1
STATE OF MINNESOTA
IN SUPREME COURT
A25-1711
Workers' Compensation Court of Appeals Jennifer Williams,
Respondent,
vs.
Delta Air Lines, Inc., and
ACE USA, administered by
Sedgwick Claims Management Services, Inc.,
Relators.
Hennesy, J.
Took no part, Aligada, Jr., J. Filed: November 12, 2026
Office of Appellate Courts
________________________
C. Jeremy Lagasse, Benjamin M. Kline, Aaron Ferguson Law, P.L.L.C., Arden Hills, Minnesota, for respondent.
Robin D. Simpson, Aaron Meland, Aafedt, Forde, Gray, Monson & Hager, P.A., Minneapolis, Minnesota, for relators.
________________________
S Y L L A B U S
1. The Workers' Compensation Court of Appeals erred in setting aside an expert's opinion because there is evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's implied findings that the expert's opinion was based on facts supported by the record and thus had adequate foundation.
2
2. The Workers' Compensation Court of Appeals erred in reversing the compensation judge's denial of benefits for the respondent's November 12, 2019 skin injury and vacating the compensation judge's denial of benefits for the respondent's January 29, 2020 respiratory injury because, taking the employer's expert's opinion into consideration, there is evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's denial of benefits for both claimed injuries. Reversed.
Considered and decided by the court without oral argument.
O P I N I O N
HENNESY, Justice. We are presented here with a disputed workers' compensation claim. Respondent Jennifer Williams, a flight attendant for relator Delta Air Lines, filed a claim petition alleging that exposure to Delta's uniform caused her to develop an "occupational disease"
pursuant to Minn. Stat. § 176.011, subd. 15, on two separate dates, November 12, 2019, and January 29, 2020. A workers' compensation judge found that Williams failed to meet her burden of establishing causation between the uniform and her injuries and denied her claim in its entirety. The Workers' Compensation Court of Appeals (WCCA) reversed the compensation judge's denial of benefits for the November 12, 2019 skin injury and vacated the denial of benefits for the January 29, 2020 respiratory injury.
3
Delta1appealed the WCCA's decision by writ of certiorari. Before us, Delta argues that the WCCA erred by reversing the compensation judge's denial of benefits for the November 12, 2019 skin injury and vacating the denial of benefits for the January 29, 2020 respiratory injury. Delta argues this was predicated on the WCCA's conclusion that the opinion of Delta's expert, Dr. Andrew Topliff, lacked foundation and its reversal of the compensation judge's findings adopting Dr. Topliff's opinions. We conclude that the WCCA erred in setting aside Dr. Topliff's opinion because there is evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's implicit findings that Dr. Topliff's opinion was supported by the evidence in the record and had adequate foundation. Based on that determination, we further conclude that the WCCA erred in reversing the compensation judge's denial of benefits for the skin injury and vacating the denial of benefits for the respiratory injury because there is evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's denial of benefits as to both claimed injuries.2 Accordingly, we reverse the WCCA's decision and reinstate the compensation judge's decision denying benefits as to both claimed injuries.
4
FACTS
Williams has worked as a flight attendant for Delta and its predecessor Northwest Air Lines for nearly 30 years. Before having the skin reactions she reported in this case, Williams struggled with various skin issues most of her life. Because of her skin sensitivity, Williams is careful with products such as perfumed lotions and uses one brand of laundry detergent exclusively.
In 2015, Delta began a selection and testing process for new uniforms. As part of this process, Delta recruited 1,000 employee-volunteers to conduct "wear tests" of the uniform at issue in this case, the Passport Plum uniform (the uniform), over a period of three months. Although Williams did not participate in the testing process, 500 out of the 1,000 volunteers were "above-the-wing" employees, such as flight attendants and gate agents; and 300 out of those 500 were flight attendants. During those three months, Delta received no complaints of reactions to the uniform from the 500 "above-the-wing"
employees. There were also no complaints from non-participating employees in close proximity to the testing employees wearing the uniform. Delta officially introduced the uniform to all its employees in May 2018.
In October 2018, while wearing the uniform on a three-day trip, Williams "became itchy, had a splotchy red rash on her skin, and developed a bladder infection." Williams attributed her symptoms to the uniform because the itchiness stopped when she took the uniform off. At this time, none of Williams's doctors connected her symptoms to the uniform.
