D ISORDERS 9, https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/FHEO/documents/kerner_commission_full_report.pdf.
33
City of Wenatchee v. Frank Edward Stearns, No. 102680-3 Whitener, J., concurring
9
of the 911 system by an increasing number of "citizen informants." Id. at 9-10. Under a totality of the circumstances test, however, how the tipster gathered their facts is extremely relevant. To protect our privacy interest, article I, section 7 of the Washington State Constitution requires that the informant's tip bears sufficient indicia of reliability under the totality of the circumstances to support a stop. State
v. Z.U.E., 183 Wn.2d 610, 617-19, 352 P.3d 796 (2015). It requires a stronger showing by the State as to what constitutes reasonable suspicion. Id. Washington's constitution provides that "[n]o person shall be disturbed in his private affairs, or his home invaded, without authority of law." W ASH. CONST. art. I, § 7. "Private affairs" means that in Washington, a person's right to privacy is extensive, and the circumstances under which those privacy rights can be disturbed is not built on a bedrock of reasonableness but is instead allowed only under the authority of law. State v. Snapp, 174 Wn.2d 177, 194, 275 P.3d 289 (2012). Thus, a police officer responding to an informant tip regarding a possible crime in progress and interacting with or interrogating the "suspect" could constitute authority of law, provided that the informant's tip has some "indicia of reliability." State v. Saggers,
182 Wn. App. 832, 840, 332 P.3d 1034 (2014). The reliability, veracity, and basis of knowledge of an informant are highly relevant considerations in the totality of the circumstances analysis. Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213, 230-33, 103 S. Ct. 2317, 76
34
City of Wenatchee v. Frank Edward Stearns, No. 102680-3 Whitener, J., concurring
10
L. Ed. 2d 527 (1983). In assessing reliability, courts require evidence of either "(1) circumstances establishing the informant's reliability or (2) some corroborative observation, usually by the officers, that shows either (a) the presence of criminal activity or (b) that the informer's information was obtained in a reliable fashion."
Z.U.E., 183 Wn.2d at 618 (emphasis added).
Here, Frank Stearns sustained a Terry46stop on the basis of a 911 tip given by a citizen informant who identified himself as David Gilliver. According to the majority, the facts that support indicia of reliability are Gilliver provided his name during the 911 call, so he was an identified caller. Majority at 13. "Known citizen informants are generally presumed to be reliable." Saggers, 182 Wn. App. at 840. Officer Natalie BrinJones responded to the parking lot of Cascade Motorsports within minutes of the call. Gilliver's call was the "sort of contemporaneous report [that] has long been treated as especially reliable." Navarette v. California, 572 U.S. 393, 399-400, 134 S. Ct. 1683, 188 L. Ed. 2d 680 (2014); majority at 13. However, even assuming that those are solid and reasonable indicators of a 911 caller's veracity, Navarette's remaining logic, cited approvingly by this court in Z.U.E, that a caller's use of the 911 system is itself an indicator of reliability, has not held up
35
City of Wenatchee v. Frank Edward Stearns, No. 102680-3 Whitener, J., concurring
11
under the weight of recent history and should be disavowed. Z.U.E., 183 Wn.2d at 621-23.
