Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes

Couturier & Ors v. Hastie & Anor

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiffs, merchants based in City A, chartered a vessel in City C to carry approximately 1,180 quarters of Indian corn to the United Kingdom. A policy of marine insurance was taken out on 8 February 1848. The cargo sailed on 23 February 1848.

During the voyage the corn overheated and, after a survey in City D, the master lawfully sold the cargo on 22 April 1848. Neither the Plaintiffs nor the Defendants knew of this sale when, on 15 May 1848, the Defendants (corn factors in City B) sold the same cargo on a del credere commission to a third-party buyer. On learning—via shipping reports—that the cargo no longer existed, the buyer repudiated the contract on 23 May 1848.

The Plaintiffs sued the Defendants for the price of the cargo. At first instance, Judge Martin directed a verdict for the Defendants, holding that the subject-matter no longer existed at the time of the contract. The Court of Exchequer later entered judgment for the Plaintiffs non obstante veredicto on one plea; the Defendants carried the point by bill of exceptions. The Exchequer Chamber unanimously reversed the Court of Exchequer. The Plaintiffs in Error (the original Plaintiffs) then appealed to the House of Lords, leading to the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a contract for the sale of goods is void when, unknown to both parties, the goods had ceased to exist before the contract was concluded.
  2. Whether the wording “free on board … including freight and insurance” transfers to the buyer merely a chance of arrival and the benefit of insurance, or necessarily presupposes an existing cargo capable of delivery.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs in Error (Sellers) – Key Arguments

  • The contract transferred to the buyer the chance of the cargo’s arrival and the associated shipping documents; such “sale of an expectation” is valid (Paine v. Meller; Cass v. Rudele).
  • The phrase “free on board” signified that the risk had already passed to the buyer (Cowasjee v. Thompson), so any loss—even total—should fall on the purchaser.
  • So long as something had been shipped, the contract could attach notwithstanding subsequent deterioration or disposal; authority was drawn from Barr v. Gibson and Johnson v. Macdonald.
  • Even if the cargo was lost, the purchaser could have recovered under the marine policy (Roux v. Salvador), demonstrating that the contractual risk lay with the buyer.
  • Cases such as Strickland v. Turner were distinguished on the basis that, there, nothing existed at all; here, the cargo had once existed and had been properly shipped.

Defendants in Error (Factors) – Key Arguments

The opinion records that counsel for the Defendants in Error were not called upon to address the House because the Judges unanimously supported their position. Their detailed arguments are therefore not set out in the judgment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Paine v. Meller (6 Ves 349) Validity of selling an expectation or chance Cited by Plaintiffs to argue the contract could attach to an expectation; the House distinguished the situation because the parties did not purport to sell a mere expectation.
Cass v. Rudele (2 Vern 280) Same principle as above Treated in the same manner as Paine v. Meller.
Cowasjee v. Thompson (5 Moore P.C. 165) “Free on board” places risk on the buyer Relied on by Plaintiffs; ultimately outweighed by the primary requirement that the goods exist.
Barr v. Gibson (3 M.&W. 390) Contract valid if anything exists on which it can attach Distinguished; here nothing existed at the time of sale.
Johnson v. Macdonald (9 M.&W. 600) Effect of “to arrive” terms vs. “free on board” Cited by Plaintiffs; not determinative because the subject-matter was non-existent.
Strickland v. Turner (7 Exch 208) Sale void where subject matter has ceased to exist Accepted by the House as analogous and supportive of the Defendants’ position.
Hitchcock v. Giddings (4 Price 135) Purchaser of a chance bears the consequences Cited by Plaintiffs; House found parties did not intend a sale of a pure chance.
Sutherland v. Pratt (11 M.&W. 296) Scope of insurance recovery for total loss Discussed but not decisive; the primary question was contractual, not insurance law.
Roux v. Salvador (3 Bing N.C. 266) Recovery under a marine policy after total loss Used by Plaintiffs to show insurance coverage, but court held contract must first pass property.
March v. Pigott (5 Burr 2802) Insurable interest principles Referenced in argument; did not alter the outcome.
Vlierboom v. Chapman (13 M.&W. 230) Effect of non-payment of freight where cargo lost Peripheral reference; not central to the decision.
Owens v. Dunbar (12 Ir L Rep 304) Duty to accept cargo under certain terms Cited by Plaintiffs; found irrelevant once contract held void.
Dickson v. Zizinia (10 C.B. 602) Limits of implied warranty by vendor Mentioned in support of Plaintiffs’ view; no effect on ultimate reasoning.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The House, advised by nine summoned Judges, unanimously affirmed the judgment of the Exchequer Chamber. The Lord Chancellor emphasised that:

  • The contract language presupposed the existence of “an existing something” capable of sale and purchase on 15 May 1848.
  • No evidence of contrary mercantile usage was admitted; therefore the plain meaning of the words governed.
  • Because the cargo had been lawfully sold in City D on 22 April 1848, nothing existed to which the contract could attach on 15 May 1848.
  • Without an existing subject-matter, the agreement failed for want of consideration, consistent with civilian and common-law principles (the Lord Chancellor referred to Pothier’s analysis).
  • The question of insurance was immaterial: the buyer could only benefit from the policy if property passed, and no property could pass when the goods were non-existent.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The House of Lords affirmed the Exchequer Chamber; judgment entered for the Defendants in Error with costs.

Implications: The decision confirms that a contract for the sale of specific goods is void if, unknown to the parties, the goods have ceased to exist at the time of the contract. The parties cannot, by references to insurance or shipment terms, shift the fundamental requirement that an identifiable subject-matter must exist. The ruling clarifies the allocation of risk in “goods afloat” transactions and has become a leading authority on the doctrine of res extincta in English contract law.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Couturier & Ors v Hastie & Anor

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Couturier & Ors v Hastie & Anor
(Jun 26, 1856)