5
November 12, 2019 Skin Injury On November 10, 2019, Williams began a three-day work trip wearing the uniform. On the first two days of the trip, Williams noticed the beginnings of a rash, and by the last day, November 12, she was "noticeably rashy." On November 13, Williams brought her uniform to an appointment with PA (physician assistant) Michael Steele. Williams told PA Steele that she believed the uniform was causing her symptoms. PA Steele examined Williams and noted that her skin was "mildly pink around the upper chest." He then instructed her to put on the uniform and re-examined her after 10 minutes. Upon re-examination, PA Steele noticed that Williams's "upper chest and neck were notably more red/inflamed" and "her face began to look puffy around her eyes." Williams took the uniform off but still had the rash when she left PA Steele's office about 20 minutes later. PA Steele diagnosed Williams with contact dermatitis and advised Williams to avoid contact with the uniform.
Toxicology Testing and the Black-and-White Accommodation Around the same time, Delta started receiving complaints from employees nationwide about health issues related to the uniform. In response to the complaints, Delta formed an investigative committee, encouraged employees to submit their claims properly and seek medical attention, and worked with Intertox, a toxicology and research company, to conduct independent testing on the uniform. In the meantime, Delta approved alternative uniform accommodation requests from employees. Flight attendants were allowed to wear their own black-and-white clothing. Williams was approved for the black-and-white accommodation and returned to work on December 17, 2019. Delta
6
continued to receive complaints from flight attendants who wore their own clothing but were experiencing symptoms due to close proximity to co-workers wearing the uniform. Intertox's report, however, identified no chemicals that could cause the dermal or respiratory effects Delta's employees reported. According to its report, Intertox obtained 300 uniform pieces from two manufacturing facilities. Specifically, Intertox selected five of each of the 60 above-the-wing uniform garment types that are worn closest to the skin and those about which Delta had received a health complaint. Ultimately, over 628 samples were subjected to laboratory analysis for over 200 chemicals, including unique dermal allergens and airborne irritants. Intertox also conducted a toxicological risk assessment based on the laboratory results. Intertox's report concluded that its analyses "have not linked the tested uniform garments to any attributable health risk."
January 29, 2020 Respiratory Injury
In January 2020, Williams worked a two-and-a-half-day trip wearing her black- and-white clothing. Williams started having breathing issues when she was sitting in a crew van with other flight attendants, one of whom was wearing the uniform. A co- worker sitting next to Williams recognized Williams's difficulty breathing and offered Williams an inhaler, which Williams declined. On the return trip, Williams experienced similar reactions while sitting next to a co-worker wearing the uniform. According to Williams, both times she felt better after distancing herself from the uniform. After this trip, PA Steele conducted an asthmatic test on Williams, which came back negative. PA Steele gave Williams two inhalers and referred her to Dr. Zeke McKinney, an occupational medical specialist.
7
On March 17, 2020, Dr. McKinney saw Williams for a rash and multiple symptoms possibly related to the new work uniform. Williams informed Dr. McKinney of her experiences with the uniform since October 2018. Williams reported nasal congestion with bloody mucus, elevated blood pressure, a splotchy rash, and occasional shortness of breath and chest tightness. Dr. McKinney diagnosed Williams with "[r]ash, likely irritant contact dermatitis," "[u]pper airway irritation including nasal congestion and throat irritation," and "[i]rritant volatile organic compound chemical sensitivity."
Dr. McKinney believed Williams's rash and upper airway irritation were consistent with "irritant volatile organic compound exposures" at work, but he noted there was "a large degree of uncertainty with respect to these uniforms and the exposures." He observed that uncertainty existed "because although [Delta] has provided a list of the chemicals used in the garment processing of these uniforms, they were manufactured in several different countries, all of which have very different manufacturing standards from the United States." Despite this uncertainty, Dr. McKinney concluded that "there is a substantial degree of evidence from an epidemiologic perspective that [Delta's] employees are being impacted by these new work uniforms."
With respect to Williams's other symptoms, Dr. McKinney stated that it is difficult to say for certain that the uniform caused those symptoms, but "there does seem to be a temporospatial association with [Williams] wearing the uniform, given that her symptoms have worsened over her time of wearing the uniform, and she seems to have had improvement in the symptoms with time away from working and wearing the uniform."
8
Two months later, on May 21, 2020, Williams reported to Dr. McKinney that her rash symptoms had improved while she had been away from work for two months,3but she still had residual symptoms. At this appointment, Dr. McKinney discussed the process and benefit of patch testing4with Williams, but Williams told him that she "did not feel the patch testing [wa]s necessary to confirm the reactions she ha[d] already had."5Ultimately, Williams did not undergo patch testing due to financial concerns, apprehension of pain, time away from work, and the lack of any guarantee that it would help.
