the field of Ambika Pandit wherein
plants of Dhania, Maize and Radish had been sown. In para-13, she
had also said that firstly when she had seen Ambika Pandit, he was
irrigating his maize crop in his field and soon thereafter 4 to 5 persons
took him to the field of Brahamdeo Chaudhry. She has further
disclosed that she could not remember whether Ambika Pandit had
sustained gun-shot injury in standing position or while lying on
ground. In para-17, she had said that as soon as accused appellant
Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapo Chaudhry (since dead) began to fire
at villagers, they started running away and during this course she had
sustained fire arm injury on her person.
32. Thus from her evidence, it is evident that she had
confined herself as an eyewitness to the extent of causing murder of
Ambika Pandit as well as sustaining of injury on her own person as
well as on Wakil (PW-6) and Subhas (PW-5) because of the fact that
she had arrived at the place of occurrence after Baithaka of Meghu
Pandit was already put on fire. There is however nothing to impeach
her evidence as an eyewitness to the main part of the occurrence.
33. PW-4, Kokai Sah is another injured witness. He had
deposed that on the alleged date and time of occurrence while he was
doing agricultural work, he heard sound of firing from eastern side
over which he rushed to the place of occurrence and had seen the
villagers coming from north side who were saying that his son Subhas
Sah (PW-5) has been shot at. On this, he rushed near the house of
Ambika and from there he saw people dragging one dead body nearly
50 hands east to the house of Ambika Pandit. He thought it to be dead
body of his son and accordingly, he rushed towards the dead body and
begged the accused persons to leave the dead body. On this appellant
Brahamdeo Chaudhry had fired at him but fortunately, for him, the
same did not hit him but in the meantime appellant Anil Chaudhry
gave Bhala blow, appellant Babulal Chaudhry gave a blow by sword,
appellant Bhavesh Chaudhry gave a Bhala blow, appellant Mahendra
Rai gave Lathi blow on his person. Apart from these persons, he also
claimed identification of Kapildeo Chaudhry (since dead) armed with
pistol, appellant Ashok Rai armed with sword, appellant Bal Mukund
Sharma @ Balmukund Chaudhry armed with Bhala and appellant
Kishore Rai aremed with Lathi, appellant Sanjay Chaudhry armed
with Lathi, appellant Pankaj Chaudhry armed with Lathi, and
appellant Sadanand Chaudhry armed with Lathi. He however had not
named appellant Mani Chaudhry.
34. He had also disclosed that the dead body being dragged
by the accused persons was not that of his son Subhas (PW-5) but of
Ambika Pandit, the deceased. According to him all the accused
persons took away the dead body of Ambika Pandit, the deceased, to
the Basa of Brahamdeo Chaudhry and thereafter, Brahamdeo
Chaudhry had put his Basa on fire as also had scattered bundles of
paddy in between house of Ambika Pandit and Basa of Brahamdeo
Chaudhry. He further claimed that he had got his injuries treated.
During cross-examination at para-17, he had disclosed that he could
not remember whether he had sustained any gun-shot injury. In para-
18 he had said that sword blow on him was given from its blunt side.
In para-23, he had said that he could not remember whether he had
identified the accused persons who were dragging the dead body of
Ambika Pandit.
35. Thus from this evidence of PW-4 Kokai Sah, it is
evident that he is not a witness of the main occurrence relating to
causing injury on the deceased and in fact he had confined himself to
be the witness to the later part of the occurrence wherein he had
sustained injuries on his own person in the hands of accused. None the
less he has remained firm on his version to the later part of the
occurrence which is corroborated from the evidence of PW3 the other
injured eyewitness.
