AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company, Plaintiff, v. Shurtape Technologies, Inc. and Manco, Inc., Defendants.

ORDER

MICHAEL J. DAVIS, District Judge

This matter is before the Court on the objections of Plaintiff Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company to United States Chief Magistrate Judge Jonathon Lebedoff's Report and Recommendation ("RR") dated May 2, 2002, denying the parties' motions to enforce the Settlement Agreement and reopening litigation in this case. Pursuant to statute, the Court conducts a de novo review of the record. 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1); Local Rule 72.1(c). For the reasons that follow, the Court rejects the Report and Recommendation.

BACKGROUND

Plaintiff Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company ("3M") manufactures a blue, professional-grade, masking tape used by painters. Defendant Shurtape Technologies, Inc. ("Shurtape") also manufactures and Defendant Manco, Inc. ("Manco") distributes a professional-grade masking tape for painters that closely matches the blue color of 3M's tape. On September 22, 1998, 3M commenced a lawsuit against Shurtape and Manco, asserting claims for trademark infringement, unfair competition, and trademark dilution of its blue masking tape. As the parties were fast approaching an April 1, 2002, trial date, they began extensive settlement negotiations. On December 27, 2001, the parties participated in a settlement conference with Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff. Again, on January 18, 2002, the parties participated in a settlement conference with Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff. On March 7, 2002, the parties met in person and by telephone to further engage in settlement negotiations. On March 21, 2002, the parties met again in person and by telephone to discuss settlement. At that meeting, the parties reached an agreement on all but two issues. Specifically, the parties reached an agreement as to what shades of blue Defendants would be permitted to use for their tape. The parties agreed that Defendants could use a blue (1) darker than "Dark Blue," a tape of which was marked as Exhibit C during the negotiations, and (2) lighter than "Light Blue," a tape of which was marked as Exhibit D during the negotiations. The rolls of tape used during these negotiations were laboratory rather than production line rolls. Nevertheless, 3M's counsel initialed the rolls of tape used during these negotiations to signify 3M's acceptance of this agreement as to these colors. The parties reduced their agreement to a writing in the form of a draft Settlement Agreement. The Settlement Agreement provided that:

1.6 "Dark Blue" is the blue color depicted at Exhibit C. The color defined, [sic] is understood to be the color of the actual roll of tape comprising Exhibit C regardless of the method used to achieve the color.
1.7 "Light Blue" is the blue color depicted at Exhibit D. The color defined is understood to be the color of the actual roll of tape comprising Exhibit D regardless of the method used to achieve the color.
3.1 Beginning ninety (90) days after the Effective Date, Shurtape and Manco may only manufacture, or cause to have manufactured on their behalf, blue painter's masking tape that is darker (or more distinct from 3M's 2090 Blue) than Dark Blue or lighter (or more distinct from 3M's 2090 Blue) than Light Blue. Manco and Shurtape will not manufacture or sell blue painter's tape that is manufactured in a color that is Dark Blue or Light Blue or in the color range between Dark Blue and Light Blue. Defendants will ensure that 100% of the blue painter's masking tape manufactured and sold by Defendants will be darker (or more distinct from 3M's 2090 Blue) than Dark Blue or lighter (or more distinct from 3M's 2090 Blue) than Light Blue.

At the final settlement conference with Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff on March 26, 2002, the parties presented the draft Settlement Agreement. After several hours of negotiation, the parties resolved the remaining two issues, hand wrote the agreed revisions on the draft Settlement Agreement, and initialed the revisions signifying their agreement. Also at the meeting, Shurtape presented 3M with a roll of blue laboratory-created tape, marked as Exhibit E. Shurtape claimed that it would target that color in manufacturing its blue tape. The parties agreed that Exhibit E, in any event, would be darker than Exhibit C. The Settlement Agreement was changed to reflect that agreement:

3.7 3M shall not object or interfere with Shurtape and/or Manco offering painter's masking tape in a color more distinct from 3M's 2090 Blue than Light Blue or Dark Blue or lighter than Light Blue or darker than Dark Blue by any increment whatsoever. 3M agrees that the roll of blue painter's masking tape depicted at Exhibit E is darker than Dark Blue (Exhibit C).

After finalizing the written agreement, Shurtape's President Jim Shuford ("Shuford") indicated that all of the tapes samples used had been produced in a laboratory and did not reflect the results of the actual production process. Shuford expressed his concern over whether Shurtape would be able to produce tape in the same color as, or darker than, Exhibit C. Thomas Tinkham, attorney for 3M recalls asking Blake Duerre ("Duerre"), counsel for Shurtape, whether Mr. Shuford was taking the position that the settlement was contingent on the manufacturing process and that Duerre said, "No." Neither Duerre not David Shultz ("Schultz"), Manco's counsel, recalls being asked whether the Agreement was contingent. Nevertheless, it is undisputed that Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff asked the parties whether there was a "full and final settlement" of the dispute and told the parties that it would not notify this Court to take the case off the trial calendar if there were contingencies. The attorneys represented to Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff that there were indeed no contingencies.