Dr. Topliff's Opinions, 2020 and 2021 In response to Williams's two claimed injuries, Delta sought the opinion of Dr. Topliff, a toxicologist. Between 2020 and 2021, Dr. Topliff authored two reports. The first report was completed in August 2020, after he reviewed Williams's medical records dating back to 2010. In this report, Dr. Topliff noted all of Williams's diagnoses and treatments to date and concluded that "[t]here is no objective evidence of any causal
9
connection between the new Delta uniform and any of Ms. Williams's complaints consisting of skin lesions, allergic responses or shortness of breath." Dr. Topliff opined that Williams's complaints could be explained by "her history of allergies with multiple rashes and ongoing allergic conditions which predate exposure to the new Delta uniform by many years." As part of this record review, Dr. Topliff analyzed Dr. McKinney's diagnosis of Williams's symptoms. In his report, Dr. Topliff noted that Williams informed Dr. McKinney what happened at PA Steele's office on November 13, 2019: she wore the uniform for 10 to 15 minutes, she got a rash, and PA Steele advised her to avoid contact with the uniform. Dr. Topliff further noted that he had not seen PA Steele's note from the November 13, 2019 appointment.
Ultimately, Dr. Topliff disagreed with Dr. McKinney's opinions, particularly that Williams's symptoms could be caused by close proximity to the uniform without wearing it. Dr. Topliff further maintained that Dr. McKinney did not read Williams's past medical records. In Dr. Topliff's view, there was no objective evidence to connect the uniform to Williams's symptoms, and Dr. McKinney based his opinion on Williams's subjective description of her symptoms.
In May 2021, Dr. Topliff physically examined Williams, reviewed additional medical records, and wrote another report. In this 2021 report, Dr. Topliff confirmed his earlier conclusion that the uniform is "not the direct and proximate cause of any condition or symptoms reported by Ms. Williams." Dr. Topliff opined that Williams's reported symptoms were attributable to pre-existing conditions, including a pre-existing history of allergies with multiple rashes and ongoing allergic conditions pre-dating exposure to the
10
Delta uniform in question. Dr. Topliff also suspected that Williams might have immune problems.
Dr. McKinney's Opinions, 2020 to 2023 Between 2020 and 2023, Williams had numerous appointments with Dr. McKinney and other medical professionals, during which she reported a wide range of symptoms, including thinning hair, nasal congestion, and scratchy eyes. Some of Williams's reported symptoms, however, were inconsistent with medical professionals' observations when they physically examined her. For example, although Williams reported that the uniform was causing thinning hair, a physician assistant who examined her at a 2022 appointment observed "full, thick hair" with "[n]o obvious broken strands or patchy spots; no visible excess of telophase hair strands." Additionally, even though both PA Steele and Dr. McKinney initially diagnosed Williams with contact dermatitis, Dr. McKinney's notes from 2022 to 2023 indicated that Williams's symptoms "are not (and have not been) consistent with contact dermatitis."
On May 19, 2023, at Williams's request, Dr. McKinney issued a report regarding Williams's conditions in relation to the uniform. In this report, Dr. McKinney diagnosed Williams with irritant contact urticaria, vocal cord dysfunction, and chronic inflammatory rhinosinusitis. Dr. McKinney also opined that Williams's laboratory results "likely indicate an inflammatory and/or immunologic response resulting from [Williams's] use or proximity to the work uniform."
11
Dr. Topliff's Opinion, 2024 In response to Dr. McKinney's 2023 report, on January 24, 2024, Dr. Topliff conducted an updated record review of Williams's treatment history and prepared a third report. In this 2024 report, Dr. Topliff again opined that Williams had not been injured by the uniform. Dr. Topliff provided other possible explanations for Williams's symptoms, including that the symptoms may simply be "the patient's baseline" or arise due to viruses, other unrelated exposure, or anxiety. Dr. Topliff believed that Williams's anxiety caused "difficulty in the exploration and evaluation of all of these complaints." Dr. Topliff also disagreed that Dr. McKinney's lab tests supported Dr. McKinney's hypothesis that the uniform caused Williams's symptoms. In Dr. Topliff's view, because Dr. McKinney had not conducted lab tests before the reported injury, he had no baseline with which to measure change. Dr. Topliff concluded that there was no objective evidence that the uniform caused Williams's injuries, either by direct contact (for the skin injury) or by close proximity (for the respiratory injury).
