AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Revision Petition concerning pre-emption under the Bengal Tenancy Act)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is a revision petition against an order of a lower appellate court which, in effect, affirmed a learned Munsif's allowance of pre-emption applications under Section 26P of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The dispute arises from a sequence of litigation and settlement between the plaintiff (the purchaser) and defendants:

  • In 1935 the plaintiff attached the disputed property before judgment in a suit; the suit concluded in a compromise decree on 29-5-1936.
  • The defendants failed to carry out the compromise; in 1937 the plaintiff sought execution of the decree, but proceedings were stayed after the defendants applied to the Debt Settlement Board and an order was made under Section 34 of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act.
  • On 10-6-1939 the parties settled before the Debt Settlement Board, agreeing that the defendants would convey certain properties to the plaintiff in discharge of the debt. An award embodying this agreement was made on 18 June and registered on 15-9-1939.
  • Because the defendants again failed to transfer the agreed properties, the plaintiff sued for specific performance; upon refusal by the defendants to execute transfer documents, the Court executed a deed of sale on their behalf on 23-9-1946 (registered on 26-3-1947).
  • Two co-sharers challenged the transfer by bringing pre-emption proceedings: before the Munsif one application was allowed and the other dismissed; on appeal the Subordinate Judge affirmed the allowance in one case and varied the other, partly allowing it.
  • The plaintiff/purchaser filed the present revision petition challenging the lower appellate court's orders.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Section 26P of the Bengal Tenancy Act applies where the conveyance was executed by the Court on behalf of a defendant (i.e., whether a court-executed transfer is to be treated as a transfer by the co-sharer).
  2. Whether a claimant seeking pre-emption was a co-sharer at the relevant date, given prior attachments and alleged void intermediary sales (specifically sales in 1941 and 1944) said to be affected by an earlier attachment.
  3. When the period of limitation for an application for pre-emption (by a co-sharer who had not been given notice) begins to run — from the date of execution of the deed of sale or from the date of registration of the deed.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Mr. Sitaram Banerjee) — Purchaser / Revision Petitioner

  • Section 26P would not apply because the conveyance was executed by the Court and not by a co-sharer; the Court had no title and merely acted as agent, so the statutory right of pre-emption should not attach.
  • One claimant asserting pre-emption was not a co-sharer at the date of the sale because his asserted title rested on sales in 1941 and 1944 that were void due to an attachment in existence on the property; consequently, that claimant could not claim pre-emption.
  • The pre-emption applications were time-barred. The deed was executed on 23-9-1946 and the pre-emption applications were filed on 11-11-1949 (more than three years later). He relied on the Special Bench decision in Asmatali Sharip v. Mujaharali Sardar (52 C.W.N 64) and Article 181 of the Limitation Act to argue that the limitation period for these applications ran from the date of the sale (execution), thus rendering the applications barred.

Respondent (Mr. Janah — opposite parties / co-sharers)

  • The relevant date for accrual of the right of pre-emption is the date of registration of the deed, not the date of execution. Under provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act a transfer is effective only by a registered instrument; therefore a co-sharer gains the right to pre-empt only when registration has occurred.
  • The practical operation of registration and the decisions of the Court support the proposition that limitation must run from registration because there is no effective transfer, and hence no right to pre-empt, until registration.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Asmatali Sharip v. Mujaharali Sardar (Special Bench), (52 C.W.N. 64) Held that the right of pre-emption under Section 26F accrues as soon as a transfer is made; a co-sharer tenant's remedy, when not served with notice, is by application under S.26F; Article 181 Limitation Act applies to such an application. The Court considered this Special Bench decision as part of the limitation debate but reconciled it with other authorities, construing the Special Bench to mean that limitation runs from the date when the sale is effective for pre-emption purposes (i.e., registration), not necessarily the bare date of execution.
Gobardhan Bar v. Gunadhar Bar, (44 C.W.N. 802) Held that the date of registration is the material date for accrual of pre-emption rights; there is no effective sale for pre-emption purposes until registration, even if the deed was executed earlier; the amending Act of 1938 was not retrospective but applied where registration occurred after the Act came into force. The Court relied on this Bench decision to support the proposition that no right to pre-empt accrues before registration and that limitation cannot run before the right accrues.
Debendra Nath Sen v. Ganendra Nath Bera, (53 C.W.N. 107) Held that the date of accrual of the right of pre-emption is the date when the deed of sale is registered and title effectively passes, not the date of execution of the deed. The Court cited this decision (Das, J.) to reinforce the conclusion that limitation for bringing a pre-emption application begins on registration when title effectively passes.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a modular fashion, addressing each contention on the basis of the facts and cited authorities:

  1. Applicability of Section 26P to a Court-executed conveyance:

    The Court found the contention without substance.

