AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Dharmadhikari, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was filed by the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation (MSRTC) against an Award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Sangli in Motor Accidents Claim No. 33 of 1980. The Tribunal had awarded Rs. 36,000 with future interest at 9% per annum from the date of application until realisation, by order dated 29th September 1982.

The underlying facts (admitted) are that on 5 April 1980 at about 5:30 p.m. on the Sangli–Indapur Road, a collision occurred between an S.T. bus and a motor-cycle carrying two persons. Moula Babalal Mulani (the deceased) was driving the motor-cycle and Rambhau Dhondiram Shinde was pillion rider. Moula died at the spot. Moula's parents filed Motor Accidents Claim No. 33 of 1980 claiming Rs. 1,00,000. The Tribunal, after evidence (including panchnama, testimony of the pillion rider, bus driver, conductor and other witnesses) and inspection of the spot, held both the motor-cycle driver (deceased Moula) and the bus driver equally responsible (50:50), applied a multiplier of 25 and, after deductions and additions, reduced for contributory negligence, awarded Rs. 36,000 to the dependents.

The MSRTC challenged (first) the Tribunal's findings on liability, the apportionment of contributory negligence, and the quantum of compensation (including the method of arriving at the amount). The appeal was argued before Dharmadhikari, J., who dismissed the appeal with costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the bus driver was responsible for the accident or whether the motor-cycle driver (deceased Moula) was solely or primarily responsible (including the significance of the absence of a driving licence).
  2. Whether the apportionment of contributory negligence at 50:50 was correct or whether a greater share (suggested 75% against the motor-cyclist) should have been fixed.
  3. Whether the Tribunal's method of fixing compensation (multiplier method, deductions and additions) produced an excessive award that should be reduced by reference to the interest a prudent investor could earn on a lump-sum (the "interest theory" or discount-for-lump-sum argument).
  4. What orders should be made concerning funds already deposited (in the event the appellants deposited the awarded amount in court).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (MSRTC) Arguments

  • The motor-cycle was driven by the deceased Moula who had no driving licence; he was inexperienced and driving at high speed and on the wrong side, and therefore his rash driving caused the accident; the bus was being driven properly on the left side at a low speed (about 30 km/h).
  • Accordingly, the tribunal should have held the motor-cycle driver solely responsible, or at least apportioned contributory negligence in the ratio 75:25 against the motor-cycle driver (75% motor-cycle, 25% bus).
  • The quantum of compensation awarded is disproportionately high. The Tribunal should have reconsidered the lump-sum by taking into account the interest the claimants would receive if they invested the award (relying on several authorities including Jaikumar Chhaganlal Patni v. Mary Jerome D'Souza and other cases).

