Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Section 7B of the Indian Telegraph Act.
  • Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules 1951.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Section 7B of the Indian Telegraph Act.
  • Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules 1951.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment disposes jointly of Writ Appeal No. 851/96 (preferred by the Telephone Authorities) and related Original Petitions filed by Shri S.J. Pandit (O.P. No. 8761/96 and O.P. No. 14587/95). The petitioner, Shri S.J. Pandit, was a subscriber of two telephones at the Kayamkulam Telephone Exchange: Nos. 445431 and 445463.

Subscription/rental arrears in respect of telephone No. 445431 were claimed by the Department to be Rs. 1,11,672 as on 16-6-1996. The petitioner disputed part of the bill for the period 26-9-1994 to 25-11-1994; that dispute was referred to arbitration in O.P. No. 17852/94 under Section 7B of the Indian Telegraph Act. The arbitrator issued an award dated 14-7-1995 upholding a claim of Rs. 27,214 for that period; that award was challenged in O.P. No. 14587/95.

Separately, in relation to telephone No. 445463, the Department billed Rs. 1,861 for the period 26-2-1996 to 11-4-1996. Because of non-payment of that bill and because of the arrears relating to telephone No. 445431, the Telephone Authorities disconnected telephone No. 445463. The petitioner challenged the disconnection in O.P. No. 8751/96; the learned single Judge directed reconnection of No. 445463 upon payment of the amount due for that telephone (Rs. 1,861). Aggrieved, the Telephone Authorities preferred Writ Appeal No. 851/96.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an award passed by an arbitrator under Section 7B of the Indian Telegraph Act is final and immune from challenge in ordinary proceedings, and what remedy (if any) is available to an aggrieved party.
  2. Whether, under Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951, the Telegraph/Telephone Authorities may disconnect one or more other telephones or telex services rented by the same subscriber on account of default in payment in respect of a particular telephone.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner disputed the correctness of the bill for the period 26-9-1994 to 25-11-1994 and challenged the arbitrator's award in O.P. No. 14587/95.
  • The petitioner contended that the Telephone Authorities could not disconnect another telephone (No. 445463) on account of arrears relating to telephone No. 445431, relying on the decision of a Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court in Santokh Singh v. Divisional Engineer, Telephones, Shillong (AIR 1990 Gauhati 47), which held that Rule 443 did not authorise disconnection of telephones other than the one in default.
  • The petitioner sought reconnection of telephone No. 445463 on payment of the amounts billed in relation to that telephone alone (Rs. 1,861), as directed by the single Judge.

Respondents' (Telephone Authorities') Arguments

  • The Department maintained the correctness of the arrears claimed in relation to telephone No. 445431 (Rs. 1,11,672 as of 16-6-1996) and relied upon the procedural and statutory schemes (including Rule 443) that permit disconnection for non-payment.
  • The Telephone Authorities challenged the single Judge's direction to reconnect telephone No. 445463 on payment of only the dues for that telephone, contending that they were entitled to disconnect other telephones of the subscriber in the event of arrears on any telephone account.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M.L. Jaggi v. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd., (1996) 3 SCC 119; AIR 1996 SC 2476 The principle that an award passed under Section 7B of the Indian Telegraph Act is conclusive and final and not open to ordinary challenge in a court; the appropriate remedy is judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution; where reasons exist and the award is supported by evidence, the High Court should not interfere under Article 226. The court applied this principle to uphold the arbitrator's reasoned award (dated 14-7-1995), holding that it was supported by evidence (including meter readings) and reasons; consequently, the challenge to the award in O.P. No. 14587/95 was dismissed.
Santokh Singh v. Divisional Engineer, Telephones, Shillong, AIR 1990 Gauhati 47 The Division Bench's view that Rule 443 could not be interpreted to authorise disconnection of any telephone other than the particular telephone in respect of which there was default in payment. The court expressly disagreed with and dissented from this view, concluding instead that Rule 443 plainly authorises disconnection of other telephones or telex services rented by the subscriber when charges on any telephone are in arrears; the Gauhati decision was not followed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in two main parts: (A) the finality of the Section 7B arbitration award, and (B) the interpretation of Rule 443 with respect to disconnection of other telephones.

