Factual and Procedural Background
The Claimant applied on 12 August 2023 to re-amend its Claim Form and Particulars of Claim to introduce a claim under the Commercial Agents (Council Directive) Regulations 1993. The central dispute between the parties concerns whether the claim has a real prospect of success, with the Defendant seeking reverse summary judgment. The parties executed a Master Partner Agreement (MPA) on 26 August 2013, followed by an Addendum incorporating a referral partnership. The Claimant was to introduce clients to the Defendant for sales of a software product, LiveEngage, a subscription-based, centrally hosted digital engagement platform. Two types of arrangements existed: a referral agreement and a resale agreement, each governed by separate contracts exhibited to the MPA.
The Claim was initially filed in December 2018 but was not progressed beyond June 2019 pending the outcome of a preliminary ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in the Software Incubator case, which addressed the definition of "sale of goods" under EU law.
The Claimant sought to add three elements in the proposed amendment: a compensation claim under Regulation 17 of the Regulations, a commission claim under Regulations 7 and 11, and reference to a Resale Partnership Terms and Conditions Exhibit executed on 26 August 2013.
The relevant contracts include the MPA between the parties and a Master Services Agreement (MSA) between the Defendant and end users of the software, which grants limited, revocable, non-exclusive licences to access the hosted software services. The MSA includes terms regarding the service provision, fees, licence restrictions, acceptable use, and intellectual property rights.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Claimant's proposed claim under the Commercial Agents Regulations 1993 has a real prospect of success, specifically whether the Claimant qualifies as a "commercial agent" under Regulation 2(1).
- Whether the grant of a limited, revocable licence to use the Defendant's cloud-based software constitutes a "sale of goods" within the meaning of the Regulations and EU law.
- Whether the LiveEngage platform marketed by the Claimant is properly characterised as "goods" or a "service" for the purposes of the Regulations.
- Whether the Claimant is entitled to commission under Regulations 7 and 11.
- Whether the Claimant's resale activities under the Resale Exhibit fall within the scope of the Regulations.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The Regulations apply only to commercial agents negotiating the sale of goods; they do not apply to agents marketing or selling services.
- Computer software does not constitute "goods" unless there is a permanent transfer of ownership, such as by a perpetual licence; a limited, revocable licence is a rental, not a sale.
- The terms of the contracts must be determinative of whether the Regulations apply, not the manner of performance.
- The LiveEngage platform is a service accessed via a hosted model, not a sale of goods, analogous to a gym membership providing access to facilities rather than ownership of goods.
- Auto-renewal of licences does not convert a limited licence into a perpetual one.
- Commission claims under the Regulations do not apply if the Claimant is not a commercial agent under the Regulations; any entitlement must derive from the contract.
- The resale activities under the Resale Exhibit involve contracts in the Claimant's own name and thus do not constitute commercial agency under the Regulations.
Claimant's Arguments
- The Regulations should be given a purposive construction consistent with the Directive's aim to protect commercial agents and reflect the CJEU's interpretation.
- Following the binding CJEU judgment in Software Incubator, computer software constitutes "goods" and licences to use software constitute a "sale of goods".
- The Defendant's characterisation of LiveEngage as a service is inconsistent with the Software Incubator analysis and ignores that the product is described as a "product" in contractual documents.
- The practical reality is that licences were automatically renewed and treated as effectively unlimited, aligning with the concept of a sale rather than a rental.
- The Claimant's activities fall within the definition of negotiating a sale under Regulation 2(1), as "negotiate" is to be interpreted broadly.
- There are factual disputes regarding the nature of SaaS and the use of LiveEngage that require a trial to resolve.
