AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

MICROSOFT CORPORATION, Plaintiff, v. MICRO/MINI SYSTEMS, INC., a Nebraska corporation, COMPUTERS BY MALONE, an unknown business entity, and JOHN J. MALONE, Defendants.

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

LAURIE SMITH CAMP, United States District Judge

This matter is before the Court on the Statement of Appeal of Magistrate Judge's Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion to Compel (Filing No. 98) filed by the Defendants Micro/Mini Systems, Inc., Computers by Malone, and John J. Malone. The Court has considered the record that was presented to Magistrate Kathleen A. Jaudzemis, as well as the briefs and evidence (Filing No. 103) submitted to this Court.

The Defendants have appealed from Magistrate Judge Kathleen Jaudzemis's order (Filing No. 90) compelling the Defendants to respond to certain interrogatories and requests for production. The Magistrate Judge's order was stayed pending the resolution of this appeal. (Filing No. 101).

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Generally, the Complaint alleges that the Defendants violated Microsoft Corporation's copyrights and trademarks by unlawfully distributing counterfeit and infringing copies of software. Two specific incidents are described, although the Complaint generally alleges continuing violations. ( See, e.g., Filing No. 1, ¶ 32.) Through investigation, Microsoft has discovered software that the Defendants distributed to Midland Lutheran College. Deposition testimony reveals that the items distributed to Midland Lutheran College were most likely acquired among several hundred similar units from an unauthorized software distributor in Hong Kong.

Information and Documents Requested

At issue are Interrogatory Nos. 16, 17, 18 and 19, as well as Requests for Production Nos. 1, 2 and 3. Interrogatory No. 16 requests the identity of government entities to which the Defendants have distributed computer systems. Interrogatory No. 17 seeks the identity of school-related entities to which the Defendants have distributed computer systems. Interrogatory No. 18 seeks the identity of customers to whom the Defendants have distributed ten or more computer systems. Interrogatory No. 19 seeks the identity of customers to whom Defendants have distributed computer systems with Microsoft software installed. Requests for Production Nos. 1, 2 and 3 seek documents relating to distributions of computer systems to government entities and school-related entities, and distributions of more than ten computer systems to a single customer. (Filing No. 54.)

Defendants' Response

The Defendants' answer to all of the Interrogatories and Requests for Production is that the interrogatories/requests are overly broad, unduly burdensome, and not reasonably calculated to lead to relevant information. The Defendants also contend that compliance would require a significant amount of time and expense. Defendants argue that the interrogatories and requests are not relevant, and are too broad absent some reasonable basis for the Court to conclude that other such conduct occurred. (Filing NO. 54.)

Magistrate Judge's Order

Judge Jaudzemis found that the sales to Midland Lutheran College substantially undercut the Defendants' argument that a reasonable basis does not exist for the Court to conclude that "other conduct" occurred. She also found that the Defendants' argument was weakened by the deposition of Robert Miszuk,. Miszuk implied that the software from Hong Kong was supplied by the Defendants to Midland Lutheran College. Miszuk also testified that from the Defendants' records it was not possible to determine what software was distributed to their customers. He also testified that customers were given numbers which could be used to identify the customer shown on the redacted invoices previously provided to Microsoft. Judge Jaudzemis concluded that Microsoft met its burden of establishing the relevance of the requested information and documents. She also found that the Defendants failed to show that the burden was unusual, considering normal discovery burdens. She noted that the parties advised her that they agreed upon a limitation of documents and customers for the years 1998 through 2001, which made discovery compliance more manageable.

STANDARD OF REVIEW

The Magistrate Judge's order may be modified, set aside, or remanded only if the order is clearly erroneous or contrary to law. 28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1)(A); Fed.R.Civ.P. 72(a); NELR 72.3(d).

DISCUSSION

The Defendants argue: Only allegations of counterfeit exist and that ordering them to provide the requested information and documents is inappropriate absent a finding of liability; the identity of customers is irrelevant to the Complaint; the Magistrate Judge failed to consider the stipulated protective order (Filing No. 19), which Defendants contend would not have been voluntarily entered or would have been significantly different had they known that Microsoft would request customer names; and, as a competitor, Microsoft might misuse customer information.

The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provide:

Parties may obtain discovery regarding any matter, not privileged, that is relevant to the claim or defense of any party, including the existence, description, nature, custody, condition, and location of any books, documents, or other tangible things and the identity and location of persons having knowledge of any discoverable matter. For good cause, the court may order discovery of any matter relevant to the subject matter involved in the action. Relevant information need not be admissible at the trial if the discovery appears reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence.

Fed.R.Civ.P. 26(b)(1) (emphasis added).

Discovery rules are to be construed broadly and liberally. Advanced Const. Serv., Inc., v. N.L.R.B., 247 F.3d 807, 812 (8th Cir. 2001). Briefly, under the 2000 version of Rule 26(b)(1), the information and documents requested must be produced if they are relevant to the claims or defenses involved in the action. Alternatively, for good cause, the Court may order that the information be produced if it is related more generally to the subject matter involved in the litigation. 8 Charles A. Wright, Arthur R. Miller, Richard L. Marcus, Federal Practice and Procedure § 2008 (2d ed. 1994). The initial standard, "relevant to the claim or defense of any party," remains a "very broad" criterion. Id.

Applying these liberal standards, the Court finds that the requested information and documents are relevant to the claims or defenses raised in this action. A reasonable basis has been provided to require production of the requested information and documents. See Gucci America, Inc. v. Ashley Reed Trading, Inc., 2001 WL 1398389, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 17, 2001), modifying on reconsideration Gucci America, Inc. v. Ashley Reed Trading, Inc., 2001 WL 1173503, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 4, 2001). The discovery of the distribution to Midland Lutheran College and Miszuk's deposition testimony demonstrates the required relevance. It is likely that the components distributed to the college were among other counterfeit units received from Hong Kong. It is also likely that the college was not the sole recipient of goods from the Defendants. Even if these facts would not support production of the information and documents as relevant to the claims or defenses, alternatively these facts provide "good cause" for an order requiring the production of the information as relevant to the subject matter of the litigation. If the stipulated protective order is not sufficient to protect certain information adequately, the parties may wish to fashion an appropriate protective order either by stipulation or by motion.

CONCLUSION

For the reasons discussed, the Court finds that the Magistrate Judge's order is not clearly erroneous or contrary to law. Accordingly, the Court will deny the appeal from the Magistrate Judge's order.

IT IS ORDERED:

1.The Defendants' Statement of Appeal of Magistrate Judge's Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion to Compel (Filing No. 98) is denied;
2. The Magistrate Judge's order (Filing No. 90) is affirmed; and
3. The stay (Filing No. 101) of the Magistrate Judge's order (Filing No. 90) is lifted. The Defendants shall comply with the requested discovery and provide complete answers to Interrogatory Nos. 15, 16, 17, 18 and 19 and make available the documents responsive to Requests for Production Nos. 1, 2, 3 and 6 on or before January 17, 2003.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

MICROSOFT CORPORATION v. MICRO/MINI SYSTEMS, INC., (D.Neb. 2003)
(Jan 3, 2003)