AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Legal-Analytical Summary of the High Court Opinion (Anil Kumar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was filed by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD) challenging the Central Administrative Tribunal's (CAT), Principal Bench, New Delhi order dated 12 May 2010 in OA No. 3678/2009 (Surender Singh v. MCD). The CAT had allowed the respondent's original application and directed the petitioners to accord the respondent the "look after charge" of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) with effect from 19 October 2007 with difference of salary and arrears within three months.

The respondent, a diploma-holder who joined MCD as a Junior Engineer in 1993 and allegedly obtained a degree in 2002, was not included in an office order dated 19 October 2007 that assigned look after charges of Assistant Engineer (Civil) to certain Junior Engineers. The 19 October 2007 order specified that look after charge was a stop-gap arrangement, conferred no entitlement to ad-hoc/regular promotion, seniority or additional pay and could be terminated at any time; the period spent on look after charge would not count as qualifying service for promotion or seniority.

Allegations of irregularities in work on public parks led to a CBI registration (PE-DAI-2007-A-2002) against the respondent and others; the record shows a charge sheet was filed by the CBI in Police Case No. 2031.SIO(P)/Vig/CBI/2007 on 29 December 2008. The respondent filed OA No. 1466/2009 challenging non-allocation of look after charge; the CAT disposed of that application on 6 August 2009, directing respondents to consider the claim for look after charge/ad-hoc promotion within four weeks, on the premise that no charge sheet had then been filed. Pursuant to that direction, a reconsideration was undertaken and, by order dated 1 October 2009, the Screening Committee declined to recommend the respondent for ad-hoc promotion on the ground that a charge sheet had been filed on 29 December 2008. The respondent then filed OA No. 3678/2009 (decided by CAT on 12 May 2010), which led to the impugned direction to grant look after charge retrospectively and pay arrears; that CAT order is the subject of the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal (CAT) was justified in directing retrospective grant of look after charge to the respondent with effect from 19 October 2007 together with payment of difference of salary and arrears.
  2. Whether assignment of a "look after charge" is equivalent to an ad-hoc promotion (and therefore whether the Tribunal could equate them for relief purposes).
  3. Whether the pendency of a criminal prosecution and the filing of a charge sheet (filed on 29 December 2008) disentitles the respondent to be considered for ad-hoc promotion or look after charge.
  4. Whether the sealed-cover procedure or administrative guidelines (and related Department of Personnel & Training OM) should have applied to the respondent's case and, if so, whether the Tribunal correctly applied those principles.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (Municipal Corporation of Delhi)

  • Look after charge is a stop-gap administrative arrangement without entitlement to additional remuneration; it is not a promotion and confers no service benefits, seniority or promotion rights.
  • The look after charge could not be directed retrospectively from 19 October 2007 because (a) it was a stop-gap duty assigned for operational exigencies and (b) no additional pay is payable for look after charge under the terms of the 19 October 2007 office order.
  • The respondent's case could legitimately be declined for ad-hoc promotion because a charge sheet in the criminal case had been filed on 29 December 2008; therefore, sealed-cover procedure or ad-hoc promotion was not appropriate.
  • Juniors who were assigned look after charge did not receive additional financial benefit; hence the respondent's claim of discrimination was not legally sustainable.
  • The Screening Committee (on 2 July 2009 and reconsideration on 1 October 2009) properly did not recommend the respondent for ad-hoc appointment given the adverse vigilance/CBI materials and the charge sheet filed earlier.

Respondent's Arguments (Surender Singh)