Proceedings Before the Compensation Judge The compensation judge held a hearing on September 6, 2024, to determine Williams's eligibility for workers' compensation benefits for the two dates of alleged injury. Williams submitted, among other things, medical records related to her claimed injuries, including PA Steele's note and Dr. McKinney's report and notes. Delta submitted, among other things, Intertox's analysis and Dr. Topliff's reports. Based on all the evidence and testimony presented, including testimony from Williams, Williams's husband, and two management-level Delta employees, the compensation judge found that
12
Dr. Topliff's opinion as to causation of Williams's alleged injuries was not only more persuasive than Dr. McKinney's opinion, but "best aligned with the evidence as a whole."
The compensation judge further determined that "[Williams's] testimony with respect to the nature and cause of her injuries, though earnest, was not credible." Consequently, the compensation judge found that Williams failed to show by a preponderance of the evidence that the uniform was a direct and proximate cause of either of her alleged injuries and denied benefits for both claims.
Proceedings Before the WCCA Williams appealed to the WCCA, which reversed the compensation judge as to the November 12, 2019 skin injury. The WCCA concluded that the compensation judge erred in relying on Dr. Topliff's opinion because that opinion lacked foundation for two reasons: (1) Dr. Topliff had not conducted an adequate review of Williams's medical records, and (2) the opinion was inconsistent with the compensation judge's finding that Williams experienced a skin reaction after putting the uniform on at PA Steele's office. Williams v. Delta Air Lines, Inc., No. WC25-6597, 2025 WL 2785577, at *7-8 (Minn. WCCA Sep. 22, 2025). The WCCA determined that "absent [Dr. Topliff's] medical opinion," the compensation judge's findings established that Williams had met her burden of proving an occupational skin-related injury on November 12, 2019, and reversed the compensation judge's denial of benefits. Id. at *7. The WCCA further vacated the compensation judge's finding that no respiratory injury occurred on January 29, 2020, finding there was evidence in the record supporting Williams's claim, and remanded to
13
the compensation judge to "review the existing record" and "determine whether [Williams] ha[d] met her burden of proof." Id. at *9.
Before the WCCA, Williams also argued that the compensation judge's finding that her testimony was not credible "with respect to the nature and cause of her injuries"
was manifestly contrary to the evidence. The WCCA stated that Williams "made no persuasive argument" compelling a reversal of the compensation judge's credibility determination. Id. Nevertheless, the WCCA concluded that the compensation judge had
"limit[ed] the credibility finding to the employee's assertion of causation" because "the compensation judge's unappealed factual findings [we]re drawn largely from the testimony of [Williams] and match[ed] [Williams's] description of events surrounding the wearing of, and proximity to, the Passport Plum uniform." Id.
Delta appealed the WCCA's decision by writ of certiorari.
ANALYSIS
Generally, to obtain workers' compensation benefits resulting from an occupational disease, an employee must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that their employment directly and proximately caused the occupational disease. See Minn. Stat. § 176.021, subds. 1, 1a; see also Minn. Stat. § 176.011, subd. 15(a) (emphasizing that a disease arises out of employment only if there is a direct causal connection between the working condition and the disease). In this case, Williams bore the burden of proving that the uniform was the direct and proximate cause of her injuries by a preponderance of the evidence. The compensation judge and the WCCA disagreed on whether Williams
14
met her burden of establishing causation, primarily because they credited different medical opinions.
As such, we first consider whether the WCCA erred in concluding that Dr. Topliff's opinion lacked foundation and in setting it aside. Because we conclude that the WCCA erred in setting Dr. Topliff's opinion aside for lack of adequate foundation, we next determine, considering Dr. Topliff's opinions as part of the record, whether the WCCA erred in reversing the compensation judge's denial of benefits for Williams's skin injury and vacating the denial of benefits for her respiratory injury on the basis of causation.
I.
The compensation judge adopted Dr. Topliff's opinion over other conflicting opinions after finding it was "persuasive and best aligned with the evidence as a whole."
The WCCA, on the other hand, found that Dr. Topliff's opinion lacked foundation and set it aside. We consider whether the WCCA erred in setting Dr. Topliff's opinion aside.
A.
First, to determine the applicable standard of review, we must decide if the issue before us—whether the WCCA erred in setting aside Dr. Topliff's opinion—presents a question of law or fact. See Peterson v. City of Minneapolis, 23 N.W.3d 582, 592 (Minn. 2025). In making this determination, we look to relevant law, the nature of Delta's arguments, and the WCCA's decision in this case. See id.