Respondent's (Claimants / Respondent No. 3) Arguments

  • The finding that Moula did not hold a driving licence is not determinative of his ability to drive; evidence showed he owned and drove a Rajdoot motor-cycle for 5–7 years, and therefore inference of inexperience is unwarranted.
  • The Tribunal correctly concluded that both drivers were negligent and equally responsible; the apportionment at 50:50 is reasonable and should not be interfered with.
  • The quantum of compensation fixed by the Tribunal is just and fair and not disproportionate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jaikumar Chhaganlal Patni v. Mary Jerome D'Souza, A.I.R. 1978 Bom. 239 The appellant relied on this decision to argue that a "second thought" should be given to lump-sum awards by considering interest likely to be earned on prudent investment (discount for lump-sum). The Court held that the observations in para 17 of that judgment (dealing with discounting of lump-sum) were not directly applicable to this controversy and refused to accept the broad proposition that compensation should be further reduced on the basis of interest realizable on lump-sum investments when the correct multiplier and deductions have already been applied.
Smt. Sushila Devi v. Ibrahim, A.I.R. 1974 M.P. 181 The Madhya Pradesh High Court's observations (quoted in the opinion) that when a lump sum is received it will earn interest and therefore the multiplier may be smaller than the plain number of years; the prudent person is expected to invest and use it gradually. The Court noted those observations but considered them irrelevant to the present case's controversy; the quoted passage was discussed and its applicability limited in context.
Balubhai Hirji Gajlar v. Sureshkumar Nathuram, A.I.R. 1977 M.P. 58 The opinion lists this case among those relied upon by the appellant; the text does not set out a specific rule or principle from it. The Court did not specifically describe application of this authority in reasoning; it was part of the list of authorities relied upon by the appellant but no discrete application is recorded in the opinion.
Flatchar v. Autocar and Transporters Ltd., 1969 A.C.J. 99 Listed by the appellant (and later the opinion discusses the English Court of Appeal's practice of looking at the overall figure and considering interest when assessing fairness of the award). The Court acknowledged that in Fletcher/Flatchar the Court of Appeal considered interest when reviewing overall compensation, but observed that the present Tribunal used the multiplier method and the interest-theory cannot be applied as an inflexible rule here.
Mailet v. Mc Monagle, 1969 A.C.J. 312 Listed by the appellant as authority where interest on lump-sum was taken into account in assessing compensation. The Court noted the decision as an example where interest was considered when reviewing a global figure, but held that such an approach is not a mandatory rule to apply after correct multiplier and deductions have been used.
Jokl Ram v. Smt. Naresh Kanta, A.I.R. 1977 Punjab & Haryana 214 The opinion quotes this Full Bench authority for the proposition that the "interest theory" cannot be adopted as an inflexible principle for assessing compensation, especially given inflation and erosion of purchasing power. The Court relied on this authority to support the view that interest-theory should not be rigidly applied in India and that monetary awards should not be automatically reduced on the assumption of prudent investment returns.
Motor Owners Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jadavji Keshavji Modi, (1981) 4 SCC 660; A.I.R. 1981 S.C. 2059 Quoted for the observation that delays in final disposal of compensation cases and inflation reduce the real value of awards, undermining the efficacy of compensation if recipients wait to receive money. The Court relied on the Supreme Court's observation to emphasise judicial notice of inflation and delay, reinforcing the rejection of the appellant's submission that lump sums should be reduced by reference to expected interest earnings.
Srisallam Devastanam v. Bhavanl Pramilamma, A.I.R. 1983 A.P. 297 Quoted for the view (approving Delhi High Court observations) that the benefit of lump-sum payment is offset by increase in prices and decrease in value of rupee. The Court cited this authority to support the conclusion that taking interest on lump-sums into account is not determinative and that inflationary considerations may offset any benefit from immediate payment.
Nav Bharat Builders v. Smt. Pyarabal w/o Dadu Mane, 1984 (2) Bombay Cases Reporter 9 Listed in relation to procedural guidelines for disposal of deposited amounts arising from an appeal or litigation. The Court directed the Tribunal to pass appropriate orders (after hearing claimants) in accordance with the guidelines laid down in the Nav Bharat Builders case if the appellants had deposited the awarded amount in Court.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the evidence, the panchnama and the Tribunal's inspection of the scene. The Tribunal's specific factual recitals (reproduced by the Court) included: the position and damage indicating contact in the middle of the far road; the right rear carrier of the motor-cycle had dashed the bumper and right front portion of the bus; blood and teeth found in the driver's cabin; the motor-cycle having gone about 35 feet and falling on the kacha road; and scratch marks and blood on the right side of the bus (the Tribunal's para 18 recitals are reproduced in the opinion).

The Court analysed eyewitness evidence: the pillion rider Shinde testified that the deceased had a Rajdoot motor-cycle for 5–7 years and had a driving licence (this evidence suggested experience with the motorcycle). Shinde said the bus was coming from the opposite side and dashed the motorcycle; he denied suggestions that the motor-cycle was doing 90–100 km/h. The bus driver admitted limited visibility around the turn and gave evidence of seeing the motorcycle when about 250–300 feet from the turn; he also claimed a low speed (about 15 km/h). The conductor admitted not personally seeing the accident but described the noise and the eventual positions of the vehicles and the motor-cycle.

From the combined evidence and panchnama recitals the Court agreed with the Tribunal that both vehicles were driven rashly/negligently and that both drivers owed a reciprocal duty to take greater care at the curve. The Court emphasised that absence of a driving licence does not necessarily mean inability to drive: the deceased owned and used the motor-cycle for several years, so a negative inference from non-production of licence was unsustainable.

On apportionment, the Court found the Tribunal's 50:50 division supported by facts and the evidence; it rejected the appellant's contention for a 75:25 split because the record did not justify such reallocation. The Tribunal's equal apportionment was therefore confirmed.