  • The respondent contended he had been falsely implicated and that no charge sheet had been registered against him as of certain dates (he asserted that criminal charges had not been registered when he sought consideration).
  • He relied on a vigilance report dated 18 December 2007 which, he asserted, gave "no objection" to promotion because only a preliminary enquiry had been received and no regular case had been registered.
  • He argued the denial of look after charge was discriminatory because juniors were assigned the next promotional post (or look after charge) while he was not, and therefore he should be considered at par with those juniors.
  • He treated the current duty as tantamount to an ad-hoc promotion and invoked administrative instructions (including an OM dated 14 November 1992 of DoPT) as having applicability to ad-hoc promotion.
  • He also pointed out that he had been granted certain upgradations/benefits later (for example pay scale of Assistant Engineer w.e.f. 22 September 2009 and financial upgradation under ACP from 1 May 2007), which his counsel argued would affect the practical impact of retrospective arrears (the respondent later conceded he might not receive difference if already paid).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
OA No. 1466/2009: Surender Singh v. MCD (Central Administrative Tribunal order dated 6 August 2009) Directed respondents to consider the applicant's claim for look after charge/ad-hoc promotion, on the premise that no charge sheet had been filed as of that date. The High Court reviewed this prior Tribunal order and concluded that the direction to reconsider was premised on an incorrect factual premise (i.e., that no charge sheet had been filed) because a charge sheet had in fact been filed on 29 December 2008; this undermined the respondent's entitlement to take benefit of the CAT direction.
High Court order in W.P.(C) 7450/2008 (dated 21 October 2008) Used in administrative implementation — the opinion notes compliance via an Office Order dated 28 January 2009 assigning look after charge to a Junior Engineer pursuant to that High Court direction. The opinion cites this High Court order as background showing that at least one other employee had been assigned look after charge pursuant to a court direction; it appears in the factual matrix relied upon before the Tribunal, but the High Court's present judgment does not treat that order as authorising retrospective look after charge for the respondent challenged here.
Apex Court ruling (unnamed in the opinion) Referred to in the opinion for the general administrative-law principle that consideration for promotion can be protected as a fundamental right; the opinion quotes the Tribunal's reliance on an "Apex court ruling" that administrative instructions have been "approved in law." The High Court records that the Tribunal invoked such an "Apex court ruling" to treat consideration for promotion as protected under Articles 14 and 16; however, the High Court emphasized that the Tribunal's specific relief (retrospective look after charge and arrears) could not be sustained on the factual and regulatory record before it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court's analysis proceeds in several interrelated steps grounded in the factual record and administrative framework reflected in the files:

  1. Distinction between look after charge and ad-hoc promotion: The Court observed that the Tribunal treated assignment of look after charge as equivalent to an ad-hoc promotion, but no rule or regulation was produced to support that equivalence. The Court emphasized that the respondent's counsel could not point to any statutory or regulatory provision mandating that assignment of a look after charge must be treated as ad-hoc promotion subject to Screening Committee approval.
  2. Relevance of the charge sheet: The Court found it undisputed that a charge sheet had been filed by the CBI on 29 December 2008. The CAT's earlier direction of 6 August 2009 (in OA No. 1466/2009) had been premised on the assertion that no charge sheet had been filed, but that premise was factually incorrect. The Court held that the respondent could not take advantage of non-disclosure (or alleged lapse) by the petitioners about the existence of the charge sheet; since the charge sheet existed prior to the CAT direction, the respondent was not entitled to the benefit of the CAT's reconsideration direction on the basis that no charge sheet existed.
  3. Screening Committee's exercise of discretion: The Court accepted that the Screening Committee had considered the respondent's case and, on account of the pending criminal prosecution and the filed charge sheet, did not recommend him for ad-hoc promotion. The Court held that this exercise could not be faulted, given the material before the Screening Committee and the fact that the charge sheet had been filed.
  4. Retrospective relief and salary arrears: The Tribunal had ordered the retrospective grant of look after charge from 19 October 2007 and directed payment of arrears. The High Court concluded that awarding retrospective look after charge and salary arrears under these circumstances had no rational basis: look after charge is a stop-gap assignment without additional remuneration under the terms set out in the 19 October 2007 office order, and the Tribunal's grant of retrospective financial relief was inconsistent with the terms and nature of look after charge as recorded in the municipal office order.
  5. Sealed cover procedure and administrative instructions: The Tribunal applied sealed-cover guidelines and administrative instructions to justify the relief. The High Court recorded that the respondent had not insisted on sealed-cover procedure before the Tribunal. Moreover, the High Court stressed that administrative instructions or an OM cannot be treated as mandating an outcome where the factual and procedural preconditions (such as the absence of a charge sheet) are not met. The High Court therefore declined to endorse the Tribunal's reliance on administrative guidance to override the factual finding that a charge sheet had been filed.
  6. Overall legal posture: The Court repeatedly returned to the core proposition that the Tribunal's relief depended on an erroneous factual premise and an unsupported equivalence between look after charge and ad-hoc promotion. On that basis the Tribunal's order was held to suffer material illegality and irregularity.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

The writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 12 May 2010 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in OA No. 3678/2009 (Surender Singh v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi) directing the petitioners to accord the respondent the look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) w.e.f. 19 October 2007 and to pay arrears of salary is set aside.

