JOHN A. JARVEY, United States District Court Magistrate Judge.
This matter comes before the court pursuant to defendant's motion to disqualify plaintiff's counsel, or in the alternative, for protective order (docket number 79). For the reasons set forth below, the defendant's motion is denied.
BACKGROUND
In January 1997, the plaintiff, Dr. Garry Goodlett filed for disability benefits under a group disability policy that his employer, Integra Health, obtained from the Paul Revere Insurance Company. The Paul Revere Company denied the claim on April 16, 1997. On May 1, 1997, attorneys Mark Zaiger and Kevin Collins of Shuttleworth Ingersoll, P.C., of Cedar Rapids, Iowa, filed suit for wrongful denial of benefits. Since May 1997, the attorneys have been involved in all aspects of trial preparation; the case is scheduled for trial in March 21, 2000.
In January 1997, the Paul Revere Insurance Company was a subsidiary of the Paul Revere Corporation which was organized in 1992 as an insurance holding company domiciled in Massachusetts. On March 27, 1997, Paul Revere Corporation became a wholly-owned subsidiary of Provident Companies, Inc., which is domiciled in Delaware. Then, in November 1998, Provident Companies, Inc., announced a merger with UNUM Corporation, effective June 30, 1999. As a result of the merger, UNUM Provident Corporation, a publically owned insurance holding company, was created (NYSE: UNM). Also, as a result of the merger, UNUM Provident acquired 100 percent of the Paul Revere Corporation.
Mark Zaiger, of the law firm of Shuttleworth and Ingersoll in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, became aware of the merger on September 7, 1999. Shuttleworth had represented UNUM (now a subsidiary of UNUM Provident) in a number of cases and Mr. Zaiger has been involved in six UNUM cases, five of which have been closed since early 1998, prior to the merger of UNUM and Provident; and one, commenced in May 1999, recently settled and has been dismissed. Mr. Zaiger claims that except for the most recent case, all of Shuttleworth's files (except billing information) for UNUM matters have been destroyed in accordance with office procedure.
Disqualification
The defendant moves for Mark Zaiger's disqualification in the suit against Paul Revere Insurance because the defendant claims Mr. Zaiger has a conflict of interest due to prior representation of UNUM. The defendant claims that Mr. Zaiger has a conflict of interest in representing the plaintiff against Paul Revere because (1) the financial interests of UNUM and Paul Revere are intertwined; (2) that the matters at issue in this lawsuit are "substantially related" to the lawsuits in which Mr. Zaiger acted as counsel for UNUM; (3) that five of the lawsuits in which Mr. Zaiger defended UNUM involve the same subject matter — ERISA disability claims filed against UNUM; (4) that Mr. Zaiger possessed and had knowledge of confidential business documents and information protected by the attorney-client privilege when he represented UNUM; and (5) that Mr. Zaiger's representation of plaintiff in this case violates Canons 4 (preserving confidences and secrets of a client); Canon 5 (exercising independent professional judgment on behalf of the client); and Canon 9 (avoiding the appearance of professional impropriety) of the Code of Professional Responsibility.
A motion to disqualify an attorney must be approached with caution in today's world of "national or multi-national public corporations owning or partially owning subsidiaries which may also be national or multi-national." Ramada Franchise System, Inc. v. Hotel of Gainesville Associates, 988 F. Supp. 1460, 1462 (N.D. Ga. 1997). There is the need for a delicate balance: Courts must ensure the trust and loyalty owed by lawyers to clients are not compromised. Id. Courts must uphold an individual's right to be represented by counsel of choice, and disqualification has the immediate adverse effect on the client by separating him from his counsel of choice. Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company v. RJR Nabisco, Inc., 721 F. Supp. 534, 539 (S.D.N.Y. 1989). Courts must be wary of motions to disqualify attorneys often interposed for tactical reasons. Id. Mindful of competing interests, courts must approach motions to disqualify an attorney with heightened scrutiny. It is not a time to paint with broad strokes, but to carefully examine the specific conduct of each particular case. Hoffman, supra, at 836.