Generally, a compensation judge's choice between two conflicting expert opinions
"must be upheld unless the facts assumed by the expert in rendering his or her opinion are
15
not supported by the evidence." Smith v. Carver County, 931 N.W.2d 390, 398-99 (Minn. 2019) (citation omitted) (internal quotation marks omitted). "A compensation judge may rely on an expert opinion if it has an adequate factual foundation." Id. (citation omitted) (internal quotation marks omitted). An opinion's foundation is not adequate where it
"(1) does not include the facts and/or data upon which the expert relied in forming the opinion; (2) does not explain the basis for the opinion; or (3) when the facts assumed by the expert in rendering an opinion are not supported by the evidence." Id. (citations omitted) (internal quotation marks omitted). An expert opinion "need only be based on enough facts to form a reasonable opinion that is not based on speculation or conjecture."
Id. (citation omitted) (internal quotation marks omitted).
Here, Delta argues that the WCCA erred in reversing the compensation judge's choice of expert based on its conclusion that the expert's opinion lacked adequate foundation. Generally, "[w]hether an expert's opinion rests on adequate foundation 'is a decision within the discretion of the trial judge, subject to review for abuse of discretion.' " Mattick v. Hy-Vee Foods Stores, 898 N.W.2d 616, 621 (Minn. 2017) (quoting Gianotti v. Indep. Sch. Dist. 152, 889 N.W.2d 796, 802 (Minn. 2017)). Here, the WCCA reached its conclusion based on two findings: first, that Dr. Topliff did not conduct an adequate review of Williams's medical records; and second, that Dr. Topliff's opinion that Williams's symptoms were not caused by the uniform was inconsistent with the compensation judge's findings. See Williams, 2025 WL 2785577, at *7-8. Each of these findings amounts to an assertion that the foundation for Dr. Topliff's opinion was not adequate because "the facts assumed by the expert in rendering [the] opinion [were]
16
not supported by the evidence." Smith, 931 N.W.2d at 398. Thus, the basis for the WCCA's reversal on this issue—that the facts the expert assumed were not supported by the evidence—is a question of fact. Id. (describing this same inquiry into this aspect of an expert's foundational reliability as "reviewing the factual findings of a compensation judge").
B.
Having concluded that the issue presented is a question of fact, we next decide whether a conflict exists between the compensation judge's findings and the WCCA's findings. Lagasse v. Horton, 982 N.W.2d 189, 201 (Minn. 2022). If no conflict exists, we
"uphold the WCCA's findings unless they are manifestly contrary to the evidence."
Ludwig v. Dakota County, 34 N.W.3d 42, 47 (Minn. 2026). When a conflict exists, the WCCA must be reversed if "there is any evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support" the compensation judge's findings. Lagasse,
982 N.W.2d at 201-02. A conflict exists when the WCCA substitutes its own finding for an explicit or implicit finding of the compensation judge. Id. at 201-03. A compensation judge's finding qualifies as implicit for the purpose of this standard "when the compensation judge has specifically considered the issue." Id. at 203.
Here, a conflict exists between the compensation judge's findings and the WCCA's findings. The compensation judge found that Dr. Topliff's opinions "regarding causation of [Williams's] claimed injuries are persuasive and best aligned with the evidence as a whole," and relied on Dr. Topliff's opinion in determining the uniform did not cause
17
Williams's injuries. "It is well settled that expert opinions must have an adequate factual foundation to be admissible." Hudson v. Trillium Staffing, 896 N.W.2d 536, 540 (Minn. 2017). We therefore conclude that in order for the compensation judge to have relied on Dr. Topliff's opinion, the compensation judge necessarily considered whether Dr. Topliff's opinion had adequate foundation, including considering whether the facts Dr. Topliff assumed in rendering his opinion were supported by the evidence, and implicitly found that they were. See Smith, 931 N.W.2d at 398 ("A compensation judge may rely on an expert opinion if it has an adequate factual foundation." (citation omitted) (internal quotation marks omitted)).
The WCCA, on the other hand, replaced the compensation judge's finding with its own finding that the facts Dr. Topliff assumed in rendering his opinion were not supported by the evidence because he did not conduct an adequate review of the record and because his opinion was inconsistent with findings made by the compensation judge. We therefore conclude that a factual conflict exists as to the foundation of Dr. Topliff's opinion. Consequently, we will reverse the WCCA's substituted finding if "there is any evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support" the compensation judge's finding. Lagasse, 982 N.W.2d at 201-02.
