Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The 1st respondent filed OS No. 31 of 2001 in the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Nalgonda, seeking partition and separate possession of certain suit schedule properties. The petitioner and respondents numbered 2 to 9 were defendants in the suit. The petitioner resisted the suit primarily on the ground of a prior partition allegedly effected in 1957. During trial, after the plaintiff's evidence was closed, the petitioner sought to mark two documents dated 15-7-1957 and 16-8-1957 as evidence. The 1st respondent objected, arguing these documents constituted unregistered partition deeds and hence were inadmissible. The Trial Court sustained this objection by its order dated 7.8.2003. The petitioner filed this revision petition challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether unregistered documents that allegedly constitute partition deeds can be admitted as evidence in a suit for partition.
  2. Whether such unregistered partition deeds can be admitted for collateral purposes despite being inadmissible to prove the factum of partition by meets and bounds.
  3. The extent to which the Trial Court erred in excluding the documents from evidence on the ground of non-registration.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The documents dated 15-7-1957 and 16-8-1957 do not by themselves effectuate partition.
  • Even if treated as partition deeds, their non-registration does not render them inadmissible in evidence.
  • Unregistered partition deeds can be admitted for collateral purposes, relying on precedents such as Muthyalareddy v. Venkatareddy, Kaheeda Moin v. Md. Iqbal Ali, Pallapothu Naga Prasad v. Pallapothu Venkata Krishna Rao, and Pudi Balraju v. Jallu Annapoorna.

1st Respondent's Arguments

  • The documents direct a partition to be undertaken and thus constitute partition deeds.
  • Since the documents are unregistered, they are inadmissible in evidence.
  • As the documents do not confer any right of possession or effect division of property by meets and bounds, they cannot be admitted even for collateral purposes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Muthyalareddy v. Venkatareddy Unregistered partition deeds can be received in evidence for collateral purposes. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that unregistered partition deeds may be admitted for severance of status.
Kaheeda Moin v. Md. Iqbal Ali Defined three phases of partition: severance of status, division by meets and bounds, and nature of possession; held that phases 'a' and 'c' are collateral purposes admissible by unregistered documents, but phase 'b' requires registered deeds. The Court applied this analysis to conclude that the documents are inadmissible to prove division by meets and bounds but admissible for severance of status.
Pallapothu Naga Prasad and Ors. v. Pallapothu Venkata Krishna Rao and Ors. Confirmed that partition by meets and bounds requires registered deeds. Used to support the principle that unregistered documents cannot establish partition by division of property.
Pudi Balraju v. Jallu Annapoorna, 2003 (3) LS 154 Reiterated the requirement of registration for partition deeds dealing with division of property. Reinforced the Court's finding that the documents in question are inadmissible to prove partition by meets and bounds.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the nature of the documents sought to be admitted. It found that the document dated 16.8.1957 clearly indicates a partition deed by specifying the extent of shares of various persons and intending to effect partition. Since the document was neither registered nor stamped, the Court upheld the Trial Court's finding that it is inadmissible to prove partition by meets and bounds. The Court reviewed relevant precedents, particularly the classification of partition into three phases: severance of status, division by meets and bounds, and nature of possession. It held that unregistered partition deeds can be admitted only for collateral purposes—specifically severance of status and not for establishing actual division of property or possession. The document in question did not indicate the nature of possession, further limiting its evidentiary value. Accordingly, the Court allowed the revision petition to the extent that the documents may be admitted for the limited collateral purpose of severance of status and directed the Trial Court to consider stamp duty implications.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is allowed. The Trial Court is directed to admit the documents dated 15-7-1957 and 16-8-1957 into evidence solely for the limited collateral purpose of establishing severance of status, and not for proving the factum of partition by division of property or possession. The Trial Court shall also determine whether the documents are liable to stamp duty.

The decision affects the parties by permitting limited evidentiary use of the unregistered documents but does not establish new precedent beyond the application of existing principles regarding admissibility of unregistered partition deeds.

    Khaja Habeebuddin v. Md. Ibrahim & Ors.

    1. The 1st respondent filed OS No. 31 of 2001 in the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Nalgonda, claiming the relief of partition and separate possession of the suit schedule properties.

