Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
- Mrs McCoy for the Appellant
- Miss Dosanjh, officer, for the
Respondents
See more information ...
Click here to read the full judgment
Mitchell & Anor v. Revenue and Customs (VAT - BUILDERS : Do -it-yourself)
Smart Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal concerns whether the appellants are entitled to a VAT refund under section 35 of the Value Added Tax Act 1994 (VATA), specifically under the DIY Builders Scheme, in respect of the construction of a building at the bottom of their garden. The appellants, a husband and wife, owned a semi-detached house and decided to demolish their prefabricated garage to construct a new two-storey brick building with a pitched roof. The building includes a garage, a bathroom with toilet and shower, and an upstairs open area laid out as a bedroom and sitting room, with no kitchen but an area suitable for a microwave. The building is connected to mains utilities and has planning consent with a condition prohibiting its use as a separate residential unit without local authority approval.
The appellants applied for a VAT refund of £3,903.62 under the DIY Builders Scheme, which HMRC rejected. The appellants appealed the decision, focusing on the principle of entitlement to the refund, as HMRC reserved their position on the amount (quantum).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the building constructed by the appellants qualifies as a "building designed as a dwelling" under section 35(1A) of the Value Added Tax Act 1994, specifically regarding the requirement for self-contained living accommodation under Note 2(a) to Group 5 of Schedule 8.
- Whether the planning condition prohibiting separate residential use of the building breaches the requirement in Note 2(c) to Group 5 that the separate use or disposal of the dwelling is not prohibited by any planning consent or similar provision.
- Whether the appellants can rely on alleged guidance from HMRC regarding their entitlement to a VAT refund despite statutory conditions not being met.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The building constitutes self-contained living accommodation as it has sufficient facilities including a toilet, shower, and an area where a microwave can be used, enabling independent living.
- The planning condition prohibiting separate residential use should not disqualify them because they could obtain local authority consent for separate use if required, and would have done so had they known it was an issue.
- The appellants were advised by HMRC in telephone conversations that they met the conditions for a VAT refund under the DIY Builders Scheme and were entitled to repayment, which should be considered.
Respondents' Arguments (HMRC)
- The building is not self-contained living accommodation because it lacks a kitchen and is described as a garage in the planning consent, which is inconsistent with being a dwelling.
- The planning condition clearly prohibits separate residential use, thus failing the requirement in Note 2(c) that separate use or disposal is not prohibited.
- The test for separate use must be judged at the time of the refund claim, and the possibility of future consent does not affect the current claim.
- Any representations or guidance given by HMRC do not create entitlement to relief if the statutory conditions are not met; this Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to consider legitimate expectation arguments arising from HMRC guidance.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| Oldrings Development Kingsclere Limited (VTD 17769) |
Determination that a studio flat can be self-contained living accommodation despite lacking a shower or bath. |
Supported the appellants’ argument that absence of a full kitchen does not preclude self-contained status. |
| SA Whiteley |
Basic elements of living must be contained within one building, not spread over several buildings. |
Reinforced the requirement for self-contained accommodation to be within a single building. |
| Agudas Israel Housing Association (VTD 18798) |
A microwave cooker and kettle are sufficient facilities for self-contained living accommodation. |
Supported the appellants’ position that the ability to use a microwave suffices for self-contained accommodation. |
| Revenue and Customs Commissioners v Lunn [2009] UT 244 |
Restrictions on use ancillary or incidental to the main property constitute a prohibition on separate use under Note 2(c). |
Supported HMRC’s position that the planning condition prohibiting separate residential use satisfies the prohibition under Note 2(c). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal accepted that the building qualifies as self-contained living accommodation under Note 2(a) to Group 5, reasoning that the presence of a toilet, shower, sleeping and sitting areas, and the ability to use a microwave meet the necessary facilities. The Tribunal rejected the significance of the building being described as a garage in the planning consent, focusing instead on the design and facilities.
However, the Tribunal found that the planning condition prohibiting separate residential use clearly breaches Note 2(c) to Group 5, which requires that separate use or disposal is not prohibited by planning consent. The Tribunal agreed with HMRC and precedent that such a condition constitutes a prohibition on separate use. Furthermore, the Tribunal held that compliance with Note 2(c) must be assessed at the time the works are carried out, making any future possibility of obtaining consent irrelevant to the current claim.
Regarding the appellants’ argument that HMRC’s guidance during telephone calls entitled them to the refund, the Tribunal concluded that it lacks jurisdiction to entertain legitimate expectation claims based on HMRC guidance. Such matters are exclusively within the Administrative Court’s jurisdiction.
Consequently, the Tribunal held that the statutory conditions for a VAT refund under section 35 were not met because the building is not designed as a dwelling for the purposes of the legislation.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal's final decision is to DISMISS the appellants' appeal.
The direct effect is that the appellants are not entitled to the VAT refund claimed under the DIY Builders Scheme because the building does not meet all statutory conditions, specifically the prohibition on separate use under planning consent. No new legal precedent was established by this decision. The appellants retain the right to seek permission to appeal the decision within the prescribed timeframe.
Click here to read the full judgment