    The Court observed that although the conveyance instrument was executed by the Court because the defendants refused to carry out a decree for specific performance, the Court did so on behalf of the defendants and not as owner. In law and in fact the transfer amounted to a transfer by the defendant (a co-sharer), so Section 26P applied.

  2. Effect of the Debt Settlement Board award and attachment:

    The Court treated the registered award of 15-9-1939 as terminating the earlier attachment and extinguishing the old debt-based rights.

    The Court reasoned that the Debt Settlement Board award embodied an agreement which settled the debt that had been the subject-matter of earlier suit and proceedings; from the date of that award there was no debt existing between the parties that could sustain the earlier attachment. Consequently, any attachment that had subsisted earlier was discharged by the registered award, and therefore the alleged intervening sales (in 1941 and 1944) were not vitiated by any continuing attachment.

  3. Limitation: date from which time runs for pre-emption applications:

    This was the central analytical issue; the Court focused on when a co-sharer acquires a right to make the pre-emption application.

    The Court examined the competing positions (limitation running from execution of deed vs. from registration) and the practical consequences of treating execution as the triggering date. It concluded that limitation cannot start before a person has a right to sue: because a co-sharer has no right to claim pre-emption until there is an effective transfer, the limitation period cannot begin before registration. The Court relied on prior Bench decisions (Gobardhan Bar v. Gunadhar Bar and Debendra Nath Sen v. Ganendra Nath Bera) holding that there is no effective sale for pre-emption purposes until the deed is registered. The Court interpreted the Special Bench decision in Asmatali Sharip as compatible with that rule (i.e., the Special Bench’s reference to limitation from the "date of sale" must be read as the date on which the sale is effective for pre-emption — registration).

    Applying this reasoning to the facts, the Court held that the relevant date for limitation was the date of registration (March 1947), not the date of execution (23-9-1946); the pre-emption applications filed on 11-11-1949 were within three years of registration and therefore timely.

  4. On the respondent's attempt to challenge lower appellate findings:

    The Court addressed procedural propriety of a respondent challenging the lower appellate court's findings without giving notice.

    One respondent sought to contest the lower appellate court's findings (specifically whether an exchange in 1928 establishing co-shares had been proved). The Court held that a respondent may uphold a decision on grounds other than those relied upon below, but cannot challenge a decision merely because he has been made a respondent without giving notice to other parties. Accordingly, the Court refused to permit that respondent to challenge the lower appellate court’s specific finding and upheld the lower court’s determination that that respondent could claim co-sharer status only to the extent of lands actually purchased.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is dismissed. The lower appellate court's orders (allowing pre-emption in the respects stated) are upheld; the petition fails and is dismissed with costs to opposite party No. 1. The Rule is discharged.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The orders of the lower appellate court are sustained — pre-emption was allowed in favour of the co-sharers as determined below (one co-sharer only to the extent of land actually purchased, the other as allowed), and the revision petition by the purchaser was rejected.
  • Limitation law application: The Court reaffirmed and applied the principle that, for pre-emption applications by co-sharers who have not been served with notice, the right to claim pre-emption accrues and the limitation period begins to run only when the deed of sale is registered (i.e., when title effectively passes). On the facts of this case, the pre-emption applications were within the three-year limitation period measured from registration.
  • Procedural point: A respondent in revision cannot challenge findings of the lower appellate court without giving notice to the other parties; therefore the particular respondent's challenge was not entertained.
  • No broader novel precedent was announced beyond the Court’s application and reiteration of existing authorities on accrual of pre-emption rights and limitation (the Court relied on and reconciled prior Bench decisions).
Judge: V.S.B

Disposition: Revision petition dismissed; costs to opposite party No. 1; Rule discharged.