    2. Petitioner and Respondents No. 2 to 9 figured as defendants therein. The suit was resisted by the petitioner mainly on the ground that there was a prior partition way back in the year 1957. The trial of the suit was commenced. The evidence on behalf of the plaintiff- 1st respondent is said to have been closed. The petitioner is being examined as DW-1. During the course of his evidence, he sought to mark the two documents viz., the alleged agreement dated 15-7-1957 and alleged award dated 16-8-1957. The 1st respondent opposed the same on the ground that the documents, if taken on their face value constitute partition deeds and unless registered, cannot be accepted in evidence. Through its order dated 7.8.2003, the Trial Court has sustained the objection raised by the 1st respondent. Hence, this Revision Petition by the petitioner.

    3. The learned Counsel for the petitioner Sri V. Ravi Kiran Rao submits that the documents referred to above by themselves did not bring about any partition and even if they were not registered they were admissible in evidence. The learned Counsel also submits that even if the document is to be treated as a partition deed and not registered, it can be received in evidence for collateral purpose. He placed relies upon the judgments of this Court reported in Muthyalareddy v. Venkatareddy, , Kaheeda Moin v. Md. Iqbal Ali, , Pallapothu Naga Prasad and Ors. v. Pallapothu Venkata Krishna Rao and Ors. and Pudi Balraju v. Jallu Annapoorna, 2003 (3) LS 154.

    4. On the other hand, Sri K. Mahipathi Rao, learned Counsel for the 1st respondent submits that a perusal of the documents which are sought to be marked, discloses that a partition was directed to be undertaken in terms thereof and as such the documents, or, one of them is nothing but a partition deed. The learned Counsel also submits that since it is hot registered, it is inadmissible in evidence. He further submits that when the document did not confer any right of possession or resulted in division- of properties by meets and bounds, the question of there being any collateral purposes does not arise.

    5. In the suit for partition filed by the 1st respondent, the petitioner raise a plead of prior partition. He intended to prove and establish his plea on the basis of the two documents referred to above. It is not in dispute that they were neither stamped nor registered. The Trial Court took the view that the contents of one of the document dated 16.8.1957 indicate that it is a partition deed and in the absence of registration, it is not admissible in evidence. Though the learned Counsel for the petitioner has made an attempt to impress upon this Court that the document cannot be treated as partition deed by itself, the contents of the same disclose that it provides for the extent of shares of various persons and intends to bring about a partition. Under these circumstances, no exception can be taken to the finding of the trial Court that the document is partition deed.

    6. The admissibility of an unregistered partition deed has been the subject-matter of discussion by this Court in several cases. A Larger Bench of this Court in its decision rendered in Muthyalareddy v. Venkatareddy (supra), held that even an unregistered partition deed can be received in evidence for the collateral purposes. In Kaheeda Moin v. Md. Iqbal Ali (supra), this Court analysed the nature of purposes which can be treated as collateral or otherwise, in the context of partition. It was held therein that the whole process of partition contemplates three phases, viz.,

    (a) Severance of status,

    (b) Division of joint property by meets and bounds; and

    (c) Nature of possession of the various sharers.

    7. Phases 'a' and 'c' were treated as collateral purposes and capable of being evidenced by even unregistered documents. So far as phase 'b' viz., partition of property by meets and bounds is concerned, it was held that such an aspect can be dealt with only by registered partition deeds. This view was adopted in the subsequent Judgments of this Court in Pallapothu Naga Prasad and Ors. v. Pallapothu Venkata Krishna Rao and Ors. (supra) and in Pudi Balraju v. Jallu Annapoorna (supra).

    8. Reversing to the facts of this case, it is evident that the document in question did provide for extent of shares of various individuals. This fact can be brought in evidence only through a registered document. Therefore, the documents in question are inadmissible to establish the factum of partition of the property by meets and bounds. So far as the collateral purpose referred to above are concerned, the documents can be taken into account for the purpose of severance of status. As regards the nature of possession, it needs to be observed that the document itself did not indicate the nature of possession of the properties by various sharers. The result of this discussion is that:

    (i) The document in question is partition deed.

    (ii) It is not registered and

    (iii) It does not deal with the nature of possession.

    9. In the light of the law laid down by this Court in the judgments referred to above, the document in question cannot be received in evidence to establish the factum of partition. It, however, can be received in evidence for the collateral purpose of severance of status and nothing more.

    10. Accordingly, the civil revision petition is allowed, directing the Trial Court to receive the documents in question subject to proof for the limited purpose of establishing severance of status and nothing more. The Trial Court shall also consider the question as to whether the document is liable to be levied any stamp duty.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Khaja Habeebuddin v. Md. Ibrahim & Ors.
    (Mar 5, 2004)