C.
Accordingly, we next consider whether there is "any evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's" implicit findings that Dr. Topliff's opinion was based on facts supported by the record and thus had adequate foundation.
18
To have adequate foundation, an expert's opinion must be based on facts that are supported by the record. Gianotti v. Indep. Sch. Dist. 152, 889 N.W.2d 796, 802 (Minn. 2017). Before forming an opinion, however, the expert need not be provided with every possible fact, only "enough facts to form a reasonable opinion that is not based on speculation or conjecture." Id. It is soundly within a compensation judge's discretion to determine whether an expert's opinion has adequate foundation. Id. Our decision in Gianotti v. Independent School District 152 is instructive. Similar to this case, in Gianotti, we were asked to consider whether the WCCA erred when it concluded that an employer's expert's testimony lacked foundation and reversed the compensation judge's finding for relying on that testimony. Id. The WCCA found that the expert's opinion that the employee did not suffer a concussion or post-concussive syndrome stemming from a head injury lacked foundation because the expert had not reviewed a video of the incident that caused the employee's head injury. Id. at 800, 802. In reversing the WCCA, we observed that the WCCA had not explained how the expert's failure to view the video was "dispositive on the adequacy of the foundation," especially given that no one disputed the employee had suffered a blow to the head, and the WCCA had "credited the opinions of other doctors" who had not seen the video. Id. at 802. We considered the thoroughness of the expert's factual foundation, observing that the expert had reviewed the employee's prior medical history, reviewed the majority of the employee's post-injury medical history, conducted significant testing, and personally interviewed the employee. Id. Following this review, we concluded that the expert's opinion arguably "had as solid a factual foundation as any other expert" in the case. Id.
19
As such, we held that "[t]he compensation judge did not abuse his discretion in finding that [the expert] had an adequate factual foundation for his opinion … [and] the WCCA erred when it reversed the compensation judge's decision based primarily on [the expert]'s report." Id.
Like the employer's expert in Gianotti, Dr. Topliff thoroughly reviewed Williams's pre- and post-injury medical history, analyzed the available testing results, and personally interviewed and examined Williams. Dr. Topliff conducted three extensive reviews of Williams's medical records, reviewing documentation back to 2010. He performed a physical examination of Williams and took a personal history from her directly. He reviewed testing done by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and multiple chemical laboratories, observing that this testing found "no compounds present in the amounts that could even possibly cause these symptoms." Dr. Topliff also reviewed the lab work Dr. McKinney had performed on Williams. Based upon his record review and physical examination, Dr. Topliff concluded that it was simply not possible for the uniform to cause her myriad ongoing symptoms and opined that Williams's symptoms could have been caused by her pre-existing and ongoing allergic conditions which pre-dated her exposure to the uniform, viruses, other unrelated exposure, her anxiety, or hypertension.
Despite Dr. Topliff's thorough investigation, the WCCA found that Dr. Topliff's opinion lacked adequate foundation. The WCCA focused on a single piece of evidence— PA Steele's November 13, 2019 medical record noting that he observed Williams's skin react after she put on her uniform. First, the WCCA stated that Dr. Topliff failed to
20
conduct an adequate review of the record because he did not review PA Steele's November 13, 2019 medical record. Second, the WCCA determined that Dr. Topliff's opinion was inconsistent with the compensation judge's finding that PA Steele observed Williams experience "symptoms of contact dermatitis" after exposure to the uniform in his office on November 13, 2019.
Although Dr. Topliff had not reviewed PA Steele's November 13, 2019 note when he issued his reports, he was fully aware that PA Steele had observed Williams's reaction after wearing the uniform for 10-15 minutes. Indeed, Dr. Topliff wrote about Williams's appointment with PA Steele in his August 2020 report.6Dr. Topliff's failure to review PA Steele's note, which contained facts of which he was clearly otherwise aware, does not undermine his opinion's foundation. See Gianotti, 889 N.W.2d at 802 (commenting that the WCCA's decision that an expert's opinion as to the nature of the employee's injury lacked foundation because the expert failed to review video of the incident "perplex[ed]"
us when there was "an admitted blow to the head").