On quantum, the Court examined the appellant's submission (relying on several authorities) that compensation should be reduced by reference to interest a prudent investor would earn on the lump-sum. The Court reviewed precedent and contrasting approaches: while some English authorities had taken interest into account when revisiting an overall figure, the Court rejected any inflexible application of an "interest theory" in India. The reasons given included:

  • The Tribunal had employed the multiplier method (multiplier 25) appropriate to the deceased's age (25) and had made deductions (including a 25% deduction for lump-sum uncertainties), so no further discount was warranted.
  • Inflation and erosion of purchasing power (and delay in receiving awards) undermine any general assumption that interest earnings will compensate dependents; in the Indian context, interest theory cannot be an inflexible principle (citing Jokl Ram and Motor Owners Insurance Co. observations).
  • Prudent investment is not a realistic general assumption in the Indian context because of illiteracy/ignorance and the practical difficulties of achieving guaranteed real returns above inflation.

Consequently, the Court held that the Tribunal's method and figure were just and fair; no interference with quantum was warranted.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.

Direct consequences and orders:

  • The Tribunal's finding that both drivers were equally responsible (50:50) is confirmed.
  • The Tribunal's award of Rs. 36,000 (with interest at 9% per annum from the date of application till realisation) is upheld; the Court declined to reduce that award further on the basis of the interest-theory invoked by the appellant.
  • The Court directed that if the appellants have already deposited the awarded amount in Court, the Tribunal must pass appropriate orders in accordance with the guidelines of Nav Bharat Builders (1984 (2) Bom. C.R. 9), after giving the claimants an opportunity to be heard. The amount deposited in the Court will be subject to those Tribunal orders.

Broader implications: The opinion emphasises that the "interest theory" (discounting a lump-sum award on the ground that the recipients could earn interest) is not to be applied inflexibly in India. The Court reiterates the relevance of inflation, delay and practical difficulties of prudent investment when assessing whether further reduction of an awarded lump sum is appropriate. The judgment confirms the continued use of multiplier methodology combined with sensible deductions as an acceptable method for assessing dependency compensation in motor accident cases.

This summary has been prepared strictly from the text of the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond that opinion.

    Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Babalal Daud Mulani And Others .

    Per Dharmadhikari, J.:— This is an appeal filed by the Maharashtra, State Road transport Corporation against the Award made by the Motor, Accidents Claims Tribunal, Sangli, in Motor Accidents Claim No. 33 of 1980, awarding an amount of Rs. 36,000/- with future interest at the rate of 9 per cent per annum from the date of application till realisation of the amount, vide order dated 29th September 1982.

    2. It is an admitted position that an accident took place on 5th April 1980 at about 5-30 p.m on the Sangli-Indapur Road. It was the case of the claimants that on the evening of 5th April 1980 one Moula Babalal Mulani and Rambhau Dhondiram Shinde were returning to their village Mangrul from Tasgaon on a motor-cycle. Deceased Moula was driving motor-cycle and Shinde was sitting on the pillion seat. At about 5-19 p.m when they were negotiating a sharp curve, they were dashed by a S.T bus coming from the opposite side. The head of Moula was smashed and he died on the spot. For the death of Moula, his parents filed Motor Accidents Claim No. 33 of 1980, claiming a compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/-. For the injuries received by Rambhau Shinde, Motor Accidents Claim No. 34 of 1980 was filed. However, we are not concerned with the said claim as no appeal has been filed against the Award passed in the said Motor Accidents Claim. According to the claimants, the accidents took place because of the rash and negligent driving of the bus driver. These allegations were denied by the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation as well as the driver of the bus. According to the driver, Moula Babalal Mulani was not holding a driving licence at the time of the accident. He was driving the motor-cycle at a very high speed and in a rash and negligent manner and by the wrong side of the road. He was also not conversant with driving of the motor-cycle. Therefore, he could not control the motor-cycle on the curve and dashed against the S.T bus. In order to avoid the accident, the driver of the bus took his bus towards the left side end on the Katcha road, but the carrier on the rear side of the motor-cycle deshed against the bumper of the bus and the deceased Moula was killed because of this accident. Thus, according to the opponents, the accident took place because of the rash and negligent driving of Moula.

    3. In support of their respective cases, the parties relied upon the oral and documentary evidence. So far as the claimants are concerned, they examined Dr. Asrwade to prove the injuries caused to Shinde. Rambhau Shinde was examined as an eye-witness since he was sitting on the pillion seat of the motor-cycle. Witness No. 3 is the wife of the deceased Moula. On the other hand, the opponents examined Shankar Govind Gore, the driver of the bus, and the conductor Uttam Mahadik. The Police Officer was also examined to prove the panchnama.