Courts have come to differing conclusions in determining whether parent or sister corporation of an entity that was represented by an attorney should also be considered a "client" for disqualification purposes. Rather than focusing on labels as a means of resolving attorney disqualification disputes, courts should sift the facts and circumstances involved. Ramada, supra, at 1463.
Analysis
In order for an attorney to be disqualified on the basis of a prior representation, the party seeking disqualification must prove it once had an attorney-client relationship with the opposing lawyer, and that the subject matter of the two transactions is substantially related. Id. See Hoffman v. Internal Medicine, P.C., of Ottumwa, 533 N.W.2d 834 (Iowa Ct.App. 1995) (the standard used to resolve motions to disqualify counsel based on prior representation of a present adversary is the "substantial relationship" test); Richers v. Marsh McLennan Group Assocs., 459 N.W.2d 478 (Iowa 1990); Killian v. Iowa District Court, 452 N.W.2d 426 (Iowa 1990); Fred Weber, Inc., v. Shell Oil Co., 566 F.2d 602, 607-08 (8th Cir. 1977), cert denied, 436, U.S. 905, 98 S. Ct. 2235, 56 L. Ed. 2d 403 (1978); First Wisconsin Mortgage Trust v. First Wisconsin Corp., 584 F.2d 201 (7th Cir. 1978) (citing cases in circuits where the "substantial relationship" test determines whether counsel has a conflict).
First, the focus is on whether there exist sufficient aspects of the attorney-client relationship for the purposes of triggering inquiry into a potential conflict. Then, the "substantial relationship" inquiry is restricted to the possibility of disclosure; the court may not inquire into whether actual confidences were disclosed. Ramada, supra.
The substantial relationship rule calls for disqualification when the subject matter of the new litigation or representation is substantially related to the subject of the prior representation. Hoffman, supra, at 835. The purpose of the rule is to ensure that a client's confidential communications to his or her lawyer will not be used against that client when the attorney-client relationship has ended and the lawyer later represents a party adverse to the former client. Id. The "substantial relationship" test embodies the substance of Canon 4 (preserving the confidences and secrets of a client), and Canon 9 (avoiding the appearance of professional impropriety), of the Code of Professional Responsibility. The Canons protect the integrity of the attorney-client relationship from a conflict of interest and demands that lawyers serve each client with undivided loyalty. In making its "substantial relationship" analysis, the court must determine three things: (1) the scope of the prior legal representation; (2) the reasonableness of inferring that the confidential information allegedly given would have been given to a lawyer representing a client in those matters; and (3) the relevance of the information to the issues raised in the pending litigation. Ramada, supra, at 1462. If the moving party meets its burdens, the court will make an irrebuttable presumption that relevant confidential information was disclosed during the former period of representation. Id.
The movant has the burden to prove a substantial relationship between the two representations by producing evidence to support its claim. Hoffman, supra, at 836. A mere claim of conflict is insufficient. Id. Again, the movant is not required to divulge the actual confidential communication in order to prove the prior representation is substantially related. Id.
Attorney-Client Relationship
There is no dispute about the fact that Mr. Zaiger, Mr. Collins and Shuttleworth Ingersoll defended UNUM Corporation in six separate lawsuits, five of which took place prior to UNUM's merger with Provident. This court must decide whether a "substantial relationship" existed here by determining whether Mr. Zaiger, Mr. Collins and Shuttleworth owe a duty of loyalty to UNUM Provident Corporation based on the six times they have provided legal representation to UNUM. While Mr. Zaiger is the main attorney for the plaintiff, when one lawyer is involved, the entire firm is involved for the purpose of evaluating conflicts of interest. Hoffmann, supra, at 836. Since five of the six lawsuits at issue here were completed before 1998, and the sixth suit has been settled and dismissed by this date, this court will focus its analysis on prior representation.
Representation is permissible where (1) the attorney has not represented and does not now represent the subsidiary; (2) the subsidiary is not the "alter ego" of the parent corporation; (3) there is no adversity between the corporation and the subsidiary on the subject of the representation. Teradyne, Inc. v. Hewlett-Packard Company, 1991 WL 239940 (N.D. Cal).