The WCCA further concluded that Dr. Topliff's opinion was inconsistent with PA Steele's observation, which the WCCA viewed as significant because the compensation judge adopted PA Steele's observation as a factual finding. That analysis, however, does not account for the compensation judge's explicit determination that PA Steele's observation and subsequent diagnosis were of limited significance because they were
21
later contradicted by Williams's own expert, Dr. McKinney. The compensation judge wrote:
The most direct evidence of the uniform having adverse effect on the employee is the observation of its effects made by PA Steele during the November 13, 2019, appointment where the employee brought her uniform to the visit. However, PA Steele did not observe urticaria, which Dr. McKinney believes to be the employee's injury, but rather contact dermatitis. Dr. McKinney later ruled out contact dermatitis, as he believed her symptoms were inconsistent with such a diagnosis. Thus, there is no direct link between the uniform and the employee's current claimed injury.
Instead, the compensation judge was persuaded by Dr. Topliff's description of his own observation of Williams and his medical explanations of Williams's symptoms. During his physical examination, Dr. Topliff observed significant redness on Williams's neck, which Williams stated was not unusual for her. Dr. Topliff opined that Williams did not have urticaria as the redness seemed to be "a vasoactive type of response" given Williams's history of hypertension and frequent alcohol use. The compensation judge credited Dr. Topliff's opinion that the skin redness that Williams frequently attributed to the uniform was likely due to her hypertension.
It is within the unique function of the compensation judge as the trier of fact to assess witnesses' credibility. Kubis v. Cmty. Mem'l Hosp. Ass'n, 897 N.W.2d 254, 260 (Minn. 2017). And "evaluation of the evidentiary worth of [a doctor's] report is within the province of the compensation judge." Scalf v. LaSalle Convalescent Home/Beverly Enters., 481 N.W.2d 364, 366 (Minn. 1992); see also Gianotti, 889 N.W.2d at 803 ("In weighing medical evidence, a compensation judge has the discretion as the trier of fact to choose between competing and conflicting medical experts' reports and opinions.").
22
Here, the parties presented conflicting medical reports and opinions, and the compensation judge found that Dr. Topliff's opinions "regarding causation of [Williams's] claimed injuries [were] persuasive and best aligned with the evidence as a whole." It was within the compensation judge's discretion to do so. While Dr. Topliff may not have been aware of every possible fact, there is evidence in the record to reasonably support the compensation judge's implicit findings that Dr. Topliff's opinion was supported by the evidence in the record and thus had adequate foundation. We therefore conclude that the WCCA improperly substituted its own finding that Dr. Topliff's opinion lacked foundation for the compensation judge's implicit finding that Dr. Topliff's opinion had adequate foundation. See Lagasse,
982 N.W.2d at 202-03 (stating that the WCCA may set aside a compensation judge's finding "only if there is no evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's finding[.]" (emphasis added)); see also Gianotti, 889 N.W.2d at 802 (concluding that compensation judge did not err in finding that employer's doctor's opinion had adequate factual foundation because the doctor's opinion was adequately supported by evidence in the record); Mattick, 898 N.W.2d at 621-22 (same); Smith, 931 N.W.2d at 398-99 (same).
II.
Delta also argues that the WCCA erred in reversing and vacating the compensation judge's denial of benefits on the basis of causation. The compensation judge denied benefits for both of Williams's claimed injuries—the skin injury and the respiratory injury—after concluding that Williams failed to meet her burden of establishing that the
23
injuries were caused by exposure to the uniform. The WCCA reversed the denial for the skin injury, concluding that, absent Dr. Topliff's opinion, Williams had met her burden of showing that the uniform caused her skin injury. Williams, 2025 WL 2785577, at *7. The WCCA vacated the denial of benefits for the respiratory injury and remanded the case for the compensation judge to reconsider whether Williams had met her burden of proving causation for the respiratory injury. Id. at *9. Having concluded that there was adequate foundation for Dr. Topliff's opinion, we must now determine whether the WCCA was correct in setting aside the compensation judge's findings that Williams failed to meet her burden of establishing that both injuries were caused by exposure to the uniform.
A.
