Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (2) of S. 213 holding that sub-section (1) to S. 213
  • S. 278 of the Indian Succession Act,
  • sub-section (1) to S. 213
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (2) of S. 213 holding that sub-section (1) to S. 213
  • S. 278 of the Indian Succession Act,
  • sub-section (1) to S. 213
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The fifth and sixth defendants in the suit are the revision petitioners. The first respondent originally filed a petition under S. 278 of the Indian Succession Act seeking Letters of Administration of the Will. Due to contestation under S. 295 of the Act, the original petition was converted into a regular suit. The petitioners raised a preliminary objection based on an amendment to sub-section (2) of S. 213, which holds that sub-section (1) to S. 213 shall not apply to Christians, arguing that the proceedings were unnecessary and that a regular suit should be filed instead. They contended that by invoking the summary procedure, they were deprived of their right to contest the matter regularly. The first respondent argued that there is no bar under S. 213 to probate the Will and that in case of contest, the original petition is converted into a regular suit, thus no prejudice is caused to the petitioners.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the amendment to sub-section (2) of S. 213 of the Indian Succession Act bars Christians and Mohammedans from getting a Will probated.
  2. Whether the procedure for probate under S. 278 and contentious cases under S. 295 amounts to a summary procedure that deprives petitioners of their right to a regular suit.
  3. The applicability and scope of S. 213 in relation to probate and rights of legatees under the Will.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The amendment to sub-section (2) of S. 213 excludes Christians from the requirement of probate under sub-section (1), making probate proceedings unnecessary for them.
  • Invoking summary procedure under S. 278 deprives them of their right to contest the matter through a regular suit.
  • Reliance on the decision in Hajira Khatoon v. Mustafa Husain, which held that a regular suit is the proper course in such matters.

First Respondent's Arguments

  • There is no bar under S. 213 to get the Will probated, even for Christians or Mohammedans.
  • In case of contest, the original petition is converted into a regular suit as per S. 295, ensuring no prejudice to the petitioners.
  • The probate procedure is not a summary procedure when contested and must be tried as a regular suit under the Civil Procedure Code.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hajira Khatoon v. Mustafa Husain, (28) AIR 1941 Oudh 474 Proper course in contested succession matters is a regular suit, not summary probate or letters of administration. The court found this precedent not directly applicable as it did not consider the scope of S. 213 and involved intricate personal law questions distinct from the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court acknowledged that there is no bar for Mohammedans or Christians to get a Will probated if they choose. The bar under sub-section (1) of S. 213 is that rights as executor or legatee cannot be established without probate, but this restriction is lifted for Christians by sub-section (2). However, this does not prohibit Christians or Mohammedans from opting to probate the Will if they desire.

The court held that the procedure under S. 295 requiring a regular suit in contentious cases means that probate proceedings are not summary when contested. Therefore, the petitioners' grievance that the respondents can bypass contest by summary probate is unfounded.

The court referred to authoritative commentary from “Law of Wills” by Mantha Ramamoorthi, which supports that probate cannot be declined merely because S. 213(2) exempts Christians from mandatory probate.

The court distinguished the cited precedent Hajira Khatoon on the basis that it dealt with complex personal law issues and did not consider the amended scope of S. 213.

On these grounds, the court found no reason to interfere with the order under revision.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is dismissed.

The decision affirms that Christians and Mohammedans may probate a Will if they choose, and that probate proceedings under the Indian Succession Act are not summary when contested but proceed as regular suits under the Civil Procedure Code. The ruling directly affects the parties by upholding the existing order and does not establish any new precedent beyond clarifying the interpretation of S. 213 and procedural aspects under S. 295.

    Thressiamma & Anr. v. Joseph & Ors.

    1. Fifth and sixth defendants in the suit are the revision petitioners herein. Originally the 1st respondent herein filed a petition under S. 278 of the Indian Succession Act, to grant Letters of Administration of the Will. As the matter was contested as per S. 295 of the Act, the original petition was converted into a regular suit. Thereafter, a preliminary question was raised by the petitioner contending that in the light of the amendment to sub-section (2) of S. 213 holding that sub-section (1) to S. 213 shall not apply to Christians, the proceedings are unnecessary and the proper course is to file a regular suit. By invoking the summary procedure, the petitioners are deprived of their regular contest in the matter. In that context, learned counsel for the petitioner referred to the decision in Hajira Khatoon v. Mustafa Husain, (28) AIR 1941 Oudh 474). Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the 1st respondent submitted that there is no bar under S. 213 of the Act to get the Will probated and in case of contest, the O.P is converted into a regular suit and, therefore, there is no prejudice for the petitioner.

    2. I have heard the counsel.

    3. There cannot be any dispute that there is no bar for a Mohammedan or Christian to get the will probated if they choose. The bar under sub-section (1) to S. 213 is to the effect that unless a Will is probated, no rights as an executor or legatee can be established.

    4. In other words, without probating a Will, the legatee is not entitled to claim the benefits under the Will. This restriction is now lifted to Christians. There is no need for a legatee to get the Will probated. However, this provision does not bar a legatee to get a will probated if he desires. By reading sub-section (2), no inference can be drawn to the effect that there is a bar for Mohammedans or Christians from getting a will probated.

    5. Section 295 of the Act provides that in case of contentious cases, the procedure is to make a regular suit, according to the provisions of the C.P.C Therefore, the stand of the learned counsel for the petitioners that this is a summary procedure cannot be accepted. It will be summary only if it is not a contentious suit, otherwise it will be tried as a regular suit. Therefore, the petitioners' grievance that the respondents can walk away by probating the Will in a summary procedure, cannot be correct. The learned District Judge referred to a passage in “Law of Wills” by Mantha Ramamoorthi, IV Edn., page 773 wherein it is observed that “the court will not be justified in declining to grant a probate on the ground that it does not require probate in accordance with S. 213(2) read with 8.54(c) of the Act.”

    6. The decision cited in Hajira Khatoon's case would not be of any help to the present case. There, the Division Bench was concerned with intricate questions of personal law involving question of title to estate. In that context, the Division Bench held that the proper course is regular suit and not application for letters of administration. In any event, the Division Bench did not consider the scope of S. 213.

    7. For all these reasons, I do not find any reason to interfere with the order. The revision is accordingly dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Thressiamma & Anr. v. Joseph & Ors.
    (Feb 6, 1998)