AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition was filed by a Director of Amalgamated Commercial Traders (Private) Ltd. seeking leave to inspect documents and obtain certified copies of records relating to T.C. No. 218 of 1959 (an Income-tax Reference) for use in Company Petition No. 87 of 1964 (winding-up) and in Civil Suit C.S. No. 65 of 1964 (filed by the Company against several defendants, including A.C.K. Krishnaswami). In C.S. No. 65 of 1964 the company sought, among other reliefs, a decree against defendants 1 and 2 for Rs. 2,25,000 with interest, alleging that the first defendant received Rs. 3,15,000 as surrender value of a lease and misappropriated sums belonging to the Company.

Defendants in the suit (defendants 2 and 3) filed Company Petition No. 87 of 1964 for winding up the Company and referred to T.C. No. 218 of 1959 to challenge the Company's right to the magnesite lease. The excerpted portion of the T.C. No. 218 judgment indicated the Bench's conclusion that, although the lease was nominally in the Company's name, the beneficial interest belonged to the assessee (A.C.K. Krishnaswami).

The Company was not a party to T.C. No. 218 of 1959. The Director therefore sought inspection and copies of the Reference records either to defend the company petitions/suit or to prosecute a contemplated review or appeal against the Reference judgment. The petition was opposed by A.C.K. Krishnaswami and the Income-tax Department, and the Court considered whether inspection and certified copies should be granted in advance of any review petition or appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a party who was not a party to an Income-tax Reference (T.C. No. 218 of 1959) is entitled, prior to filing a review petition or appeal, to inspect and obtain certified copies of documents on the Reference file for the purpose of preparing such review/appeal or for use in separate civil/company proceedings.
  2. Whether documents produced in Income-tax proceedings are protected from disclosure by statutory provision(s) (including historical provisions of the Income-tax Act) and, if so, whether any such protection survives repeal by later legislation (with reference to the General Clauses Act, Section 6).
  3. Whether the High Court, when hearing an Income-tax Reference under Section 66, exercises ordinary civil jurisdiction (and therefore whether civil rules on inspection and copying apply), or whether the jurisdiction is special/advisory and civil procedural rules do not apply.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's (Company's) Arguments

  • The Company was not a party to T.C. No. 218 of 1959, so the Bench's finding that A.C.K. Krishnaswami was the real owner is not binding on the Company; the Company therefore wishes to seek remedy against that judgment (by review or appeal) and requires inspection and copies to prepare such proceedings.
  • Inspection and certified copies were required for defending Company Petition No. 87 of 1964 and for prosecuting C.S. No. 65 of 1964.
  • The petitioner contended that the repeal of statutory protection (Section 137/earlier provisions) meant protection had been taken away and that the Company should therefore be able to obtain documents; the petitioner relied on that legislative change as a basis for disclosure.

Respondent A.C.K. Krishnaswami's Arguments

  • The application was not bona fide and amounted to a request for a roving inspection of Krishnaswami's documents for ulterior purposes.
  • If documents were required for defending or prosecuting Company Petition No. 87 of 1964 or C.S. No. 65 of 1964, the Company should obtain them in those proceedings rather than by this petition.
  • Inspection and copying in contemplation of a review petition or appeal should not be entertained before those proceedings are instituted.
  • Certain documents are confidential because they relate to Income-tax proceedings and therefore copies should not be granted.

Income-tax Department's Arguments (as advanced by their counsel)