    4. After appreciation all the evidence on record end after inspecting the spot, the learned Member of the Tribunal came to the conclusion that both i.e the deceased Moula, driver of the motor-cycle, as well as the bus driver were equally responsible for the accident. This responsibility was apportioned by the learned Member as 50:50. The learned Member, on the basis of the evidence adduced before him, came to the conclusion that the deceased might be spending at least on amount of Rs. 300/- per month for the family. Taking a multiplier of 25 and making certain deductions, the learned Member arrived at the figure of Rs. 67,500/- as the total compensation payable to the dependents of the deceased. To this he added Rs. 4,500/- towards shock and loss of company and affection and on the basis of the contributory negligence he reduced this amount by 50% and ultimately awarded Rs. 36,000/- as fair and just compensation to the dependents of the deceased. As already observed, it is this Award which is challenged in the present first Appeal.

    5. Shri Hegde, the learned Counsel appearing for the appellants, the Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, contended before us that the learned Member of the Tribunal committed an error in holding that the bus driver responsible was responsible for the accident. According to Shri Hegde, the motor-cycle was being driven by the deceased Moula, who had no driving licence. He was not conversant with the driving of the motor-cycle and in any case, there is no evidence on record to show this. The motor-cycle was being driven at a high speed with the pillion rider. The bus was being driven on the left side of the road at a speed which could not be more than 30 kilometres per hour and, therefore, the learned Member should have held that it was the driver of the motor-cycle who was rash and negligent in driving the motor-cycle and he alone was responsible for the accident. In the alternative, it is contended by Shri Hegde that in any case the apportionment of the contributory negligence should have been 75:25 viz. that it should have been held that the degree of negligence on the part of the motor-cycle driver was 75%. He then contended that in any case, the quantum of compensation awarded is disproportionately high. The learned Member should have fixed the compensation after taking into consideration the interest it will earn if the amount is invested prudently and that should have been the basis for fixing the compensation. In support of this contention, Shri Hegde has placed strong reliance upon the decision in 1(Jaikumar Chhaganlal Patni v. Mary Jerome D'Souza*), A.I.R 1978 Bom. 239, as also 2(Smt. Sushila Devi v. Ibrahim), A.I.R 1974 M.P 181, 3(Balubhai Hirji Gajlar v. Sureshkumar Nathuram), A.I.R 1977 M.P 58, 4(Flatchar v. Autocar and Transporters Ltd.), 1969 A.C.J 99 and 5(Mailet v. Mc Monagle) 1969 A.C.J 312.

    6. On the other hand, it is contended by Shri Apte, learned Counsel appearing for respondent No. 3, that the finding recorded by the learned Member that Moula was not holding any driving licence is in itself wrong-According to Shri Apte, in any case, the learned Member has rightly come, to the conclusion that the deceased used to drive a motor-cycle for a long time. He was the owner of a motor-cycle and, therefore, only because the driving licence is not forthcoming, an Inference cannot be drawn that the deceased Moula was not holding a driving licence or did not know how to drive a motor-cycle. According to Shri Apte, the apportionment of negligence by the learned Member in itself is on the higher side and, therefore, no interference is called for with the said finding. Shri Apte also, contended that the quantum of compensation fixed is just and fair and it cannot be said that the compensation awarded is disproportionate so as to call for an interference in this first appeal.

    7. With the assistance of the learned Counsel appearing for both the sides, we have gone through the entire evidence on record. In our opinion, the learned Member of the Tribunal was quite justified in drawing the following conclusions from the recitals of the panchnamas, which were also not disputed before us. This is what the learned Member has observed in para 18 of his judgment:

    “(i) The dash of the motor-cycle and the bus must be in the middle of the far road.

    (ii) The right rear carrier of the motor-cycle must have dashed the bumper and right front portion of the bus.

    (iii) The head of the deceased Moula must have dashed against the driver's cabin of the bus and that is why blood and hair were still attached to the cabin and some blood and two teeth of the deceased had fallen in the driver's cabin.

    (iv) The motor-cycle had gone ahead upto a distance of 35 ft. and then fallen on the kacha road towards west. It was there that the deceased must have finally fallen, because there was a big pool of blood near the handle of the motor-cycle.

    (v) While going ahead, the motor-cycle must have gone brushing the right portion of the bus as is clear from the scratch marks and sprinkling of blood on right side of the bus.”

    8. This is not the end of the matter. We have gone through the evidence of Shinde the pillion rider as well as the evidence of the bus driver and the conductor of the bus. Shinde has stated in his deposition that the deceased Moula was having a motor-cycle of Rajdoot Company at Jaunpur. He was having the motor-cycle for 5 to 7 years. According to him, Moula was having a driving licence. So far as the actual accident is concerned, it is stated by him that the S.T bus was coming from the opposite side. It was coming at a high speed, being a superfast bus. The bus was coming by the middle of the road end it was the bus which dashed against the motorcycle. Thereafter the bus stopped at a distance of 100 to 150 feet from the place of dash. It was suggested to him in the cross-examination that the motor-cycle was being driven at a speed of 90 to 100 kilometres, which suggestion was denied by the witness.

