Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Legal Opinion (Y.K. Sabharwal, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner sought winding up of M/s. Polar Forging and Tools Ltd. on the ground that the company was unable to pay its debts. The petitioner supplied furniture to the company during September 1989 to December 1989 and submitted bills aggregating Rs. 5,25,707.60 (inclusive of sales tax, packaging, forwarding charges and freight). The company had paid Rs. 4,05,000 (including payments made before the commencement of supply), leaving a balance claimed by the petitioner of Rs. 1,20,707.60. The petitioner alleged that the final payment was due by the end of January 1990 (or, according to the order placed on record, payment should have been made by end of February 1990). The petitioner claimed interest at 18% p.a. from 1 February 1990 as per market practice and served demand letters dated 10 May 1990, 6 June 1990 and 30 June 1990. The company filed an affidavit in opposition taking several pleas including that no valid notice of demand had been served.

During the pendency of the petition the company paid Rs. 1,15,249.60, described in the opinion as the undisputed part of the claim; that payment was made without prejudice to the parties' contentions about liability for interest and the validity of the notice under Section 434 of the Companies Act, 1956. The court heard counsel on the disputes.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in the absence of a specific contract for payment of interest, the Company Court (winding up court) can adjudicate the liability to pay interest and the rate thereof in a winding up petition where the principal amount is admitted (and in fact paid) by the company, and whether failure to pay such adjudicated interest can justify winding up the company.
  2. Whether the letters dated 10 May 1990, 6 June 1990 and 30 June 1990 constituted a valid demand under Section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956 — specifically, whether a statutory demand must state the consequences (such as a threat of winding up) in case of non-payment.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that Rs. 1,15,249.60 (the undisputed portion) was due from as early as February 1990 and was paid only about two years later during the proceedings; therefore the company is liable to pay interest at 18% p.a. for the delay.
  • The petitioner relied on confirmations by the company as to satisfaction with the work and admitted liability for the principal amount; on that basis the petitioner argued the winding up petition deserved admission and ultimately the company would be liable to be wound up for failure to pay interest.
  • The petitioner had, prior to presenting the petition, sent registered letters seeking payment within specified time and warning of overdue interest at 18% p.a from due dates till realisation.

Respondent Company's Arguments

  • The company contended that even if Rs. 1,15,000 (approx.) was due and paid late, the petition should not be admitted because there was no contract between the parties for payment of interest; thus non-payment of interest could not form the basis for invoking winding up jurisdiction.
  • The company also argued that the petitioner had not served a valid notice of demand prior to presentation of the petition and that the letters alleged as notices of demand were not legal.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ultimate Advertising and Marketing v. G.B. Laboratories Ltd., 66 Company Cases 232 (Allahabad High Court) Held that a winding up court could not investigate the rate and quantum of interest and that unless interest was agreed, admitted or decreed it did not become a debt for winding up purposes. The court distinguished and disagreed with this view on the facts of the present case, explaining that where the principal is admitted and paid, the Company Court can determine interest; the present case contained specified due dates and figures enabling mathematical calculation of interest.
Stephen Chemical Limited v. Innosearch Limited, 60 Company Cases 702 (Punjab & Haryana High Court, Division Bench) Stated that the Company Judge is an appropriate forum to determine whether a creditor is entitled to interest where the company admits liability and pays the amount. The court expressed respectful agreement with this decision and relied on it to support the proposition that the Company Court can adjudicate interest when principal is admitted and paid.
Delhi Cloth & General Mill Co. Ltd. v. Stepan Chemicals Limited, 60 Company Cases 1046 (Punjab & Haryana High Court, Single Bench) Similar principle that the Company Judge is the appropriate forum for deciding entitlement to interest where liability is admitted and payment is made. The court expressed respectful agreement with this decision as consistent with allowing the Company Court to determine interest in such circumstances.
N.K. Gossain & Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. Dytron (India) Ltd., 1990 Company Cases Vol. 69 757 (Calcutta High Court) Held that a demand under section 434(1)(a) does not require the notice to recite a threat of winding up; the absence of an expressed threat does not invalidate the demand. The court cited this decision in support of its conclusion that the demand letters in the present case were valid even though they did not state consequences in terms of a winding up threat.
Paramjit Lal Badhwar v. Prem Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd., 60 Company Cases 420 (Allahabad High Court) Expressed the view that, though it is not necessary to mention Section 434(1)(a), there should be some indication in the notice that in case of non-compliance the creditor will take steps for winding up. The court disagreed with this view and held that the law does not prescribe such a requirement; the court found the earlier reasoning inapplicable to the present case.
K. Suresh Shenoy v. Cochin Stock Exchange Ltd., (1988) 3 Company Law Journal 350 (Kerala High Court) Expressed the view that a demand should indicate, in case of non-compliance, that the creditor will take steps for winding up. The court respectfully disagreed with this position and held that Section 434(1)(a) and the Rules do not require specification of consequences (such as an explicit threat of winding up) in the demand letter.
Babu Ram & another v. Krishna Bharadwaj Cold Stores & General Mills Co. (P) Ltd. and others, 1965 (2) C.L.J. 215 Held that the law does not require that a demand notice must recite a threat of winding up in case of non-payment. The court referred to this earlier decision as supporting the proposition that absence of a threat in the demand does not invalidate a statutory demand; the court indicated this earlier decision was not brought to the notice of the judge in the Paramjit Lal case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a stepwise analysis:

  1. The court identified a principal question of procedural and substantive importance: whether the Company Court, in winding up proceedings, may determine the liability to pay interest (and the rate) where the principal debt is admitted and has been paid in the course of those proceedings, or whether the interest question must be litigated separately in a civil court.
  2. The court emphasized the policy objective of avoiding multiplicity of litigation. When the principal amount is admitted and payment is made in winding up proceedings so as to avoid an order for winding up, the Company Court is, in the court's view, competent to decide whether the creditor is also entitled to interest and to direct winding up if the company fails to pay the adjudicated interest amount.
  3. The court relied on Section 61(2)(a) of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 (cited by the court) which permits the court, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, to award interest at such rate as it thinks fit on the price from the date the price was payable. The court held that the interest amount can be determined by the Company Court either by exercising power under the Sale of Goods Act provisions or on the principles underlying those provisions.
  4. The court reviewed contrary decisions (notably an Allahabad High Court decision in Ultimate Advertising and Marketing v. G.B. Laboratories Ltd.) which held that a winding up court could not investigate rate and quantum of interest unless interest had been agreed, admitted or decreed. The court found that decision distinguishable on facts and respectfully disagreed with its general proposition in circumstances where the principal is admitted and paid, and when the creditor has specified the balance, rate claimed and due dates.
  5. The court aligned itself with decisions of the Punjab & Haryana High Court (Stephen Chemical and Delhi Cloth & General Mill cases) which held that the Company Judge is the appropriate forum to determine entitlement to interest where liability is admitted and payment is made.
  6. On the validity of the demand letters under Section 434(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 1956, the court analyzed the statutory language. It concluded that:
    • The statute and rules do not prescribe any special form of demand;
    • There is no statutory requirement that a demand specify the consequences (for example, a threat of winding up) in case of non-payment;
    • Non-specification of the three-week period in the demand does not invalidate it;
    • Authorities such as N.K. Gossain supported the view that the absence of an explicit threat does not invalidate a statutory demand; the court rejected contrary views in Paramjit Lal Badhwar and K. Suresh Shenoy.
  7. Applying these principles to the facts, the court found that the letters dated 10 May 1990, 6 June 1990 and 30 June 1990 prima facie constituted valid demands under Section 434(1)(a).
  8. Having determined that the principal liability was admitted/paid and the demand was valid, the court exercised its discretion to award interest but reduced the rate claimed by the petitioner (18% p.a.) to a rate which the court deemed just and reasonable on the facts: 12% p.a. The court specified that interest be calculated on Rs. 1,15,000 from 1 March 1990 until payment was made in the proceedings.
  9. The court set a specific time for payment of the interest (on or before 20 November 1992) and specified the procedural consequence if payment was not made: the petition would stand admitted and the petitioner would proceed with publication of citations for a hearing listed on 26 February 1993.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Company Court is competent to determine entitlement to interest (and the reasonable rate) in winding up proceedings where the principal amount is admitted and, in this case, the court awarded interest at 12% p.a. on Rs. 1,15,000 from 1 March 1990 until payment; if the interest is not paid as directed the petition shall be treated as admitted.

