Crone, Judge.
ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANT Scott B. Cockrum
Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP
Schererville, Indiana ATTORNEY FOR APPELLEE James Harper
Harper & Harper, LLC
Valparaiso, Indiana Appeal from the LaPorte Circuit Court The Honorable Thomas J. Alevizos, Judge Trial Court Cause No. 46C01-1303-CT-366 Crone, Judge.
Case Summary
[1] Brett Carney reported to Michigan City police that Fernando Patino, Jr., took various fixtures from a residence that Carney had purchased at a sheriff's sale. Based on Carney's report, Patino was placed on Michigan City's "most wanted" list, arrested, and charged with a felony. Patino was later found not guilty of the criminal charge. Patino sued Carney for, among other things, defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Following a trial, the jury awarded Patino $256,000 in damages against Carney. [2] Carney now appeals, first contending that the trial court erred in denying his pretrial motion for summary judgment on grounds that his statements to police were protected, as a matter of law, by the doctrine of qualified privilege. Carney also contends that the trial court erred in denying his subsequent motion for judgment on the evidence for the same reason. Finally, Carney contends that the jury verdict is excessive and that the trial court should have granted his motion to correct error on that basis. Concluding that the trial court did not err in denying Carney's various motions, and further concluding that the jury verdict is not excessive, we affirm.
Facts and Procedural History
Although Carney appeals the trial court's rulings at various stages of the proceedings, for clarity's sake, we primarily recite the relevant facts most favorable to the jury's verdict.
[3] In February 2011, Patino resided at a home on Franklin Street ("the Residence") in Michigan City that was owned by his father. Patino's father purchased the Residence in 2006 and secured a mortgage on the Residence. Following subsequent foreclosure, the Residence was sold at a sheriff's sale on the morning of February 18, 2011. Carney purchased the Residence at the sale for $33,676. [13] A jury trial began on September 25, 2017. Prior to the start, Patino withdrew his negligence claims, leaving only his defamation and intentional infliction of emotional distress claims. Patino presented his case-in-chief, and at the close of his evidence, Carney made an oral motion for judgment on the evidence again based upon qualified privilege, which the trial court took under advisement. Carney then presented his evidence, after which he renewed his motion for judgment on the evidence, which the court again took under advisement. Following deliberations, the jury returned a verdict in favor of Patino. The jury awarded total damages in the amount of $320,000 and apportioned fault as follows: Patino 5%, Michigan City Police Department 5%, Detective Corporal McClintock 10%, and Carney 80%. Accordingly, the trial court entered final judgment against Carney in the amount of $256,000. [14] Carney filed a motion to correct error which was denied by the trial court. The court also entered its order denying Carney's motion for judgment on the evidence. Carney now appeals the court's denial of his motion for summary judgment, the denial of his motion for judgment on the evidence, and the denial of his motion to correct error.
Carney claims that although Patino gave him a correct phone number, he gave a false name.
Discussion and Decision
Section 1 - The trial court did not err in denying Carney's
motion for summary judgment on the basis of qualified
privilege.
[15] Carney first argues that the trial court erred in denying his pretrial summary judgment motion. "The purpose of summary judgment is to terminate litigation enforcement to report criminal activity are qualifiedly privileged." Williams v. Tharp, 914 N.E.2d 756, 763 (Ind. 2009) (quoting Kelley v. Tanoos, 865 N.E.2d 593, 600 (Ind. 2007)). This furthers the compelling public interest of encouraging citizens not only to report suspected wrongdoing but also to assist law enforcement in investigating and apprehending persons who engage in criminal activity. Id. at 762-63. Our supreme court has stated,
If this purpose is to be met, the privilege must offer a robust defense against liability. Protecting unverified and even speculative reports of suspected wrongdoing to law enforcement is, in our view, supported by ample reasons of social advantage. It is important that citizens not opt for inaction, chilled from communicating with police in all but the most certain of situations.
Id. at 765. [18] The privilege, however, "is not without limits: a statement 'may lose its privileged character upon a showing of abuse wherein: (1) the communicator was primarily motivated by ill will in making the statement; (2) there was excessive publication of the defamatory statement; or (3) the statement was made without belief or grounds for belief in its truth.'"
Bah v.
Mac's Convenience Stores,
LLC, 37 N.E.3d 539, 548 (Ind. Ct. App. 2015) (quoting
Bals, 600 N.E.2d at 1356),
trans.
denied (2016). Thus,
the burden is upon the defendant in the first instance to establish the existence of a privileged occasion for the publication, by proof of a recognized public or private interest which would justify the utterance of the words. Then the plaintiff has the
burden of overcoming that privilege by showing that it has been abused. When speaking of abuse, the essence of the concept is not the speaker's spite but his abuse of the privileged occasion by going beyond the scope of the purposes for which privilege exists. And unless only one conclusion can be drawn from the evidence, the question of whether the privilege has been abused is for the jury.
