JUDGMENT VACATED, AND RENDERED.
SUPREME COURT OF LOUISIANA
NO. 2024-C-01492
DARLENE WARD PELLECER, INDIVIDUALLY AND AS THE
ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF CARLOS F. PELLECER, AND
CYNTHIA PELLECER KEPPLER, LINDA PELLECER SEWARD, AND
BONNIE PELLECER PEREZ
VERSUS
WERNER CO., A CORPORATION OF DELAWARE, ET AL.
On Writ of Certiorari to the Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit, Parish of Orleans
Hughes, J., dissents.
The Opinion follows the trend of lauding juries that return low verdicts while determining that a high verdict rendered by a jury must be questioned, and employs judicial activism to negate the jury verdict rendered in this case. The law defines a "manufacturer" as "a person or entity who labels a product as his own or otherwise holds himself out to be the manufacturer of the product."
(emphasis added)
To the law as written the Opinion adds the gloss that "one must do something to or with the product that affects it in a meaningful way" in order to be a manufacturer. This is new language, not the words of the Legislature. Let's be realistic. The new entity did not name itself "Jones Ladder Company". It used the Werner name to hold itself out to the public as the manufacturer of the traditional Werner ladders. This was the "actor's actions", holding itself out, not physically tinkering with the ladder. The jury as finder of fact in this case determined defendant Werner Co. to be a manufacturer. I respectfully dissent and would affirm the jury and the Court of Appeal.
16