Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

WG v. HG

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment concerns the final hearing of an application dated 2 March 2017 by the Wife for financial provision from her Husband pursuant to the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. The parties married and had two children. The Husband had been previously divorced and brought substantial premarital assets into the marriage, including significant family wealth and property. The parties separated following a period of marital breakdown and reconciliation attempts, with the date of separation disputed.

The Wife suffered a catastrophic brain injury in a horse-riding accident in late 2015 during the marriage, resulting in significant medical treatment and ongoing needs. The parties have incurred substantial legal costs in financial remedy and Children Act proceedings. The Husband has invested heavily in a large property project ("Project A") post-separation, which has depreciated in value and is unfinished.

The Wife purchased a property ("Property C") shortly before the final hearing, without disclosure to the Husband or court, and with financial involvement of a new partner. The Husband contests some of the Wife’s claims, including her needs and the impact of her partner's involvement. The parties dispute the quantum and nature of financial provision, housing needs, capitalised maintenance, and costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the fair financial provision to be made by the Husband to the Wife under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, having regard to the parties’ needs, resources, and conduct?
  2. What is the appropriate date of separation for financial remedy purposes, particularly in relation to the Wife’s accident?
  3. How should the value and treatment of the unfinished property project ("Project A") be accounted for?
  4. What is the appropriate valuation and treatment of the Husband’s inheritance and trust income?
  5. What are the Wife’s ongoing needs arising from her brain injury, and how should they be reflected in maintenance?
  6. What is the impact of the Wife’s new property purchase and relationship on her financial needs and entitlement?
  7. How should the parties’ substantial legal costs be addressed in the financial order?
  8. What orders should be made regarding the children’s school fees and child maintenance?

Arguments of the Parties

Wife's Arguments

  • The Wife primarily advances a needs-based claim rather than a sharing claim, seeking provision to meet her financial needs post-accident.
  • She contends that her brain injury necessitates ongoing full-time assistance, including a live-in couple, with lifetime costs estimated at over £1 million.
  • The Wife argues for a housing fund sufficient to purchase Property C, asserting it meets her needs despite the late and undisclosed purchase.
  • She seeks a capitalised maintenance fund of £5 million and recovery of her litigation loan and unpaid legal fees of approximately £915,000, arguing for a full indemnity of costs on the basis that costs are a need in a needs case.
  • The Wife’s legal team initially sought to add back expenditure on Project A to the asset pool but abandoned this claim late in proceedings.

Husband's Arguments

  • The Husband maintains that the case is essentially a needs case with limited marital acquest, reflecting the passive growth of premarital assets.
  • He argues that the date of separation was effectively mid-2015, prior to the Wife’s accident, placing the accident at the tail end of the marriage’s breakdown.
  • The Husband submits that the Wife’s claimed needs, including staffing costs and lifestyle budget, are excessive and unaffordable.
  • He contends that the Wife’s new property purchase was undisclosed and inappropriate, crystallising her housing need unreasonably.
  • The Husband offers a housing fund of £1.3 million and capitalised maintenance generating approximately £57,000 per annum, seeking a clean break and resisting ongoing maintenance.
  • He challenges the Wife’s claim for full indemnity of costs, proposing costs subject to detailed assessment and a reduction of the Wife’s Duxbury fund accordingly.
  • The Husband denies any obligation to pay child maintenance given the shared care arrangement and offers to pay school fees.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K v L [2011] EWCA Civ 550 Recognition of unmatched financial contribution by one party is not discriminatory but reflects substantive differences in contribution. The court accepted that the Husband’s financial contribution was unmatched by the Wife and that recognition of this was appropriate.
SS v NS (Spousal Maintenance) [2014] EWHC 4183 (Fam) The marital standard of living is not the lodestar for assessing needs in financial remedy cases. The court applied this principle to reject the Wife’s budget as an unreasonable aspiration beyond her needs.
BD v FD [2016] EWHC (Fam) 594 Needs are not necessarily to be met at the marital standard of living, and this benchmark does not guarantee indefinite maintenance at that level. The court used this precedent to support a needs-based approach with adjustments rather than automatic maintenance at the marital standard.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully considered the statutory framework under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, focusing on fairness, the welfare of the children, and the parties' needs and resources under section 25. The court acknowledged the substantial premarital wealth of the Husband and the limited marital acquest, framing the case as a needs-based claim rather than a sharing case.

Regarding the date of separation, the court found on the balance of probabilities that the marriage was effectively over by mid-2015, with a brief unsuccessful reconciliation period, and that the Wife’s accident occurred during the marriage but after the relationship had irretrievably broken down. The Husband’s financial support post-accident was proper and continued, notwithstanding his protests.

The court rejected attempts to add back expenditure on Project A to the asset pool, finding the property’s value should be assessed on a willing buyer-willing seller basis in its current unfinished condition, and that speculation about future value was inappropriate. The court expressed concern about the extravagance of Project A and noted the risk of bankruptcy if spending continued at the current rate.

On the Husband’s inheritance and Will Trust income, the court took a cautious approach, including the annual income but excluding the capital value from the asset pool, noting the uncertain nature of future capital appointments and the post-separation timing of the inheritance.

The court accepted the Wife’s ongoing needs arising from her brain injury but found the claimed lifetime cost of full-time live-in assistance unsupported by expert evidence and excessive in the context of the overall case. It allowed for some assistance but required the Wife to budget responsibly.

Regarding the Wife’s purchase of Property C, the court found her non-disclosure to be serious but accepted the property as within the likely range of her housing need, setting a housing fund figure lower than the Wife’s claimed amount to reflect reasonable purchase and associated costs, while noting the complications and proximity to her new partner’s residence.

The court rejected the Husband’s assertion that the Wife’s cohabitation with her partner should reduce her needs, finding no evidence that the partner was contributing financially in a way that would affect the Wife’s entitlement.

On maintenance, the court rejected the Husband’s low offer and the suggestion of a random term capitalisation (Fournier approach), preferring a full-life basis using Duxbury tables, resulting in a capitalised maintenance fund of £2 million generating approximately £90,000 per annum.

In relation to costs, the court recognised the excessive and unreasonable litigation conduct by the Wife but also her difficult circumstances and the disproportionate burden of costs incurred. The court ordered the Husband to pay a significant portion, but not all, of the Wife’s costs and litigation loan, reducing the capitalised maintenance fund accordingly.

The court emphasised the need for a clean break order to bring finality given the substantial costs and history of litigation, leaving the Husband with significant remaining resources and income.

Regarding children, the court ordered the Husband to pay school fees until completion of full-time secondary education but declined jurisdiction over child maintenance, inviting the parties to consider arrangements through the Child Maintenance Service.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision is to order the Husband to pay the Wife a lump sum of £4.05 million, comprising approximately £1.65 million for housing (including purchase costs) and £2 million capitalised maintenance, plus £400,000 towards the Wife’s legal costs and litigation loan.

The court orders a clean break financial settlement, leaving the Husband with around £8 million in remaining assets and an annual income of £50,000 from the Will Trust. The Wife’s purchase of Property C is accepted as within her housing need, though the court warns that any additional expenditure beyond the ordered sum must be funded from her capital.

The court rejects the Wife’s claim for full indemnity costs and the Husband’s lower maintenance offer, finding both parties’ positions excessive or unrealistic to varying degrees. The court’s order reflects a balanced assessment of needs, resources, and conduct without creating new precedent.

The children’s school fees will be paid by the Husband, but no child maintenance order is made at this time due to shared care arrangements and lack of jurisdiction absent consent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

WG v HG

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

WG v HG
(Jul 30, 2018)