Direct consequences and practical implications:

  • The company was ordered to pay interest at 12% p.a. on Rs. 1,15,000 from 1 March 1990 until payment made in the proceedings; the parties were to calculate the exact amount and the company was directed to pay the interest on or before 20 November 1992.
  • In case of non-payment by the specified date, the court directed that it would be presumed the company was unable to pay its debts, the petition would stand admitted, and the petitioner would publish the required citations indicating listing before the court on 26 February 1993 (in specified newspapers).
  • Broader legal implication articulated by the court: where the principal debt is admitted and settled in winding up proceedings, the creditor need not be forced to commence separate proceedings in a civil court to recover interest; the Company Judge can determine the interest and, on non-payment, proceed to winding up. The court stressed that this approach avoids multiplicity of litigation.

The court expressed disagreement with some earlier High Court decisions to the extent they discouraged Company Courts from adjudicating interest in such circumstances, and expressed agreement with other High Court decisions that recognize the Company Court as the appropriate forum when the principal liability is admitted and payment has been made in the proceedings.

    Devendra Kumar Jain. v. Polar Forgings & Tools Ltd

    Y.K Sabharwal, J.— Petitioner seeks winding up of M/s. Polar Forging and Tools Ltd. (for short “the company”) on the ground that the company is unable to pay its debts. In short the case of the petitioner is as under:—

    Petitioner as per the order placed by the Company supplied to the company furniture during the period from September 1989 to December 1989 and submitted bills aggregating a sum of Rs. 5.25,707.60 inclusive of sales tax, packaging and forwarding charges and freight. The company paid Rs. 4,05,000/- to the petitioner including payments made before commencement of supply and thus a sum of Rs. 1.20,707.60 was still due and payable by company to the petitioner. The final payment was required to be made by the company to the petitioner latest by the end of January 1990 for the reason that the supplies were completed in December 1989 and the period of 30 days thereafter expired sometime in January 1990. According to practise and usage of the market the petitioner is entitled to interest on the outstanding amount at 18% p.a from 1st february, 1990. The company has been acknowledging its liability and had also confirmed that the job had been carried out by the petitioner to the satisfaction of the company. The petitioner has demanded payment of Rs. 1,12,707.60 with interest at 18% p.a but the company has not even sent reply to the letters of the petitioner and has further failed to pay the amount within three weeks from the date of receipt of the letters of demand and thus the company is unable to pay its debts and liable to be wound up.

    In the affidavit filed in opposition to the petition various pleas have been taken by the company including the plea that no notice of demand has been served on the company prior to the presentation of the petition and even otherwise notices alleged as ‘notices of demand’ are not legal.

    During the pendency of this petition the company has, however, paid to the petitioner a sum of Rs. 1,15,249.60 being the undisputed part of the claim of the petitioner. This payment was made without prejudice to the contentions of the parties in regard to liability to pay interest and validity of the notice under Section 434 of the Companies Act, 1956 (for short ‘the Act’). I have heard learned counsel in support of these contentions.

    Mr. Aggarwal, learned counsel for the petitioner contends that on Rs. 1,15,249.60 the company is liable to pay interest at the rate of 18% p.a as admittedly this amount was due as far back as in February 1990 but was paid about two years later during these proceedings. Counsel contends that delay in payment occured inspite of the fact that the company had confirmed not only the amount due but also the fact that the petitioner had carried out the work to the entire satisfaction of the company and thus the petitioner is entitled to payment of interest. The contention of Mr. Aggarwal is that on the failure, refusal and neglect of the company to pay the interest the petition, at this stage, deserves admission and ultimately the company would be liable to be wound up.

    Mr. Singhla, learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, contends, that assuming sum of about Rs. 1,15,000/- was due and payable by the company to the petitioner in February 1990 and it was paid after about two years from the due date, the present petitionis still not liable to be admitted. Two grounds are urged by Mr. Singhla. (One) There is no contract between the parties for payment of interest and thus for non payment of alleged interest liability the petitioner is not entitled to invoke the winding up jurisdiction and (two) the petitioner has not served the company with a valid notice of demand.