    9. So far as the evidence of the driver of the bus 19 concerned, in our opinion, the said evidence cannot help the appellants. The driver, Shri Gore, has admitted in his deposition that he saw a motor-cycle coming from the opposite side and at that time his bus was at a distance of about 250 to 300 feet from the turn. He then wanted to suggest that he was not a party to the panchanama. However, obviously the said versions is Incorrect. He admitted that it was true that while coming from Vita the driver of a vehicle cannot see the vehicle coming from beyond the turn till he goes upto the turn. He then stated that the driver of a vehicle at a distance of 150 ft. towards Vita side from the turn, can see a vehicle coming from beyond the turn. According to him, the speed of the bus was merely 15 kilometres per hour. The conductor of the bus, Uttam Mahadik, has tried to support the version given by the bus driver, but had to admit in cross examination that he had personally not seen the accident. He admitted that when the bus was at the turn, there was a big noise. He also admitted as correct that the motor cycle had fallen on the Katcha road at a distance of about 100 feet behind the S.T bus. Therefore, if this oral evidence is read together with the recitals in the panchnama, then, in our opinion, the learned Member of the Tribunal was wholly justified in drawing the conclusions as enumerated in para 18 of his judgment.

    10. It appears that the deceased Moula at the relevant time, had no driving licence. But from that an inference cannot be drawn that he was not knowing as to how to drive a motor-cycle. From the evidence of Shinde and Moula's widow, it is quite clear that the deceased Moula was owning a motor-cycle of the Rajdoot model for the last 5 to 7 years. Therefore, simply because his driving licence could not be produced or he was not holding a driving licence, it cannot be presumed that he had no knowledge of driving. The bus driver was driving the bus in middle of the road and, therefore, was obliged to drive the vehicle with reasonable care, strictly observing the traffic regulations and rules of the road. The accident took place near the curve. As the curve was ahead, there was a further obligation upon the driver to drive the vehicle more cautiously. The duty to be careful and diligent increases proportionately with the danger involved. If two persons are driving vehicels on a turn, each owes to the other a duty and are obliged to drive the vehicle with due care and caution. A person driving a motor vehicle on a public road must drive the vehicle with reasonable care, strictly observing the traffic regulations and the rules of the road so as not to imperil the safety of others, who have a similar right to use the road. From the recitals in the pahchnama, it is quite clear that the bus was being driven in a rash and negligent manner, and so also the motor-cycle. Both the drivers had not taken proper precaution or care. In this view of the matter, we have no hesitation in confirming the finding recorded by the learned Member of the Tribunal that both were equally responsible for the accident. Equal apportionment of the contributory negligence is also justified by the facts and circumstances of the case. Hence it is not possible for us to accept the contention of Shri Hegde that the contributory negligence on the part of the deceased should have been apportioned at 75%. In our opinion, the learned Member has rightly apportioned it equally. Hence the finding recorded in that behalf is hereby confirmed.

    11. So far as the quantum of compensation is concerned, it is seriously contended by Shri Hegde, relying upon the decision of this Court in Jaikumar's case, A.I.R 1978 Bom. 239, that while fixing just end fair compensation, a second thought should be given to the question as to how much amount the dependents will be getting by way of interest on the investment of the lump sum for years to come. In support of this contention, he has placed strong reliance upon the observations of this Court in Jaikumar's case, and particularly those in para 17 thereof it is not possible for us to accept this contention of Shri Hegde for more than one reason. In para 17 of the said judgment, this Court was dealing with a contention relating to the discount to be made for the lump sum payment. The compensation in that case was not fixed on the basis as to how much interest will be received by the claimants if the amount is invested in the Bank. The Madhya Pradesh High Court has also considered the said question, as it thought it to be one of the standards of determining the compensation. This is what the Madhya Pradesh High Court has observed in Sushila Devi's case, A.I.R 1974 M.P 181 at page 187, sub-para (iv):—

    “(iv) If the period is a long one, the ‘multiplier’ will be much smaller than the number of years, even where the contingencies which are allowed for are of small account. The reason is that while in so far as the lump sum of damages is still unspent, it will be earning interest and the damages and interest together will be adequate to last out for the period. The reason is that a prudent person receiving a lump sum to make good his loss over a period, is expected to invest it end to use it up gradually.”

