Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)

Response Clothing Ltd v. The Edinburgh Woollen Mill Ltd

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff, a company based in The City, designs and markets clothing. The Defendant is a major clothing retailer with approximately 400 stores across The State. Between December 2009 and 2012, the Plaintiff supplied the Defendant with ladies tops made from a jacquard fabric featuring a distinctive 'wave arrangement' design woven into the fabric. In 2012, the Plaintiff sought to increase the price of these tops, but the Defendant rejected the new price and subsequently shared a sample or swatch of the Plaintiff’s fabric with other garment suppliers, including Company A, a UK-based manufacturer. Company A secured the supply contract and provided tops made from a similar jacquard fabric from 2012 to 2015. Thereafter, the Defendant switched suppliers to two other companies, one based in Vietnam (Company B) and another in Bangladesh (Company C), supplying tops made from fabrics referred to as the 'Cingo Fabric' and 'Bengal Knittex Fabric' respectively. Tops made from the Cingo Fabric were sold for one season only, while those made from the Bengal Knittex Fabric have been sold continuously since and remain in the Defendant's range.

The Plaintiff claims copyright subsists in its wave arrangement design, either as a graphic work or a work of artistic craftsmanship, and alleges ownership of that copyright. The Plaintiff contends that the fabrics supplied by Company A, Company B, and Company C infringe its copyright and that the Defendant has infringed by selling tops made from these infringing fabrics, constituting both primary and secondary infringement. The case was heard with legal representatives for both parties present.

The Plaintiff relied on two witnesses of fact, including its sole director and shareholder, and a witness statement from a South Korean fabric manufacturer who did not attend trial but whose evidence was admitted via a Civil Evidence Act Notice. The Defendant called three witnesses of fact, including senior company officers and buyers, with some concerns noted about the reliability of one witness. Additional witness statements from manufacturers in China were also admitted under Civil Evidence Act Notices. Both parties presented expert witnesses with extensive experience in textile design, whose evidence was considered helpful.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether copyright subsists in the Plaintiff’s wave arrangement design as a graphic work or as a work of artistic craftsmanship under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
  2. Whether the Wave Fabric qualifies as a copyright work, particularly addressing the definition and scope of 'graphic work' and 'artistic craftsmanship'.
  3. The originality of the Wave Fabric and whether it is the author’s own intellectual creation.
  4. Whether the Defendant’s fabrics supplied by Company A, Company B, and Company C are infringing copies of the Wave Fabric.
  5. The nature of the Defendant’s infringement, distinguishing between primary and secondary infringement under the 1988 Act and relevant EU Directives.
  6. The applicability of European Union copyright law and its interpretation by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to the facts of this case.
  7. Whether the Defendant had reason to believe that the fabrics it sold were infringing copies, relevant to secondary infringement liability.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The wave arrangement design embodied in the Wave Fabric qualifies for copyright protection either as a graphic work or as a work of artistic craftsmanship.
  • The Wave Fabric is original, being the author's own intellectual creation, and copyright subsists in it.
  • The Defendant’s fabrics supplied by Company A, Company B, and Company C are infringing copies, having been copied directly or indirectly from the Wave Fabric.
  • The Defendant has infringed the Plaintiff’s copyright through both primary infringement (issue of copies to the public) and secondary infringement (possession and sale of infringing articles with knowledge or reason to believe they infringe).

