Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

British Gas Services Ltd v. McCaull

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent was employed by the appellant company as a service engineer responsible for servicing and repairing central heating systems at customers' homes, operating primarily from home with a van and laptop. The respondent had epilepsy since 1991, which was unknown to the appellant until a driving accident caused by an epileptic fit in November 1996. Following the accident, the respondent’s driving licence was withdrawn by the DVLA in September 1997 and remained so at the time of the tribunal hearing in November 1998.

In March 1997, the appellant initiated its "management of absence attributable to sickness" (MAAS) procedure. The appellant was unaware of the Disability Discrimination Act (the Act) at that time. Medical advice restricted the respondent from driving and performing several tasks typical of his role. Meetings in May and June 1997 led to the respondent being told he could no longer work as a service engineer but could take alternative clerical work as a Customer Service Adviser (CSA) with a significant pay reduction. The respondent declined the alternative role, and his employment was terminated on grounds of capability in September 1997.

The respondent appealed the dismissal internally unsuccessfully and subsequently lodged claims for unfair dismissal and disability discrimination under the Act in late 1997. The Employment Tribunal found discrimination under both section 5(1) and section 5(2) of the Act and held the dismissal to be unfair. The appellant appealed these findings.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant discriminated against the respondent under section 5(1) of the Disability Discrimination Act by dismissing him for a reason related to his disability.
  2. Whether the appellant breached its duty under section 6 of the Act, constituting discrimination under section 5(2), by failing to take reasonable steps to accommodate the respondent’s disability.
  3. Whether the dismissal of the respondent was unfair under the Employment Rights Act 1996.
  4. Whether the Employment Tribunal applied the correct legal test for discrimination under section 5(1) regarding the comparator used.
  5. Whether the tribunal had jurisdiction to consider complaints about failure to supply information concerning alternative employment.
  6. Whether the tribunal erred in its approach to the duty imposed by section 6 of the Act and the reasonableness of the steps taken by the employer.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that the Employment Tribunal applied an incorrect comparator in assessing discrimination under section 5(1), relying on the EAT decision in Clark v Novacold rather than the later Court of Appeal decision.
  • The appellant argued that the tribunal lacked jurisdiction to consider complaints about failure to supply information regarding the alternative job as these were out of time and not explicitly raised by the respondent.
  • It was submitted that the tribunal erred in law by finding a breach of the section 6 duty merely because the employer did not consciously consider its obligations under the Act.
  • The appellant maintained that an employer can justify non-compliance with section 6 by showing certain steps were not reasonable, even if not considered at the time.
  • Regarding unfair dismissal, the appellant argued that offering alternative employment at the prevailing rate for that role was reasonable, especially as no other suitable alternative was available.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent relied on the tribunal’s approach using the EAT decision in Clark v Novacold and argued the appellant was estopped from challenging that legal test on appeal.
  • It was contended that the appellant failed to comply with its duty under section 6 by not considering reasonable adjustments and that the failure to provide sufficient information about alternative employment was part of the discrimination.
  • The respondent argued the dismissal was unfair due to the significant pay reduction involved in the alternative employment offer and the appellant’s intention to prevent qualification for ill-health pension.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Clark v Novacold Ltd [1998] IRLR 420 (EAT) and [1999] IRLR 318 (Court of Appeal) Proper comparator in disability discrimination cases under section 5(1); rejection of "like for like" comparison. The tribunal initially applied the EAT approach but this was overturned by the Court of Appeal. The court held the tribunal applied the wrong legal test and must reconsider the claim under the correct legal standard.
Jones v Burdett Coutts School [1998] IRLR 521 Principles on raising new points of law on appeal and reopening conceded points. The court considered whether the respondent could rely on the Court of Appeal decision in Clark despite it not being argued below but found no compelling reason to allow the new point of law to be raised.
British Sugar plc v Kirker [1998] IRLR 624 Conflicting authority on comparator issues in disability discrimination. Referenced to highlight conflicting legal approaches and that the tribunal chose the approach it deemed appropriate.
Cast v Croydon College [1998] IRLR 318 Interpretation of time limits for presenting discrimination complaints and continuing acts doctrine. The court applied principles from this case to reject the notion of a continuing discriminatory act regarding failure to supply information.
Lupetti v Wrens Old House Ltd [1984] ICR 348; Gloucester Working Men's Club v James [1986] ICR 603 Time limits in dismissal cases for discrimination complaints run from the end of employment. Used to support the tribunal’s jurisdiction to consider complaints about failure to provide information related to dismissal.
Morse v Wiltshire County Council Application of section 6 duty: objective test for reasonableness of employer’s steps. The court endorsed the tribunal’s obligation to objectively assess what reasonable steps were taken and whether failure to comply was justified.
Merseyside and North Wales Electricity Board v Taylor [1975] IRLR 60 Reasonableness of dismissal related to incapacity and availability of alternative employment. The tribunal applied principles from this case in assessing the fairness of dismissal and the obligation to consider alternative employment.
Wilson v Liverpool Corporation [1971] 1 WLR 302 Appeal principles regarding agreed legal bases and the possibility of upholding decisions despite wrong legal basis. Referenced to illustrate that a tribunal decision may stand even if based on an incorrect legal test if both parties agreed to it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined the tribunal’s application of the comparator test under section 5(1) of the Disability Discrimination Act. It found that the tribunal erred by applying the EAT's "like for like" comparator approach from Clark v Novacold, which was subsequently overturned by the Court of Appeal. The correct approach requires comparison with persons to whom the disability-related reason does not apply, without requiring identical circumstances. This error affected the tribunal's discrimination findings.

Regarding the tribunal’s jurisdiction to consider complaints about failure to supply information concerning alternative employment, the court held the tribunal did have jurisdiction. The failure was linked to the dismissal, and time limits run from the end of employment, not the omission.

The court also found that the tribunal improperly considered acts of omission as discriminatory without evidence that the failure to provide information was related to the disability, thus failing to apply the statutory test fully under section 5(1).

On the section 5(2) claim concerning the employer's duty to make reasonable adjustments under section 6, the court found that the tribunal erred in law by requiring the employer to be aware of the statutory duty and by disallowing post hoc arguments that certain steps were not reasonable. The statutory test is objective, focusing on what steps the employer took or failed to take, and whether those steps were reasonable in all circumstances. The tribunal failed to consider whether the employer could reasonably have taken any steps, which was a legal error.

In relation to unfair dismissal, the tribunal found the dismissal unfair because the alternative employment offered involved a substantial pay cut and was not reasonable. The court disagreed, noting the appellant offered the only suitable alternative employment at the prevailing rate, and the tribunal did not adequately consider whether the dismissal was within the range of reasonable responses by an employer.

Overall, the court concluded that the tribunal made significant errors in law on all three claims and that the case must be reconsidered by a differently constituted Employment Tribunal applying the correct legal principles.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is ALLOWED on all aspects of the case. The findings of discrimination under sections 5(1) and 5(2) of the Disability Discrimination Act and the finding of unfair dismissal are set aside. The matter is remitted for rehearing by a differently constituted Employment Tribunal applying the correct legal tests as outlined by the Court of Appeal and this tribunal.

The direct effect is that the respondent’s claims must be reconsidered afresh, and no new precedent is established by this decision beyond clarifying the application of legal principles already established by higher courts.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

British Gas Services Ltd v. McCaull

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

British Gas Services Ltd v. McCaull
(Sep 28, 2000)