    Gopi Nath Das v. Namai Charan Das And Another Opposite Party.

    1. This is a petition for revision of an order of a lower appellate ct. allowing an appeal in fact from an order of a learned Munsif who allowed in fact the petitioners' applications for pre-emption under Section 26P of the Bengal Tenancy Act. The facts in the case are somewhat complicated. But the relevant facts can be stated as follows. In the year 1935 the property in dispute was attached before judgment by the pltf. in a suit. On 29-5-1936 the suit ended in a compromise decree. But as the defts. failed to carry out the compromise an application was made in 1937 for execution of the decree. Shortly after this application the deftsapplied to the Debt Settlement Board for a settlement of the debts owed by them to the pltf. among others. The usual order was made under Section 34 of the Bengal Agricultural Debtors Act, staying all proceedings in respect of debts pending in civil cts. The application for execution therefore of the compromise decree was stayed. On 10-6-1939, the parties arrived at a compromise of the matter pending before the Debt Settlement Board & it was agreed that the defts. should convey to the pltf. certain properties during the month of Assar, 1346, in discharge of all their indebtedness to the pltf. On June 18 an award was made by the Debt Settlement Board embodying these terms & on 15-9-1939, this award was registered.

    2. It is clear that the award brought to an end the proceedings before the Debt Settlement Board & the debt which was the subject-matter of the earlier suit & which was the subject-matter of the proceedings was settled on the terms of this award. It is quite clear, I think, that after this award there was no debt existing between the defts. & the pltf. & that there was nothing to execute. The ‘Pltf's rights thereafter were governed by the award of the Debt Settlement Board which embodied the agreement entered into between the parties.

    3. The defts. failed to transfer the properties as agreed upon before the Debt Settlement Board & eventually the pltf. had to bring a suit for specific performance of this agreement. That suit was ultimately decreed, but the defts. refused to execute any document of transfer. On 23-9-1946, the Ct. on behalf of the defts. executed a deed of sale or conveyance of the property in dispute in favour of the pltf. & this document was registered on 26-3-1947. There was a transfer by this deed of sale of certain property & two co-sharers brought proceedings to preempt this sale. One application was allowed by the learned Munsif & the other dismissed. The learned Subordinate Judge affirmed the decision allowing the application of one applicant & reversed the learned Munsif with regard to the decision on the other application & allowed it in part.

    4. The purchaser who was the pltf. in the original proceeding has now preferred this revision on his behalf Mr. Sitaram Banerjee has taken number of points. In the first place he contended that Section 26P of the Bengal Tenancy Act would not apply to this case at all because the conveyance here was conveyance by the Ct. & not by a co-sharer. It is true that in this case the conveyance or deed of sale was executed by the Ct. merely because the defts. had refused to carry out a decree for specific performance. The Ct. executed the transfer not as owners of the property as obviously the Ct. had no title at all. The Ct. merely executed this transfer as an agent as it were of the deft. & the transfer is in fact & in law a transfer by the deft, who was a co-sharer. That being so there is no substance in this contention.

    5. Mr. Banerjee tnen argued that one of the claimants for pre-emption was not a co-sharer at the date of the sale sought to be pre-empted, by reason of the fast that applicant based his claim to pre-empt on a sale in his favour which Mr. Banerjee contends was void. This applicant claimed to be a co-sharer by reason of sales in 1941 & 1944 & Mr. Banerjee contends that both these sales were void by reason of the fact that an attachment existed on the property at the date of these sales. As I have already stated the property in question was attached before judgment in 1935, but it seems to me that attachment came to an end certainly on 15-9-1939 when the award of the Debt Settlement Board was registered. That award put an end to the whole of the litigation & discharged any right which the pltf. had against the deft. & which had led to the attachment before judgment. There had been an attachment before judgment & a decree & an application to execute the decree. Then came the Debt Settlement Board proceedings which resulted in the execution application being stayed. Up to that stage the attachment subsisted. But eventually the parties settled their differences & the deft, agreed to transfer certain property to the pltf. in full discharge of his indebtedness. From that moment the pltf. had no claim against the deft, upon which an attachment before judgment could be based & this agreement incorporated in a registered award of the Board created entirely new rights between the parties. The old rights were extinguished & so was the attachment before judgment. That being so there was no attachment in existence either in 1941 or 1944 & the applicant's title to pre-empt could not be said to be affected by reason of this attachment.

