Factual and Procedural Background
This private law case concerns child arrangements for two young children following the breakdown of their parents' relationship. The father applied for a shared 50/50 'live with' child arrangements order and a prohibited steps order preventing the mother from removing the children from the United Kingdom. The mother opposed the shared care proposal and sought a specific issue order to allow temporary travel with the children to visit family in Hong Kong and Malaysia. The local authority became involved following allegations of domestic abuse and concerns for the children's welfare, resulting in child protection plans and supervised contact arrangements. The mother breached court confidentiality orders by publishing identifying information on a fundraising website, which influenced the court’s assessment of travel risks. The case was managed by a High Court-authorised judge due to the complexity of travel issues involving jurisdictions outside the Hague Convention 1980.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the father’s application for a shared 50/50 child arrangements order should be granted.
- Whether the mother should be permitted to remove the children temporarily to Hong Kong and Malaysia.
- The extent to which the mother’s breach of confidentiality orders affects the court’s trust and the travel applications.
- The appropriate safeguards and risk assessments concerning international travel and potential abduction.
- The suitability and duration of contact arrangements between the children and the father pending final determination.
Arguments of the Parties
Father's Arguments
- Seeks a shared 50/50 'live with' order for the children.
- Opposes the mother’s travel applications to Hong Kong and Malaysia due to risk of abduction.
- Raised concerns about the mother’s conduct and breach of court orders via the 'gofundme' webpage.
- Advocated for increased contact time with the children and opposed restrictions on his girlfriend’s involvement in handovers.
Mother's Arguments
- Opposes shared 50/50 care, proposing the children live primarily with her and spend less than 50% time with the father.
- Seeks permission to travel temporarily with the children to visit maternal family in Hong Kong and Malaysia.
- Denied any intention to permanently remove the children from the United Kingdom despite past statements.
- Offered multiple safeguards to mitigate the risk of abduction during travel.
- Contended lack of knowledge that publishing identifying information online was prohibited.
- Agreed to give undertakings not to raise certain defences in abduction proceedings abroad.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| EBK v DLO [2023] 4 WLR 51 |
Test for permission to bring contempt proceedings under FPR r. 37.3(5). |
Referenced to assess whether contempt proceedings should be initiated regarding the mother's breach of confidentiality. |
| HM Solicitor-General v. JS [2023] EWHC 2684 (Fam) |
Legal aid entitlement in contempt proceedings. |
Referenced to confirm the mother’s entitlement to legal aid if contempt proceedings were brought. |
| F v L (Child Arrangements Order - Relocation) [2018] 4 WLR 141 |
Considerations for relocation and child arrangements. |
Guided the court’s future resolution of the shared care dispute after trial period. |
| Bedfordshire Police v U [2014] Fam 69 |
Criteria for court-initiated contempt proceedings under FPR 37.6. |
Applied to determine whether the court should initiate contempt proceedings for the mother's disclosure. |
| Isbilen v Turk [2021] EWHC 854 (Ch) |
Application of contempt procedure rules mirroring FPR 37. |
Considered in relation to the procedural approach to contempt applications. |
| Jian Xi An Fa Da Wine Co. Ltd. v Zhan King [2019] HKCFI |
Enforcement of foreign judgments in Hong Kong. |
Discussed the limitations and potential for enforcement of UK orders in Hong Kong. |
| Balasubramaniam v Kohila [1997] 4 CLJ 676 (Malaysia) |
Malaysian court’s approach to child return orders and application of English case law. |
Supported expert evidence on Malaysian legal safeguards against unlawful retention of children. |
| Re A (Prohibited Steps Order) [2014] 1 FLR 643 |
Principles for permitting travel to non-Hague Convention countries. |
Established the framework for assessing best interests, risk of abduction, and safeguards. |
| Re H (A Child) [2014] EWCA Civ 989 |
Application of travel permission principles and rigorous scrutiny of safeguards. |
Supported the court’s analysis of risk and safeguards for the travel applications. |
| M (Children) (Non-Hague Convention State) [2020] EWCA Civ 277 |
Application of travel permission principles to non-Hague Convention jurisdictions. |
Informed the court’s approach to assessing travel to Malaysia. |