Consequent reliefs and disposition:

  • The original application OA No. 3678/2009, insofar as it sought directions to issue order for ad-hoc promotion of the respondent to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) and grant consequential benefits, is dismissed.
  • The Court held that the respondent is neither entitled to be accorded look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) nor entitled to ad-hoc promotion to that post on the facts and circumstances of this case.
  • Considering the facts and circumstances the parties were directed to bear their own costs.

Implications: The decision's direct effect is to overturn the CAT's order granting retrospective look after charge and arrears and to dismiss the respondent's OA for ad-hoc promotion. The opinion does not purport to create a new principle of law extending beyond the facts of this case; it emphasizes that without statutory/regulatory support, look after charge cannot be equated with ad-hoc promotion and that factual preconditions (such as whether a charge sheet has been filed) are determinative in the administrative reconsideration context.

    Municipal Corporation Of Delhi & Ors. Petitioners v. Surender Singh

    ANIL KUMAR, J.

    1. The petitioner, Municipal Corporation of Delhi, through its Commissioner & Ors., have challenged the impugned order dated 12th May, 2010 passed by Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in OA No. 3678/2009 titled as ‘Sh. Surender Singh v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi’, allowing the original application of the respondent and directing the petitioners to accord to the respondent the look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) w.e.f 19 October, 2007 with difference of salary, including the arrears within a period of three months.

    2. Brief facts to comprehend the disputes between the parties are that the respondent is a diploma holder engineer and had initially joined Municipal Corporation of Delhi as a Junior Engineer in the year 1993. He had allegedly completed degree in Engineering in the year 2002. Since 1993 the respondent had been working as a Junior Engineer and had been posted at different places.

    3. During the period 2005-2006, a reliable information was received that the respondent and Sh. D.S Dhanda, EE, Sh. A.K Jain, AE and Sh. S.S Chikkatra, JE in connivance with Pvt. Contractors committed gross irregularities/violations in connection with the Civil Construction works carried out for improvement of public parks in Sector 15 and 16 of Rohini. PE-DAI-2007-A-2002 was registered by CBI against the respondent and other conniving officials. On 19 October, 2007 an Office Order No. F.5(27)/CED/(III)/94.Pt.VIII/37/30711 was issued by the petitioner assigning the look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) with immediate effect in addition to carrying out the duties by Junior Engineers. In the order dated 19 October, 2007, it had been clarified that the officials who were given the look after charge would draw the salary in their own pay scale and would not claim any additional pay or undue benefit for holding the additional charge and also that the assignment of the look after charge would not confer on them any right for claiming an ad hoc/regular promotion or seniority of the said post or any other service benefits. It was further specified that the look after charge being a stop gap arrangement could be terminated at any time by the Competent Authority without assigning any reason and/or prior notice and also that the period spent on look after charge was not to be counted as qualifying service for promotion to the higher grade or for seniority. It was also categorically stated that the look after charge would be terminated as and when direct recruits would become available.

    4. Since, the name of the respondent was not included in the order dated 19 October, 2007 assigning the look after charge to various Junior Engineers including some of them even junior to the respondent, the respondent challenged the same by filing an original application being OA No. 1466 of 2009, titled as ‘Surender Singh v. MCD’, which was decided on 6 August, 2009. While deciding the OA No. 1466/2009, the Tribunal in para 4 had held as under:-

    “We have heard both the counsel and perused the pleadings as well. Applicant's grievance is that till date no charge sheet has been filed in the police case yet he has not been given the look after charge though his juniors have been assigned the next promotional post of Assistant Engineer. This averment has not been denied by the respondents in their counter affidavit. They have themselves stated that applicant's case is under active consideration for grant of ad hoc promotion, therefore, this OA is disposed off with a direction to the respondents to consider the claim of the applicant for look after charge of ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) at par with his juniors because till date, admittedly, no charge sheet has been filed in the police case. This should be done within a period of 4 weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order under intimation to the applicant.”