Williams, 914 N.E.2d at 762 (citations, quotation marks, and alterations omitted). [19] We agree with Carney that the privileged occasion implicated by his communication to law enforcement related to the public interest in encouraging private citizens to report crime. Patino contends that Carney abused the privilege because, when he reported that Patino removed numerous fixtures from the Residence, he was primarily motivated by ill will and made the statement without belief or grounds for belief in truth. Carney claims that Patino presented no evidence but simply offered "speculation about the intent or knowledge of Carney in making the statement." Appellant's Br. at 33. "It is well settled, however, that '[s]ummary judgment must be denied if the resolution hinges upon state of mind, credibility of the witnesses, or the weight of the testimony.'"
Bah, 37 N.E.3d at 548 (quoting
Nelson v.
Jimison, 634 N.E.2d 509, 512 (Ind. Ct. App. 1994)). This is precisely the scenario that confronted the trial court here. [20] It is undisputed that, prior to Carney's communication to law enforcement, Patino and Carney had an extremely contentious second encounter. Patino
and the reasonable inferences to be drawn therefrom, was sufficient to establish a genuine issue of material fact on whether the qualified privilege had been abused, and therefore Carney was not entitled to summary judgment on Patino's claims based on the qualified privilege defense. Accordingly, the trial court did not err when it declined to enter summary judgment for Carney.
Defamation is that which tends to injure reputation or to diminish esteem, respect, good will, or confidence in the plaintiff, or to excite derogatory feelings or opinions about the plaintiff." Davidson v. Perron, 716 N.E.2d 29, 37 (Ind. Ct. App. 1999) trans. denied (2000). "To establish defamation, the plaintiff must prove the following elements: (1) a communication with defamatory imputation, (2) malice, (3) publication, and (4) damages." Id. A communication is defamatory per se if it imputes criminal conduct. Kelley v. Tanoos, 865 N.E.2d 593, 596 (Ind. 2007).
Although Patino's amended complaint raised several claims in addition to defamation, the basis of each claim was Carney's purported false statements to law enforcement. Thus, Carney asserts that he was entitled to summary judgment on all of Patino's claims based on the qualified privilege defense. Indeed, the qualified privilege defense to defamation has also been applied to claims of false imprisonment, negligence, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Brown v. Indianapolis Housing Agency, 971 N.E.2d 181, 186 (Ind. Ct. App. 2012).
Carney asserts that Patino failed to designate evidence that Carney's statements to police were, in fact, false. However, in his affidavit, Patino denied being at the Residence on February 20 or being in possession of the fixtures. This, in effect, is an averment that Carney's statements to the contrary were, in fact, false.
Carney briefly argues that the trial court erred in failing to enter at least partial summary judgment on Patino's defamation claim because Patino's amended complaint "failed to plead the alleged defamatory statements with any specificity." Appellant's Br. at 35. Carney did not assert this as grounds for summary judgment in his original brief in support of summary judgment. Indeed, his only mention of this alleged lack of specificity is a passing reference in a footnote in his reply brief in support of summary judgment. This was insufficient to alert the trial court to this argument. It is well settled that arguments not presented to the trial court on summary judgment are waived on appeal. Anderson v. Four Seasons Equestrian Ctr., Inc., 852 N.E.2d 576, 581 (Ind. Ct. App. 2006), trans. denied. The trial court cannot be found to have erred as to an issue or argument that it never truly had an opportunity to consider. Id. Thus, Carney has waived this argument, and we will not consider it on appeal.
Section 2 - The trial court did not err in denying Carney's
motion for judgment on the evidence on the basis of qualified
privilege.
[22] Carney next asserts that the evidence presented by Patino at trial "was insufficient to overcome the application of the [qualified] privilege" and therefore his motion for judgment on the evidence should have been granted. Appellant's Br. at 19. The standard of review for a challenge to a ruling on a motion for judgment on the evidence is the same standard utilized by the trial court in making its decision. Bah, 600 N.E.2d at 1357. We look only to the evidence and reasonable inferences therefrom most favorable to the nonmoving party. Id. The motion should be granted only where there is no substantial evidence supporting an essential issue in a case. Id. (citing Ind. Trial Rule 50(A); Johnson v. Naugle, 557 N.E.2d 1339, 1342 (Ind. Ct. App. 1990); Whisman v. Fawcett, 470 N.E.2d 73, 79 (Ind. 1984)). [23] Our supreme court has stated that determining whether evidence was sufficient to defeat a motion for judgment on the evidence requires both a quantitative and a qualitative analysis. Purcell v. Old Nat'l Bank, 972 N.E.2d 835, 840 (Ind. 2012). Specifically, the court explained,
Evidence fails quantitatively only if it is wholly absent; that is, only if there is no evidence to support the conclusion. If some evidence exists, a court must then proceed to the qualitative analysis to determine whether the evidence is substantial enough to support a reasonable inference in favor of the non-moving party.
