Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Morrow v. Safeway Stores Plc

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant was employed by the Respondents as a bakery production controller at their store. Over several months, the Appellant experienced harassment and unreasonable pressure from the store manager concerning her work performance, with little support from staff or supervisors. On 20th August, the store manager publicly reprimanded the Appellant, making disparaging remarks about her ability to perform her job. After further criticism two hours later, the Appellant became distressed, sought alternative employment, and resigned on 10th September claiming unfair constructive dismissal. The Respondents denied constructive dismissal, asserting the Appellant simply resigned without entitlement. The Employment Tribunal dismissed the Appellant's complaint on 17th January 2000, finding that although the store manager breached the implied term of trust and confidence, the breach was not sufficiently serious to amount to repudiatory conduct justifying resignation. The Appellant appealed that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Employment Tribunal erred in law by finding that the employer's breach of the implied term of trust and confidence was not sufficiently serious to amount to repudiatory conduct entitling the Appellant to resign and claim constructive dismissal.
  2. Whether, if such a misdirection occurred, the Tribunal's conclusion was nevertheless plainly and unarguably correct based on the precedent in Dobie v Burns International Security [1984] IRLR 818.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The implied term of trust and confidence means every breach is fundamental and entitles the employee to resign and claim constructive dismissal.
  • The Tribunal misdirected itself by applying a test of seriousness beyond the mere finding of breach.
  • The Tribunal's decision was not plainly and unarguably right given the facts found.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The implied duty is a general obligation not to undermine trust and confidence, but not all breaches are repudiatory.
  • Only conduct likely to destroy or seriously damage the relationship amounts to repudiatory breach.
  • The Tribunal was entitled to conclude the employer's conduct was not sufficiently serious to be repudiatory and there was no misdirection.
  • If misdirection is found, the Tribunal's decision was nevertheless plainly right based on facts and seriousness assessment.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Courtaulds Northern Textiles Ltd. v Andrew [1979] IRLR 84 Recognition and scope of implied term of trust and confidence in employment contracts. Confirmed that conduct likely to destroy or seriously damage trust and confidence goes to the root of the contract and is repudiatory.
Western Excavating (ECC) Ltd. v Sharp [1978] IRLR 27 Conduct must amount to repudiation of contract to justify constructive dismissal. Applied to clarify that only fundamental breaches entitle resignation for constructive dismissal.
Woods v W M Car Services (Peterborough) Ltd. [1981] IRLR 347 Implied term forbids conduct calculated or likely to destroy or seriously damage trust and confidence; repudiatory conduct may be cumulative. Emphasized importance of implied term and repudiatory nature of breach for constructive dismissal claims.
Lewis v Motorworld Garages Ltd. [1986] ICR 157 Repudiatory conduct may consist of a series of acts which cumulatively breach implied term of trust and confidence. Approved Woods and reinforced cumulative breaches as repudiatory.
Malik v Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA [1997] IRLR 462 Implied term prohibits employer conduct likely to destroy or seriously damage trust and confidence; contextual and objective assessment required. Confirmed implied term as fundamental and evolving, with social and contractual importance.
TSB Bank plc v Harris [2000] IRLR 157 Confirmed that breach of implied term is fundamental and repudiatory; repudiation may be found if conduct seriously damages trust and confidence. Applied to find employer conduct breached implied term and was fundamental breach.
Johnson v Unisys Ltd. [2001] IRLR 279 Described implied term as overarching obligation of good faith and fair dealing in employment contracts. Reaffirmed the implied term’s significance and its contractual basis, emphasizing relational nature of employment.
Dobie v Burns International Security [1984] IRLR 818 Standard for appellate courts to interfere with Tribunal’s factual conclusions: only if decision is plainly and unarguably wrong. Used to assess whether Tribunal’s decision should be disturbed despite legal misdirection.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court carefully examined the factual findings of the Employment Tribunal, particularly the public reprimand by the store manager and the resulting distress of the Appellant. It acknowledged that the Tribunal correctly identified a breach of the implied term of trust and confidence by the employer's conduct. However, the Tribunal erred by applying a separate test of seriousness to determine whether the breach was repudiatory, effectively bifurcating the breach and its seriousness. The Court held that any breach of this implied term necessarily amounts to a repudiatory breach going to the root of the contract, entitling the employee to resign and claim constructive dismissal.

Despite this misdirection, the Court found it unclear whether the Tribunal’s ultimate decision that the constructive dismissal claim failed was plainly and unarguably right under the Dobie test. The factual findings and assessment of the employer’s conduct’s seriousness did not justify overturning the Tribunal’s decision outright. Therefore, the Court allowed the appeal but did not substitute its own finding of constructive dismissal, instead remitting the matter for rehearing before a fresh Tribunal.

Holding and Implications

The Court's final ruling was to ALLOW THE APPEAL and remit the case to a fresh Employment Tribunal for rehearing.

The direct effect is that the original Tribunal’s decision dismissing the claim of unfair constructive dismissal is set aside for reconsideration. No new precedent was established beyond clarifying that any breach of the implied term of trust and confidence constitutes a repudiatory breach entitling resignation. The case reaffirms the importance of correctly applying the legal principle that breaches of this implied term are fundamental, and it underscores the appellate court’s limited role in overturning factual findings absent clear error.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Morrow v. Safeway Stores Plc

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Morrow v. Safeway Stores Plc
(Sep 21, 2001)