    5. Before the Tribunal, the respondent had contended that he had been falsely implicated in the criminal case and that he had also made a representation dated 20 October, 2007 against order dated 19 October, 2007 assigning look after charge to other junior engineers and not to him. The respondent had also contended that the petitioners had ignored the report of the vigilance department dated 18 December, 2007, which had given no objection for promotion in respect of the respondent as only preliminary enquiry had been received by the vigilance department against the respondent and no regular case had been registered.

    6. The respondent had also made a grievance in respect of order dated 29 May, 2008, whereby Sh. Yogender Singh Sanger s/o Sh. S.S Sanger was assigned the look after charge inspite of issuance of chargesheet against him. The respondent also relied on the Office Order dated 28 January, 2009 which was passed in compliance of the High Court's order dated 21st October, 2008 in W.P(C) 7450 of 2008, whereby Sh. Indra Vir Singh, Junior Engineer (Civil) was directed to be assigned look after charge regardless of the chargesheet issued against him.

    7. Pursuant to the disposal of the OA of the respondent by order dated 6 August, 2009, the petitioners considered the case of the respondent and passed order dated 1 October, 2009 which is as under:-

    “Whereas the Hon'ble CAT (PB) in the case of Shri Surender Singh v. MCD in OA No. 1466/2009 on 06.08.2009 ordered in para No. 04 that:

    “We have heard both the counsel and perused the pleadings as well. Applicant's grievance is that till date no charge sheet has been filed in the police case yet he has not been given the look after charge though his juniors have been assigned the next promotional post of Assistant Engineer. This averment has not been denied by the respondents in their counter affidavit. They have themselves stated that applicant's case is under active consideration for grant of ad hoc promotion, therefore, this OA is disposed off with a direction to the respondents to consider the claim of the applicant for look after charge of ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) at par with his juniors because till date, admittedly, no charge sheet has been filed in the police case. This should be done within a period of 4 weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order under intimation to the applicant.”

    2. Whereas, Screening Committee held on 02.07.2009, considered the case of Shri Surender Singh for ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500/-(pre-revised) and observed that:

    “Unfit (due to pending Police Case No. 2031.SIO(P)/Vig/CBI/2007, prosecution sanctioned and charge sheet has been filed in the court of law on 29.12 2008).”

    3. Since, the Hon'ble CAT had passed the directions based on the averment that no charge sheet has been filed in the police case till date, but the fact of matter is that charge sheet in Police Case No. 2031.SIO(P)/Vig/CBI/2007 had been filed on 29.12.2008 Hence, the Screening Committee, after consideration, didn't recommend the name of Shri Surender Singh for ad hoc promotion to the post of AE(C).

    4. In view of the above facts, the official is intimated that he was not recommended by the Screening Committee for ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil)”

    8. The petitioners held that though the OA No. 1466/2009 was filed in respect of not assigning the look after charge, however, while considering the original application of the respondent, a direction was given to consider the claim of the respondent for look after charge or ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil).

    9. The plea of the respondent for ad hoc promotion was, however, declined on account of pendency of police case No. 2031.SIO(P)/Vig/CBI/2007 whereby prosecution was sanctioned and charge sheet had been filed on 29 December, 2008. The petitioners noted that since the order dated 6 August, 2009 in OA No. 1466 of 2009 was passed on the premise that no charge sheet had been filed till that date, but in fact a charge sheet had been filed on 29 December, 2008, therefore, the case of the respondent was not considered by the screening committee for ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil).

    10. Aggrieved by the order dated 1 October, 2009 the respondent filed another original application being OA No. 3678 of 2009 contending, inter-alia, that the ad-hoc promotion be made only on the basis of seniority and since it is not disputed that juniors to the respondent have been assigned ad-hoc promotion, therefore, the respondent is also entitled for ad hoc promotion. The respondent further contended that initially his name was approved for ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) along with other officials, however, subsequently, his name was dropped on account of pendency of the criminal case against him. The respondent contended that mere pendency of the criminal case does not disentitle the respondent from getting the ad-hoc promotion. In the OA 3678 of 2009 filed on 18 December, 2009, the respondent categorically asserted that the criminal charges had not been registered against him. His grievance was that he has been compelled to work under his juniors, who would be writing his confidential report, which would be the decisive factor at the time of regular promotion when the respondent would be considered for promotion by DPC along with his junior officials.

