AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Docket Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Booker T. Perry and Betty J. Perry appealed a judgment of foreclosure entered by the Circuit Court of Orange County in favor of Fairbanks Capital Corp., the mortgagee, concerning a residence owned by the Perrys. The foreclosure judgment arose from a mortgage securing a promissory note, which the appellants challenged on grounds related to the production and authenticity of the note and mortgage documents.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the mortgagee failed to establish that the promissory note securing the mortgage was lost, thereby affecting the foreclosure proceeding.
  2. Whether the mortgagee was required to produce and file the original mortgage document with the court as part of the foreclosure process.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The appellants contended that the mortgagee failed to prove the promissory note was lost, which they implied undermined the foreclosure proceeding.
  • They also argued that the mortgagee should be compelled to produce and file the original mortgage document with the court.

Appellee's Arguments

  • The mortgagee initially sought to establish the note as a lost instrument but ultimately filed the original promissory note with the court.
  • The mortgagee served requests for admissions on the appellants, which the appellants failed to respond to, resulting in deemed admissions that the mortgage copy attached to the complaint was true, that the appellants executed the note and mortgage, and that the mortgagee is the holder of those instruments.
  • The mortgagee argued that the original promissory note, not the mortgage, is generally required to be filed in foreclosure proceedings, supported by Florida Evidence Code provisions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mason v. Rubin, 727 So.2d 283 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999) Requirement that the promissory note, as a negotiable instrument, must be produced or reestablished if lost. Supported the conclusion that the original promissory note must be produced or properly accounted for if lost.
Downing v. First Nat'l Bank of Lake City, 81 So.2d 486 (Fla. 1955) Supporting authority on handling negotiable instruments in foreclosure contexts. Reinforced the legal framework regarding negotiable instruments in foreclosure proceedings.
Thompson v. First Union Nat'l Bank, 643 So.2d 1179 (Fla. 5th DCA 1994) Requirement and handling of promissory notes in foreclosure. Used to clarify the necessity of producing the original note or establishing its loss.
Figueredo v. Bank Espirito Santo, 537 So.2d 1113 (Fla. 3d DCA 1989) Further authority on negotiable instruments and foreclosure requirements. Supported the court’s interpretation of evidentiary requirements for foreclosure documents.
Home Bldg. Loan Co. v. Rivers, 108 Fla. 23, 145 So. 873 (1933) Distinction between mortgage and promissory note regarding evidentiary requirements. Supported the court’s conclusion that the mortgage may be proved by duplicate, unlike the promissory note.
Routh v. Richards, 103 Fla. 752, 138 So. 69 (1931) Similar principle on proof of mortgage documents. Reinforced the court's reasoning on admissibility of mortgage duplicates.
Scott v. Taylor, 63 Fla. 612, 58 So. 30 (1912) Characterization of mortgage as ancillary to the negotiable promissory note. Used to explain the relationship between the mortgage and the promissory note in foreclosure.
Johns Supply Co. v. McNeeley, 125 Fla. 306, 169 So. 732, 734 (1936) Further support for the mortgage as ancillary security to the promissory note. Supported the court’s legal rationale distinguishing mortgage and note evidentiary requirements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the appellants' claim that the mortgagee failed to establish the loss of the promissory note by noting that the mortgagee ultimately filed the original note with the court, negating the need to prove loss. Regarding the appellants' demand for the original mortgage, the court found that the appellants had failed to respond to requests for admissions, resulting in deemed admissions that the mortgage copy was authentic and that the mortgagee held the relevant instruments. The court then examined Florida Evidence Code provisions, concluding that while the original promissory note—being a negotiable instrument—must be produced or properly accounted for if lost, the mortgage itself need not be produced in original form and may be proven by a duplicate. This distinction arises because the mortgage is ancillary security to the promissory note and not itself a negotiable instrument. The court further noted that the trial court had sufficient evidence to consider the mortgage duplicate in its foreclosure judgment.

Holding and Implications

The court affirmed the judgment of foreclosure in favor of Fairbanks Capital Corp.