36. PW-5, Subhas Sah is son of Kokai Sah PW-4. He had
deposed that on the alleged date and time of occurrence while he was
at his house, he heard the sound of firing over which he came to the
Darwaja of Ambika Pandit. He saw Baithka of Meghu Pandit under
flame. Then thereafter, 22-25 persons had gone to the field of Ambika
Pandit where they apprehended Ambika Pandit and took him away
towards east direction. He had identified Brahamdeo Chaudhry armed
with gun, Kapo Chaudhry (since dead) armed with pistol, Babulal
Chaudhry, Sanjay Chaudhry, Pankaj Chaudhry, Manoj Chaudhry,
Sadanand Chaudhry, Anil Chaudhry, Sunil Chaudhry, Mahendra Rai,
Ashok Rai, Mani Chaudhry and Bhavesh Chaudhry. He had also said
that the accused persons had thrown Ambika Pandit in the field of
appellant Brahamdeo Chaudhry and then thereafter appellant
Brahamdeo Chaudhry had shot at Ambika Chaudhry causing his
instantaneous death at the spot. According to him when the villagers
had assembled there appellant Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapo
Chaudhry had fired on them in which he (PW-5) also had sustained
injury at his left ribcage (Panjra) and left hand while Wakil Yadav
(PW-6) and Shanti Devi (PW-3) had also sustained injury. He had
also stated that when he fell down after sustaining injury it was his
father who came to save him but he was also assaulted by appellant
Brahamdeo Chaudhry as well as other members of unlawful
assembly. Thereafter appellants namely, Babulal Chaudhry, Sanjay
Chaudhry, Mani Chaudhry and Mahendra Rai along with others had
dragged the dead body of Ambika Pandit to the Basa of Brahamdeo
Chaudhry and Brahamdeo Chaudhry had his Basa on fire as also had
scattered bundle of paddy in between house of Ambika Pandit and
Basa of Brahamdeo Chaudhry.
37. During his cross-examination in para-8 PW-5 had said
that at the time of sustaining of gun-shot injury, he was standing in the
Dhania field of Ambika Pandit and firing on him was made from
eastern side and after sustaining injury he had tried to escape but fell
down. In Para-14, he had said that for the first time when he saw
Ambika Pandit the deceased, he was engaged in irrigating maize crop
in his field. In para-16, he had said that the member of the unlawful
assembly dragged Ambika and threw him in the field of Brahamdeo
Chaudhry after covering a distance of 50 yards whereafter the
members of the mob having thrown Ambika Pandit on the ground had
withdrawn themselves and only thereafter firing was made on the
person of Ambika Pandit on which the villagers had made a protest. In
para-19, he had disclosed that the dead body of Ambika Pandit was
thereafter dragged from the field of Brahamdeo Chaudhry to his Basa.
38. From the evidence of PW 5 also it is clear that he too is
not any eyewitness to the entire occurrence but then he has proved
two important things namely the manner of assault on the deceased
and sustaining his injuries on his own person as well as on PW-3,
PW-4 and PW-6. It is true that he had not named Bal Mukund Sharma
@ Balmukund Chaudhry, Kishore Rai as well as had not mentioned
any kind of weapon possessed by member of mob save and except
Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapo Chaudhry but then his being an
injured eyewitness also lends support to the prosecution case.
39. PW-6, Wakil Yadav, is another injured witness who
had deposed that on the alleged date and time of occurrence, he was
engaged in agricultural works. He heard sound of firing coming from
eastern side over which he had gone to the field lying east to the
house of Ambika Pandit. At that very time, Brahamdeo Chaudhry and
Kapo Chaudhry were engaged in firing over the villagers by means of
gun as well as pistol respectively he (PW-6) had sustained injury at
the hands of both of them and apart from him Subhas Sah (PW-5)
and Shanti Devi (PW-3) who were standing by his side had also
sustained injuries on their persons. He also claimed identification of
Babulal Chaudhry, Sanjay Chaudhry, Pankaj Chaudhry, Manoj
Chaudhry, Sadanand Chaudhry, Mani Chaudhry, Bal Mukund Sharma
@ Balmukund Chaudhry, Anil Chaudhry, Sunil Chaudhry, Mahendra
Rai, Kishore Rai, Ashok Rai, apart from Brahamdeo Choudhary and
Kapo Chaudhry and had also stated that they were armed with deadly
weapon. PW-6 had also explained that after sustaining injury on his
person he had returned back to his house. During cross-examination at
para-14 he had categorically stated that he had sustained injury in his
hand and back while he was near about 50 yards away from the
accused persons. In para-20 he had given detailed account of the
manner in which he had received injuries on his own person.