First, we decide what standard of review applies to this determination. We have said that "[i]n cases involving undisputed facts, the question of whether an injury arises out of employment is a question of law that we review de novo." Roller-Dick v. CentraCare Health Sys., 916 N.W.2d 373, 376 (Minn. 2017) (emphasis added) (footnote omitted). Where, however, the question of causation turns on determinations regarding witness credibility, it presents a factual dispute. Id. at 378 (observing that, contrary to the causation question before the court in Roller-Dick in which the facts were undisputed, in Kubis, 897 N.W.2d at 261-63, because the WCCA disregarded the compensation judge's finding that the employee's explanation for her injury was credible, causation was a factual dispute); see also O'Rourke v. N. Star Chems., Inc., 281 N.W.2d 192, 194 (Minn. 1979) (observing that reviewing a lower court's choice between conflicting medical opinions on the question of causation presents a fact question). "It is not the function of a
24
reviewing court to evaluate the credibility and probative value of witness testimony and to choose different inferences from the evidence than the compensation judge." Kubis,
897 N.W.2d at 260 (citations omitted) (internal quotation marks omitted). Here, after reviewing the entire record, the compensation judge found Dr. Topliff's opinion "persuasive and best aligned with the evidence as a whole." The compensation judge evaluated both experts' credibility and their opinions' probative value and chose to rely on Dr. Topliff's opinion in concluding there was no causal connection between the uniform and Williams's claimed injuries. The WCCA, on the other hand, discredited Dr. Topliff's reports and did not consider Dr. Topliff's opinion at all when determining causation. See Williams, 2025 WL 2785577, at *7. Because the question of causation here turned on the compensation judge's evaluation of the credibility and probative value of the experts' testimony, whether the WCCA was correct in substituting and setting aside the compensation judge's findings that Williams failed to meet her burden of establishing that both injuries were caused by exposure to the uniform is a question of fact. See Kubis,
897 N.W.2d at 260; see also O'Rourke, 281 N.W.2d at 194 (emphasizing that whether there was a causal relation between the employee's injury and his employment was a fact question because the issue of causation depended on resolving conflicting medical opinions).
B.
Having determined that the issue of causation here is one of fact, we next consider whether there is a conflict between the WCCA's findings and the compensation judge's findings regarding whether the uniform caused Williams's injuries. See Ludwig,
25
34 N.W.3d at 46. Here, there are clear conflicts between the findings of the compensation judge and those of the WCCA on causation. The compensation judge found that Williams failed to meet her burden of establishing each injury was caused by exposure to the uniform. With respect to the skin injury, the WCCA substituted the compensation judge's finding that Williams failed to establish causation for its own finding that Williams had met her burden of showing that the uniform caused her skin injury. Williams, 2025 WL 2785577, at *7. With respect to the respiratory injury, the WCCA set aside the compensation judge's finding that Williams failed to establish causation and remanded the case for the compensation judge to reconsider whether Williams had met her burden of proving causation for the respiratory injury without considering Dr. Topliff's opinion. Id. at *9. Because a conflict exists, we next determine whether the WCCA was correct in substituting and setting aside the compensation judge's findings, which it may do "only if there is no evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's finding." Lagasse, 982 N.W.2d at 202-03.
C.
We now consider whether there is evidence in the record that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to support the compensation judge's findings that Williams failed to establish that her injuries were caused by either having direct contact with or being in close proximity to the uniform. Our review of the record persuades us that there is.
26
The record reflects that Williams has had a lifelong struggle—pre-dating any exposure to the uniform—with skin reactions to a variety of different substances, and that these reactions were similar to those she reported the uniform causing. Intertox's testing
"identified no chemicals that could have been eluted (transferred) from the textile in sweat or emitted to air that could account for the rates of dermal or respiratory effects reported." This testing is consistent with the results of the survey Delta conducted of its employees prior to the rollout of the uniform at issue—none of the 500 above-the-wing employees reported reactions to the uniform during the wear test. Moreover, Williams did not undergo patch testing, which could have confirmed her allegations or identified alternative explanations for her symptoms, despite the recommendation of several providers. Dr. Topliff, after conducting three record reviews and a physical examination of Williams, repeatedly concluded that there was no objective evidence that the uniform caused Williams's injuries, either by direct contact for the skin injury, or being in close proximity for the respiratory injury. And as we have already concluded, the compensation judge acted within her discretion in concluding that there was adequate foundation for Dr. Topliff's opinion.
Because a reasonable mind might accept the evidence described above as adequate to support the compensation judge's findings that Williams failed to establish causation for both injuries, the WCCA should have deferred to those findings rather than substituting its own judgment as to the compensability of the skin injury or remanding based on its rejection of Dr. Topliff's opinion as to the respiratory injury. Accordingly, we
27
reverse the WCCA's decision and reinstate the compensation judge's denial as to both injuries. See id. at 203.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, we reverse the decision of the Workers' Compensation Court of Appeals and reinstate the compensation judge's denial as to both injuries. Reversed.
ALIGADA, Jr., J., not having been a member of the court at the time of submission, took no part in the consideration or decision of this case.