Per Hawaiʻi's emergency management statute, the governor may
64
*** FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER ***
"[s]uspend any law that impedes or tends to impede or be detrimental to the expeditious and efficient execution of, or to conflict with, emergency functions." HRS § 127A-13(a)(3). The laws may be suspended only in response to a declared state of emergency and only during the emergency period. Id. "For the purpose of carrying out any provision of this chapter, the governor may adopt rules for the State and the mayor may adopt rules for the county which may, if so stated in the rules, have the force and effect of law." HRS § 127A-25(a). "Such rules shall not be subject to chapter 91." Id.
Plaintiffs' argument that the governor's interpretation of HRS chapter 127A invades the legislature's lawmaking powers lacks merit. The emergency proclamations do not "interfere with the functions of the Legislature," nor do they "deprive the Legislature of its full authority to pass laws." See Desrosiers, 158 N.E.3d at 840-41 (no separation of powers violation because the emergency orders did not prevent the legislature from passing legislation to address COVID-19). The governor did not usurp the legislature's role by passing new laws or acting outside the scope of his delegated authority. See id.; Alakaʻi Na Keiki, 127 Hawaiʻi at 275, 277 P.3d at 1000. Rather, the governor's rules were authorized by statute, and directly related to the suspension of laws under the proclamation. HRS §§ 127A-13(a)(3), 127A-25. Thus, we hold
65
*** FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER ***
that the rules appended to the emergency proclamations were a valid exercise of HRS chapter 127A emergency powers. That the governor's rules under HRS § 127A-25(a) carry the
"force of law," does not mean the rules involved legislatively- reserved "lawmaking." Wolf v. Scarnati, 233 A.3d 679, 704 (Pa. 2020) ("Executive orders that affect individuals outside the executive branch 'implement existing constitutional or statutory law.'. . . But an executive order or an administrative regulation promulgated by an executive agency that implements a statute still has the force of law. Otherwise, no entity outside the executive branch could be compelled to abide by a regulation issued by an executive branch agency. Such a result would be inconsistent with long-standing precedent."). The governor's statement that the certification rules "carry the force of law" thus only reflects that the rules are authorized by statute - not that the governor seeks to engage in unauthorized lawmaking. See id.
Though Plaintiffs did not raise the non-delegation doctrine, it often surfaces in separation of power cases. The State argued that the Governor's suspension of laws and rules were "within the authority vested in the Governor by the Legislature during a time of emergency, and do not present separation of powers concerns." We reason that granting the governor the authority to suspend laws and make rules to carry
66
*** FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER ***
out the emergency management statute in HRS § 127A-13(a)(3) and HRS § 127A-25 does not violate the non-delegation doctrine. See Application of Kauai Elec. Div. of Citizens Utilities Co., 60 Haw. 166, 181, 590 P.2d 524, 535 (1978) ("[Hawaiʻi] has adopted the nondelegation doctrine as part of its own body of constitutional law.").
Plaintiffs raising separation of powers claims to contest pandemic-related emergency powers often relied on the non- delegation doctrine. See Casey, 258 A.3d at 663-66; Acree, 615 S.W.3d at 805.
The statutory safeguards, courts held, were what separated permissible delegated powers from unconstitutionally-granted legislative powers. Casey v. Lamont held that the legislature did not impermissibly delegate its lawmaking function because it
"was as precise as it could be in defining the contours of the governor's authority given that there are myriad serious disasters that could arise and the actions the governor would be required to take could vary significantly from one serious disaster to another." 258 A.3d at 667. Likewise, Beshear v. Acree held that there was no violation of the non-delegation doctrine. 615 S.W.3d at 805. The emergency statute includes
"'safeguards, procedural and otherwise, which prevent an abuse of discretion' thereby 'protecting against unnecessary and uncontrolled discretionary power.'" Id. at 809 (citations
67
*** FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER ***
omitted). Here, we hold that the legislature did not unconstitutionally delegate legislative power to the executive branch in enacting HRS chapter 127A. The scope and duration of the emergency "defin[e] the contours" of the governor's powers. See Casey, 258 A.3d at 667. The governor may only suspend laws related to the emergency, and may only suspend those laws during the emergency period. HRS § 127A-13(a)(3).
We conclude that HRS chapter 127A's statutory limitations establish clear safeguards to "protect against uncontrolled discretionary power." See Acree, 615 S.W.3d at 809; Casey, 258 A.3d at 663-66. Still, those limits preserve a wide-latitude, discretionary space for the executive branch to operate when responding to emergency situations.
Thus, we hold that the legislature's delegation of the suspension of laws and rulemaking necessary to address an emergency under HRS chapter 127A does not violate the separation of powers.
F. Article I, Section 15 is inapplicable
Last, we address Plaintiffs' article I, section 15 arguments.
Plaintiffs say that the proclamations violate the Hawaiʻi Constitution because the governor's interpretation of a HRS chapter 127A "emergency" bypasses the "particular cases"
68
*** FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER ***
requirement under article I, section 15. They believe that HRS § 127A-13(a)(3) only expressly authorized the suspension of laws in emergency situations. Because the statute did not expressly authorize the proclamations' specific suspension of laws for housing, Plaintiffs insist the proclamations violate article I, section 15.
These arguments lack merit.
The Hawaiʻi Constitution's suspension of laws clause only covers the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus. Article I, section 15 does not apply to suspension of laws unrelated to the writ of habeas corpus. That constitutional provision reads:
"The power of suspending the privilege of the writ of habeas corpus, and the laws or the execution thereof, shall never be exercised except by the legislature, or by authority derived from it to be exercised in such particular cases only as the legislature shall expressly prescribe." Haw. Const. art. I, § 15. (emphasis added). "Thereof" references the privilege of habeas corpus. The "particular cases" requirement is thus specific to suspension of the writ of habeas corpus and related laws.
The emergency proclamations did not violate article I, section 15 of the Hawaiʻi Constitution.
G. Prospective Application
We understand the potential impacts of our decision on
69
*** FOR PUBLICATION IN WEST'S HAWAIʻI REPORTS AND PACIFIC REPORTER ***
existing affordable housing projects already approved through the expedited certification process. Thus, this holding only applies prospectively to projects that have not received approval under the emergency proclamations as of final judgment in this case. See League of Women Voters of Honolulu v. State,
150 Hawaiʻi 182, 207, 499 P.3d 382, 407 (2021).
III.
We vacate the circuit court's order dismissing Plaintiffs' declaratory judgment claims. We hold that the series of emergency proclamations related to affordable housing issued by the governor are valid.
Lance D. Collins
(Bianca Isaki, Linda J. Nye,
and Ryan D. Hurley on the
briefs)
for appellants
Ewan C. Rayner
(Craig Y. Iha, Linda L.W. Chow,
Klemen Urbanc, Chase S.L.
Suzumoto on the briefs)
for appellees
David L. Henkin
for amici curiae
Nā ʻOhana o Lele Housing
Committee, American Civil
Liberties Union of Hawaiʻi, E Ola
Kākou Hawaiʻi, Hawaiʻi Advocates
for Truly Affordable Housing,
Sierra Club, and Kūʻikeokalani
Kamakea-ʻŌhelo
/s/ Mark E. Recktenwald
/s/ Sabrina S. McKenna
/s/ Todd W. Eddins
/s/ Lisa M. Ginoza
/s/ Vladimir P. Devens
70