  • The High Court's jurisdiction in a Reference under Section 66 of the Income-tax Act is a special, advisory jurisdiction distinct from its ordinary civil jurisdiction; the High Court does not exercise appellate or revisional jurisdiction over the Tribunal in such References.
  • Income-tax proceedings are revenue, not civil, proceedings; civil rules of practice and the Appellate Side Rules do not apply to them, and the High Court's civil rules for inspection and copies are thus inapplicable.
  • Under Section 54 of the Income-tax Act, 1922, documents produced in an Income-tax enquiry were treated as confidential; although later provisions (Section 51 → Section 137) were repealed by the Finance Act, 1964, Section 6 of the General Clauses Act preserves rights, privileges or obligations acquired under a repealed enactment unless a different intention appears, so the Department contended the confidentiality protection still subsists.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Income-tax v. Scindia Steam Navigation Co. Ltd., 1962-1 SCR 788 (AIR 1961 SC 1633) That jurisdiction of a High Court in a Reference under Section 66 is special and advisory; High Court does not exercise appellate/revisional/supervisory jurisdiction over the Tribunal. Cited to support the proposition that proceedings under Section 66 are special/advisory and not ordinary civil proceedings; used to show civil procedural rules are not automatically applicable to Income-tax References.
Petlad Turkey Red Dye Works Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax, 1963-1 SCJ 248 (AIR 1963 SC 1484) Confirmed that High Court jurisdiction under Section 66 is purely advisory and confined to opinion on questions of law arising from Tribunal orders. Reinforced the Court's view that Rules applicable to civil suits/appeals do not apply to Income-tax References because the jurisdiction is advisory.
First Additional Income-Tax Officer v. R. Shanmugha Rajeswara Sethupathi, ILR (1963) Mad 620 (AIR 1963 Mad 190) Held that Income-tax proceedings do not fall within the expression "civil proceedings". Used as local authority to support the view that Income-tax proceedings are revenue proceedings and civil procedural rules (including inspection/copy provisions) are not applicable.
Chettiappan v. Income Tax Officer, ILR (1964) 2 Mad 704 Reiterated that Income-tax proceedings are revenue proceedings; held that a certificate under Article 133(1)(c) of the Constitution could not be granted in such context. Adopted to show the consistent stance of this Court that Income-tax matters are not civil proceedings and thus to circumscribe the application of civil procedural norms.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying the narrow issue properly before it: whether inspection and certified copies of documents on the Income-tax Reference file should be furnished now to enable the petitioner to file a contemplated review petition or an appeal.

Key steps in the Court's reasoning were:

  1. The Court observed strained relations between the parties but excluded irrelevant allegations from its decision-making analysis.
  2. The petitioner had already been permitted to peruse the judgment in T.C. No. 218 of 1959 and to note particulars of documents referred to in the judgment; the petitioner was directed to furnish a list of specific documents with reasons if he sought inspection beyond the judgment itself. This was intended to establish, prima facie, that specific documents existed on which the Bench had relied.
  3. After perusing the judgment, the petitioner filed a further affidavit but did not identify particular documents or give specific reasons; instead he made a general statement that the High Court might not have been fully apprised of the circumstances and therefore inspection of documents referred to in paragraph 6 of the affidavit was necessary.
  4. The Court emphasised that the petitioner was not a party to the Income-tax Reference and therefore the Bench's decision in T.C. No. 218 is not binding on the petitioner; the Company's only immediate purpose in seeking inspection before instituting review or appeal was to correct what it considered an erroneous conclusion.
  5. The Court examined the judgment to determine whether the Bench had relied on particular documents for reaching the pivotal conclusion (that the lease benefited A.C.K. Krishnaswami). The Court found that references in the judgment (to Tribunal orders, to certain pages of typed papers, to cheque books and accounting entries) were either general or used for subsidiary findings (e.g., the assessee's capacity to carry on business), and were not relied upon as decisive documentary foundation for concluding the lease benefited the assessee rather than the Company.
  6. The Court noted that the petitioner is in possession of the Company's account books and that, from certain cheque books produced by Krishnaswami at the Income-tax proceedings, it would not follow that the Company is entitled to a sweeping inspection of all of Krishnaswami's private cheque books.
  7. The Court concluded that on the available materials it could not be stated that the Bench had relied upon any particular document such that inspection of that document should be ordered now. Therefore the petitioner had not made out a prima facie case to warrant inspection and certified copies for the purpose of a contemplated review or appeal.
  8. On the legal question of statutory confidentiality, the Court recorded the competing submissions: (a) that earlier statutory provisions treated Income-tax inquiry documents as confidential but had been repealed; and (b) the Department's contention that under Section 6 of the General Clauses Act rights acquired under a repealed enactment survive unless a different intention appears. The Court considered these arguments interesting but explicitly stated it was unnecessary to decide that question for the present petition because the petitioner had failed on merits to show entitlement to inspection and copies.
  9. The Court directed the office to furnish a certified copy of the judgment to the petitioner (so far as the judgment itself), and left open the route that, upon filing a review petition or appeal, the appropriate Court could determine whether inspection or copying of particular documents should be permitted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition for inspection of documents and for certified copies was DISMISSED.

Implications and immediate effects:

  • The petitioner was not granted inspection of the Reference file or certified copies of documents at this stage, apart from being furnished with a certified copy of the judgment itself.
  • The Court made clear that the petitioner may obtain necessary documents in the ordinary course in Company Petition No. 87 of 1964 or Civil Suit C.S. No. 65 of 1964, or may file a review petition or appeal and then apply for inspection/copies before the court hearing that review/appeal, which will decide whether particular documents were relied on and should be produced.
  • No definitive ruling was made on the broader statutory question whether confidentiality rights under prior provisions of the Income-tax Act survive repeal by later enactments via operation of the General Clauses Act; the Court observed the point but found it unnecessary to decide in this petition.
  • There was no order as to costs.