| Re DO and BO (Children) (Temporary Relocation to China) [2017] EWHC 858 (Fam) |
Practice for removal from jurisdiction and assessment of risk and safeguards. |
Referenced in relation to travel to jurisdictions outside the UK and Hague Convention states. |
| M v F (Removal from Jurisdiction: Practice) [2017] 4 WLR 149 |
Requirement for oral evidence to assess credibility and risk of abduction. |
Applied in considering the evidence and credibility of the parties regarding travel risk. |
| P. (A Minor) (Residence Order - Child's Welfare) (C.A.), Re [2000] Fam 15 |
Guidance on the use of s 91(14) orders restricting further applications. |
Considered in relation to the mother’s ability to make future applications. |
| A (A Child) (Supervised contact) (Section 91(14) Children Act 1989 orders), Re [2022] 4 WLR 25 |
Use of s 91(14) orders to prevent coercive litigation tactics ('lawfare'). |
Informed the court’s decision to impose a s 91(14) order on the mother. |
| G (Residence Restriction on Further Applications), Re [2009] 1 FLR 894 |
Considerations on granting s 91(14) orders to provide 'breathing space'. |
Referenced by mother in submissions; court distinguished and imposed s 91(14) order nonetheless. |
| Re T (Infants) [1968] 1 Ch 704; Re L (Minors) [1974] 1 WLR 250; G v G (Minors) (Abduction) [1991] 2 FLR 506 |
English case law supporting child return orders and welfare paramountcy. |
Applied by Malaysian courts and relied on in expert evidence on Malaysian law. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully considered the welfare of the children as the paramount consideration under the Children Act 1989. It acknowledged the children’s British nationality and habitual residence, the parents’ respective backgrounds, and the history of parental conflict and child protection involvement. The court found that the existing s 7 Report was outdated and that fresh safeguarding concerns required a new report and evidence from the current social worker before a final child arrangements order could be made.
In the interim, the court ordered increased contact with the father, balancing the children’s need for stability and contact with both parents while avoiding disruption.
Regarding the travel applications, the court applied established legal principles for permitting removal of children to jurisdictions outside the UK, particularly those not party to the Hague Convention 1980. The court identified three key elements: the risk of abduction, the consequences of abduction, and the effectiveness of safeguards.
The court accepted the father’s legitimate concern of a moderate risk of abduction or retention, heightened by the mother’s breach of confidentiality via the fundraising webpage, which undermined trust. The court noted that legal safeguards exist in Hong Kong (a Hague Convention jurisdiction) and Malaysia (a non-Hague jurisdiction) but recognized these would not eliminate the trauma, cost, and delay associated with any wrongful retention proceedings.
Balancing the children’s welfare, the court found that the minimal benefit of travel at this stage was outweighed by the risk of emotional harm from parental conflict and potential abduction. The court therefore prohibited travel to Hong Kong and Malaysia for 12 months to allow the parents to rebuild trust and co-operation, essential for the children’s emotional wellbeing.
The court also addressed the mother’s breach of court orders and confidentiality, concluding that although a prima facie case for contempt existed, further proceedings were not proportionate or in the children’s best interests given the mother’s apology and removal of the webpage.
Finally, the court imposed a s 91(14) order restricting the mother from making further applications without leave for 12 months, to prevent renewed conflict and support stability.
Holding and Implications
The court adjourned the father's application for a final child arrangements order for six months pending an updated s 7 Report and evidence from the new social worker.
The court dismissed the mother's application for a specific issue order to permit travel to Hong Kong and Malaysia.
The court granted the father's application for a prohibited steps order preventing the mother from removing the children to Hong Kong and Malaysia for 12 months.
These decisions directly affect the parties by maintaining the children’s residence primarily in the United Kingdom and restricting international travel to mitigate risks of abduction and emotional harm. The order for increased contact with the father aims to enhance the children’s relationship with him while preserving stability. The imposition of the s 91(14) order seeks to prevent further litigation-driven conflict during this critical period. No new legal precedent was established; the court applied established principles to the facts.