    6. Lastly, Mr. Banerjee contended that the applications were barred by limitation. It is clear that the point of limitation was never taken before the learned Munsif or the lower appellate ct. But if it is clear on the face of the record that the applications were barred by limitation, I am bound by reason of Section 3 of the Limitation Act to give effect to limitation.

    7. The document was executed, as I have said, on 23-9-1946, & the applications for pre-emption were made on 11-11-1949 more than three years from the date of sale. Of course there was no notice given to the co-sharers of this sale & Mr. Banerjee contends that any claim to pre-empt this sale was barred by limitation after, the expiry of three years from the date of sale. He relies upon a Special Bench decision of this Ct. in ‘Asmatali Sharip v. Mujaharali Sardar’, (52 C.W.N 64), In which it was held that the right of pre-emption given to a co-sharer tenant by Section 26F of the Bengal Tenancy Act is not dependent on a notice being served on him under S. 26C. The right is given to all co-sharer tenants irrespective of whether they are served with a notice or not & the right accrues as soon as a transfer is made. The procedure for a co-sharer tenant who has not been served with a notice to avail himself of the right is by way of an application as contemplated under Section 26F. Article 181 of the Limitation Act, applies to the case of an application under S. 26P by a co-sharer tenant who has not been served with a notice under S. 26C & his application would be in time if made within three years of the sale.

    8. Mr. Banerjee's contention is that the application was made more than three years from the date of sale, & if the date of sale be 23-9-1946, that is, the date upon which the document was executed by the Ct., the application was beyond three years.

    9. Mr. Janah on behalf of the opposite party has however contended that in cases of pre-emption the relevant date is not the date of the conveyance or transfer of the property but the date of registration. The property sought to be pre-empted can only be transferred by a registered instrument by reason of the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act. A mere execution of a deed of transfer would not give a co-sharer a right to pre-empt. His right to pre-empt would only arise when there had been an effective transfer, that is when the deed of sale had been registered. Normally registration dates back & makes the sale effective from the date of the execution of the document. Mr. Banerjee therefore argues that though these sales have to be registered, once they are registered the date of sale for the purposes of limitation must be the date of the execution of the document.

    10. If Mr. Banerjee were right a somewhat unfortunate result would follow. Pour months are given for execution of documents such as deeds of sale. If a deed of sale was executed but not registered for four months no proceedings could be brought for pre-emption within those four months, because there would be no effective transfer giving rise to a right to pre-empt. However, if the moment the document was registered the sale became an effective sale from the date of execution of the document, then time would begin to run from the execution of the document though for four months of that period the co-sharer seeking to pre-empt would have no right whatsoever to pre-empt. That being so, the period of three years laid down by the Full Bench might well be cut down to two years & eight months by reason of days in registering documents.

    11. It appears to me that this Ct. has laid down that the starting point for limitation in the case of pre-emption is not the date upon which the document is executed, but rather the date upon which it is registered. In short this Ct. has held that there is no effective sale for the purposes of pre-emption until registration.

    12. The matter was considered by a Bench of this Ct. in the case of ‘Gobardhan Bar’ v. ‘Gunadhar Bar’, (44 C.W.N 802). In that case property had been sold before the Act of 1938 amending the Bengal Tenancy Act came into force. The deed of sale was not registered however until the Amending Act came into force & the question arose whether the old Act as amended in 1938 applied to the transaction. The Bench held that the Amending Act of 1938 was not retrospective & therefore could not be construed as applying to any transactions which took place before the Act was passed & further the Amending Act could not be held to take away any rights which had accrued to parties before it was passed. The Bench nevertheless held that the Amending Act of 1938 applied to the case because though the sale deed was executed before the Amending Act was passed, it was not registered until after the passing of the Act & that there was no effective sale for the purposes of pre-emption until after the Act was passed. That being so it could not be said that the pre-emptor had any rights before the Amending Act was passed & there was no question of taking away accrued rights. At p. 804 Mukherjee, J. who delivered the judgment of the Bench observed:

    “I am inclined to hold that the date of registration is the material date & both under the old Act as well as under the new, no right could possibly accrue in favour of the landlord or the co-sharer tenants as the case may be, until the document of transfer was registered.