The opinion confines its decision to the specific procedural question at hand and does not establish a new principle beyond applying existing appellate and High Court authorities to deny pre-proceedings, general inspection/copy requests when no specific documents have been identified as having been relied upon by the deciding Bench.

    Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P.) Ltd. v. A.C.K Krishnaswami .

    1. This petition is filed by a Director of Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P.) Ltd., for leave to inspect the documents relating to proceedings in T.C No. 218 of 1959, and for grant of the copies of documents for the purpose of their defence in Company Petition No. 87 of 1964 and for prosecuting C.S No. 65 of 1964. The Company, Amalgamated Commercial Traders Pvt. Ltd., filed a suit C.S No. 65 of 1964 against A.C.K Krishnaswami, Hariprasad, Smt. Godavari Bhai and Factors (P.) Ltd. In this suit the company, amongst other reliefs, prayed for a decree against defendants 1 and 2 jointly and severally for a sum of Rs. 2,25,000 with interest at 6% per annum from the date of suit. The contention of the plaintiff Company is that the first defendant received a sum of Rs. 3,15,000 as and for the surrender value of a lease, and appropriated the proceeds which properly belonged to the Company. The suit is resisted by the defendants and is pending before the Original Side of this Court. Defendants 2 and 3 in the suit filed Com. P. No. 87 of 1964 for winding up of the Company, Amalgamated Commercial Traders Pvt. Ltd. In that application they have referred to T.C No. 218 of 1959 on the file of this Court for the purpose of negativing the right of the Company to the magnesite Lease. The portion of the judgment extracted in the affidavit is as follows:—

    “We are further satisfied that, though the Amalgamated Commercial Traders (Private) Limited was the formal lessee on record from the inception of these transactions it must have been understood quite clearly between the assessee and the Amalgamated Commercial Traders (Private) Limited that the beneficial interest in the lease should belong to the assessee…… We have endeavoured to show and we find it satisfactorily established that notwithstanding that the lease stood nominally in the name of the Amalgamated Commercial Traders (Private) Limited the true beneficiary was the assessee himself….”

    2. In this petition it is contended on behalf of the Company that the company was not a party to the reference Application, T.G No. 218 of 1959, and that the finding of the Bench in its absence that A.C.K Krishnaswami is the real owner is not binding on it, and that as the decision affected the Company adversely it was desirous of seeking its remedy against the judgment by appropriate proceedings. Though in the petition it was stated that inspection and copies of the documents were required for the defence in Comp. P. No. 87 of 1964 and for prosecuting the suit, C.S No. 65 of 1964, it was contended in this Court that the Company was contemplating relief against the judgment by review or by an appeal to the Supreme Court and therefore inspection and grant of certified copies of documents was necessary.

    3. This petition is strongly opposed by the first respondent A.C.K Krishnaswami, on the ground that the application is not bona fide, and that the intention of the petitioner was to have a roving inspection into his documents for ulterior purposes, and that if any document was required for the purpose of prosecuting Comp. P. No. 87 of 1964 or C.S No. 65 of 1964 the Company might have taken steps to obtain the documents in those proceedings.

    4. If the petitioner contemplated a review or appeal to the Supreme Court he might have taken appropriate steps and then asked for relief, and this petition for inspection and copies of the documents in contemplation of the filing of the review petition or an appeal to the Supreme Court should not be entertained. It was also contended that the documents were in the nature of confidential documents as they related to income-tax proceedings and therefore copies should not be granted.

    5. It is clear from the affidavits filed by the parties that the relationship between the parties is very strained. Several allegations made in the affidavit may not be quite relevant for deciding the question whether the inspection of the documents should be allowed and copies of the same should be granted to it and therefore it is unnecessary to refer to these allegations.