40. On a close perusal of evidence of PW-6 this much
becomes clear that his version as an eyewitness is confined to
sustaining injuries on his own person because he did not speak with
regard to having seen the Baithka of Meghu Pandit put on fire as well
as any subsequent event. Thus his evidence for his own injuries may
be that of an eyewitness giving support only to the later part of
prosecution case specially when he had not named appellant Bhavesh
Chaudhry as well as had not specified the weapon in the hands each of
the accused whom he identified.
41. From the perusal of evidence of aforesaid four injured
witnesses, it is however crystal clear that they have not tried to give
any sort of embellishment in their evidence by way of claiming
themselves to be eyewitnesses to main occurrence rather they have
deposed to that extent only which they had witnessed or suffered at
the hands of the accused persons. As stated above, save and except the
inconsistency amongst the evidence of injured Shanti Devi with the
evidence of Doctor who too had found injury over her person in a
diameter of 1/4" and on account of absence of any foreign material
during cross-examination had accepted the suggestion of defence the
injury to be caused by sharp pointed weapon, the rest of her ocular
evidence with regard to other injured witnesses is found to be fully
corroborated from the medical evidence. In fact there is a minor
variation only in the case of PW-3 Shanti Devi but then that would not
in any manner weaken the prosecution case much less make it
doubtful. Reference in this connection may usefully be made to the
judgment of Apex Court in the case of Gajoo v. State of
Uttarakahand reported in (2012) 9 SCC 532 wherein it has been held
as follows:-
"We have also noticed that there is not
variation between the medical evidence and the
ocular evidence, and once they are conjointly read, it
does not falsify either the statement of the witnesses,
PW 2 and PW 3 or the post-mortem report, Ext. Ka-
10. In fact, both of them must be read as
complementary to each other. Even if for the sake of
argument we assume that there is some variation,
still, it would be so immaterial and inconsequential
that it would not give any benefit to the accused. It is
a settled principle by a series of decisions of this
Court that while appreciating the variation between
the medical evidence and ocular evidence, primacy is
given to the oral evidence of the witnesses. Reference
can be made to the judgments of this Court in
Kapildeo Mandal v. State of Bihar, State of U.P. v.
Krishna Gopal and Bhajan Singh v. State of
Haryana."
42. It has also been repeatedly held by the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court that the evidence of injured witnesses should not be discarded
in haphazard way or in a light manner because of the fact that
sustaining of injury at the place of occurrence in a manner suggested
by the injured witnesses is indicative of the fact that the witnesses
were present at the place of occurrence during course of commission
of occurrence. The nature of evidence as discussed above in its true
spirit, not only suggest the genuine conduct of the injured witnesses
rather they are truthful to such extent that they did not want to bring
any sort of contradiction or embellishment in their evidence to support
the part of prosecution case which they had not witnessed. This
conduct of the injured witnesses namely, PW-3, PW-4, PW-5 and
PW-6 would furnish an additional inspiring ground for its acceptance
by this Court.
43. The other important witness on material point is PW-9,
Baijnath Pandit who happens to be the father of deceased Ambika
Pandit. PW-9 had categorically stated that he was cousin of informant
Madhu Pandit and his house was towards south to the house of Meghu
Pandit and his land was east to his house some 8 to 10 hands away
from there. He had also stated that on the alleged date and time of
occurrence while he was along with his son Ambika Pandit was
irrigating his field Meghu Pandit was engaged in digging earth from
pond while his wife was carrying the same. All of a sudden, a mob
consisting of 20 to 25 persons variously armed with came and seeing
them Meghu Pandit and his wife ran away towards their house and got
themselves confined therein. He had claimed identification of
Brahamdeo Chaudhry who was armed with gun, Babulal Chaudhry
armed with sword, Sunil Chaudhry, Sanjay Chaudhry, Pankaj
Chaudhry armed with Lathi, Kapo Chaudhry armed with pistol, Anil
Chaudhry armed with Bhala, Mahendra Rai armed with Lathi,
Kishore Rai armed with Lathi, Ashok Rai armed with sword, Bhavesh
Chaudhry armed with bhala, Manoj Chaudhry armed with Lathi,
Sadanand Chaudhry armed with Lathi, Mani Chaudhry armed with
Lathi. Members of the unlawful assembly followed Meghu Pandit and
his wife and came at his house and further tried to break open his
door.
