Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by

MICHAEL PEREZ, Mo v. nt,

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION OF THE UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE

W. ROYAL FURGESON, District Judge

BEFORE THE COURT is the Memorandum and Recommendation of the United States Magistrate Judge, filed in the above-styled and numbered cause on November 2, 2004. The Magistrate Judge recommended that Movant's Motion to Vacate his Sentence (Docket No. 1190) pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 2255 be denied. The Court entered an Order Granting Movant's Motion for an Extension of Time to file objections to the Magistrate Judge's Memorandum and Recommendation, and Movant filed Objections on January 13, 2005. After due consideration, the Court is of the opinion that the Magistrate Judge's Memorandum and Recommendation should be ADOPTED IN ITS ENTIRETY.

BACKGROUND

On March 3, 1999, Movant was found guilty by a jury of two counts: (1) conducting the aff airs of an enterprise through a pattern of racketeering, and (2) committing conspiracy to conduct the affairs of an enterprise through a pattern of racketeering. He was sentenced to serve life imprisonment on each count to run concurrently. His conviction was affirmed by the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals on September 16, 2002, and his petition for writ of certiorari to the United States Supreme Court was denied on March 24, 2003.

The superseding indictment alleged that Perez was a soldier in the Mexican Mafia and participated in the murders of Luis Adames in November 1994 and Ernest Ybarra in January 1995. Perez denied his membership in the Mexican Mafia and his involvem ent in the murders. To prove Perez's membership, the government submitted a letter from Perez's uncle, Robert Perez, who held a top position in the Mexican Mafia in the San Antonio area, and a photograph of Perez with his uncle and other Mexican Mafia members at a barbecue. Two codefendants, Fred Carrasco and Frank Estrada, testified for the government and implicated Perez as a member of the Mexican Mafia and as a participant in the murders.

After review of Movant's § 2255 Motion, the Government's Response, and the applicable law, Magistrate Judge John Primomo recommended that Movant's Motion be denied .

STANDARD OF REVIEW

The Court reviews de novo a Magistrate Judge's Memorandum and Recommendation if a party files specific objections within ten days of service. The Court need not consider objections that are frivolous, conclusive, or general in nature. If there are no specific objections to a Magistrate Judge's Memorandum and Recommendation, the District Court is to review it for findings and conclusions that are either clearly erroneous or contrary to law. In the instant case, the Court granted Movant an extension of time for filing his objections to the Magistrate Judge's Memorandum and Recommendation, and Movant timely filed objections. This Court, thus, reviews the Magistrate Judge's Memorandum and Recommendation de novo.

28 U.S.C. § 636(b)(1).

Battle v. United States Parole Comm'n, 834 F.2d 419, 421 (5th Cir. 1987).

See United States v. Wilson, 864 F.2d 1219, 1221 (5th Cir. 1989).

Movant's main Objections contend that his trial counsel, Ed ward Camara, Jr., committed ineffective assistance of counsel. To prove ineffective assistance of counsel, Movant must provide evidence to meet the standard set forth by the U.S. Supreme Court in Strickland v. Washington. In Strickland, the U.S. Supreme Court held:

466 U.S. 668, 687 (1984).

A convicted defendant's claim that counsel's assistance was so defective as to require reversal of a conviction or death sentence has two components. First, the defendant must show that counsel's performance was deficient. This requires showing that counsel made errors so serious that counsel was not functioning as the "counsel" guaranteed the defendant by the Sixth Amendment. Second, the defendant must show that the deficient performance prejudiced the defense . This requires showing that counsel's errors were so serious as to deprive the defendant of a fair trial, a trial whose result is reliable. Unless a defendant makes both showings, it cannot be said that the conviction or death sentence resulted from a breakdown in the adversary process that renders the result unreliable. Evaluated under the proper standard of "reasonably effective assistance," the Court upholds the Magistrate Judge's finding that counsel's representation did not fall below an objective standard of reasonableness or prejudice the Defendant.

ANALYSIS

I. Membership in the Mexican Mafia

One of Movant's main Objections contends that Attorney Camara committed ineffective assistance of counsel because he did not follow Movant's instructions to have investigators interview Martin Ramos or J.R Rodriguez, who allegedly would have testified that Movant was not a member of the Mexican Mafia and would have discredited Government evidence that he committed the crimes of which he was convicted. Movant claims that these witnesses would have testified that the picture introduced by the Government of a meeting of the "Tex as Mexican Mafia" actually represented family members at a barbeque. Movant contends that Camara should have taken the information Movant provided to him, inquire from the codefendants' attorneys whether the codefendants would be willing to testify that Movant was not a member of Mexican Mafia, and, if codefendants agreed to testify, then moved for a severance in lieu of the need for exculpatory testimony of a codefendant.

