JUDGMENT INSTRUCTION
To sustain the trial court's decision to give the exercise of judgment instruction here, there must be (1) evidence of Dr. Gala's thought process in reaching her diagnoses and treatments and (2) expert testimony that Dr. Gala's thought process met the standard of care.
The plaintiff alleged that Dr. Gala was negligent in her treatment of Ms. Beard by failing to do the following:
1. Failing to order follow-up imaging after Dr. Gala saw Ms. Beard on March 1, 2018;
2. Failing to refer Ms. Beard to an infectious disease specialist on March 1, 2018;
3. Failing to refer Ms. Beard to an infectious disease specialist on March 2, 2018;
4. Failing to alert the gastroenterologist of a suspected infection. Suppl. Br. of Pet'r Beard at 3.
As discussed below, there was evidence of Dr. Gala's thought process for each decision backed by expert testimony that the thought process met the standard of care. Therefore, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in giving the exercise of judgment instruction here.
A. Dr. Gala's Decision Not To Order Follow-up Imaging
Dr. Gala provided evidence of her thought process in deciding not to order follow- up imaging on March 1. Dr. Gala testified that she did not order repeat chest imaging
38
Beard v. The Everett Clinic, No. 103635-3 (Mungia, J., concurring)
11
because Ms. Beard did not complain of coughing or shortness of breath. 6 VTP at 819. In addition, Dr. Gala listened to Ms. Beard's lungs and they sounded clear. Id. Dr. Gala provided an expert witness, Dr. Volkmann, who opined that Dr. Gala's thought process met the standard of care. Dr. Volkmann testified that the standard of care required Dr. Gala to consider Ms. Beard's response to the antibiotics, which she did. Id. at 746, 751-52. Dr. Volkmann also testified that the standard of care required Dr. Gala to consider the physical examination findings, which Dr. Gala did. Id. Accordingly, for this diagnosis and treatment, the trial court had evidence of what Dr. Gala's thought process was in reaching her treatment plan and evidence that the thought process met the standard of care.
B. Dr. Gala's Decision Not To Make a Referral to an Infectious Disease Specialist on March 1 and March 2
Mr. Beard alleges that Dr. Gala fell below the standard of care by not referring Ms. Beard to an infectious disease specialist both on March 1 and on March 2. As there was no evidence that a referral on March 1 would have resulted in any different outcome than a referral on March 2, the only evidence that the trial court needed to consider was Dr. Gala's thought process on March 2.
Dr. Gala explained her thought process as to why she did not refer Ms. Beard to an infectious disease specialist on March 2: Ms. Beard's blood and urine tests had, up to that time, been negative. 7 VTP at 913-14. Dr. Volkmann opined that Dr. Gala's thought process in making this decision met the standard of care. 6 VTP at 617-18, 697, 700-02, 707-10, 712-14, 742.
39
Beard v. The Everett Clinic, No. 103635-3 (Mungia, J., concurring)
12
C. Dr. Gala's Decision Not To Alert the Gastroenterologist of Her Suspicions That Ms. Beard May Have an Infection
Mr. Beard alleges that Dr. Gala breached the standard of care by not informing the gastroenterologist that Dr. Gala thought Ms. Beard may have had an infection. Dr. Gala testified about her thought process in making that decision: the gastroenterologist would do their own evaluation of Ms. Beard and would have access to the health care records.
7 VTP at 917-18, 967. In addition, Dr. Gala testified that she was going to wait for the results from the final cultures of the blood and urine tests. 6 VTP at 820-23, 7 VTP at 913-14. This is because the information she had up to that date made infection less likely than a flare-up of Ms. Beard's lupus. Dr. Volkmann opined that Dr. Gala's thought process in making this decision met the standard of care. 6 VTP at 618, 697, 709, 712- 14, 717, 746-48.
Altogether, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in giving the exercise of judgment instruction. There was evidence of Dr. Gala's thought process for each decision and expert testimony that each decision met the standard of care.
V. CONCLUSION
The bottom line for any plaintiff in a medical negligence case is to convince the jury that the defendant's treatment fell below the standard of care and the treatment was a cause of the plaintiff's injury. The plaintiff must present expert opinion evidence to establish the standard of care.
40
Beard v. The Everett Clinic, No. 103635-3 (Mungia, J., concurring)
13
The defendant need not present any evidence of their thought process in reaching their diagnosis or treatment plan. As long as the jury does not find that the defendant health care provider breached the standard of care, it is irrelevant how the defendant reached their conclusions.
However, if the defendant wants to request the exercise of judgment instruction, they must support the request with specific evidence: their thought process in reaching their diagnosis or treatment plan and expert testimony that this thought process met the standard of care. If they have done this, then the trial court may, but is not obligated to, give the exercise of judgment instruction.
I disagree with the majority to the extent that it holds that a defendant's process is not their thought process, and to the extent that it holds that a jury can determine what the standard of care is for that process without expert testimony.
Because in this case the defendant provided evidence of her thought process and expert testimony that her thought process met the standard of care, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by giving the exercise of judgment instruction. Accordingly, I respectfully concur.
41
Beard v. The Everett Clinic, No. 103635-3 (Mungia, J., concurring)
14
______________________________________ ______________________________________ _____________________________________
42