Although 3M incorporated the language revisions into the draft Settlement Agreement and circulated it, the Agreement was not yet signed because the parties were awaiting Shurtape to make 8 additional sets of Exhibits C and D and 9 additional rolls of Exhibit E to attach to all copies of the Settlement Agreement for the formal closing. Defendants take the position that these additional rolls were to be production run rolls.

On April 4, 2002, this Court issued an Order dismissing this action with prejudice because it settled. The Court retained jurisdiction for 15 days to permit any party to move to seek enforcement of the settlement terms. See Order of April 4, 2002. Thereafter, on April 15, Shurtape's counsel presented a roll of tape lighter than the roll marked as Exhibit C, and asked that it be substituted for Exhibit C. 3M refused the substitution, determining that it would result in modifying an essential, material term of the Settlement Agreement. 3M determined that the tape was not darker or more distinct than the agreed upon "Dark Blue" used in the negotiations. Duerre claims that Shurtape cannot make a darker blue with its production equipment, but 3M disputes this contention.

The parties cross-moved for enforcement of the Agreement. Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff held argument on the matter, and ultimately issued a Report and Recommendation to deny the motions in favor of reopening litigation. 3M now objects to that Report and Recommendation. The Court held oral argument in the matter and has reviewed the parties' submissions. The Court will address each objection in turn.

DISCUSSION

Settlement agreements are governed by basic contract law. Sheng v. Starkey Lab., Inc., 53 F.3d 192, 194 (8th Cir. 1995). The parties to a settlement agreement must agree on all material terms in order for the settlement agreement to be enforceable. Id.

1. Exhibit C, Material Term, and Meeting of the Minds

3M objects to Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff's conclusion that Exhibit C does not exist because it was to be a "production line" roll rather than the laboratory roll used during the negotiations. (See RR at 3, 7-8.) 3M also disputes Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff's legal conclusions that there was no meeting of the minds and that the Settlement Agreement lacks a material term. Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff found that the conduct and dealings of the parties indicated that there was to be further negotiations as to Exhibit C, and therefore, no meeting of the minds occurred. (See RR at 7.) Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff also concluded that because Exhibit C does not exist, the Settlement Agreement lacks a material term. (Id.)

3M argues that Exhibit C was finalized on March 21 when the "Dark Blue" tape roll created by Shurtape was placed on the table before the negotiating teams. The Court agrees. During the settlement negotiations, the parties and counsel identified and agreed upon an acceptable color to represent "Dark Blue." They marked the roll of tape that represented that color as Exhibit C. 3M's counsel initialed the very roll of tape used as Exhibit C during the settlement negotiations. The Settlement Agreement contains no language that the roll marked as Exhibit C would be replaced with a production line roll. Rather, the Settlement Agreement specifically states that "`Dark Blue' is the blue color depicted at Exhibit C. The color defined, is understood to be the color of the actual roll of tape comprising Exhibit C regardless of the method used to achieve the color." (Settlement Agreement at 1.6) (emphasis added).

Defendants argue that a letter dated March 27, 2002, from 3M's counsel, confirming the final settlement, suggests that the tapes in question were to be the production line rolls rather than the laboratory rolls used during negotiations. Defendants point to counsel's use of the word "create" to prove this point.

The confirmation letter reads:

Based upon the representations made by the parties at the settlement conference yesterday morning, this document constitutes that final written settlement agreement of the parties. At this point we are awaiting the creation of Exhibits C, D and E by Shurtape.

Shultz Aff. ¶ 6. Nevertheless, Defendants' argument is semantic. The word "create" means "to bring into being," "cause to exist," "make," or "produce." THE NEW MERRIAM-WEBSTER DICTIONARY 185 (4th ed. 1989). The Court fails to see how the term "create" is necessarily inconsistent with 3M's contention that Shurtape was to make or produce additional copies of the Exhibit C already in existence. Certainly, Defendants' interpretation of the term "create" to the contrary is not sufficient to overcome the overwhelming evidence that the Exhibit C used during the settlement negotiations represented the dark blue color agreed upon by the parties.

Finally, this interpretation of the parties' negotiations and Agreement is the most logically sound of all the parties' arguments. The parties had finalized the Agreement and indicated to Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff that there were no contingencies. It is logical that the parties would have agreed to an acceptable range of the color blue before they finalized the Agreement. Given that the color blue is at the heart of the lawsuit 3M initiated, the Court simply cannot conclude that 3M would have entered a final settlement contingent on shades of blue that it had never seen before or that did not even exist.

For these reasons, the Court concludes that the parties agreed to specific colors of blue represented by Exhibits C and D that would form the boundary of Shurtape's blue tape. The parties had a meeting of the minds on this matter, and the Settlement Agreement reflects the material terms of that Agreement.