(A) Finality of Section 7B award

  • The court relied on the Supreme Court's pronouncement in M.L. Jaggi that awards under Section 7B are conclusive and final and not amenable to ordinary challenges; the appropriate remedy is by judicial review under Article 226.
  • The court emphasised that when an arbitrator gives reasons and those reasons are supported by evidence, the High Court under Article 226 cannot interfere. In this case the arbitrator's award ran to six typed pages, dealt with all aspects in detail, addressed points raised by the subscriber, and relied on evidence including meter readings.
  • Because the award was reasoned and founded on evidence, the court found no ground to interfere and dismissed the petition challenging the award (O.P. No. 14587/95).

(B) Interpretation of Rule 443 — power to disconnect other telephones

  • The court set out Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951 verbatim and undertook a plain-language reading of the provision.
  • The rule states that if rent or other charges are not paid, "any telephone or telephones or any telex service rented by him may be disconnected without notice," and that such disconnected services may be restored if the defaulter pays outstanding dues, reconnection fee and prescribed rental for intervening periods. The court considered the later part of the rule (restoration on payment) as clarifying that disconnection of other telephones/telex services is contemplated by the rule.
  • The court rejected the narrower interpretation adopted by the Gauhati High Court in Santokh Singh (that the power to disconnect should be confined to the telephone in default) as inconsistent with the plain words of Rule 443. The court stated its dissent from the Gauhati Division Bench's view, holding that the Rule clearly permits disconnection of other telephones and telex services rented by the same subscriber when there are arrears on any of the subscriber's telephone accounts.
  • Applying the rule to the facts, with arrears in respect of telephone No. 445431 exceeding Rs. 1,11,000 as of 16-6-1996, the court held that Telephone Authorities were within their power to disconnect telephone No. 445463. Therefore the single Judge's direction to reconnect No. 445463 upon payment of its own due (Rs. 1,861) was incorrect.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

Writ Appeal No. 851/96 is allowed. Consequently, O.P. No. 8761/96 is dismissed. In addition, the challenge to the arbitrator's award in O.P. No. 14587/95 is dismissed, as the arbitrator's reasoned award under Section 7B was upheld.

Implications:

  • The court confirmed (following the Supreme Court in M.L. Jaggi) that an award under Section 7B of the Indian Telegraph Act, when reasoned and supported by evidence, is final and not open to ordinary challenge; the appropriate remedy is judicial review under Article 226.
  • The court held, on a plain reading of Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules, 1951, that the Telephone Authorities are authorised to disconnect other telephones or telex services rented by a subscriber on account of arrears relating to any one of the subscriber's telephones. On the facts, disconnection of telephone No. 445463 was lawful given the substantial arrears on telephone No. 445431.
  • The direct effect of the decision: the single Judge's order directing reconnection of telephone No. 445463 on payment of Rs. 1,861 was set aside; both O.P. No. 8761/96 and O.P. No. 14587/95 were dismissed. The court made no order as to costs.
Order accordingly.

    Union Of India And Others v. S.J Pandit

    K. Sreedharan, A.C.J:— Writ Appeal No. 851/96 is at the instance of respondents in O.P No. 8761/96. Petitioner in O.P No. 8761/96 is the petitioner in O.P No. 14587/95. Since the issues raised in both matters are same, we consider it advaritageous to dispose of these matters by this common judgment.

    2. Short facts necessary for disposal of the appeal and Original Petition are as follows: Writ petitioner Shri S.J Pandit is a subscriber of telephone Nos. 445431 and 445463 of Kayamkulam Telephone Exchange. Subscription and rent in respect of telephone No. 445431 happened to fall in arrears. As on 16-6-1996, the arrears in respect of that phone, according to the Department, is Rs. 1,11,672/-. Disputing the amount claimed by the Department for the period from 26-9-1994 to 25-11-1994, writ petitioner moved O.P No. 17852/94. This Court directed that dispute to be referred to arbitration. Arbitrator by award dated 14-7-1995 came to the conclusion that the amount of Rupees 27,214/- claimed in respect of the said period by bill dated 11-12-1994 is correct and that the subscriber is not entitled to any reduction. Award passed by the arbitrator is under challenge in O.P No. 14587/95.