44. He had further stated that on being frustrated, they set
ablaze Baithka of Meghu and during said course Brahamdeo
Chaudhry fired. Then the members of the unlawful assembly came to
his field and caught hold his son Ambika Pandit and dragged him to
the field of Brahamdeo Chaudhry where they threw Ambika Pandit to
the ground and then Brahamdeo Chaudhry shot at him on account of
which he died instantaneously. The villagers who had assembled were
shot at by Brahamdeo Chaudhry and Kapo Choudhar as a result of
which SubhasSah, Shanti Devi and Kokai Sah sustained injury. Kokai
Sah under wrong impression rushed to the accused persons who was
also assaulted. Then thereafter, Brahamdeo Chaudhry, Babulal
Chaudhry, Sanjay Chaudhry, Mahendra Rai, Pankaj Chaudhry, Mani
Chaudhry along with others dragged the dead body of his son to the
Basa of Brahamdeo Chaudhry. Thereafter, Brahamdeo Chaudhry lit
fire in his own Basa. The accused persons scattered bundle of paddy
in between the Basa and his house. He had given his statement before
the police. He was cross-examined at length but it is found that the
appellants could not be able to impair his testimony more particularly
after taking into account para-20 of his cross-examination which reads
as follows:-
ष्जिस समय अम्बिका पंडित को गोली लगी थी
उस समय वह चित पड़े हुये थे । उनपर सात-आठ हाथ की दूरी पर
से बन्दुक की गोली चलाई गई थी । अभियुक्त ब्रहमदेव चैधरी उस
समय अम्बिका पंडित से पूरब में थे । अम्बिका पंडित पर एक ही
बन्दूक की गोली चलाई गई थी । वह गोली उसके बायाॅं भौं पर लगी
थी । मुझे याद नहीं है कि उस समय अम्बिका पंडित के शरीर पर
कोई वस्त्र था या नहीं । जिस खेत में अम्बिका पंडित को गोली मारी
गई थी उस समय उस खेत में गाॅंव का कोई आदमी नहीं था ।
(स्वतः) उस समय गाॅंव के लोग मेरे खेत में थे ।ष्
45. Thus PW-9 alike the informant PW-2 is another
eyewitness who has given full account of the entire occurrence and
there is nothing to discredit his evidence specially when he had
narrated the manner in which his young son was done to death in front
of his own eyes.
46. PW-10, Dasrath Tatwa is a Chaukidar who after seeing
the member of the unlawful assembly proceeding towards Mahashay
Pokhar had gone to police station and informed the police official on
the basis of which the police officials rushed to the place of
occurrence for maintaining law and order but till then the substantive
offence, wherein Ambika Pandit was done to death, was already
committed. He therefore is fully responsible for getting the police on
the spot and his evidence to that extent gives support to the arrival of
police soon after the occurrence ruling out the probability of false
implication of anyone.
47. PW-15, Amar Nath Singh is formal in nature in the
background of the fact that he had only exhibited Sanha No.308 dated
18.01.1986.
