(Judgment of the Court was delivered by P.SATHASIVAM, J.)
The above Writ Appeal has been filed against the order of the learned
single Judge, dated 07.02.2004, made in W.P.18730 of 1996, in and by which,
the learned Judge quashed the declaration issued under Section-6 of the Land
Acquisition Act and permitted the Government to proceed further by issuing
another Declaration under Section-6 within the prescribed time limit. Not
satisfied with the limited relief granted, the Writ Petitioner has filed the
above Appeal.
2. Heard Mr.A.S.Vijayaragavan, learned counsel for the appellant and
learned Additional Government Pleader for the respondents.
3. At the foremost, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that
the writ petitioner/appellant is the daughter of one Thiruvenkatasamy, who
owned lands in S. Nos.267/5 and 268/3, Ganapathi Village, Coimbatore Taluk.
According to him, the said lands and other surrounded lands were sought to be
acquired at the instance of the Tamil Nadu Housing Board for construction of
houses under Ganapathi Neighbourhood scheme, Phase-II. It is further pointed
out that the petitioner's father Thiruvenkatasamy died way back on 06.3.1987,
however, Notification under Section 4(1), which was published in the
Government Gazette on 14.06.1995, was issued in the name of the said
Thiruvenkatasamydead person. It is also brought to our notice that the
petitioner/ appellant, on hearing the news that the authorities are taking
steps to acquire her father's lands, submitted her objection, wherein, it is
specifically stated that her father died long back leaving behind herself as
the only legal heir. She also mentioned that the notice/ Notification issued
on dead person is illegal, improper and void. She further stated that though
this aspect was specifically pointed out during the 5-A enquiry, even in the
subsequent declaration, the respondents did not carry out necessary changes
and issued the same only in the name of dead person, ie., Thiruvenkatasaamy.
In such circumstances, according to the counsel, the learned Judge, having
accepted the case of the petitioner, ought to have quashed the entire
proceedings including Notification under Section 4(1).
4. We verified the 4(1) Notification, 5-A enquiry proceedings and
Sec.6 Declaration. As rightly pointed out, in the Notification and
Declaration, it is stated that Thiruvenkatasamy is the owner of the lands in
S. Nos.267/5 and 268/3. We have already referred to the written objection
filed by the petitioner, who is none else than the daughter of the said
Thiruvenkatasamy, to the effect that her father died on 6.3.1987. In such
circumstances, it is but proper on the part of the Land Acquisition Officer to
rectify the mistake in all the proceedings including 4(1) Notification. The
Notification issued in the name of dead person is a nullity and the
proceedings cannot be continued based on the said Notification.
5. This Court, in Muthusamy v. The State of Tamil Nadu (1993 (1)
M.L.J. 217); Devaraj v. State of Tamil Nadu (2003 (4) CTC 134); Asiya
Mariyan v The Secretary to Government of Tamil Nadu (2000 (4) CTC 125 ); and
in series of other decisions, held that Notice/Notification issued in the name
of dead person and the proceedings with respect to the said lands cannot be
sustained. By applying the said principle, we accept the contention of the
learned counsel for the appellant and quash the Notification issued under
Section 4(1), dated 14.06.1995. Consequently, Writ Appeal is allowed. No
costs. Connected Miscellaneous Petition stands closed. It is made clear that
the respondents are free to proceed with the acquisition, if they so desire,
by initiating fresh proceedings in accordance with law.
JI.
To
1. Secretary to Government,
Housing and Urban Development
Department, Fort St. George,
Madras-9.
2. Special Tahsildar
(Land Acquisition),
Housing Scheme No.II,
Coimbatore-18.