In Navarette, the United States Supreme Court noted that while technological and regulatory developments around the 911 system do not make 911 calls per se reliable, those developments are still relevant to the extent that a police officer concludes that the person calling in a tip would not use the system fraudulently. 572 U.S. at 401. This logic is flawed at best, dangerous at worst. First, as shown by the few instances I have identified, it is a mistake to make any assertion or draw any conclusion regarding the reliability of a citizen informant merely because of their use of the 911 system. Second, to protect an individual's privacy interest in these circumstances, the presumption that law enforcement can reliably assess the totality of the circumstances upon receiving information from a citizen informant requires the officer know "how the tipster gathered their facts, such as through their own senses (e.g. sight, sound, smell) or through a particular means or intermediary (e.g. eavesdropping, looking through binoculars or at the reflection in a mirror, hearing from a friend)." Majority at 10. Third, the advancement of the use of technology is broader than stated by the majority, or by Stearns and the Washington Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers (WACDL) in their amicus briefing. The issue is not as limited as Stearns and WACDL argue. It is not just that a call "made to the
36
City of Wenatchee v. Frank Edward Stearns, No. 102680-3 Whitener, J., concurring
12
emergency line has no bearing on its reliability because callers are unaware of the technological advancements behind modern 911 systems," that the 911 call is more reliable "because callers know that technology can identify them and that they can be held accountable for false statements," or that "this reliability is undermined by the possibility that a caller will borrow or steal another person's device to make the 911 call." Majority at 12. Nor is it, as the majority states, that their arguments
"highlight important questions about how much the average person knows about 911 technology or how often people use other's phones to report crimes." Id. at 13. Advancements in technology are so far evolved that anyone can misuse the 911 call system to spoof or fake 911 calls. In fact, as early as 2008, six years prior to Navarette, the FBI warned us about the misuse of technology to make fraudulent 911 calls and that fake callers "have no trouble convincing 9-1-1 operators they are telling the truth."47
Stearns' case is not about fraudulent calls; but with what we know today, this case raises the validity of the analytical rubric we use in assessing the reliability of a citizen informant tip made using the 911 system. The indicia of reliability the 911
37
City of Wenatchee v. Frank Edward Stearns, No. 102680-3 Whitener, J., concurring
13
system once had is no longer valid. The 911 system is weaponized to place calls on noncriminal behavior specifically of Black, Indigenous and Brown people. The majority's dismissive approach to the explicit bias faced by BIPOC people misses an opportunity to provide greater protections as envisioned in our state constitution for all of Washington's citizens. In fact, without a broad approach, the existing standards necessary for reasonable suspicion have been lessened to such a degree for BIPOCs where a 911 caller can say virtually anything and with no factual basis shown, police can invade some Washington citizen's privacy. It is truly about "our evolving understanding of human behavior, which necessarily informs the reasonable inference to be drawn." Majority at 14. What we know today, is the use of the 911 system should not be relied on as an indicator or inference of a citizen informant's reliability.
The law accepts the risk that police may stop innocent people. See Terry, 392 U.S. at 22. However, for some in our society, these encounters can be life or death. The dynamics of race/ethnicity, crime, and policing are complex, and interactions between BIPOC and the police are embedded in a lengthy problematic history that
38
City of Wenatchee v. Frank Edward Stearns, No. 102680-3 Whitener, J., concurring
14
continues even after the person has been deemed innocent of the conduct attributed to them by the 911 caller.48
It is true, Stearns is not a BIPOC, and as the facts here show, Gilliver's 911 call was not grounded in anything but a desire to do the right thing. Also, it appears that the observations of Stearns' driving by Officer BrinJones could provide a sufficient factual basis for this DUI. However, that is a "twenty- twenty hindsight"
review of the facts on this very important issue. This case provides us with an opportunity to reevaluate how we analyze the reliability of a 911 call by a citizen informant, where that call could quickly escalate from a minor privacy intrusion to one that results in the loss of a person's freedom or their life.
"Our laws are not frozen into immutable form, they are constantly in the process of revision in response to the needs of a changing society." Richardson v. Ramirez, 418 U.S. 24, 82, 94 S. Ct. 2655, 41 L. Ed. 2d 551 (1974) (Marshall, J.,
39
City of Wenatchee v. Frank Edward Stearns, No. 102680-3 Whitener, J., concurring
15
dissenting). Technology has advanced by leaps and bounds, but human nature has not. Racism and prejudice should have no place in a civilized society, but still their hold lingers. We should therefore acknowledge the fact that numerous citizen informants are using today's technology, specifically the 911 system, to cause harm. This means that to protect all members of our state, under our constitution we must reassess the indicia used to assess the reliability of a 911 informant. We should require both a factual basis and a basis of knowledge by police officers before there are intrusions into a person's privacy. Accordingly, I respectfully concur in the result.
____________________________
____________________________
40