    6. If the petitioner requires the documents for the purpose of his defence in the Company petition or in the original suit it will be appropriate for him to take the necessary steps in those proceedings. So also if the petitioner seeks to have the judgment in T.C No. 218 of 1959 reviewed or seeks to prefer an appeal before the Supreme Court, he may after filing the review petition or the appeal pray for and obtain relief from either this Court or the Supreme Court. In this petition all that has to be considered is whether for the purpose of enabling the petitioner to file the contemplated review petition or appeal, inspection of the documents should be allowed and copies thereof furnished to it. When this petition came up for hearing on 20th April, 1965, the petitioner was permitted to have an inspection of the judgment of this Court in T.C No. 218 of 1959. The petitioner's Counsel was also permitted to note the particulars of the documents referred to in the judgment and if he felt that certain documents have not been properly construed and that he should have inspection of the documents he was directed to furnish a list of such documents with the reasons why he wanted inspection of those documents. This direction was given to enable the petitioner to convince this Court prima facie that certain documents had to be inspeced. In pursuance of the order of this Court the petitioner perused the judgment in T.C No. 218 of 1959, and filed a further affidavit on 23rd April 1965. The petitioner has not made reference to specific documents or given reasons why the documents should be inspected by him but generally stated that it appeared to him that the High Court was not appraised of all the circumstances of the transactions and therefore it was just and necessary that inspection should be granted regarding the documents referred to in Paragraph 6 of the affidavit. In Paragraph 6 of the affidavit he has prayed for inspection of records and proceedings in T.C No. 218 of 1959 on the file of the court from the time of the reference from the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal till its disposal, and for grant of copies of typed papers and documents referred to at the time of the hearing in T.C No. 218 of 1959. Copies of the orders of the Tribunal and relevant portions of the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and the Income-tax Officers order were also sought for. In effect the petitioner has asked for inspection of all the documents and for certified copies of the documents.

    7. As was pointed out at the outset in this petition, this Court is concerned only with making available material that may be necessary for the petitioner to prefer a review petition. It is only if and when a review petition is filed, the Court that decided T.C No. 218 of 1959 may be in a position to find on which documents the Court rested its conclusion that the lease was in favour of A.C.K Krishnaswami and not the Company, and direct inspection of those documents and for furnishing copies of the documents.

    8. At this stage unless it is shown that the conclusion was arrived at by the Bench by relying on certain documents and that those documents should be inspected, it will not be proper to grant the request of the petitioner. In this connection it is necessary to note that if the petitioner wants the documents for the defence in the suit he can obtain them in proceedings in the suit. The petitioner was not a party in T.C No. 218 of 1959 and therefore the decision of the Bench in the Income-tax Reference will not be binding on the petitioner. So the only purpose in preferring the review petition or an appeal is for correcting what according to the petitioner is an erroneous conclusion. The petitioner has not stated that the Bench has relied on any particular document, and that he should be permitted to have inspection of that document. For the purpose of finding out whether the Bench has relied on any particular document for coming to the conclusion that the lease was in fact in favour of A.C.K Krishnaswami, I referred to the Bench in T.C No. 218 of 1959. In Paragraph 22 a reference is made to the Appellate Judgment of the Tribunal. But that reference is only for the purpose of coming to the conclusion that the assessee was well qualified to start an undertaking of the kind in which he engaged himself. Again in Paragraph 25 the order of the Tribunal is referred to for the purpose of dissenting from the view of the Appellate Tribunal that the assessee had no real intention of carrying on the business. In Paragraph 34 another passage in the order of the Tribunal is referred to and in Paragraph 35, page 70 of the typed papers is referred to. But these references are not relied upon for the purpose of deciding the question whether A.C.K Krishnaswami is the person for whose benefit the lease was taken.

    9. Again in Paragraph 37 reference is made to the absence of separate private accounts of the assessee. It is further stated that the assessee produced before the Tribunal his cheque books to show that some of the payments for the maintenance of the mines and for the running of the Salem Office were made directly by him. The Bench proceeds to observe that these entries do find a place in the books of the Company itself. In this connection it may be stated that the petitioner is in possession of all the account books of the Amalgamated Commercial Traders (Private) Ltd. From a mere reference to certain cheque books produced by A.C.K Krishnaswami in the Income-tax proceedings it cannot be contended that the Company is entitled to inspection of all the cheque books of A.C.K Krishnaswami. The petitioner may rely on the Company's accounts in the original suit, O.S No. 65 of 1964, or in the Company Petition No. 87 of 1964 or in the review petition and convince the Court that the Company was the real lessee, and not A.C.K Krishnaswami. But on the materials available, it cannot be stated that the Bench relied on a particular document for coming to its conclusion and therefore the petitioner is entitled to inspection and copies of those documents. The Office was directed to furnish a certified copy of the judgment to the petitioner. It is upto the petitioner to file a review petition or an appeal and convince the concerned Court that he is entitled to inspection and copies of the documents. But it this stage I am not convinced that for the purpose of the contemplated review or the appeal the petitioner is entitled to inspection of the documents or for having copies thereof. On this ground this petition is dismissed.