48. PW-16, Arvind Kumar Singh is the I.O. who had
conducted investigation after recording the FIR of informant, Meghu
Pandit (PW-2) after arriving at the P.O. on the basis of information
conveyed by Chaukidar (PW-10) leading to entry of Sanha no. 308
dated 18.01.1986. He had inspected the place of occurrence and from
his examination-in-chief it is evident that he had given detailed of all
the three places of occurrence separately and independently, that
means to say, the first place of occurrence was at Mahashay Pokhar,
the second place of occurrence was house as well as Baithka of
Meghu Pandit and the third one was the land belonging to the
deceased from-where he was dragged to the land of appellant,
Brahamdeo Chaudhry and from there to the Basa of appellant,
Brahamdeo Chaudhry where dead deceased was dragged. He had also
seized remnant of burnt Baithka from the second place of occurrence
as also seized blood stained earth and sent the dead body for
postmortem. He also took statement of the witnesses as well as got the
statement of witnesses recorded under Section 164 of the Cr.P.C. He
(PW-16) received injury report of the injured and then submitted the
charge-sheet. During cross-examination, it is evident that the defence
could not be able to discredit his testimony with regard to objective
finding relating to respective place of occurrence.
49. Learned counsel for the appellants had however
assailed testimony of this PW 16, I.O., on two counts. The first one
relating to non entry of Sanha No. 308 in verbatim in the case diary
during course of investigation as well as on account of non recording
of trampling mark, if any, present at the field belonging to the PW-9
as well as deceased. It was also argued that his objective finding is not
at all found to be authentic one because of the fact that he had not
mentioned whether the crops which were standing in the field of
Brahamdeo Chaudhry where, as alleged, deceased was done to death
but in absence of trampling mark, the said theory would be
completely falsified. Therefore, the submission is that in the
background of the deficiency in the objective finding as is evident
from para 45, 46, 48 and further absence of seizure of any wads (para-
15), makes the whole prosecution case doubtful to have been
committed in a manner as suggested by the prosecution.
50. It has further been submitted that there happens to be
no counter-case nor the defence had ever suggested to any of the PW
or trend of the cross-examination also did not divulge the plea of alibi,
and thus in that event, the story of the prosecution has got no basis at
all. In likewise it has also been pointed out that manner of occurrence
also becomes doubtful because prosecution had come out with a case
that the dead body of deceased was lifted and dragged from the field
belonging to Brahamdeo Chaudhry to the Basa of Brahamdeo
Chaudhry and then Brahamdeo Chaudhry himself put his Basa on fire
and further also scattered bundle of paddy in between house of PW-9
and Basa of Brahamdeo Chaudhry. This imaginary story, though,
according to learned counsel for the appellants is corroborated with
objective finding of the I.O. but would speak a lot with regard to the
so called genuineness of the prosecution version over commission of
the occurrence in a manner as suggested by the prosecution. It has
thus been submitted that in view of the aforesaid materials before the
Court an inference could be drawn to the extent of prosecution party
being itself an aggressor and during course thereof deceased was done
to death on its own fault of prosecution party. In this regard it has also
been sought to be highlighted that filing of counter case is not a
condition precedent rather an inference could be drawn from the
evidence of prosecution itself.
51. In the considered opinion of this Court these
hypothetical submissions at the appellate stage would amount to
making a third case which was never placed before the trial court. It is
well settled that the Courts are forbidden to make out a third case.
There is version and counter version or version with an explanation or
version with complete denial. So far present case is concerned, the
evidence suggest the mode of cross-examination that there happens to
be complete denial of occurrence. When there is mob frenzy, in what
manner the mob will react is unknown or beyond expectation of
others. Therefore, when there happens to be positive assertion by the
prosecution to that extent, it was incumbent upon the
appellants/accused to establish that the same was incorrect but in
doing so they have failed. Therefore, only one option is left and that is
with regard to the acceptance/rejection of the prosecution version.
52. As stated above, it is beyond controversy that majority
of the witnesses so examined are related to each other and in the
aforesaid background as to in what manner their evidence is to be
adjudged, reference can be made to a judgment of Apex Court in the
case of State of A.P. v. S Rayappa reported in (2006) 4 SCC 512
wherein it has been held as follows:-
"6 .... By now it is a well-established principle
of law that testimony of a witness otherwise inspiring
confidence cannot be discarded on the ground that he being
a relation of the deceased is an interested witness. A close
relative who is a very natural witness cannot be termed as
interested witness. The term interested postulates that the
person concerned must have some direct interest in seeing
the accused person being convicted somehow or the other
either because of animosity or for some other reasons."