    In order to appreciate the grounds urged by Mr. Singla few more facts may be notice. The order dated 3rd September 1989 containing the terms and conditions on which the furniture was supplied to the company has been placed on record. The order stipulates the stages at which the payments were required to be made by the company to the petitionr. As per those stipulations the payment should have been made by the company to the petitioner latest by end of February 1990. The payment was not made. By registered AD letter dated 10th May 1990 the petitioner requested the company to make the payment of Rs. 1,20,707.60 within one week of the receipt of the letter and also stated that in case the payment is not released as requested the petitioner will be constrained to charge overdue interest at 18% p.a from the due dates of payment till realisation. Similar requests were repeated by the petitioner in his letters dated 6th June, 1990 and 30th June, 1990. As payment was still not made this petition was filed. The company admitted the liability of only about Rs. 1,15,000/- and paid that amount to petitioner during pendency of these proceedings. The delay in making this payment to the petitioner is about two years.

    The question to be determined is, whether in absence of specific contract for payment of interest even where the price of the goods is not paid admittedly by the due date, can the liability to pay interest and rate thereof be adjudicated by the Company Court in a petition filed for winding up of the company and on failure of the company to make payment of interest amount as may be adjudicated, can the Company Judge direct winding up of the company or the question of interest should be left to be determined by a civil court where creditor should file a suit for recovery of the interest amount.

    On the aforesaid question divergent opinions have been expressed by Allahabad and Madras High Courts. Counsel for the parties have not cited any decision of this Court. In my opinion, it is the duty of the court to adopt that approach which would result in avoiding multiplicity of litigation. When the Company Court is seized of the matter and liability to pay the principal amount is not only admitted by the company but that amount is in fact paid in the winding up proceedings so as to avoid an order for the winding up, the Company Court will be fully competent to determine whether the creditor is also entitled to interest and direct winding up of the company on its failure to make payment of such amount. Reference may also be made to Section 61(2)(a) of the Sale of Goods Act, 1930 which inter-alia, provides that in the absence of a contract to the contrary the court may award interest at such rate as it thinks fit on the amount of the price to the seller in a suit by him for the amount of the price from the date of the tender of the goods or from the date on which the price was payable. The interest amount can be determined by the company court in exercise of power under the provisions of the Sale of Goods Act or on the principles underlying the said provisions. Learned counsel for the Company relies upon a decision of Allahabad High Court in Ultimate Advertising and Marketing v. G.B Laboratories Ltd., 66, Company Cases Page 232 holding that the winding up court could not investigate into the question of rate and quantum of interest and unless it was established that the amount claimed was either agreed upon or admitted or decreed by a competent court, the amount did not become a debt. The learned Judge came to the conclusion on the facts of that case that the amount claimed as interest had yet to be established as a debt inspite of the fact that the principal amount was paid in the proceedings for winding up initiated by the creditor. In the present case the petitioner has specified the balance amount payable by the company and specified the rate of interest at 18% p.a, Due dates when the balance price of the goods was payable have also been specified. The rest is a matter of mathematical calculation and the petition for winding up cannot be dismissed on the ground that mathematical calculation as to the amount of interest have not been stated. The exact amount of interest payable is likely to change depending upon the time when the payment of the principal amount is made. The court in its discretion, on consideration of all the facts and circumstances of the case and the financial market conditions, in the absence of agreement as to rate of interst between the parties, can award a reasonable rate of interest. There may not be a specific contract for payment of interest but if the contract provides for payment of the price of the goods by a particular date it is clear that the creditor would ordinarily be entitled to interest if the amount is not paid by the due dates. As noticed above, the court has discretion to award interest at a reasonable rate on the amount of price from the date on which the price was payable to the seller. Unlike the facts of the cited decision the petitioner has been writing to the company that in case the outstanding balance is not released the petitioner will be constrained to charge overdue interest at 18% p.a from the due dates of payment till realisation. With utmost respect, I am unable to concur with the opinion expressed by learned single Judge in the cited decision to the effect that winding up court cannot investigate into a question of rate and quantum of interest even where (he principal amount is admitted by the company and paid in the course of the winding up proceedings. I am in respectful agreement with the opinion expressed by a Division Bench of the Punjab & Haryana High Court in Stephen Chemical Limited v. Innosearch Limited, 60 Company Cases Page 702 and single Bench decision of the same court in Delhi Cloth & General Milla Co. Ltd. v. Stepan Chemicals Limited, 60, Company Cases Page 1046 to the effect that the forum of the Company Judge is the appropriate forum for determining as to whether the creditor is entitled to interest where the company admits its liability and, in fact, pays the amount.