Defendant's Arguments

  • The wave arrangement design does not qualify as a graphic work under the 1988 Act because it is not created by marks on a substrate but is woven or knitted fabric.
  • The Wave Fabric does not constitute a work of artistic craftsmanship because it was made on a machine and mass-produced, which excludes it from the traditional understanding of craftsmanship.
  • The Plaintiff has not identified the original parts of the Wave Fabric's design, undermining the claim of infringement under the revised law post-Directive 2001/29.
  • The Defendant contends that the fabrics supplied by Company A were the ones that first issued the copies to the public, absolving the Defendant of primary infringement.
  • The Defendant denies having reason to believe that the fabrics supplied by Company A, Company B, and Company C were infringing copies, asserting that the fabrics were materially different and generally available in the market.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
George Hensher Ltd v Restawhile Upholstery (Lancs) Ltd [1976] AC 64 Consideration of the meaning of 'work of artistic craftsmanship' under copyright law. The Court analyzed the judgment and noted the lack of a straightforward definition, concluding that the Wave Fabric would likely not qualify under the reasoning of some Law Lords but that no binding principle bars its qualification now.
Lucasfilm Ltd v Ainsworth [2011] UKSC 39; [2012] 1 AC 208 Assessment of 'artistic craftsmanship' and the difficulty in defining it. The Court referenced the difficulty in defining 'artistic craftsmanship' and the approach taken by Mann J, supporting the use of a combined craftsmanship and artistic creativity test.
Bonz Group (Pty) Ltd v Cooke [1994] 3 N.Z.L.R. 216 Definition of 'artistic craftsmanship' as requiring both craftsmanship and artistic creativity. The Court adopted the summary definition that a work must be made skilfully with justified pride and have aesthetic appeal, applying it to the Wave Fabric.
Vermaat (t/a Cotton Productions) v Boncrest Ltd (No.1) [2001] FSR 5 Assessment of artistic merit in textile designs. Referenced for the proposition that artistic merit is required for a work of artistic craftsmanship and that mere pleasing designs may be insufficient.
Levola Hengelo BV v Smilde Foods BV (Case C-310/17) EU:C:2018:899; [2019] ECDR 2 Interpretation of 'work' under Directive 2001/29/EC requiring originality as author's own intellectual creation. The Court applied the CJEU’s autonomous and uniform interpretation of 'work' in EU law, affirming that the Wave Fabric design, if original, qualifies as a work.
Cofemel-Sociedade de Vestur rio SA v G-Star Raw CV (Case C-683/17) EU:C:2019:721 Requirement that copyright protection is not subject to aesthetic or artistic value under EU law. The Court interpreted the 1988 Act in conformity with the Directive, adopting a definition of artistic craftsmanship that allows for machine-made works and aesthetic appeal as understood commercially.
Marleasing SA v La Comercial Internacional de Alimentaci n SA (Case C-106/89) EU:C:1990:395; [1990] ECR I-4135 Requirement to interpret national law in conformity with EU Directives. The Court applied this principle to interpret the 1988 Act in line with Directive 2001/29.
Lambretta Clothing Co. Ltd v Teddy Smith (UK) Ltd [2004] EWCA Civ 886; [2005] RPC 88 Illustration of gaps in copyright protection under UK law. Referenced by the Defendant to support the argument that gaps in protection may exist and are accepted by Parliament.
Abraham Moon & Sons Ltd v Thornber [2012] EWPCC 37; [2013] FSR 17 Interpretation of 'issue to the public' under s.18 of the 1988 Act and related EU law. The Court relied on this case to determine which party in a supply chain constitutes issuing copies to the public for primary infringement purposes.
Peak Holding AB v Axolin-Elinor AB (Case C-16/03) EU:C:2004:759; [2005] ETMR 28 Definition of 'putting on the market' and exhaustion of rights under EU trade mark law, analogized to copyright distribution right. The Court applied principles from this case to conclude that the sale by Company A to the Defendant constituted issuing copies to the public, negating primary infringement by the Defendant for those fabrics.
L.A. Gear Inc v Hi-Tech Sports plc [1992] FSR 121 Definition of 'reason to believe' for secondary infringement liability. The Court adopted this test to assess whether the Defendant had sufficient knowledge or reason to believe the fabrics infringed copyright.
ZYX Music GmbH v King [1995] FSR 566 Reasonable person test for knowledge in secondary infringement, considering defendant’s position. The Court applied this precedent to evaluate the Defendant’s knowledge and belief regarding infringement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by examining whether the Wave Fabric qualified as a copyright work under the 1988 Act, first considering the Plaintiff’s claim that it was a graphic work. The statutory definition of a graphic work involves marks made on a substrate to generate an image, which the Court found incompatible with a woven or knitted fabric. Consequently, the Court rejected the graphic work classification.

The Court then analyzed whether the Wave Fabric constituted a work of artistic craftsmanship. Drawing on authoritative case law, including the House of Lords decision in George Hensher Ltd and the New Zealand case Bonz Group, the Court adopted the definition that such a work must be created by an author who is both a craftsman—someone who makes something skillfully and takes pride in workmanship—and an artist—someone who produces something with aesthetic appeal.

