ORDER ADOPTING FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF MAGISTRATE JUDGE - 1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF IDAHO
CINDY STONE, as a parent and legal heir of Antonio Ray Stone; ZACHARY WILLEY, as a child of and legal heir of Antonio Ray Stone; MERRICK J. STONE, as a child of and legal heir of Antonio Ray Stone; W. S., as a child of and legal heir of Antonio Ray Stone; and E.R.L.S, as a child of and legal heir of Antonio Ray Stone,
Plaintiffs,
v.
BANNOCK COUNTY SHERIFF'S
DEPARTMENT; BANNOCK COUNTY
SHERIFF TONY MANU, in his official and personal capacity; CAPTAIN LYLE THURGOOD, in his official and personal capacity; CORPORAL AUSTIN
FERGUSON, in his official and personal capacity; DEPUTY CORPORAL
ALBERT LUCE, in his official and personal capacity; DEPUTY GARY GUNNELL, in his official and personal capacity; and JOHN DOES 1-10, in his official and personal capacities, Defendants.
Case No. 4:25-cv-00269-BLW-DKG
ORDER ADOPTING FINDINGS AND
RECOMMENDATIONS OF
MAGISTRATE JUDGE
This matter is before the Court on Defendants Bannock County Sheriff's Office, Tony Manu, Lyle Thurgood, Austin Ferguson, and Gary Gunnell's Objection to the Report and Recommendation issued by United States Magistrate Judge Debora K.
1
Grasham. See Dkts. 23, 24. Judge Grasham recommends dismissing Count I of Plaintiffs' Complaint without prejudice, with leave to amend, and denying Defendants' motion to dismiss as to Counts II and III.1See Dkt. 23 at 15. Defendants object to that recommendation, arguing that Judge Grasham erred by failing to consider matters Defendants presented outside of the pleadings and failing to "correctly use its discretion when it declined to treat Defendants' motion as one for summary judgment." See Dkt. 24 at 2.
Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 636, the Court has conducted a de novo review of those portions of the Report and Recommendation to which Defendants have objected. The objections are overruled. The Court accepts the findings and recommendations of Judge Grasham and adopts the Report and Recommendation in its entirety. The decision whether to convert a motion to dismiss to a motion for summary judgment lies squarely within the Court's discretion. Young v. City of Visalia, 687 F. Supp. 2d 1141, 1150 (E.D. Cal. 2009) (quoting 5C Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller, Federal Practice and Procedure § 1366, at 159 (3d ed. 2004)) (noting district courts have "complete discretion"
whether to accept any material beyond the pleadings offered in connection with a Rule 12(b)(6) motion). Moreover, conversion of a Rule 12(b)(6) motion to a Rule 56 motion
2
"should be exercised with great caution." 5C Charles Alan Wright & Arthur R. Miller, Federal Practice & Procedure § 1366 (3d ed. 2018). Here, Judge Grasham properly exercised her discretion in declining to treat Defendants' motion to dismiss as one for summary judgment where the parties are ill-equipped at this stage of the proceedings to present all evidence required for a proper Rule 56 review. Accordingly,
IT IS ORDERED that:
1. Defendants' Objections to United States Magistrate Judge Debora K. Grasham's Report and Recommendation (Dkt. 24) are OVERRULED;
2. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss (Dkt. 6) is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part, as follows:
a. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' First Claim for Relief is
GRANTED without prejudice and with leave to amend; b. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Second Claim for Relief is
DENIED; c. Defendants' Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' Third Claim for Relief is
DENIED.
DATED: March 2, 2026 _________________________ B. Lynn Winmill
U.S. District Court Judge
3