The Shuttleworth firm and Mr. Zaiger represented UNUM in five lawsuits which were completed by 1998, before the merger; one suit was filed in May 1999, while the corporate merger was under way, but before it became effective on June 30, 1999. That one lawsuit was settled in 1999, and at this time, there is no defense litigation pending between Mr. Zaiger or Shuttleworth Ingersoll, and any of UNUM Provident's subsidiaries.
Mr. Zaiger claims that UNUM is not a parent company to Paul Revere. Rather, he argues, they are sister companies, under the corporate umbrella of UNUMProvident. See Corporate Structure chart in affidavit of Gloria Langevin, Discovery Coordinator of the UNUM Provident legal department. According to Ms. Langevin, Paul Revere's profits and losses are calculated separately from UNUM's, even though Paul Revere's financial picture becomes part of UNUM Provident's quarterly and year-end reports. The fact that Paul Revere's finances are calculated separately from UNUM's would support the notion that these are separate entities, sister companies within the UNUM Provident corporate structure. There is no evidence that would suggest that UNUM is the "alter ego" of Paul Revere, that UNUM could stand in the place of Paul Revere. As a result, the court will view these companies as two entities, not one.
Bringing suit against a subsidiary will not violate an attorney's duty of loyalty to the parent company unless there are or may be "direct" adverse consequences on the parent company. Id. at *3. "Direct" consequences are limited to the case in which the parent is or may be made a party to the suit; or where the parent is directly related to the case or transaction in which the attorney will undertake representation against the subsidiary. Id. The express exception to this rule is where the corporation and its subsidiary would be treated as a single entity because the subsidiary is acting essentially as the "alter ego" of the parent. Id. The court must evaluate the separateness of the entities, whether corporate formalities are observed; the extent to which each entity has distinct and separate managements and board of directors; and whether, for legal purposes, one entity could be considered the "alter ego" of the other.
Confidences
The defendant claims that Mr. Zaiger, while working with UNUM's in-house counsel and other employees, possessed and had knowledge of UNUM's confidential business documents and information subject to the attorney-client privilege. Also, the defendant claims that because UNUM owns Paul Revere, UNUM Provident attorneys are responsible for defending cases filed against its subsidiaries, and the law departments have undergone merger and consolidation. UNUM claims that in the process of previous representations, Mr. Zaiger likely discussed UNUM's philosophy on how to defend cases, including how to settle claims. At the very minimum, the defense claims, some confidences were likely disclosed to Mr. Zaiger.
In representing UNUM as outside counsel for the six previously mentioned cases, Mr. Zaiger claims he reported to different in-house attorneys, except for two cases; and in the most recent matter, he reported to a legal assistant. Mr. Zaiger claims he never personally met any UNUM representatives and does not recall any depositions of UNUM representatives. Of course, he did see the individual files of former cases, letters from UNUM representatives and a litigation memo specific to the facts of the individual cases.
The Eighth Circuit has determined that "the attorney-client relationship raises an irrefutable presumption that confidences were disclosed." State of Arkansas v. Dean Foods Products Company, Inc. 605 F.2d 380, (8th Cir. 1979) (overturned in Multi-Piece Rim Products Liability Litigation. Firestone Tire Rubber Co. v. Risjord, (8th Cir. 1980) (order denying motion for disqualification of counsel is not a final order and is not appealable under collateral order doctrine. Also overturning Fred Weber v. Shell Oil Co., 566 F.2d 602 (8th Cir. 1977). Confidential disclosures, actual or presumed, necessitate disqualification of the attorney when he represents an adverse interest in a related matter. Id. Moreover, confidences imputed to the attorney are presumed shared among his partners and employees associated with him at that time. Id.
