JUDGMENT OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF WASHINGTON COUNTY IS
REINSTATED AND AFFIRMED.
RANDOLPH, C.J., COLEMAN, P.J., ISHEE AND GRIFFIS, JJ., CONCUR.
KING, P.J., DISSENT WITH SEPARATE WRITTEN OPINION JOINED BY
SULLIVAN J.
KING, PRESIDING JUSTICE, DISSENTING:
¶20. I respectfully dissent from the majority's decision to reverse the judgment of the Court of Appeals and to reinstate and affirm the judgment of the trial court. Because Dr. Scott Resnick was sufficiently qualified to testify as to the standard of care that should be followed by a general surgeon when evaluating a patient with Lisa Lee's conditions, I would find that the Court of Appeals correctly held that the trial court abused its discretion by striking Dr. Resnick as an expert witness.
¶21. Lisa was admitted into Delta Regional Medical Center on February 12, 2018, complaining of weakness, all-over pain, nausea, and vomiting. Lisa had a past medical history of diabetes, fibromyalgia, hepatitis, hypertension, liver disease, migraine, morbid
11
obesity, and valvular heart disease. Dr. Ellis O'Neal, an emergency-room physician, noted that Lisa was jaundiced. His clinical impression was liver pain and cryptogenic cirrhosis. On February 13, 2018, Dr. Ronald Pritchard, board certified in radiology, signed an ultrasound report stating that his impression was "[c]holelithiasis with evidence of cholecystitis."
¶22. On February 14, 2018, Dr. Jeffrey Doolittle, a board-certified general surgeon, was consulted for "cirrhosis of liver." The consult narrative stated "50-year-old female was asked to see regarding gallbladder with gallstones possible cholecystitis. She has autoimmune hepatitis now with cirrhosis with greatly elevated [liver function tests]." The following was Dr. Doolittle's assessment of Lisa:
Code(s): K80.20 - Calculus of gallbladder without cholecystitis without obstruction Status: Acute 50-year-old female with end-stage liver disease. Unfortunately she is not a surgical candidate. She understands her terminal disease. No surgical options available. Will sign off. Dr. Satwinder Singh, an infectious-disease specialist, subsequently evaluated Lisa and determined that she was suffering from cholecystitis with cholelithiasis. Lisa was treated with steroids and antibiotics and was discharged on February 19, 2018.
¶23. On February 21, 2018, Lisa arrived via ambulance at Bolivar Medical Center and was diagnosed with sepsis. On February 22, 2018, Lisa died. Lisa's death certificate lists her cause of death as cardiopulmonary arrest due to end-stage liver disease and urosepsis. ¶24. Lisa's daughter Whitney Lee filed suit against Dr. Doolittle, among others, alleging claims of medical malpractice and wrongful death. Whitney alleged that Dr. Doolittle had failed to properly monitor, diagnose, and treat Lisa's sepsis and that Lisa was prematurely
12
discharged. Whitney designated as an expert Dr. Resnick, a board-certified interventional radiologist. Dr. Resnick opined that Dr. Doolittle had "failed to meet the nationwide standard of care for an adult patient with the clinical signs and symptoms of sepsis." Moreover, Dr. Resnick concluded that "[t]he delay in diagnosis and definitive care by Dr. Jeffrey Doolittle's deviations and departures from the applicable nationwide standards of care for this adult patient led to Lee's February 22, 2018 untimely and unfortunate death."
¶25. Dr. Doolittle submitted a motion to strike Dr. Resnick as an expert, arguing that Dr. Resnick was unqualified to render opinions related to the standard of care of a physician practicing general surgery. The trial court granted Dr. Doolittle's motion to strike, finding that Dr. Resnick was not qualified to "render opinions related to the standard of care applicable to a general surgeon determining whether or not decedent Lisa Lee was a surgical candidate . . . ." The Court of Appeals reversed the trial court's grant of the motion to strike and its subsequent grant of Dr. Doolittle's motion for summary judgment for lack of medical expert testimony. Lee v. Doolittle, No. 2022-CA-00186-COA, 2025 WL 1110881, at *1 (Miss. Ct. App. Apr. 15, 2025). It found that "Dr. Resnick's averments, combined with his knowledge, training, and education, provided him with sufficient familiarity to testify to the standard of care that should be followed by a general surgeon when diagnosing a patient with the decedent's condition." Id. at *6.