    3. As stated earlier, arrears in respect of telephone No. 445431 held by writ petitioner was Rs. 1,11,672/- as on 16-6-1996. Writ petitioner is a subscriber of another telephone bearing No. 445463 of Kayamkulam Telephone Exchange. In relation to that telephone, a claim of Rs. 1,861/- was made towards rental and call charges for the period from 26-2-1996 to 11-4-1996. On account of the non-payment of the said amount as also on account of the arrears in relation to telephone No. 445431, Telephone Authorities disconnected telephone No. 445463. Questioning the said action of the Telephone authorities, writ petitioner moved O.P No. 8751/96. Learned single Judge disposed of that Original Petition by directing the respondents, viz. Telephone Authorities to reconnect telephone No. 445463 after receiving the amount covered by the bill, viz. Rs. 1,861/-, Aggrieved by the said direction, Telephone Authorities have preferred Writ Appeal No. 851/96.

    4. When writ petitioner disputed the correctness of the amount claimed by the Telephone Authorities for the period from 26-9-1994 to 25-11-1994, this Court directed that dispute to be referred to arbitration as per judgment in O.P No. 17852/94. Pursuant to that direction, the matter was referred to arbitrator in accordance with the provisions contained in Section 7B of the Indian Telegraph Act. Arbitrator passed a reasoned award dated 14-7-1995. The nature of the award passed by an arbitrator under Section 7B has been pronounced upon by the Supreme Court in M.L Jaggi v. Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Ltd., (1996) 3 SCC 119): (AIR 1996 SC 2476). Their Lordships stated that the award passed under Section 7B is conclusive and final. It is not open to challenge in a Court of law. The actual remedy available to the aggrieved person is by way of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution. If reasons are not given, it would be difficult for the High Court to adjudge as to under what circumstances, the arbitrator came to his conclusion. If the decision was arrived at by the arbitrator on the basis of evidence in the case, supported by reasons and those reasons fully support his conclusion, the High Court in exercise of the powers under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot interfere with the said award. In the instant case, the arbitrator has, passed a reasoned award running to six typed pages. All aspects of the case have been considered by the arbitrator. Points raised by the subscriber before the arbitrator were dealt with in minute detail. The conclusions arrived at by the arbitrator are based on evidence and the readings given by the meters fixed in the Exchange. He, as a matter of fact, came to the conclusion that the writ petitioner was corretly billed for the actual number of calls that originated from his telephone during the disputed period. The said award, under no circumstances, can be said to be passed on surmises and conjectures. We do not find any ground to interfere with the said award. It, therefore, follows that contention raised by the writ petitioner in O.P No. 14587/95 against the award passed by the arbitrator appointed under Section 7B of the Indian Telephone Act is devoid of any substance and it is only to be dismissed. We do so.

    5. Coming to the Writ Appeal, the only question that arises for consideration is whether on account of default in paying the rental and call charges in respect of a particular telephone, other telephones held by the subscriber can be disconnected. On account of the default of the writ petitioner in not paying the rental and call charges in respect of telephone No. 445431, the telephone authorities disconnected his other telephone No. 445463. Learned single Judge directed the Telephone Authorities to re-connect telephone No. 445463 on subscriber remitting the amount covered by the bill in relation to that telephone. Learned Judge did not go into the question as to Whether the telephone authorities have the power to disconnect telephone No. 445463 on account of huge arrears in respect of his telephone No. 445431.