    13. A transfer of occupancy holding can be made only by a registered document & no title would pass to the transferee unless registration is effected. ……Not only there was no valid or complete transfer till the document was registered, but so-long as it was not registered, the landlord's right to apply for pre-emption did not arise. If, therefore, the document was not presented for registration till after the expiry of the old Act, there was no accrued right in favour of the landlord which could be said to have been saved by the repealing enactment. Then again, as in the present case, if the document is registered after the new Act came into force, the provision of the new S. 26C would certainly be attracted to it.”

    14. It seems to me clear that in this case the Bench held that a co-sharer or a landlord had no right to preempt until the deed of sale had been registered. Limitation is a period during which a person who can sue must sue or be barred for his delay. Limitation cannot begin to run before a person has a right to sue or to take proceedings. Therefore it is clear that in cases where no notice of a transfer is given there can be no right to claim pre-emption until registration. If it be held that the period of limitation begins to run from the date of the execution of the deed of sale, then it is tantamount to holding that the period of limitation begins to run before a co-sharer has a right to pre-empt.

    15. A similar view was taken by Das, J. in the case of ‘Debendra Nath Sen’ v. ‘Ganendra Nath Bera’, ‘53 C.W.N 107. The learned Judge held that the date of accrual of the right of pre-emption is not the date of execution of the deed of sale or any earlier date but the date when the deed of sale is registered & title effectively passes.

    16. It is to be observed that both Mukherjee & Das, JJ. were members of the Special Bench & I think I can safely presume that they never intended the decision of the Special Bench to be in conflict with their other decisions. If the decision of the Special Bench be taken literally it might be argued that it was held that limitation would be three years from the date of sale, that is, the actual date of the execution of the deed of sale which was afterwards registered. However, having regard to the other cases, I think it is clear that what the Special Bench meant by limitation running from the sale was that the period of limitation would begin to run when the sale for the purposes of pre-emption was effecting & as I have said both Mukherjee & Das, JJ. have taken the view that for the purposes of pre-emption there is an effective sale until registration. Until registration a co-sharer would not have a right to present an appln. for pre-emption & it appears to me that I am bound to hold that the period of limitation for such an appln. could not begin to run until the right to maw the appln. accrued. That right in this case accrued not when the Ct. executed the deed of sale on behalf of the deft. but when the deed was registered in March of 1947. The appln. was brought well within three years of the date of registration & therefore the appln. was within time & the lower appellate Ct. was entitled to make the order which it did.

    17. The lower appellate Ct. allowed pre-emption by two co-sharers. One co-sharer claimed that he was a co-sharer in respect of lands obtained by an exchange in 1928 & in respect of land purchased by him later but before the transaction sought to be pre-empted. The lower appellate Ct. was not satisfied that the exchange had been established & only allowed pre-emption in respect of the land purchased. This particular appct. who is a resp. in these proceedings has not challenged the order of the lower appellate Ct. by way of revision, but he seeks to challenge it as a resp. A resp. may uphold the decision of the lower Ct. on ground other than the grounds upon which the lower Ct. decided the case. But a resp. without giving notice to the other parties cannot claim to challenge a decision merely because he has been made a resp. in the proceeding. I do not think it is open to this resp. to challenge the findings of the lower appellate Ct. & therefore the finding of that Ct. that this resp-could only claim to be a co-sharer to the extent of the lands purchased must be upheld. For these reasons I can see no ground for interfering with the decision of the lower appellate Ct. & accordingly the petn. fails & is dismissed with costs to opposite party No. 1. The Rule is discharged.

    V.S.B

    18. Rule discharged.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gopi Nath Das v. Namai Charan Das And Another Opposite Party.
    (Apr 27, 1951)