Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Pro Sieben Media AG v. Carlton Television Ltd & Anor

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal from an order made by Judge Laddie on 31 July 1997 following a trial concerning copyright infringement. The Plaintiff, a major German television company, alleged that the Defendant companies, a UK television broadcaster and an independent production company, infringed its copyright by including a 30-second extract from a German television programme in a UK current affairs programme. The German programme was broadcast on 27 August 1996, and the UK programme was broadcast on 29 August 1996. The Defendants also copied the entire German programme to select the extract used. The Plaintiff's programme included an interview with a woman pregnant with eight embryos, which had received wide publicity. The UK programme was critical of media practices involving payments for exclusive stories, contrasting itself with such practices and including the extract from the Plaintiff's programme as part of its critique. The trial judge found infringement and rejected the Defendants' fair dealing defence under sections 30(1) and 30(2) of the Copyright Designs and Patent Act 1988. The Defendants appealed that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Did the UK programme make use of the Plaintiff's programme for the purpose of criticism or review?
  2. If so, was that use fair dealing?
  3. If so, was there a sufficient acknowledgement of the Plaintiff's work?
  4. Did the UK programme make use of the Plaintiff's programme for the purpose of reporting current events?
  5. If so, was that use fair dealing?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The trial judge erred in his general approach, particularly in assessing the nature and purpose of the UK programme.
  • The judge wrongly rejected evidence from a key witness regarding the purpose of criticism and reporting current events.
  • The appellants contended that the use of the 30-second extract was for the purpose of criticism and reporting current events, satisfying the fair dealing defence.
  • The judge's characterisation of the critical comments accompanying the extract as "throw away" was misplaced; the entire programme was a critique of 'chequebook journalism'.
  • On the issue of sufficient acknowledgement, the appellants argued that the visible title and logo of the Plaintiff's programme constituted adequate identification of the author.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Respondent contended for an objective test regarding the purpose of use under section 30.
  • They argued that the judge's construction of "reporting current events" was too favourable to the appellants.
  • The Respondent maintained that the use was not fair dealing and that sufficient acknowledgement was not given.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Re Grayan Building Services (1995 Ch 241) Standard of appellate review on mixed fact and law questions. Applied to emphasize deference to trial judge’s findings on fair dealing unless error of principle or unsustainability.
Benmax v Austin Motor Co. Ltd [1955] A.C. 370 Nature of mixed fact and law decisions. Referenced to support approach on appellate review of factual conclusions.
George Mitchell (Chesterhall) v Finney Lock Seeds [1983] 2 AC 803 Standards of appellate interference with trial judge’s discretion. Used to support reluctance to disturb trial judge’s findings.
Re Coventry [1980] Ch 461 Appellate review standards in discretionary matters. Reinforced approach to appellate deference.
Hubbard v Vosper [1972] 2 QB 84 Fair dealing as a question of degree and purpose. Applied to analyze the scope of fair dealing for criticism or review.
Beloff v Pressdram [1973] RPC 765 Fair dealing involves fact and impression. Supported the factual and impression-based approach to fair dealing.
Time Warner Entertainments v Channel Four Television [1994] EMLR 1 Fair dealing for criticism includes strong, unbalanced criticism; criticism may extend to ideas and social implications. Used to show criticism may be broad and still qualify for fair dealing; supported appellants' argument.
Ambard v A.-G for Trinidad and Tobago [1936] AC 322 Freedom of expression in criticism. Quoted to underline that criticism may be wrongheaded but still protected.
Sweet v Parsley 1970 AC 132 Construction of composite phrases in statutory interpretation. Applied to interpret "for the purposes of" as a composite whole including intention and context.
Hindley v Higgins and News Group Newspapers (1983, C.A.) Purpose test for fair dealing. Referenced to illustrate judicial caution against subjective belief alone.
Associated Newspapers v News Group Newspapers 1986 RPC 515 Purpose and fair dealing. Used to caution against users relying solely on their subjective belief of purpose.
De Garis v Neville Jeffress Pidler (1990) 18 IPR 292 Interpretation of "current events" in copyright context. Referenced to highlight the broad and indefinite scope of "current events".

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by affirming the trial judge's careful factual findings and legal framework, including the statutory provisions of sections 30(1) and 30(2) of the Copyright Designs and Patent Act 1988. The court recognized the judge’s expertise and the usual appellate reluctance to overturn factual findings, especially on mixed fact and law issues such as fair dealing.

However, the court identified a key error in the trial judge’s focus on the subjective intentions and motives of the programme makers rather than the likely impact of the programme on its audience. The court emphasized that the defence of fair dealing requires assessing the purpose of use in context, including the broader critical message conveyed, rather than narrowly scrutinizing the evidence of individual witnesses’ intentions.

The court found that the UK programme was indeed made for the purpose of criticism of a genre of 'chequebook journalism,' including the Plaintiff’s programme. The 30-second extract was part of a broader critique and was not used merely to show that others paid for interviews but to expose the practice’s implications for truth and media ethics.

On fairness, the court held that the limited use of the extract, its short duration, and the absence of direct competition with the Plaintiff’s exploitation of the copyright supported a finding of fair dealing.

Regarding sufficient acknowledgement, the court accepted that the visible title "TAFF" and the Plaintiff’s logo on screen constituted adequate identification of the work and author under section 178 of the Act, especially given the niche audience for the Plaintiff’s broadcasts in the UK.

The court also addressed the separate allegation of copying the entire Plaintiff’s programme, concluding on balance that this was done solely to enable selection of the extract and thus was for the same purposes as the broadcast.

Finally, the court considered the defence under section 30(2) for reporting current events, finding that the multiple pregnancy and media interest were current events and that the use of the extract was fair dealing in that context as well.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is allowed. The court discharged the trial judge's order, dismissed the Plaintiff's action, and ordered payment out with accrued interest. The Defendants were released from their undertaking, and leave to appeal to the House of Lords was refused.

The decision reverses the finding of copyright infringement based on fair dealing defences under sections 30(1) and 30(2) of the Copyright Designs and Patent Act 1988. It clarifies that fair dealing for criticism or review includes criticism of a genre of works and that sufficient acknowledgement may be satisfied by on-screen titles and logos when appropriate. The ruling emphasizes the importance of assessing the purpose of use from the perspective of the audience impact rather than solely the subjective intent of the users. No new precedent was established beyond the application of existing principles to the facts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Pro Sieben Media AG v Carlton Television Ltd & Anor

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Pro Sieben Media AG v Carlton Television Ltd & Anor
(Dec 17, 1998)