    6. It is common case that Shri S.J Pandit, petitioner in the O.P is subscriber of two telephones bearing Nos. 445431 and 445463. It is also admitted that huge amounts by way of rental and call charges are in arrears in respect of telephone No. 445431. As a result of this, the question is whether the telephone authorities are justified in disconnecting telephone No. 445463. Reference in this regard has to be made to the provision contained in Rule 443 of the Indian Telegraph Rules 1951. For a proper understanding of the provisions contained in the Rules, we read the same:

    “Rule 443. Default of payment: If, on or before, the due date, the rent or other charges in respect of the telephone service provided are not paid by the subscriber in accordance with these rules, or bills for charges in respect of calls (Local and Trunk) or phonograms or other dues from the subscriber are not duly paid by him, any telephone or telephones or any telex service rented by him may be disconnected without notice. The telephone or telephones or the telex so disconnected may, if the Telegraph Authority thinks fit, be restored, if the defaulting subscriber pays the outstanding dues and the reconnection fee together with the rental for such portion of the intervening period (during which the telephone or telex remains disconnected) as may be prescribed by the Telegraph Authority from time to time. The subscriber shall pay all the above charges within such period as may be prescribed by the Telegraph Authority from time to time.”

    A plain reading of that rule clearly shows that if the rent or other charges in respect of one telephone is in arrears, the Telephone Authorities are entitled to disconnect not only that particular telephone, in relation to which the default has occurred, but also other telephones and telex services rented by the subscriber. This is made more clear by the latter part of the Rule which states that the telephone, telephones or telex so disconnected have to be restored if the defaulting subscriber pays the outstanding dues and the reconnection fee. If the arguments advanced by the learned counsel that the Telephone Authorities can disconnect only the telephone the dues of which has fallen in arrears, there was no necessity for the Rule to state that telephone or telex services rented by the subscriber can be disconnected. According to us, the Rule is very clear and is not open to any doubt whatsoever. As per the Rule, on account of the default committed by the subscriber, telephone or telephones and telex services rented by him can be disconnected by the Telephone Authorities without notice. Learned counsel representing the petitioner brought to our notice the decision rendered by a Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court in Santokh Singh v. Divisional Engineer, Telephones, Shillong, AIR 1990 Gauhati 47, in support of the argument that another telephone rented by the subscriber cannot be disconnected on account of the default in respect of the telephone held by him. The Division Bench, referring to Rule 443 of the rules stated—

    “…. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. ….

    We are of the opinion that it cannot be interpreted to vest with the authorities the power to disconnect any other telephone working in the name of the same subscriber either at the same premises or elsewhere on the ground of default of payment of bill in respect of one of his telephones. This power is confined only to the particular telephone in respect of which there is default in payment and not to other telephones. Such a drastic power cannot be granted to the Telephone Department by inference. If at all it is to be given it has to be given in clear and unambiguous terms. Then also the question will arise whether it is reasonable or not. We do not propose to make any comment thereon. Suffice it to say that Rule 443 of the Rules as it presently stands, cannot be interpreted to authorise the Telecom Department to disconnect any telephone other than the one which is subject-matter of dispute as, in our opinion, such action will be highly atrocious. The Department cannot coerce the subscriber to make the disputed payment by such means. It must act in accordance with law and, if necessary, file a suit for recovery of the arrears.”

    We find it difficult to agree with the above observation made by Their Lordships. With respect, we say that Rule 443 does not lead to such an interpretation. We express our dissent from the view taken by the learned Judges of the Gauhati High Court. The Rule does not give room for any doubt. The intention of the rule making authority is specific and clear that the Telephone Authorities can disconnect other telephones and telex services rented to the subscriber, if the rental and call charges of any of his telephone is in arrears.

    7. As stated earlier, rental and call charges in respect of writ petitioner's telephone No. 445431 is in arrears exceeding Rs. 1,11,000/- as on 16-6-1996. In such a situation, Telephone Authorities are well within their power in disconnecting telephone No. 445463 rented out to the writ petitioner. Consequently, learned single Judge was not right in directing the Telephone Authorities to re-connect telephone No. 445463 on payment of its arrears amounting to Rs. 1,861. Writ Appeal is allowed and O.P No. 8761/96 is dismissed.

    W.A No. 851/96 is allowed and O.P No. 14587/95 is dismissed as stated earlier. We make no order as to costs.

    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Union Of India And Others v. S.J Pandit
    (Jul 9, 1996)