ORDERED that the judgment is reversed, on the law, without costs, determination annulled and petition granted.
Footnotes Footnote 1: Local Law 202 prescribes fines between $500 and $2,000 per violation ( see Administrative Code of City of NY § 17-1903 [a]).
Footnote 2: It bears reiterating that Local Law 202 regulates the sale of certain agricultural products only at retail food and food service establishments in New York City. Farms may continue to sell foie gras to consumers directly.
Footnote 3: By way of example, local laws banning public smoking ( see Administrative Code of City of NY § 17-503), and those requiring that calorie information be displayed on menus ( see Administrative Code of City of NY § 81.50; see also King Cnty, Wash, Bd of Health Code § 5.10.016) undoubtedly affect demand for various agricultural products and, thus, supply chains for those products locally and throughout the state.
Footnote 4: To the extent that the state respondents correctly note that the Senate Memorandum in Support of the 1997 amendments to Agriculture and Markets Law § 305-a describes same as
"expanding the scope of [section 305-a] to apply to all local laws, ordinances, rules or regulations"
(Senate Mem in Support, Bill Jacket, L 1997, ch 357 at 9), the context of such statement was the Legislature's deletion of the term "land use" in the former statutory text "local land use laws, ordinances, rules or regulations," such that a local law need not be classified as a land use law in order to fall within the scope of section 305-a.
5