    10. As copies of documents which were filed in Income-tax proceedings were prayed for, notice was ordered to the Income-tax Counsel. Mr. Balasubramaniam, the learned Counsel, appeared on behalf of the Department. He submitted that the High Court exercising powers under Section 66 of the Income-tax Act is not an appellate Court and was only exercising special jurisdiction which is different from a Civil Court, and that the function of the High Court was one purely advisory in nature. He also submitted that the Income-tax proceedings are not civil proceedings but were revenue proceedings, to which neither Civil Rules of Practice nor the Appellate Side Rules would apply, and that the rules made by the High Court for inspection of documents and grant of copies thereof in the exercise of its civil jurisdiction are not applicable to Income-tax proceedings he pointed out that while Section 66(A)(3) of the Income-tax Act made the Civil Procedure Code applicable to Income-tax proceedings before the Supreme Court, no similar provision is made regarding proceedings before the High Court. He further submitted that, there was an express provision under Section 54 of the Income-tax Act of 1922, which treated the documents produced in an Income-tax enquiry as confidential and prohibited Courts from divulging any of the materials. Section 51 of the Income-tax Act, 1922, was repealed by the Act of 1961 and re-enacted as Section 137. Section 137 of the Act of 1961-was repealed by the Finance Act of 1964. As the Act stands at present the documents are not treated as confidential but the learned Counsel would contend that by application of Section 6 Clause (c) of the General Clauses Act unless a, different intention appears, the repeal of an enactment will not affect any right, privilege, obligation or a liability acquired, or accrued or incurred under an enactment so repealed and therefore the right of the assessee not to have his documents disclosed has not been repealed as no different intention appears in the Finance Act of 1964.

    11. It has been held by the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income-tax v. Scindia Steam Navigation Co. Ltd. 1962-1 SCR 788 : (AIR 1961 SC 1633), that the jurisdiction of a Court in a Reference under Section 66 is a special one different from its ordinary jurisdiction as a Civil Court, and the High Court hearing a Reference under that section does not exercise any appellate or revisional or supervisory jurisdiction over the Tribunal, and that it acts purely in an advisor) capacity on a Reference which properly comes before it under Section 66(1) and (2).

    12. Again in Petlad Turkey Red Dye Works Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-tax Bombay, North Ahmedabad, 1963-1 SCJ 248 : (AIR 1963 SC 1484), the Supreme Court held that the jurisdiction of the High Court under Section 66 of the Indian Income-tax Act is purely advisory and is confined to giving opinion on a question of law, arising out of the order of the Appellate Tribunal.

    13. This Court in a case reported in First Additional Income-Tax Officer v. R. Shanmugha Rajeswara Sethupathi ILR (1963) Mad 620 : (AIR 1963 Mad 190), held that the Income-tax proceedings cannot come within the scope of the expression ‘civil proceedings’. The same view was reiterated by this Court in Chettiappan v. Income Tax Officer, ILR (1964) 2 Mad 704, where it was held that the Income-tax proceedings are revenue proceedings and that a certificate under Article 133(1)(c) of the Constitution could not be granted. From the decisions cited above, it is clear that the proceedings under the Indian Income-tax Act are not civil proceedings, and that the jurisdiction of the High Court is purely advisory in nature and therefore the rules relating to suits and appeals in exercise of the civil jurisdiction are not applicable to these proceedings.

    14. While it is contended on behalf of the Income-tax Department that in spite of the repeal of Section 137 of the Income-tax Act of 1961, under Section 6 of the General Clauses Act the right of the assessee to his affairs not having disclosed is still protected, the learned Counsel for the petitioner would contend that the protection granted under Section 137 has been taken away and that an intention to take away the protection is apparent from the repeal itself which would exclude the operation of Section 6 of the General Clauses Act, it was further contended on behalf of the petitioner that while Section 138 of the 1961 Act as amended by Act V of 1964 a provision is made for application to the Commissioner for information in respect of an assessment made on or after 1st April 1960, no corresponding revision is made regarding assessment made before 1st April, 1960 and this would imply that the Legislature intended that no protection should be given regarding information in respect of assessment made before 1st April, 1960 Though the question raised by learned Counsel is interesting, it is unnecessary to decide the question in this petition. For as already observed even if it is taken that there is no prohibition against inspection or furnishing of copies of the documents, the petitioner has failed to make out a case on merits for inspection and for giant of copies of documents. The petition is dismissed. No order as to costs.

    FK/MBR/D.V.C

    15. Petition dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Amalgamated Commercial Traders (P.) Ltd. v. A.C.K Krishnaswami .
    (Jun 21, 1965)