Consol. Rail Corp. v. Ace Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co.

CONSOLIDATED RAIL CORPORATION, Petitioner v. ACE PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE CO. (FORMERLY AETNA INS. CO.), ALLIANZ GLOBAL RISKS U.S. INSURANCE CO.(FORMERLY ALLIANZ INS. CO.), ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE CO., ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO. (AS SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO NORTHBROOK EXCESS & SURPLUS INS. CO. A/K/A NORTHBROOK INS. CO.),AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE CO. (AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP), AMERICAN MOTORISTS INSURANCE CO.(KEMPER), AVIVA INSURANCE CO. OF CANADA (U.S. BRANCH),(FORMERLY GAN GENERAL INS. CO. (FORMERLY SIMCOE & ERIE GENERAL INS. CO.)), BIRMINGHAM FIRE INSURANCE CO. OF PA. (AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP), BRITAMCO UNDERWRITERS, INC.C/O DEVONSHIRE GROUP, CENTURY INDEMNITY CO. (SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO CIGNA SPECIALTY INS. CO. (FORMERLY CALIFORNIA UNION INSURANCE CO.) AND AS SUCCESSOR TO CCI INSURANCE CO., SUCCESSOR TO INSURANCE CO. OF NORTH AMERICA), CONTINENTAL INSURANCE CO. (IN ITS OWN RIGHT AND AS SUCCESSOR IN INTEREST TO HARBOR INSURANCE CO.)(CNA INSURANCE COS.), EMPLOYERS MUTUAL CASUALTY CO. (EMC INSURANCE COS.), EMPLOYERS INSURANCE OF WAUSAU (FORMERLY EMPLOYERS MUTUAL OF WAUSAU), EVANSTON INSURANCE CO., EVEREST REINSURANCE CO. (FORMERLY PRUDENTIAL REINSURANCE CO.), FEDERAL INSURANCE CO. (CHUBB GROUP OF INS. COS.), FIREMAN'S FUND INSURANCE CO., FIRST STATE INSURANCE CO. (HARTFORD INSURANCE GROUP), GRANITE STATE INSURANCE CO. (AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP), HARTFORD ACCIDENT & INDEMNITY CO. (HARTFORD INSURANCE GROUP), HUDSON INSURANCE CO., INSCO C/O DEVONSHIRE GROUP, INSURANCE COMPANY OF THE STATE OF PENNSYLVANIA (AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP), LANDMARK INSURANCE CO. (AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP), LEXINGTON INSURANCE CO. (AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP), LIBERTY MUTUAL INSURANCE CO., MIDSTATES REINSURANCE CORP. (FORMERY MEAD REINSURANCE CORP.), NATIONAL CASUALTY CO., NATIONAL UNION FIRE INSURANCE CO. OF PITTSBURGH, PA (AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP), NORTHWESTERN NATIONAL INSURANCE CO.(FORMERLY BELLEFONTE UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE CO.), OLD REPUBLIC INSURANCE CO., PACIFIC INSURANCE CO.(CNA INSURANCE COS.), REPUBLIC INSURANCE CO., ROYAL INSURANCE CO. OF AMERICA (FORMERLY ROYAL GLOBE INS. CO.)(ROYAL & SUN ALLIANCE INSURANCE GROUP), SENTRY INSURANCE GROUP (AS ASSUMPTIVE REINSURER OF GREAT SOUTHWEST FIRE INS. CO. AND GREAT SOUTHWEST SURPLUS LINES INS. CO.), ST. PAUL FIRE & MARINE INSURANCE CO. (ST. PAUL TRAVELERS COMPANIES), ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INSURANCE CO. (ST. PAUL TRAVELERS COMPANIES), STONEWALL INSURANCE CO.,TIG INSURANCE CO.(AS SUCCESSOR TO INTERNATIONAL INS. CO. (FORMERLY INTERNATIONAL SURPLUS LINES INS. CO.)(FAIRFAX FINANCIAL (USA) GROUP), TIG PREMIER INSURANCE CO. (FORMERLY TRANSAMERICA INS. CO.)(FAIRFAX FINANCIAL (USA) GROUP),TRAVELERS CASUALTY AND SURETY CO. (FORMERLY ATENA CASUALTY AND SURETY CO.) (ST. PAUL TRAVELERS COMPANIES), TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO.(ST. PAUL TRAVELERS COMPANIES), TWIN CITY FIRE INSURANCE CO.(HARTFORD INSURANCE GROUP), UNIONE ITALIANA REINSURANCE CO. OF AMERICA, INC., UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE CO., ZURICH AMERICAN INSURANCE CO.(FORMERLY ZURICH INSURANCE CO.) AND CERTAIN LONDON MARKET INSURANCE COMPANIES AND PENNSYLVANIA PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSURANCE GUARANTY ASSOCIATION (FORMERLY PENNSYLVANIA INSURANCE GUARANTY ASSOCIATION), Respondents