Qualitatively, ... [evidence] fails when it cannot be said, with reason, that the intended inference may logically be drawn therefrom; and this may occur either because of an absence of credibility of a witness or because the intended inference may not be drawn therefrom without undue speculation. The use of such words as "substantial" and "probative" are useful in determining whether evidence is sufficient under the qualitative analysis. Ultimately, the sufficiency analysis comes down to one word: "reasonable."
Id. (citations and some quotation marks omitted). Unlike a motion for summary judgment under Indiana Trial Rule 56, the sufficiency test of Indiana Trial Rule 50(A) is not merely whether a conflict of evidence may exist, but rather whether there exists probative evidence, substantial enough to create a reasonable inference that the nonmovant has met his burden.
Id. at 841.
overcome Carney's qualified privilege defense. Accordingly, the trial court did not err in denying Carney's motion for judgment on the evidence.
Carney emphasizes that he never reported to law enforcement that he saw Patino actually taking the fixtures out of the Residence, only that he encountered Patino in the driveway of the Residence already in possession of the fixtures that had been taken out of the Residence. We find this to be a distinction without a difference.
Section 3 - The jury verdict is not excessive, and the trial court
did not abuse its discretion in denying Carney's motion to
correct error.
[26] Following the trial court's entry of judgment on the jury's award of $256,000 in damages to Patino, Carney filed a motion to correct error asserting that he was entitled to a new trial due to "the excessiveness of the jury verdict." Appellant's App. Vol. 5 at 158. This Court has explained that the remedy offered by Indiana Trial Rule 59(J)(5) is "available only where the evidence is insufficient to support the verdict as a matter of law." Solnosky v. Goodwell, 892 N.E.2d 174, 184 (Ind. Ct. App. 2008) (quoting City of Carmel v. Leeper Elec. Servs., Inc., 805 N.E.2d 389, 392 (Ind. Ct. App. 2004), trans. denied). Once the trial court has entered final judgment on the evidence for the amount of proper damages, we will reverse the decision only for an abuse of discretion. Id. [27] We afford a jury's damage award great deference on appeal. Sims v. Pappas, 73 N.E.3d 700, 709 (Ind. 2017). In considering whether a jury verdict is excessive, we do not reweigh the evidence and look only to the evidence and reasonable inferences that may be drawn therefrom that support the verdict. West v. J. Greg Allen Builder, Inc., 92 N.E.3d 634, 643 (Ind. Ct. App. 2017), trans. denied (2018). If there is any evidence in the record which supports the amount of the award, even if it is variable or conflicting, the award will not be disturbed. Sandberg Trucking, Inc. v. Johnson, 76 N.E.3d 178, 189 (Ind. Ct. App. 2017). "To warrant 18 reversal, the award must appear to be so outrageous as to impress the Court at first blush with its enormity." Id. (citation and quotation marks omitted). An award is not excessive unless the amount cannot be explained upon any basis other than prejudice, passion, partiality, corruption, or some other element of improper consideration. Sims, 73 N.E.3d at 709. [28] Carney complains that "Patino presented no medical expenses, no lost wages, and no documented losses of any kind" to support the jury's damage award. Appellant's Br. at 44. He argues that "[e]ven if there is an emotional toll associated with being charged with a crime, there is no justification for so large a verdict." Id. at 45. We disagree. [29] "Awards for pain, suffering, fright, humiliation, and mental anguish are particularly within the province of the jury because they involve the weighing of evidence and credibility of witnesses." Landis v. Landis, 664 N.E.2d 754, 757 (Ind. Ct. App. 1996). Indeed, "[p]hysical and mental pain are, by their very nature, not readily susceptible to quantification, and therefore, the jury is given very wide latitude in determining these kinds of damages." Groves v. First Nat'l Bank of Valparaiso, 518 N.E.2d 819, 831 (Ind. Ct. App. 1988). "Our inability to actually look into the minds of jurors and determine how they computed an award is, to a large extent, the reason behind the rule that a verdict will be upheld if the award falls within the bounds of the evidence." Griffin v. Acker, 659 N.E.2d 659, 664 (Ind. Ct. App. 1995). 19 [30] The evidence favorable to the verdict reveals that, in addition to the monetary cost incurred in defending his criminal trial, Patino suffered great mental and emotional pain due to the highly publicized charge and arrest. His criminal case was pending for more than five years, and he presented evidence of the negative impact that it had, and continues to have, on both his personal and professional life. Under the circumstances, the $256,000 award is not so outrageous as to indicate that the jury was motivated by prejudice, passion, partiality, corruption, or some other element of improper consideration. Carney has failed to persuade us that the trial court abused its discretion in denying his motion to correct error. We therefore affirm the verdict and the trial court's judgment entered thereon. [31] Affirmed. Najam, J., and Pyle, J., concur.