    11. The OA 3678 of 2009 filed by the respondent against the order dated 1 October, 2009 declining to appoint the respondent on ad-hoc basis was contested by the petitioners contending, inter-alia, that the screening committee after considering the case of the respondent has passed the order dated 1 October, 2009 and did not recommend his name for ad-hoc appointment to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil). The petitioners contended that Sh. Pankaj Goel, Sh. R.P Chahal & Mohd. Asif were promoted on ad-hoc basis to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) on the recommendation of the screening committee held on 2nd July, 2009, which was subsequently approved by the competent authority as the assessment was made in respect of these officers on the basis of vigilance clearance report received from the vigilance department which reflected that the cases were not pending against these persons. Reliance was placed on the letter dated 3rd December, 2009 seeking information regarding these officials from the Deputy Commissioner (Police), Economic Offences Wing, Crime Branch, Qutub Institutional Area, New Delhi. The case of the respondent was distinguished on the ground that the name of the respondent had also been considered by the screening committee in its meeting held on 2 March, 2009, however, due to pending cases where charge sheets had been filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation, his name was not recommended for promotion. Later on an additional affidavit dated 29 April, 2010 was also filed before the Tribunal. Reliance was placed on a detail report of the vigilance department dated 9 April, 2010. The report indicated that three letters dated 3 November, 2009, 12 January, 2010 & 8 April, 2010 were addressed to the Deputy Commissioner (Police) Institutional Area, New Delhi, but no information was received in the Vigilance Department except for the letter dated 17 November, 2009 stating that the charge sheet has been filed in FIR No. 82/2002, under Section 420/120/63 of C.R Act and the case is pending trial in case of respondent and not in case of other officials.

    12. The Tribunal, however, considering the pleas and contentions of the parties allowed the prayer of the respondent and directed the petitioners to accord the respondent the look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) w.e.f 19 October, 2007 with difference of salary including arrears. It was also observed that subsequent charge sheet issued to the respondent by the Central Bureau of Investigation shall take its own course. Before the Tribunal, the respondent had rather contended that the current duty charge is nothing but an ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) and that OM dated 14 November, 1992 of DOP&T has equal applicability to ad-hoc promotion. It was also held that denial of the look after charge to the respondent was discriminatory. The Tribunal also applied the guidelines on sealed cover for ad-hoc promotion and held that look after charge provides that in case a person against whom prosecution for a criminal charge is pending, only then his promotion can be withheld and it can be put under sealed cover. Since as on 19 October, 2007 even an FIR was not registered against the respondent, therefore, not granting look after charge on the basis of the preliminary investigation carried by the Central Bureau of Investigation could not be a bar for promotion of the respondent, and his right to be considered for promotion has to be understood in the right perspective. In the circumstances, it was held that illegality has been committed by the petitioners and, therefore, the original application of the respondent was allowed. The reasoning of the tribunal as stipulated in paras 9 and 10 of the impugned order dated 12 May, 2010 is as follows:-

    “9. On perusal of the guidelines on sealed cover for ad hoc promotion which now could be equated with the methodology adopted and approved by the MCD i.e look after charge provides that in case a person against whom prosecution for a criminal charge is pending only then his promotion can be withheld and should be put under sealed cover. As on 19.10.2007, one of the conditions was existed not even an FIR was registered against the applicant. As such, denying promotion to the applicant on the basis of a process preliminary to the investigation carried by the CBI is not a barred for promotion as his right to be considered for promotion has not been considered in the right perspective by the respondents. This illegality cannot be countenanced in law. As the applicant is basing his right when he was free from all intricacies and was not facing a criminal trial, his fundamental right guaranteed for promotion which is protected not only under Article 14 but also under Article 16 of the Constitution of India. We are not declaring his right on negativity but on the basis of the principle which has been enunciated by way of administrative instructions and approved in law by the Apex court ruling the consideration for promotion as a fundamental right. As the consideration was not apt in law, deprivation of this promotion to the applicant has prejudiced him, as his juniors have got the position getting higher emoluments to which had been deprived of.

    10. Resultantly, the OA is allowed. Respondents are directed to accord to the applicant the look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) w.e.f 19.10.2007 with difference of salary, including arrears within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. We also observe that subsequent charge sheet issued to the applicant by the CBI, the law shall take its own course. No costs.”

