BARBARA ROTHSTEIN, District Judge
The Court, having reviewed the records of the cases listed on Attachment A, and having heard argument of counsel, finds and rules as follows:
(1) Common discovery and other coordinated pretrial proceedings have been completed. All remaining issues are case-specific, and best determined by the transferor courts.
(2) These cases will not benefit from further coordinated proceedings as part of MDL 1407, and are ready to be remanded to their respective transferor courts.
For these reasons, pursuant to Rule 7.6 of the Rules of Procedure of the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, the Court issues its Suggestion of Remand Order in the cases listed on Attachment A. The Clerk is ORDERED to provide copies of this Order to the Clerk of the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation and to the clerks of the transferor district courts listed on Appendix A.
APPENDIX A
Transferor Court/Cause # WD WA Cause # Case Cause # 02-cv-538 Rhonda Bailey v. Schering-Plough Western Dist. of Healthcare Products, Kentucky, No. 01-213 Inc. 02-cv-29 Eleanor D. Beattie, et al. Middle Dist. of v. Novartis Consumer Louisiana (Baton Health, Inc. Rouge), No. 01-1025 01-cv-2026 Londell Bell v. Bayer Western Dist. of Corp., et al. Louisiana (Shreve-port), No. 01-2018 01-cv-2137 Sharon Carter v. Bayer Eastern Dist. of Corp. Kentucky (Covington), No. 01-199 02-cv-373 Lynette Fisk, et al. v. Dist. of Utah (Cen Novartis AG, et al. tral), No. 01-985 02-cv-1863 Daniel S. Goettsch v. Dist. of Minnesota, Smithkline Beecham Con No. 02-1268 sumer Healthcare, et al. 01-cv-2227 Nina Hastings, et al. v. Eastern Dist. of Novartis Corp. Texas (Sherman), No. 01-338 02-cv-1272 Gerald Jones, et al. v. Western Dist. of Perrigo Co., et al. Kentucky (Bowling Green), No. 01-182 01-cv-1406 Stacey Kerrigan, et al. v. Dist. of Massachu Whitehall Robins, et al. setts, No. 01-10325 02-cv-420 Rose Lynn Kobar v. Dist. of Arizona Novartis Corp., et al. (Phoenix), No. 01-156 02-cv-1020 Stephanie Lambert, et al. Western Dist. of v. Bayer Corp., et al. Louisiana (Shreve-port), No. 02-363 02-cv-21 Ronald Lewis, et al. v. Dist. of Connecticut Glaxosmithkline PLC, et (New Haven), No. 01-2093 al. 03-cv-2093 Barbara Ann Lupo v. Southern Dist. of Novartis Pharm. Corp., et Mississippi (East al. ern), severed from No. 01-169 02-cv-918 Bernadette Massey, et al. Southern Dist. of v. Sandoz Pharm. Corp., et Texas (Houston), al. No. 01-3795 01-cv-2167 Lurline McKinney, et al. Western Dist. of v. Bayer Corp., et al. Louisiana (Shreve-port), No. 01-2219 03-cv-1390 Sandra Mustoe, et al. v. Northern Dist. of Bayer Corp., et al. California, No. 01-4181 02-cv-278 Charles Newman, et al. v. Dist. of Nevada, American Home Products, et No. 01-1345 al. 02-cv-364 Lynne Nill, et al. v. Southern Dist. of Perrigo Sales Corp., et Ohio (Cincinatti), al. No. 01-755 02-cv-1168 Tracy Patton v. Novartis Southern Dist. of Consumer Health, Inc. Indiana (New Albany Div.), No. 02-47 01-cv-2164 Elvira S. Quarrels, et al. Western Dist. of v. Bayer Corp. Louisiana (Monroe), No. 01-2195 02-cv-904 Sharon Roberts-Weisner, et Dist. of Colorado al. v. Whitehall-Robins (Denver), No. 02-240 Healthcare, et al. 01-cv-2166 Perry Robinson, et al. v. Western Dist. of Bayer Corp., et al. Louisiana (Shreve-port), No. 01-2217 01-cv-2172 Dennis Romero, et al. v. Western Dist. of Bayer Corp. Louisiana (Lafayette), No. 01-2196 01-cv-1654 Pamela Silvey v. Southern Dist. of Smithkline Beecham Corp. Ohio (Cincinatti), No. 01-164 01-cv-1656 Bettye Lou Taylor, et al. Northern Dist. of v. Bayer Corp., et al. Texas (Lubbock), No. 01-166 01-cv-2182 John Tutwiler, et al. v. Southern Dist. of Novartis Consumer Health Ohio (Dayton), No. 01-447 01-cv-2100 Nathaniel Williams v. Western Dist. of GlaxoSmithKline, PLC et Louisiana (Shreve-port), al. No. 01-1981 01-cv-1405 Alexander P. Ziolkowski v. Dist. of Massachusetts Novartis Consumer Health, ENo. 01-10324 Inc., et al.