The decision directly resolves the foreclosure dispute by upholding the trial court’s judgment. It confirms that in Florida foreclosure proceedings, the original promissory note must be produced or properly accounted for if lost, while the original mortgage need not be filed if a properly authenticated duplicate is available. No new precedent was established beyond applying existing statutory and case law.

Booker T. PERRY and Betty J. Perry, Appellant, v. FAIRBANKS CAPITAL CORP., et al., Appellee.

MONACO, J.

The appellants, Booker T. Perry and Betty J. Perry, appeal from a judgment of foreclosure of a mortgage in favor of the appellee, Fairbanks Capital Corp. (the "Mortgagee"), regarding a residence owned by Mr. and Mrs. Perry. We affirm.

The primary argument raised by Mr. and Mrs. Perry is that the Mortgagee failed to establish that the promissory note securing the mortgage was lost. A review of the record reflects, however, that the Mortgagee filed the original promissory note with the trial court, even though it initially sought in its complaint to establish the note as a lost instrument.

Mr. and Mrs. Perry also seek to require the Mortgagee to produce and file the original mortgage with the court. Their appeal in this respect is likewise without avail. First of all, the Perrys failed to respond to requests for admissions served by the Mortgagee requesting that they admit that the copy of the mortgage attached to the complaint was a true copy of the original; that they in fact executed the note and mortgage; and that the Mortgagee is the holder of those instruments. As they failed to respond to the requests, Mr. and Mrs. Perry are deemed to have admitted those facts. See Fla.R.Civ.P. 1.370(a).

Secondly, the original document that is generally required to be filed with the court in a mortgage foreclosure proceeding is the promissory note, not the mortgage. The Evidence Code provides the rationale for this conclusion. Section 90.952, Florida Statutes (2002), indicates that original documents are required to prove the contents of a writing, unless otherwise provided by statute. Section 90.953, Florida Statutes (2002), however, indicates that duplicates are admissible unless a genuine question is raised about the authenticity of the original, or it is unfair to admit the duplicate, or:

The document or writing is a negotiable instrument as defined in s. 673.1041, a security instrument as defined in s. 678.1021, or any other writing that evidences a right to the payment of money, is not itself a security agreement or lease, and is of a type that is transferred by delivery in the ordinary course of business with any necessary endorsement or assignment.

A promissory note is clearly a negotiable instrument within the definition of section 673.1041(1), and either the original must be produced, or the lost document must be reestablished under section 673.3091, Florida Statutes (2002). See Mason v. Rubin, 727 So.2d 283 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999); see also Downing v. First Nat'l Bank of Lake City, 81 So.2d 486 (Fla. 1955); Thompson v. First Union Nat'l Bank, 643 So.2d 1179 (Fla. 5th DCA 1994); Figueredo v. Bank Espirito Santo, 537 So.2d 1113 (Fla. 3d DCA 1989). A mortgage, on the other hand, does not fit into the definition of the documents required by section 90.952 to be produced in their original form, and may thus be proved by using a properly authenticated duplicate. Cf. Home Bldg. Loan Co. v. Rivers, 108 Fla. 23, 145 So. 873 (1933); Routh v. Richards, 103 Fla. 752, 138 So. 69 (1931). A mortgage is the security for the payment of the negotiable promissory note, "and is a mere incident of and ancillary to such note." See Scott v. Taylor, 63 Fla. 612, 58 So. 30 (1912); see also Johns Supply Co. v. McNeeley, 125 Fla. 306, 169 So. 732, 734 (1936). Because it is negotiable, the promissory note must be surrendered in a foreclosure proceeding so that it does not remain in the stream of commerce. Indeed, if the foreclosing party alleges that the note is lost, destroyed or stolen, the trial court is authorized by statute to take the necessary actions to protect the party required to pay the note against loss that might occur by reason of a claim by another party to enforce the instrument. See section 673.3091(2), Fla. Stat. (2002).

In the present case ample evidence was presented to enable the trial court to consider the duplicate of the mortgage in rendering the judgment of foreclosure.

AFFIRMED.

PETERSON and GRIFFIN, JJ., concur.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

PERRY v. FAIRBANKS CAPITAL CORP
(Dec 10, 2004)