¶26. I agree with the assessment of the Court of Appeals that Dr. Resnick's resume and affidavit showed that he was sufficiently qualified to testify regarding the standard of care
13
for a general surgeon evaluating a patient with Lisa's conditions. Mississippi Rule of Evidence 702 provides that
A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise if:
(a) the expert's scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue;
(b) the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data;
(c) the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and
(d) the expert has reliably applied the principles and methods to the facts of the case.
MRE 702.
¶27. "Mississippi physicians are bound by nationally-recognized standards of care; they have a duty to employ 'reasonable and ordinary care' in the treatment of their patients."
Glenn v. Peoples, 185 So. 3d 981, 985 (Miss. 2015) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Palmer v. Biloxi Reg'l Med. Ctr., Inc., 564 So. 2d 1346, 1354 (Miss. 1990)).
"[O]ur law requires a plaintiff to establish—through a qualified expert—what is required of a minimally competent [physician], 'whose skills and knowledge are sufficient to meet the licensure or certification requirements for the profession or specialty practiced.'" Id.
(alterations in original) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Braswell v. Stinnett, 99 So. 3d 175, 179 (Miss. 2012)).
¶28. "[T]he rule is that the expert must exercise the same level of intellectual rigor that
14
characterizes the practice of an expert in the relevant field." Troupe v. McAuley, 955 So. 2d 848, 858 (Miss. 2007) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Poole ex rel. Wrongful Death Beneficiaries of Poole v. Avara, 908 So. 2d 716, 724 (Miss. 2005)). "[A] specialist in a particular branch within a profession will not be required.'" Brown v. Mladineo, 504 So. 2d 1201, 1202 (Miss. 1987) (quoting C. McCormick, Evidence § 13 (3d ed. 1984)). "Most courts allow a doctor to testify if they are satisfied of his familiarity with the standards of a specialty, though he may not practice the specialty himself." Id.
¶29. Dr. Resnick is a board-certified interventional radiologist who received his medical degree from Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine in 1992. Dr. Resnick had been on staff at Northwestern Memorial Hospital, among others, since 2000. He had been teaching vascular and interventional radiology at Northwestern Memorial Hospital since 2000 and had been teaching vascular surgery since 2004. Dr. Resnick also had served for four years at Northwestern Memorial Hospital both on the Surgical Services Executive Committee and the Bluhm Cardiovascular Institute Planning and Operations Committee. Dr. Resnick additionally had served as an Annals of Vascular Surgery reviewer and was a prior member of the Society of Vascular Surgery.
¶30. Moreover, Dr. Resnick had authored and coauthored numerous publications regarding interventional radiology and vascular and cardiovascular surgery. He had been a primary investigator in trials involving primary liver cancer and in vascular and interventional radiology research. He further gave a presentation on minimally invasive liver-directed
15
therapies. ¶31. Dr. Resnick submitted an affidavit stating that he was familiar with the national standard of care for a physician that provides medical care for an adult patient who has been admitted to a community hospital by an internal medicine physician with clinical signs and symptoms of cholecystitis similar to Lisa Lee's. I have been advised of the legal standard in Mississippi concerning the concept of a reasonable prudent minimally competent emergency room physician[1] practicing in the United States of America with similar facilities, options, services and equipment as existed during Lisa Lee's admission to Delta Regional Medical Center (DRMC) on February 12-19, 2018.
Dr. Resnick further stated that he was "generally familiar with the facilities, resources, services, equipment and options that were available to Dr. Jeffrey Doolittle, a board certified general surgeon who undertook and performed a consultation of Lisa Lee at the request of Dr. Parez Karim on February 14, 2018 at DRMC."
¶32. Dr. Resnick emphasized that Dr. Doolittle's assessment that Lisa "did not have cholecystitis contradicted the sonographic demonstration of findings consistent with cholecystitits." Dr. Resnick stated that Lisa's antibiotic treatment "temporized but did not definitively treat her cholecystitis." According to Dr. Resnick, Lisa should have undergone gallbladder decompression during her initial hospitalization. He stated that the cause of the
16
sepsis that led to Lisa's death was untreated gallbladder outflow obstruction and cholecystitis. Dr. Resnick stated that, in his opinion, Dr. Doolittle did not act within the standard of care in his assessment of and subsequent plan for Lisa and that his clinical conclusions directly contradicted the objective imaging findings of cholecystitis as well as those reached by Dr. Singh.