With respect to Movant's argument that his attorney erred by not pursuing the aforementioned strategy, the Magistrate Judge identified that Attorney Camara stated in his affidavit that he has no recollection that Movant requested investigators be sent out to interview Martin Ramos or J.R. Rodriguez. Furthermore, the Magistrate Judge determined that Camara did not violate the law because his actions did not fall outside the wide range of reasonable professional assistance expected of counsel.

Under Strickland, counsel has a duty to make a reasonable investigation of defendant's case or make a reasonable decision that a particular investigation is unnecessary. Movant contends that a better investigation by counsel would have disclosed that Movant was not a member of the Mexican Mafia and would have cleared him of the RICO charges. However, there is insufficient evidence that Martin Ramos and J.R. Rodriguez would have testified that Movant was not a member of the gang. The Fifth Circuit has reiterated on multiple occasions that, "Complaints of uncalled witnesses are not favored in federal habeas corpus review because allegations of what a witness would have testified are largely speculative. Where the only evidence of a missing witnesses' testimony is from the defendant, this Court views claims of ineffective assistance with great caution." Strickland review is highly deferential, and Movant's allegations are insufficient to overcome the presumption that his counsel's actions were reasonable.

Id. at 691.

Lockhart v. McCotter, 782 F.2d 1275, 1282 (5th Cir. 1986); Sayre v. Anderson, 238 F.3d 631, 635-36 (5th Cir. 2001).

See Sayre, 238 F.3d at 635.

Marler v. Blackburn, 777 F.2d 1007, 1010 (5th Cir. 1985).

II. Government Witness Testimony

Another one of Movant's primary Objections contends that Camera erred because he failed to challenge Frank Estrada's testimony that Movant was at the scene of the crime. According to Movant, Frank Estrada's untruthful testimony provided the only evidence that Movant drove the vehicle to the scene of the Ybarra murder, and it was inexcusable for his attorney not to interview any witnesses or challenge Estrada's testimony. According to Movant's Objections, "Frank Estrada [has] been involved in at least 10 murders and had personally committed several murders, he had been involved in extortion and drug trafficking, he was an admitted drug addict, and the Government was going to set him free for his testimony. Estrada admitted throughout his testimony that he lied to authorities, doctors, detectives, or who ever, when he thought it would benefit him."

Movant does not dispute the Magistrate Judge's finding that the jury was aware that Estrada took special education classes, admitted lying on several occasions, suffered from mental problems, attempted suicide on multiple occasions, was addicted to heroin, used marijuana, and inhaled paint, but Movant nonetheless contends that his attorney denied him effective representation because he did not introduce medical records or expert medical testimony to impeach Estrada based on his mental condition. Movant contends that Attorney Camara should have investigated further into Estrada's medical history that could have affected his ability to perceive the truth and then used the testimony of psychologists and psychiatrists to bring those facts to the attention of the jury. Movant further argues that Camara erred in failing to investigate or interview Frank Estrada prior to trial. In light of the comprising evidence about Estrada's credibility that already was before the jury, the Court holds that reasonable probability does not exist to show that, but for counsel's failure to call psychologist and psychiatrist expert witnesses, the result of the trial would have been different.

Strickland at 694; Sayre, at 635.

CONCLUSION

After having conducted an independent review of the entire record, a de novo review of the matters raised by all of Movant Perez's Objections and the applicable law, this Court concurs entirely with the factual and legal findings in the Memorandum and Recommendation. Accordingly, the Court ORDERS that the Memorandum and Recommendation be ADOPTED IN ITS ENTIRETY and Movant's 28 U.S.C. § 2255 Motion to Vacate his sentence be DENIED.

It is SO ORDERED.

FINAL JUDGMENT

On this day the Court entered an order adopting the Memorandum and Recommendation of the United States Magistrate Judge and denying Movant's Motion to Vacate (Docket No. 1190). The Court now enters its Final Judgment in accordance with Rule 58 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

It is ORDERED that the Memorandum and Recommendation of the Magistrate Judge be ADOPTED IN ITS ENTIRETY.

It is ORDERED that Movant's Motion to Vacate be DENIED and the case DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE.

It is ORDERED that each party bear its own costs.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

PEREZ v. U.S
(Apr 28, 2005)