    13. The order directing the petitioners to accord respondent the look after charge to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) w.e.f 19 October, 2007 by order dated 12 May, 2010 in OA No. 3678/2009 is challenged by the petitioners, inter-alia, on the grounds that the petitioners' department due to exigencies of work assigns to its employee the additional duty of its next promotional post on look after basis as a stop gap measure which is without any additional remuneration and the remunerations are paid to the employees according to the post held on regular basis. It was contended that since the look after charge was not assigned to the respondent, he could not be directed to be given look after charge retrospectively from 19 October, 2007, as it is practically not possible and in any case on account of having look after charge the respondent does not get any additional salary, therefore, the directions of the Tribunal to grant the arrears to the respondent w.e.f 19 October, 2007 is contrary to the terms and conditions for giving look after charge. It was also contended that the charge sheet had been filed against the respondent on 29 December, 2008 and on account of the Central Bureau of Investigation registering the case against the respondent where the charge sheet had also been filed, the respondent was not entitled for consideration to the next post even on ad-hoc basis, nor was the sealed cover procedure to be followed in case of appointment on ad-hoc basis. It was categorically contended that assigning look after charge is not a promotion but entrustment of additional work without any remuneration and that the allegation of the respondent that his juniors have been promoted and that despite this he has not been given look after charge is a legally not sustainable. It was reiterated that the juniors to the respondent, who had been given look after charge were not given any financial benefit and that the respondent cannot contend that he has been discriminated. In any case, it was contended that when the order dated 19 October, 2007, giving look after charge to some of the Junior Engineers (Civil) was assigned, the complaints against the respondent were pending investigation which were received during the period 2005-2006. The look after charge was also assigned to other Junior Engineers (Civil) for a period of 6 months by order dated 19 October, 2007. It was also contended on behalf of the petitioners that by order dated 1 October, 2009 the case of the respondent for giving ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500/- (Pre-revised) was declined on account of the criminal case pending against him, where sanction for prosecution had been granted and the charge sheet had also been filed on 29 December, 2008. In the circumstances, it is contended that the respondent could not be given look after charge from 19 October, 2007 retrospectively, nor he is entitled for any remuneration for look after charge as no additional remuneration for higher post are payable if an employee is entrusted look after charge. Therefore, it is urged that the Tribunal had gravely erred in directing the petitioners to give the difference of salary on account of alleged entitlement of the respondent for look after charge retrospectively. Since on 2 March, 2009 a criminal case was pending against the respondent and the charge sheet had already been filed, therefore, not recommending the case of the respondent for ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) cannot be faulted by the respondent on any of the grounds contended on behalf of the respondent.

    14. The writ petition is contested by the respondent contending, inter-alia, that he is already getting the pay scale of Assistant Engineer (Civil), the higher post, w.e.f 22 September, 2009, which according to the respondent was granted on the basis of the recommendations of the same Screening Committee. It is contended that as a result, the respondent will not be entitled for any difference of salary and retrospective effect will not give any advantage to the respondent. Copy of the order dated 22 September, 2009 was also relied on. Consequent to the recommendations of the Departmental Screening Committee first financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme was granted to the respondent from 1 May, 2007 in the pay scale of Rs. 6500-10500/- with stipulation that financial upgradation is subject to final acceptance by audit and subject to rectification/withdrawal, if any, adverse report comes to the notice of the department in future.

    15. This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties in detail. It is apparent that the Tribunal has considered assigning the look after charge as equivalent to an ad-hoc promotion to an employee pursuant to recommendations of the Screening Committee. The learned counsel for the respondent has not been able to show any rules and regulations on the basis of which it can be inferred and held that the assignment of look after charge is equivalent to the grant of ad-hoc promotion subject to approval and recommendations by the Screening Committee.