53. It is true that there happens to be some sort of
discrepancy amongst the PWs with regard to involvement of
appellants inconsonance with weapons having in their hands although,
they are consistent with regard to manner of occurrence and on that
very score their testimonies are found truthful. The aforesaid theme
has also been considered by the Apex Court in the case of Kuriya v.
State of Rajasthan in a decision reported in (2012) 10 SCC 433
where in it has been held as follows:-
"The testimony of an eyewitness, if found
truthful, cannot be discarded merely because the
eyewitness was a relative of the deceased. Where the
witness is wholly unreliable, the court may discard
the statement of such witness, but where the witness
is wholly reliable or neither wholly reliable nor
wholly unreliable (if his statement is fully
corroborated and supported by other ocular and
documentary evidence), the court may base its
judgment on the statement of such witness. Of
course, in the latter category of witnesses, the court
has to be more cautious and see if the statement of
the witness is corroborated. Reference in this regard
can be made to Sunil Kumar, Brathi v. State of
Punjab and Alagupandi v. State T.N."
54. A plea has also been raised that the injuries sustained
by deceased Ambika Pandit was not at all possible in a manner as
suggested by the prosecution because of the fact that the scene posed
by the prosecution on this score is that just after throwing Ambika
Pandit on the ground, he was shot from a close range. In such
circumstances, the nature of injury and the direction of cartridge
should have been in vertical way but no such injury has been found
over the dead body of deceased. In likewise manner when there
happens to be firing from close range, the injury must contain
charring, tattooing and blackening which again is absent in the
postmortem report.
55. In the considered opinion of this Court the aforesaid
contention appears to be fallacious in the background of the fact that
none of the prosecution witnesses has been cross-examined on this
score save and except PW-9 who in para-20 had disclosed that firing
was made from a distance of 7-8 hands that means to say, near about
12 feet and this distance is sufficient to undo the contention raised on
behalf of the appellants. With regard to nature of injury, it also rules
out the grievance of appellants to be genuine one because of the fact
that injury was sustained by the injured on the left eye-brow having
no exit.
56. It is well settled that the discrepancy, if any, in
between ocular as well as medical evidence, the ocular evidence has
got primacy. In a decision of the Apex Court in the case of Kuriya v.
State of Rajasthan reported in (2012) 10 SCC 433 (supra), this issue
has been elaborately dealt with in para 19, 20, 21 which are quoted
herein below:-
"19. This Court has consistently taken the view that
except where it is totally irreconcilable with the medical
evidence, oral evidence has primacy. In Abdul Sayeed v. State
of M.P. ((2010) 10 SCC 259) this Court held as under: (SCC p.
274, paras 38-40)
"38. In state of U.P. v. Hari Chand ((2009) 13
SCC 542) this Court reiterated the aforementioned
position of law and stated that: (SCC p. 545, para 13)
„13. ... In any event unless the oral
evidence is totally irreconcilable with the medical
evidence, it has primacy.‟
39. ... Thus, the position of law in cases
where there is a contradiction between medical
evidence and ocular evidence can be crystallized to
the effect that though the ocular testimony of a
witness has greater evidentiary value vis-à-vis
medical evidence, when medical evidence makes the
ocular testimony improbable, that becomes a relevant
factor in the process of the evaluation of evidence.
However, where the medical evidence goes so far
that it completely rules out all possibility of the
ocular evidence being true, the ocular evidence may
disbelieved.
40. In the instant case as referred to
hereinabove, a very large number of assailants
attacked one person, thus the witnesses cannot be
able to state as how many injuries and in what
manner the same had been caused by the accused. In
such a fact situation, discrepancy in medical evidence
and ocular evidence is bound to occur. However, it
cannot tilt the balance in favour of the appellants."