The defendant claims that Mr. Zaiger owes a duty of loyalty to his former client which precludes him from representing the plaintiff in this lawsuit. Thus, the issue here is whether Mr. Zaiger in representing the plaintiff against Paul Revere is actually representing an adverse interest in a related matter, or whether the companies are sufficiently separate as to preclude Mr. Zaiger from owning any duty to UNUM. Mr. Zaiger, in his affidavit, claims his duty of loyalty stops with UNUM and that he owes no duty to UNUM Provident. He further claims that information he received from UNUM was case-specific, and nothing of the nature of confidential communications that would give insight into UNUM Provident's corporate legal strategy. In other words, Mr. Zaiger does not purport to know any legal secrets or strategies that would hurt the defendant in this case. The defendant says UNUM's legal department also directs the defense of the ERISA claim against Paul Revere.
Mr. Zaiger claims that this case does not involve the same set of facts and circumstances as previous lawsuits. While the current case is an ERISA claim, and the previous UNUM suits were also ERISA claims, Mr. Zaiger says that is where the similarity stops. The current suit involves differing medical evidence, Mr. Zaiger says. Previous claims involved a legal causation issue of whether a claimant was killed in an accident or by disease; the timing of when a claimant became disabled; and the definition of disability as it relates to loss of income.
If there were confidential disclosures, actual or presumed, disqualification would be necessary so the attorney-client relationship would not be breached. If the court determines that indeed the two cases are substantially related, it will be presumed that Shuttleworth and Zaiger received confidential attorney-client information that could hurt UNUM in the current litigation if it were allowed to move forward without a disqualification of plaintiff's counsel.
Professional Ethics
Canons 4 and 5 of the Code of Professional Responsibility deal with the lawyer-client relationship; an attorney must use good professional judgment on behalf of a client and protect secrets and confidences. Confidences are communications made in trust and not intended for public disclosure; specifically, a communication made between client and attorney in the course of representation. From what Mr. Zaiger is saying, there were no confidences communicated between himself and the corporate attorneys and legal assistant with whom he communicated during the course of his work with UNUM. Under Canon 4, a client's secret is information that cannot be disclosed without a breach of trust; specifically, information that is acquired in the course of the attorney-client relationship. Confidences, unlike secrets, are actually communicated between lawyer and client; secrets may be knowledge that an attorney gains in the course of the representation, but not necessarily information that is communicated directly between the lawyer and the client. While secrets are to be honored, it is clear where confidences originate; it is not so clear where secrets come from.
Canon 9: The defendant relies on Canon 9 of the Code of Professional Responsibility which provides that a lawyer "should avoid even the appearance of professional impropriety." However, even defendants recognize that courts are reluctant to rest disqualification of counsel solely upon Canon 9. Hartford Accident and Indemnity Company v. RJR Nabisco, Inc., 721 F. Supp. 534, 539 (S.D.N.Y. 1989). In fact, the ethical considerations, EC9-6 of Canon 9, say the lawyer should "strive to avoid not only professional impropriety but also the appearance of impropriety." EC9-6 recognizes that in this modern corporate world of mergers and takeovers, Canon 9 is not an absolute. It is a noble goal.
CONCLUSION
In order to disqualify Mr. Zaiger from representing the plaintiff in this lawsuit, this court must determine whether Mr. Zaiger's representation of the plaintiff against Paul Revere is substantially related to the prior litigation (in which Mr. Zaiger and Shuttleworth provided counsel for UNUM) simply because this cases alleges the same theory of recovery against a sister corporation. This court finds that there is no substantial relationship. Mr. Zaiger and Shuttleworth represented UNUM, not UMUM Provident in prior litigation. Those lawsuits are no longer pending. The corporate entities are sufficiently separate as to create no attorney-client relationship between Mr. Zaiger and UNUM Provident. Also, the defendant offers no evidence to show that this particular ERISA claim has a substantial relationship to previous ERISA claims litigated for UNUM by Mr. Zaiger and Shuttleworth. Therefore, no conflict of interest exists in Mr. Zaiger's representation of the plaintiff in this case against Paul Revere. The defendant's motion to disqualify the plaintiff's counsel is denied.
Upon the foregoing,
IT IS ORDERED
That the defendant's November 5, 1999, motion to disqualify plaintiff's counsel or, in the alternative, for protective order (docket number 79) is denied in its entirety.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED
That the plaintiff's November 19, 1999, motion to permit filing of affidavit (docket number 84) is granted.