    16. No rule or regulation has also been brought to the notice of this Court which will mandate assignment of look after charge in case financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme is granted to the Junior Engineer (Civil). This is not in dispute that the charge sheet was not filed in the criminal case pending against the respondent on 19 October, 2007. However, this has also not been disputed that the complaints for the period 2005-2006 were pending against the respondent in regard to his connivance with private constructors of having committed gross irregularities/violation in connection with civil construction works carried out for improvement of Public Parks in Sector 15 & 16 of Rohini. In any case, the petitioners filed the original application being OA No. 1466 of 2009, which was disposed of by order dated 6 August, 2009 with directions to the petitioners to consider the claim of the respondent for look after charge or ad hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) on the premise that till that date i.e 6 August, 2009 no charge sheets had been filed in the criminal case. The learned counsel for the respondent has contended that the charge sheets had been filed in the criminal case No. 2031.SIO (P)/Vig./CBI/2007 on 29 December, 2008 and the fact was not disclosed by the petitioners. This plea of the respondent cannot be accepted, as there was no reason to have not disclosed that the charge sheet had been filed against him by the petitioners. Since, the charge sheet had been filed against the respondent, he cannot take the benefit of its non disclosure for any reason or alleged lapse on the part of the petitioners before the Tribunal. In the circumstances, pursuant to order dated 6 August, 2009 passed in OA No. 1466/2009, if the direction was given to the petitioners to reconsider the case of the respondent for assignment of look after charge or ad-hoc promotion on the premise that till 6 August, 2009 no charge sheet had been filed, if the charge sheet had already been filed on 29 December, 2008, i.e prior to order dated 6 August, 2009, the respondent cannot take the benefit of the same, nor can he contend that he is entitled for look after charge or the ad-hoc promotion.

    17. By order dated 1 October, 2009 pursuant to the directions given in OA No. 1466 of 2009 by order dated 6 August, 2009, it has been categorically asserted that the charge sheet had been filed in the court of law against the respondent on 29 December, 2008, therefore, while reconsidering the case of the respondent on 1 October, 2009, if the petitioners has held that his case was considered by the Screening Committee for giving ad-hoc promotion and since, the Screening Committee had not recommended his case for ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil), it could not be faulted by the respondent on any of the grounds raised by him in his OA No. 3678/2009, which was decided by the Tribunal by order dated 12 May, 2010.

    18. By order dated 1 October, 2009, the petitioners had decided that the respondent is not entitled for ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil), however, by impugned order the relief has been granted to the respondent to be given look after charge for the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) with retrospective effect from 19 October, 2007, which cannot be sustained on any rationale in the facts and circumstances of the present case. The respondent had sought ad-hoc promotion to the post of AE (C), whereas the Tribunal has granted the relief to assign look after charge for the post of AE (C) to the respondent retrospectively.

    19. The learned counsel for the respondent also categorically conceded that the respondent had not insisted that sealed cover procedure be followed for the purpose of his ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil). Even in the original application, it was not claimed that the petitioners be directed to follow the sealed cover procedure for the purpose of ad-hoc promotion of the respondent to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil). This cannot be disputed by the respondent that the assignment of the look after charge is distinguishable from ad-hoc promotion of an employee to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil). If the respondent himself had claimed ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) then the Tribunal could not have granted the relief of assigning look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) retrospectively w.e.f 19 October, 2007. No cogent reason has been disclosed for granting a relief, which had not been sought by the respondent and because assigning look after charge is not equivalent to promoting an employee on ad-hoc basis. On the date of reconsideration of the case of the respondent on 1 October, 2009 pursuant to the directions given in original application No. 1466 of 2009 by order dated 6 August, 2009, if on account of charge sheet being filed on 29 December, 2008 against the respondent in the criminal case pending against him, if the ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) could not be granted to the respondent, a fortiori, even look after charge could not be assigned to the respondent retrospectively though this was not even sought by the respondent.

    20. For the foregoing reasons, the order of the Tribunal dated 12 May, 2010 in OA No. 3678/2009 suffers from material illegality and irregularity and cannot be sustained in the facts and circumstances and in law, nor the directions can be given to the petitioners to retrospectively accord the look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) to the respondent w.e.f 19 October, 2007 and to pay the arrears. The respondent is neither entitled to be accorded look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil), nor is the respondent entitled for ad-hoc promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the facts and circumstances.

    21. Consequently, the writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 12 May, 2010 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in OA No. 3678/2009, titled as ‘Surender Singh v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi’, directing the petitioners to accord to the respondent the look after charge of the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) w.e.f 19 October, 2007 and to pay the arrears of salary is set aside and the original application being OA No. 3678/2009 seeking directions to the petitioners to issue order for ad-hoc promotion of the respondent to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) and for the grant of all the consequential benefits is dismissed. Considering the facts and circumstances the parties are, however, left to bear their own costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Municipal Corporation Of Delhi & Ors. Petitioners v. Surender Singh
    (Aug 11, 2011)