¶33. Dr. Resnick wrote that Dr. Doolittle failed to order or recommend further testing to resolve the discrepancy between his conclusion that Lisa did not have cholecystitis and the conclusion reached by Dr. Singh and the diagnostic ultrasound. Therefore, Dr. Resnick stated that "[u]pon reasonably concluding [Lisa] not to be a surgical candidate, Dr. Doolittle failed to recommend nonsurgical options for gallbladder decompression such as percutaneous cholecystostomy tube placement." He further wrote:
Percutanous cholecystostomy tube (gallbladder drain) placement is a simple and routinely performed procedure. Percutaneous cholecystostomy tube placement is regularly performed in even the most critically ill patients, with low risk for bleeding or other complications.
In my opinion based upon a reasonable degree of medical certainty, if [Lisa] had undergone percutaneous gallbladder drain placement at any time during her DRMC stay from February 12, 2018 to February 19, 2018 she would not have subsequently re-presented with and succumbed to biliary sepsis a few days later.
. . . .
In my opinion based upon a reasonable degree of medical probability, this was a preventable death, directly attributed to Dr. Doolittle's failure to resolve the discrepancy between his clinical conclusion that [Lisa] did not have cholecystitis and that reached by Dr. Singh and the diagnostic ultrasound that [Lisa] did have cholecystitis and the subsequent failure to place a drainage
17
tube to decompress and drain her gallbladder failed to meet the nationwide standard of care for diagnosis and treatment of sepsis. ¶34. This Court has recognized that "the liberal goals of [the rules of evidence] include reducing the traditional barriers to opinion testimony." Worthy v. McNair, 37 So. 3d 609, 614 (Miss. 2010) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Miss. Transp. Comm'n v. McLemore, 863 So. 2d 31, 36 (Miss. 2003)). Further, "'the trial court's role as gatekeeper is not intended as a replacement for the adversary system' when the expert's testimony is both relevant and reliable. 'Vigorous cross-examination, presentations of contrary evidence, and careful instruction on the burden of proof are the traditional and appropriate means of attacking shaky but admissible evidence.'" Id. at 615 (citation omitted) (quoting McLemore,
863 So. 2d at 39, 36). ¶35. I would find that Dr. Resnick was sufficiently qualified to offer expert-opinion testimony regarding the standard of care owed by a general surgeon to a patient with Lisa's conditions. Although the trial court found that Dr. Resnick was not qualified to "render opinions related to the standard of care applicable to a general surgeon determining whether or not decedent Lisa Lee was a surgical candidate," as the Court of Appeals stated,
"Resnick's proffered opinions did not address whether Lisa was a candidate for surgery. Instead, his opinions address Dr. Doolittle's misdiagnosis of cholecystitis and failure to recommend a routine, non-surgical percutaneous procedure to drain the gallbladder." Lee, 2025 WL 1110881, at *4 (footnote omitted).
¶36. Dr. Resnick stated that he was "familiar with the national standard of care for a
18
physician that provides medical care for an adult patient who has been admitted to a community hospital by an internal medicine physician with clinical signs and symptoms of cholecystitis similar to Lisa Lee's." He further stated that he was "generally familiar with the facilities, resources, services, equipment and options that were available to Dr. Jeffrey Doolittle, a board certified general surgeon who undertook and performed a consultation of Lisa Lee at the request of Dr. Parez Karim on February 14, 2018 at DRMC." Lastly, Dr. Resnick's extensive resume demonstrated that he was familiar with percutaneous procedures. He stated that percutanous cholecystostomy tube placement was a simple and routinely performed procedure.
¶37. Dr. Resnick's resume and affidavit qualified him to render opinions related to the standard of care for a general surgeon evaluating a patient with Lisa's conditions. Therefore, I dissent and would affirm the decision of the Court of Appeals to reverse the judgment of the trial court and remand this case for further proceedings.
SULLIVAN, J., JOINS THIS OPINION.
19