AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges

DARNELL DEBERRY Petitioner, v. LEONARD A. PORTUONDO, Respondent

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

LEONARD SAND, United States District Judge.

Petitioner Darnell DeBerry filed this petition for a writ ofhabeascorpus pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2254. Petitioner claims that (1) the manner in which the prosecutor exercised his peremptory challenges and the trial court addressed those challenges violated Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986), and its progeny; (2) he was denied the right to a fair trial because he was not present in the courtroom on March 22, 1994 during jury selection; and (3) the trial court's decision to admit certain evidence violated his right to due process.

The petition was referred to Magistrate Judge Cheryl L. Pollack for a Report and Recommendation ("Report"). On September 28, 2001, the Magistrate issued her Report, which concluded that the Petitioner'sBatson claims were meritorious and recommended holding an evidentiary hearing as to the four challenged jurors. The Report further concluded that the Petitioner's claim concerning his presence during jury selection was procedurally barred, and the Magistrate recommended denying the Petitioner's evidentiary claims. The District Attorney of Kings County, representing the Respondent by agreement with the New York State Attorney General, filed objections to the Report.

The Court adopts the Report. The Court refers the petition to the Magistrate for a reconstruction hearing to develop the record further and to recommend whether, in light of the developed record, the Petitioner'shabeas petition should be granted.

BATSON CLAIMS State Procedural Bar

Absent a showing of cause and prejudice or a fundamental miscarriage of justice, a federal court "may not review state court decisions that rest on an adequate and independent state procedural default." E.g, Fama v. Comm'r of Corr. Serv., 235 F.3d 804, 809 (2d Cir. 2000) (citing Coleman v. Thompson, 501 U.S. 722, 749-50 (1991)). Here, the Magistrate Judge concluded that the state court did not clearly and expressly rely on an adequate and independent state ground to deny the Petitioner's appeal and, thus, that the Petitioner's claims are preserved for federal review. (Report at 8-15.) For the reasons fully stated by the Magistrate, the Court adopts the Report's recommended resolution of this issue.

Substantive Merits Batson and its progeny outline the familiar three-step process used to ensure that peremptory strikes are exercised in a nondiscriminatory fashion. E.g., Hernandez v. New York, 500 U.S. 352, 358-59 (1991) (plurality opinion); Batson, 476 U.S. at 96-98. The party making theBatson motion must first make a prima facie showing of racial discrimination. Id. at 97. If the requisite showing has been made, the non-movant must then offer race-neutral explanations for the challenges.Purkett v. Elem, 514 U.S. 765, 767 (1995) (per curiam). At the third step, the court must determine whether the opponent of the strike has satisfied his burden of proving an equal protection violation. See id.; Galarza v. Keane, 252 F.3d 630, 636 (2d Cir. 2001) ("We have repeatedly emphasized that a trial court may not deny a Batson motion without determining whether it credits the race-neutral explanations for the challenged peremptory strikes.").

During jury selection of Petitioner's trial, the trial court rejected the Petitioner's Batson challenges to the prosecutor's strikes of four jurors. (Report at 4-8.) Reviewing the trial court's disposition of these claims, the Report first concludes that the court erred by failing to adjudicate the credibility of the prosecutor's explanations for challenging Jurors Three and Seven. (Report at 19-23.) The Report also concludes that the trial court erred in its treatment of the Batson challenge to Juror Eight. (Report at 23-30; see also Galarza, 252 F.3d at 640.) Finally, the Report asserts that the trial judge's failure to require the prosecutor to provide a race-neutral explanation for the prosecutor's final peremptory challenge to Juror Eleven — after requesting explanations for the previous three peremptory challenges and after all six of the previous challenges were exercised to strike black jurors — was a misapplication of Batson. (Report at 30-32.)

The Court agrees with the Magistrate and adopts the Report's conclusions as to the Petitioner's Batson claims for these four jurors.

Remedy

There are three possible remedies available: (1) a conditional writ to the original state court for reconsideration, (2) a reconstruction hearing in federal court to expand the record and resolve the claims, or (3) a new trial. E.g., Jordan v. LeFevre, 293 F.3d 587, 593 (2d Cir. 2002); Galarza, 252 F.2d at 640; Howard v. Senkowski, 986 F.2d 24, 30 (2d Cir. 1993).

The Magistrate recommended holding a hearing in federal court to reconstruct, if possible, the prosecutor's state of mind at the time ofvoirdire. (Report at 32-33.) The Court agrees and refers the petition to a Magistrate to hold such a hearing. SeeBarnes v. Anderson, 202 F.3d 150, 157 (2d Cir. 1999) (noting that a judge other than the trial judge is competent to hold a reconstruction hearing). Although the passage of time and the incomplete voirdire transcript may make the hearing futile with respect to some or all of the challenges, the Court finds that the Magistrate should nevertheless attempt to develop a complete record and determine the prosecutor's intent when the jury was selected. The hearing should address each juror identified in defense counsel's first and second Batson objections.

Subsequent to the Magistrate's Report, the District Attorney informed the Court that the state trial judge, Justice Edward K. Pincus, is no longer on the bench. (Letter from Victor Barall, Assistant District Attorney, to District Judge Renna Raggi, dated January 24, 2002.) Thus, a conditional writ to the state trial judge who tried Petitioner is unavailable.

The Court respectfully requests from the Magistrate a Supplemental keport and Recommendation indicating whether, based on the record after the hearing, the Petitioner's habeas petition should be granted. If the Magistrate concludes that circumstances have rendered a reasoned determination of the relevant facts impossible or unsatisfactory, the Magistrate should so advise the Court. SeeJordan v. LeFevre, 206 F.3d 196, 202 (2d Cir. 2000) (directing the district court to hold a reconstruction hearing or, if circumstances make a determination of the prosecutor's intent impossible or unsatisfactory, to order a new trial).

REMAINING CLAIMS

Petitioner also claims that he was not present in the courtroom during jury selection on March 22, 1994, in violation of his right to be present at all critical phases of the trial. Gomez v. United States, 490 U.S. 858, 873 (1989). Reviewing the state court's decision on this issue, the Report agreed with the Respondent that this claim was procedurally barred from federal review. (Report at 34-35.) The Court adopts the Report's disposition of this claim.

Petitioner's final claim is that the trial court erroneously admitted certain photographs of the deceased and certain ballistics evidence at trial. The Magistrate agreed with the Appellate Division that both the photographs and ballistics evidence were properly admitted and thus recommended that the Petitioner's evidentiary claims be denied. (Report at 37-38.) The Court adopts the Report's disposition of these claims.

CONCLUSION

The Court adopts Magistrate Judge Pollack's Report and directs the Magistrate to hold an evidentiary hearing on the Petitioner's Batson claims.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

DEBERRY v. PORTUONDO, (E.D.N.Y. 2002)
(Oct 21, 2002)