    My conclusion is that in a case where the liabilitty to pay the principal amount is not disputed by the company the creditor need not be forced to initiate separate litigation for recovery of the interest amount and the interest amount can be determined by the Company Judge in the winding up proceedings and on failure of the company to pay that amount the Company can be ordered to be wound up on the ground that it is unable to pay its debts.

    The validity of the letters of demand is challenged by the Company on the ground that in the letters of demand the petitioner has not stated as to what would be the consequences in case of non payment of the amount and thus it is contended that the letters alleged as “notices of demand” are not legal and do not constitute proper demand as required by section 434(1)(a) of the Act. section 434(1)(a) reads as under:—

    “A Company shall be deemed to be unable to pay its debts-(a) If a creditor, by assignment or otherwise, to whom the company is indebted in a sum exceeding five hundred rupees then due, has served on the company, by causing it to be delivered at its registered office, by registered post or otherwise, a demand under his hand requiring the company to pay the sum so due and the company has for three weeks thereafter neglected to pay the sum, or to secure or compound for it to the reasonable satisfaction of the creditor.”

    The aforesaid provision do not require the creditor to state in the notice as to what would be the consequences if the sum due is not paid by the company to the creditor. Under section 434(1)(a) presumption about insolvency of the company is liable to be drawn where the creditor serves on the company a demand requiring it to pay the sum due and in case the company for three weeks after service of demand neglects to pay the sum or to secure or compound for it to the reasonsable satisfaction of the creditor. Neither the Act nor the Rules provide for any particular form of demand. It is also well settled that in the demand served on the company under section 434(1)(a) the non specification of the period of three weeks does not result in invalidating the demand. According to Palmer's Company Precedents(Part II) 17th Edition (Page 26) the demand need not be in a special form. It need not use the word “demand”. A pre-emptory request or “call” for payment would no doubt suffice. A demand in excess of what is due can still be a valid statutory demand. It is correct that the petitioner in the letters sent to the company requesting it to make payment of the balance outstanding amount with interest at 18% p.a has not stated as to what consequences will follow and what he will do in case payment as requested was not made but, in my opinion, it does not affect the validity of the demands made by the petitioner from the company. The law does not require that demand must recite a threat for proceeding for winding up in case of non payment. (See N.K Gossain and Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. Dytron (India) Ltd., 1990 Company Cases Vol. 69 Page 757-Calcutta High Court). With respect I am unable to agree with the opinion expressed by Allahabad High Court in Paramjit Lal Badhwar v. Prem Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd., 60, Company Cases Page 420 and the opinion of Kerala High Court in K. Suresh Shenoy v. Cochin Stock Exchange Ltd., (1988) 3 Company Law Journal 350 to the effect that though in the notice sought to be given under section 434(1)(a) it is not necessary that there should be an indication that it is given under section 434(1)(a) and there is no specified mention of that section, there should be some indication given to the company that in the case of non compliance with the terms of the notice, the creditor will take steps for the winding up of the company. The law does not prescribe any such requirement. It also seems that an earlier decision of Allahabad High Court in Babu Ram and another v. Krishna Bharadwaj Cold Stores and General Mills Co. (P) Ltd. and others, 1965 (2) C.L.J Page 215 was not brought to the notice of the learned Judge which decided the case of Paramjit Lal Badhwar (Supra). In Babu Ram's case it was held that the law does not require that the notice must recite a threat of a proceeding for winding up in case of non payment. In my view, prima facie, the letters dated 10th May 1990, 6th June 1990 and 30th June 1990 constitute a valid demand under section 434(1)(a) of the Act.

    The petitioner is claiming interest at the rate of 18% p.a In my opinion, in the facts and circumstances of the case, 12% would be just and reasonable rate of interest. The company is, therefore, liable to pay to the petitioner interest calculated at 12% p.a on Rs. 1,15,000/- from 1st March 1990 till the payment of that amount was made to the petitioner in these proceedings. The parties may calculate the exact amount of interest. The company may make the payment of interest amount to the petitioner on or before 20th November 1992.

    In case payment as directed by this order is not made it will be presumed that the company is unable to pay and the petition shall stand admitted and the petitioner will take steps to get the citation published in ‘Statesmen’, ‘Jansatta’ and ‘Delhi Gazette’ indicating that the petition will be listed before court on 26th February, 1993.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Devendra Kumar Jain. v. Polar Forgings & Tools Ltd
    (Nov 3, 1992)