2. Shurtape's ability to manufacture a darker shade of blue, or otherwise comply with the agreed-upon color boundaries

3M also objects to Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff's conclusion that Shurtape cannot make a darker shade of blue tape in its manufacturing process. The RR indicates that if it adopted 3M's position, Defendants would be foreclosed from producing a dark blue tape because of production limitations. (See RR at 5.) The RR also found credible that the manufacturing process to make the darker blue would alter the essential qualities of the masking tape, which make it competitive with 3M's tape. (See RR at 5, n. 2.)

Shurtape argues that Chief Magistrate Judge Lebedoff's conclusions are sound, and also renews its argument that the doctrine of impossibility constitutes an additional basis for the finding that no Settlement Agreement exists. Under the doctrine of impossibility, "performance of a contractual duty may be excused when, due to the existence of a fact or circumstance of which the promisor at the time of the making of the contract neither knew nor had reason to know, performance becomes impossible, or becomes impracticable in the sense that performance would cast upon the promisor an excessive or unreasonably burdensome hardship, loss, expense, or injury. The distinction between objective and subjective impossibility is not to be overlooked." Powers v. Siats, 70 N.W.2d 344, 348 (Minn. 1955).

3M presents ample evidence of numerous ways in which Defendants could manufacture a competitive dark blue tape. (See Sadrakula Aff. ¶ 4.) These methods include any of the following methods or a combination of the following methods: adding additional dye into the saturant; specifying and purchasing another shade of blue dye that is darker than its current blue dye from its dye supplier; purchasing paper backing that has been dyed blue; purchasing paper backing that is not bleached white; printing the paper backing blue at the end of the manufacturing process; or putting blue dye into any other layers of Shurtape's CP-27 tape manufacturing process that are currently clear. (Id.) 3M also moves to file a reply brief and the Glass Declaration to further support its argument that it is not impossible for Defendants to manufacture a tape darker than Exhibit C. 3M argues that it ran production experiments with three times and five times the dye concentration of the standard 3M 2090 blue tape backing, and it was able to minimize the amount of white mottled surface appearance and maximize the uniformity of the color appearance with minor adjustments. Glass Decl. at 1-2. Moreover, 3M contends that this production is possible with minimal additional cost. Id. at 2.

In contrast, Shurtape argues that it is impossible for it to produce a tape darker than "Dark Blue." Shuford argues that in its own production runs, the dye concentration percentages it had used for the laboratory tapes on the lab coater did not correlate perfectly with concentrations on the production machine. Shuford Aff. ¶ 7. Shuford indicates that "it took more color concentrate in production to get the same basic color we got in the lab." Id. Shuford also indicates that he reviewed the Sadrakula Affidavit with Shurtape's Research and Development Department, and determined that the alternative methods for achieving a dark blue tape had already been tried or would require significant changes to their manufacturing process. Id.

In this case, the Court concludes that Defendants have not presented sufficient evidence to demonstrate that it would be impossible to produce a blue tape outside the color boundaries agreed upon by the parties. At worst, Shuford has suggested that higher dye concentrations would be required to produce a dark blue tape. None of the evidence presented by Defendants appears to negate the experiments described in the Glass Declaration, where 3M successfully produced a darker blue tape during a regular production run with minor adjustments to the standard manufacturing process. Further, Defendants provide no specific evidence regarding how the experiments suggested by Sadrakula were attempted and failed. Likewise, Defendants provide no details concerning what "significant" changes would be required to its manufacturing process so as to make manufacturing a dark blue tape "impossible." Perhaps more significant, this aspect of the Agreement was not "unanticipated," as required under the doctrine of impossibility. The parties agreed to the specific blue color range regardless of the method used to achieve that color. Finally, no evidence exists whatsoever to suggest that it is impossible for Shurtape to make a competitive light blue tape, or tape of another color altogether. Accordingly, based on all the files, records, and proceedings herein, IT IS HEREBY

ORDERED that:

1. Plaintiff Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company's Motion for Leave to File Reply and Glass Declaration (Clerk Doc. No. 239) is GRANTED;

2. Plaintiff Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company's Motion to Strike Shuford Affidavit is DENIED;

3. Plaintiff Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing Company's Motion to Enforce Settlement Agreement (Clerk Doc. No. 209) is GRANTED;

4. Defendant Shurtape Technologies' Motion to Enforce Settlement, or in the Alternative, to Reopen Litigation (Clerk Doc. No. 214) is DENIED; and

5. Defendant Manco's Motion to Enforce Settlement, or in the Alternative, to Reopen Litigation (Clerk Doc. no. 218) is DENIED.

LET JUDGMENT BE ENTERED ACCORDINGLY.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

MINNESOTA MINING AND MANUFACTURING v. SHURTAPE TECHNOLOGIES, (D.Minn. 2002)
(Aug 2, 2002)