The Court rejected the Defendant’s argument that machine production excludes craftsmanship, reasoning that craftsmanship can extend along a spectrum from purely manual to machine-assisted processes, provided the creator exercises skill and pride. The Court accepted that the Wave Fabric’s creator likely satisfied these criteria and that the fabric had aesthetic appeal, evidenced by its commercial success.

However, the Court acknowledged the nuanced views of the Law Lords in Hensher, noting that the Wave Fabric might not meet their stricter interpretations of craftsmanship or artistic appeal. Still, no binding authority prevented the Court from applying the broader, approved definition consistent with Bonz Group.

The Court then considered EU law under Directive 2001/29, applying CJEU jurisprudence which requires originality as the author's own intellectual creation, without imposing aesthetic or artistic value requirements. The Court held that if the Wave Fabric is original, it qualifies as a protected work under EU law and that the 1988 Act should be interpreted in conformity with this directive.

On originality, the Court found the Plaintiff had discharged the burden of proof, accepting that the Wave Fabric was not copied from any prior design and was the intellectual creation of an employee of Company D, the fabric manufacturer. The Defendant’s efforts to identify earlier similar fabrics failed, and the Court gave limited weight to hearsay evidence from the manufacturer’s representative but ultimately accepted his assertion of originality on balance of probabilities.

Regarding ownership, the Court noted a written assignment from Company D to the Plaintiff, confirming the Plaintiff’s ownership of the copyright in the Wave Fabric.

On copying, the Court found compelling expert evidence that the fabrics supplied by Company A, Company B, and Company C were copied directly or indirectly from the Wave Fabric, based on detailed design similarities, including the presence and pattern of raised fabric areas known as 'blisters'. The Defendant’s expert conceded copying was possible. Thus, the Court inferred copying of a substantial part of the original design, satisfying the requirements for infringement under s.16(3)(a) of the 1988 Act as informed by EU law.

The Court then addressed primary infringement, considering whether the Defendant issued infringing copies to the public. Applying s.18 of the 1988 Act and relevant EU Directives, the Court held that the sale by Company A to the Defendant constituted the act of issuing copies to the public, thereby negating primary infringement liability for the Defendant’s subsequent sales of those fabrics. However, the Defendant conceded infringement for fabrics supplied by Company B and Company C, which were sold directly to the Defendant outside the European Economic Area, making the Defendant responsible for issuing infringing copies within the EEA.

On secondary infringement, the Court applied the test from L.A. Gear and ZYX Music, assessing whether the Defendant had knowledge or reason to believe the fabrics were infringing copies. The Court found that the Defendant had supplied samples of the Wave Fabric to alternative suppliers, including Company A, and that the Defendant’s personnel were aware of the similarities between the Wave Fabric and the subsequent fabrics. The Court rejected the Defendant’s narrow view of infringement and found that a reasonable person in the Defendant’s position would have believed dealing in the later fabrics infringed copyright. The Defendant’s sales of the infringing fabrics thus constituted secondary infringement.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that the Wave Fabric qualifies as a work of artistic craftsmanship and that copyright subsists in the Plaintiff’s wave arrangement design as embodied in the Wave Fabric. The Plaintiff owns the copyright by assignment from the original fabric manufacturer.

The fabrics supplied by Company A, Company B, and Company C were found to be infringing copies of the Wave Fabric. The Defendant’s sales of the fabrics supplied by Company B and Company C constituted primary infringement, while its sales of all three infringing fabrics (including those from Company A) constituted secondary infringement due to the Defendant’s knowledge or reason to believe that the fabrics infringed copyright.

DISPOSED OF: The Defendant has infringed the Plaintiff’s copyright by sales of the Visage (Company A), Cingo (Company B), and Bengal Knittex (Company C) fabrics as made up into tops.

The decision directly affects the parties by confirming the Plaintiff’s copyright ownership and infringement by the Defendant, but the Court did not establish any new binding precedent beyond applying existing principles to the facts. The ruling clarifies the application of the 'artistic craftsmanship' category to machine-made fabric designs and the interpretation of primary and secondary infringement in the context of textile supply chains under UK and EU law.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Response Clothing Ltd v The Edinburgh Woollen Mill Ltd

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Response Clothing Ltd v The Edinburgh Woollen Mill Ltd
(Jan 29, 2020)