- The resale arrangement, though formally contracts in the Claimant's name, in practice operated similarly to agency and should be treated as such.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Lonsdale (t/a Lonsdale Agencies) v. Howard & Hallam Ltd [2008] Bus LR 788 |
Principles for assessing compensation under Regulation 17 of the Regulations. |
Used to explain the rationale and method for valuing compensation for commercial agents deprived of future commissions. |
| CNM Estates (Tolworth Tower) Ltd v Simon Peter Carvill-Biggs Freddy Khalatschi [2023] EWCA Civ 480 |
Test for permission to amend and summary judgment applications. |
Supported the standard that a claim must have a real prospect of success for amendment permission. |
| Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd v James Kemball Ltd [2021] EWCA Civ 33 |
Threshold for claims to carry some degree of conviction, not merely arguable. |
Applied to assess the strength of the Claimant's case. |
| Easyair Ltd v Opal Telecom Ltd [2009] EWHC 339 (Ch) |
Authority on deciding discrete points of law on summary judgment applications. |
Supported the court's approach to decide the legal question on the application without trial. |
| On the Beach Ltd v Ryanair [2023] EWHC 2694 (Comm) |
Balance of probabilities standard for deciding points of law on summary judgment. |
Guided the court's approach to deciding the legal issues on the balance of probabilities. |
| Sagal v Atelier Bunz GmbH [2009] Bus LR 1527 (CA) |
Determination of applicability of the Regulations by reference to contractual terms alone. |
Supported the court's decision to resolve the issue on documentation without oral evidence. |
| Crane v Sky [2007] 2 All ER (Comm) 599 |
Clarification that the Regulations do not apply to agents selling services. |
Supported Defendant's argument that selling services is outside the Regulations' scope. |
| Computer Associates UK Ltd v The Software Incubator Ltd (Case C-410/19) [2021] Bus LR 1442 |
Interpretation of "sale of goods" to include supply of software by perpetual licence. |
Central to the court's analysis of whether the Claimant's activities involved a sale of goods. |
| Usedsoft GmbH v Oracle International Corpn (Case C-128/11) [2013] Bus LR 911 |
Definition of sale of software as transfer of ownership rights by perpetual licence. |
Supported the principle that rental or limited licences are not sales. |
| Ingmar GB Ltd v Eaton Leonard Inc [2001] CLC 1825 |
Parties can choose the mechanism for commission in their contract; right to commission can be excluded contractually. |
Supported Defendant's position on Regulation 7 and 11 claims. |
| Mercantile International Group plc v Chuan Soon Huat Industrial Group Ltd [2002] CLC 913 |
Contracts entered into in agent's own name do not constitute commercial agency under the Regulations. |
Distinguished from the present case where resale contracts were in the Claimant's own name. |
| Okpabi v Royal Dutch Shell Plc [2021] UKSC 3 |
Test for permission to amend and summary judgment. |
Referenced regarding the standard for permission to amend. |
| Ward v Caitlin (Five) Ltd [2010] Lloyd’s Rep IR 301 |
Approach to summary judgment and permission to amend applications. |
Approved the approach cited from Easyair. |
| Royal Brompton Hospital NHS Trust v Hammond (No 5) [2001] EWCA Civ 550 |
Evidence to be considered at summary judgment stage includes what is reasonably expected to be available at trial. |
Guided the court's consideration of evidence sufficiency. |
| Doncaster Pharmaceuticals Group Ltd v Bolton Pharmaceutical Co 100 Ltd [2007] FSR 63 |
Summary judgment should be cautious where a fuller investigation might alter the outcome. |
Considered in deciding whether to grant summary judgment or allow trial. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court began by acknowledging the broad discretionary power to grant permission to amend, applying the test that an amendment should only be refused if the new claim has no real prospect of success. The court considered the material before it sufficient to decide the key legal issue: whether the Claimant's activities fell within the definition of a commercial agent under the Regulations, specifically whether the grant of a limited, revocable licence to use the Defendant's software constituted a "sale of goods".
Relying on the CJEU's decisions in Software Incubator and Usedsoft, the court emphasized that a "sale" requires a permanent transfer of ownership rights, such as by a perpetual licence. The Defendant's software licences were limited in duration, revocable, and subject to renewal payments, constituting a rental rather than a sale. The court found that the LiveEngage platform was provided as a hosted service, with customers accessing software on the Defendant's servers, analogous to a gym membership providing access rather than ownership.
The court rejected the Claimant's argument that automatic renewal rendered the licences effectively unlimited, noting that renewal was conditional and involved further payment, consistent with a rental model. The court also held that the contractual documentation was determinative, and the factual disputes raised by the Claimant regarding SaaS usage and software functionality did not preclude summary determination.
On the commission claim, the court held that entitlement under the Regulations depended on the Claimant qualifying as a commercial agent, which was not established. Thus, any claim for commission must derive from the contract rather than the Regulations.
Regarding the resale agreement, the court found that contracts entered into by the Claimant in its own name did not constitute agency under the Regulations. The Claimant's attempt to recharacterize the resale relationship as agency was impermissible absent evidence of sham contracts.
Holding and Implications
The court DENIED PERMISSION for the Claimant to amend its claim to introduce the Regulation 17 compensation claim and the commission claim under the Regulations. It further dismissed the attempt to include the Resale Exhibit claim under the Regulations.
The direct effect of this decision is that the Claimant's claims under the Commercial Agents (Council Directive) Regulations 1993 lack a real prospect of success and are therefore not permitted to proceed. The court emphasized that the contractual terms and the nature of the licences granted preclude classification of the transactions as sales of goods under the Regulations. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing CJEU authority and established principles regarding commercial agency and software licensing.