20. A similar view was taken by this Court in Baso
Prasad v. State of Bihar ((2006) 13 SCC 45) wherein this
Court held as under:(SCC p.74 paras 27-28)
"27. In some cases, medical evidence may
corroborate the prosecution witnesses; in some it may
not. The court, however, cannot apply any universal
rule whether ocular evidence would be relied upon or
the medical evidence, as the same will depend upon
the facts and circumstances of each case. No hard-
and-fast rule can be laid down therefor.
28. It is axiomatic, however, that when some
discrepancies are found in the ocular evidence vis-à-
vis medical evidence, the defence should seek for an
explanation from the doctor. He should be confronted
with the charge that he has committed a mistake.
Instances are not unknown where the doctor has
rectified the mistake committed by him while writing
the post-mortem report."
21. In Krishnan v. State ((2003) 7 SCC 56) this Court
held as under: (SCC pp. 62-63, paras 18 & 20-21)
" 18. The evidence of Dr. Muthuswami (PW 7)
and Dr. Abbas Ali (PW 8) do not run in any way
contrary to the ocular evidence. In any event, the
ocular evidence being cogent, credible and
trustworthy, minor variance, if any, with the medical
evidence is not of any consequence.
* * *
20. Coming to the plea that the medical
evidence is at variance with ocular evidence, it has to
be noted that it would be erroneous to accord undue
primacy to the hypothetical answers of medical
witnesses to exclude the eyewitnesses‟ account which
had to be tested independently and not treated as the
„variable‟ keeping the medical evidence as the
„constant‟.
21. It is trite that where the eyewitnesses‟
account is found credible and trustworthy, medical
opinion pointing to alternative possibilities is not
accepted as conclusive. Witnesses, as Bentham said,
are the eyes and ears of justice. Hence the importance
and primacy of the quality of the trial process.
Eyewitnesses‟ account would require a careful
independent assessment and evaluation for its
credibility which should not be adversely prejudged
making any other evidence, including medical
evidence, as the sole touchstone for the test of such
credibility. The evidence must be tested for its
inherent consistency and the inherent probability of
the story; consistency with the account of other
witnesses held to be creditworthy; consistency with
the undisputed facts, the „credit‟ of the witnesses;
their performance in the witness box; their power of
observation, etc. Then, the probative value of such
evidence becomes eligible to be put into the scales
for a cumulative evaluation."
57. It has to be also noted here that two DWs have been
examined on behalf of one of the appellants, namely, Bal Mukund
Sharma @ Balmukund Chaudhry on the plea of the alibi. DW-1
Shailendra Kumar Singh had disclosed that appellant Bal Mukund
Sharma @ Balmukund Chaudhry was directed to bring records, forms
etc from the office of District Education Superintendent, Bhagalpur
on 17.01.1986 and accordingly, he was present in the office of the
latter on 18.01.1986. But from the evidence of DW-1 in his
examination-in-chief itself, it is evident that his plea of alibi appears
to be doubtful apart from lacking of basic ingredients that he was not
in a position to be present at the place of occurrence at the relevant
time. Similarly DW-2 is Chandra Shekhar Prasad Singh, a retired
Deputy Superintendent of Education who was practicing as a lawyer
on the date of his examination in Court and he too got exposed in
cross-examination that he had never inspected the school of the
appellant Bal Mukund Sharma. Moreover he had himself admitted
that the stationery and materials to the school were supplied from the
office of District Superintendent of Education and not from the office
of Deputy Superintendent and thus the very plea of alibi was belied.
58. Thus, after analyzing and scrutinizing the evidence
available on the record as discussed above, we do not see any
infirmity persisting in the impugned judgment of conviction and
sentence rendered by the trial court. Consequently, the same is upheld.
All the three appeals are, accordingly, dismissed.
59. Appellants are on bail. Hence, their bail bonds are
accordingly cancelled with a direction to them to surrender before the
trial court to serve their sentences awarded by the trial court, failing
which the trial court will proceed in accordance with law to procure
the attendance of the appellants to serve their sentences.
(Aditya Kumar Trivedi, J) (Mihir Kumar Jha, J)
Patna High Court
23.05. 2013
Md.Perwez Alam/AFR