    12. Therefore, in our view, the said observations are wholly irrelevant so far as the controversy raised before us is concerned. In Fletcher v. Autocar and Transporters Ltd., 1969 A.C.J 99, the Court of Appeal in England thought it proper to look at the overall figure again to see whether it is a fair compensation, and reduce or increase it accordingly and in that context, the amount of interest which wilt be received on the amount was taken into consideration. Similar was the case in Mallet v. McMonagle, 1969 A.C.J 312. In the present case, the method followed for fixing fair and just compensation by the learned Member was the multiplier method. For fixing the fair and just compensation, the learned Member of the Tribunal has applied the multiplier of 25. The deceased was aged 25 years at the time of the accident. The normal span of life in our country has practically reached 70. Therefore, compensation, is not fixed by the Tribunal after taking into consideration the total span of life of the deceased. It is also obvious that the compensation was not fixed on the basis of the interest the lump sum will receive if it is prudently invested in the Bank. Further, in our view, as observed by the Full Bench of the Punjab High Court in 6(Jokl Ram v. Smt. Naresh Kanta), A.I.R 1977 Punjab and Haryana 214, “the interest theory cannot be adopted as an inflexible principle for the purpose of assessing the compensation specially in these days when the purchasing power in terms of money is being eroded after short intervals on account of runaway inflation”. The matters might stand on a different footing in the developed countries. Judicial notice of this fact is also taken by the Supreme Court in 7(Motor Owners Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Jadavjl Keshavji Modi), (1981) 4 SCC 660 : A.I.R 1981 S.C 2059, wherein it is observed:

    “The delay in the final disposal of motor-accident compensation cases, as in all other classes of litigation, takes the sting out of the laws of compensation because, an infant child who seeks as compensation a dependent of his deceased father has often to a wait the attainment of majority in order to see the colour of the money. Add to that the monstrous inflation and the consequent fall in the value of the rupee. Compensation demanded say, ten years ago, is less than quarter of its value when it is received today.”

    13. Similar view is taken by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in A.I.R 1983 A.P 297; 8(Srisallam Devastanam v. Bhavanl Pramilamma), wherein the observations of Delhi High Court that ‘the benefit of getting the lump sum payment is offset by the increase in prices and the progressive decrease in the value of the rupeee’ were quoted with approval. In all the cases on which reliance is placed by Shri Hegde the question regarding receipt of interest on the amount Invested was considered in the context of choosing the correct multiplier or the method of deduction. In our opinion, it will not be correct to say that even though the correct multiplier is adopted and all necessary deductions are made, then also the question should be again reconsidered by giving a second thought and the compensation should be further reduced keeping in view the interest which a prudent man can get if the lump sum is invested.

    14. As a matter of fact loss of human life cannot be adequately measured in terms of money. Even otherwise, the learned Member of the Tribunal has deducted 25% on account of lump sum payment and uncertainties and hazards in life which the deceased might have faced if he would have been alive. Any further deduction on the basis of interest theory is wholly unwarranted because of the rapidly falling rate of the value of the rupee. There is a good interest rate only for long term investments. Meanwhile there is increase in prices and cost of living and consequent fall in the value of rupee. This outweigh the rate of interest, even on long term investment. Further, because of illiteracy and ignorance, prudent investment itself is an exception and not a normality. Therefore, it is not possible to lay down a general rule that while fixing just and fair compensation. It should always be based on the basis of the interest which will be derived or received if the lump sum is prudently invested. Thus, it is not possible for us to accept the broad proposition put forth by Shri Hegde. In our view, the compensation fixed by the learned Member of the Tribunal is just and fair and no interference is called for with the quantum of the compensation awarded.

    15. In the result, therefore, the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.

    16. We are informed that the appellants have already deposited the amount of compensation. If this is so, then the Tribunal will have to pass appropriate orders in tune with the guidelines laid down by this Court in 9(Nav Bharat Builders v. Smt. Pyarabal w/o Dadu Mane), 1984 (2) Bombay Cases Reporter 9. Obviously such an order will have to be made after giving an opportunity of being heard to the claimants. Therefore, the Tribunal is directed to pass appropriate orders after taking into consideration the guidelines laid down by this Court in Nav Bharat Builders case. The amount deposited in this Court will be subject to the orders passed by the Tribunal.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation v. Babalal Daud Mulani And Others .
    (Nov 6, 1984)