Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Indescon Ltd v. Sir Robert Ogden CBE LLD

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimant, a limited company in administration formerly active in building contracting, initiated arbitration proceedings concerning disputes arising from a construction contract executed in 1989 with the respondent, a private individual engaged in property development and investment. The contract incorporated arbitration clauses under a JCT standard form and additional conditions specifying dispute resolution mechanisms. The claimant served two arbitration notices dated 16th April 1992 and 3rd May 2000, respectively, relating to disputes over the construction contract for a large office block development in London. The arbitration process was delayed over many years, with minimal prosecutorial activity by the claimant, including a failed appointment of an arbitrator in the early 1990s and subsequent negotiations and meetings between the parties.

The respondent challenged the jurisdiction of the arbitrator appointed in 2002 on the basis that the claimant's right to appoint had lapsed due to delay and that the 1992 arbitration notice had been abandoned by the issuance of the 2000 notice. The claimant maintained that both notices remained valid and that the arbitration proceedings could continue. The court was asked to determine the jurisdiction of the arbitrator and the validity and effect of the two arbitration notices.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the claimant's right to appoint an arbitrator pursuant to the 1992 arbitration notice had lapsed due to delay or abandonment.
  2. Whether the 2000 arbitration notice constituted an abandonment of the 1992 notice.
  3. The validity of the appointment of the arbitrator pursuant to the 2000 notice.
  4. The applicable arbitration regime governing each arbitration notice.
  5. Whether any implied contractual term required the claimant to appoint an arbitrator within a reasonable time following the 1992 notice.

Arguments of the Parties

Claimant's Arguments

  • The 1992 arbitration notice remains effective and the right to appoint an arbitrator under it continues to subsist.
  • The 2000 arbitration notice was served without prejudice to the 1992 notice and did not amount to abandonment of the earlier notice.
  • The appointment of the arbitrator in 2002 was valid and related to the disputes set out in the 2000 notice.
  • Any delay in appointing an arbitrator under the 1992 notice does not amount to a repudiatory breach nor lapse of the right to arbitrate.
  • There is no implied term in the contract requiring appointment of an arbitrator within a reasonable time.
  • The respondent shares responsibility for any delay in prosecuting the arbitration under the 1992 notice.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The right to appoint an arbitrator pursuant to the 1992 notice has lapsed through effluxion of time due to claimant's inaction.
  • The claimant abandoned the 1992 arbitration notice by serving the 2000 notice and seeking the appointment of a different arbitrator.
  • The appointment of the arbitrator pursuant to the 2000 notice was invalid.
  • The claimant was in repudiatory breach of the arbitration agreement by failing to appoint or apply for appointment of an arbitrator within a reasonable time.
  • The 1992 notice cannot confer jurisdiction on an arbitrator appointed in 2002 due to the excessive delay.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Leonida D [1985] 1 WLR 925 Whether contractual rights to appoint an arbitrator lapse by delay and whether such rights are "powers" that must be exercised within a reasonable time. The court rejected the submission that the right to appoint an arbitrator lapses through effluxion of time, interpreting Leonida D as not supporting a class of contractual rights described as powers that must be exercised reasonably.
Bremer Vulkan Schiffbau und Maschinenfabrik v South India Shipping Corporation Ltd [1981] AC 909 Mutual obligation of parties in arbitration to apply to the arbitrator for directions to avoid undue delay and to ensure a fair trial. The court relied on this authority to reject the respondent's argument that the claimant’s delay amounted to repudiatory breach, noting both parties have mutual obligations and that delay alone does not terminate the arbitration agreement.
The Golden Bear [1987] Lloyd's Rep 343 Some contractual rights must be exercised reasonably, but not necessarily within a fixed time. The court cited this case to clarify that the right to appoint an arbitrator is not necessarily a power that lapses, supporting the rejection of the respondent’s implied term argument.
Hannah Blumenthal [1983] 1 All ER 34 (House of Lords) Whether a party is obligated to take steps to appoint an arbitrator in the absence of agreement. The court found no basis to impose an obligation on the respondent to take steps to appoint an arbitrator, especially given the claimant's status and conduct.
Crawford v AE Prowting Parties’ obligations to proceed with arbitration with reasonable dispatch and the consequences of delay. Referenced in the context of mutual obligations to avoid delay, but the court found that neither party could treat the arbitration agreement as ended due to delay alone.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the contractual provisions governing arbitration, including the dispute resolution clauses and the arbitration notices served in 1992 and 2000. It found that the 1992 notice was a valid exercise of the claimant's right to arbitrate disputes under the contract and that the respondent was contractually bound to submit to arbitration once an arbitrator was appointed.

The court rejected the respondent's argument that the right to appoint an arbitrator under the 1992 notice had lapsed due to delay, relying on established case law that such rights do not expire merely by effluxion of time and that there is no implied contractual term requiring appointment within a reasonable period. The court also rejected the submission that the claimant had abandoned the 1992 notice by serving the 2000 notice, noting the express reservation in the 2000 notice and the absence of any conduct indicating abandonment.

Regarding the appointment of the arbitrator pursuant to the 2000 notice, the court found this appointment valid and confirmed that the arbitration under the 2000 notice was governed by the Arbitration Act 1996, while the 1992 notice arbitration would proceed under the earlier Arbitration Acts. The court noted the respondent's failure to apply for directions to address delay and emphasized that delay alone does not constitute repudiation of the arbitration agreement.

The court acknowledged the practical difficulties delay might cause in resolving disputes but held that the claimant could still seek arbitration under the 1992 notice, including applying for appointment of an arbitrator if necessary. The respondent was not under an obligation to take steps to appoint an arbitrator in the absence of agreement, especially given the claimant's insolvency and the sporadic prosecution of claims.

Holding and Implications

The court made the following orders:

  • The right to appoint an arbitrator pursuant to the 1992 arbitration notice continues to subsist.
  • The President of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators is the proper appointing authority in the absence of agreement under the 1992 notice.
  • The arbitration under the 1992 notice proceeds under the Arbitration Acts of 1950 and 1979.
  • The 2000 arbitration notice is valid and those proceedings continue.
  • The appointment of the arbitrator pursuant to the 2000 notice is valid.
  • Costs of the application before the court to be determined by the court; costs of the arbitration to be determined by the arbitrator, including interim awards.
  • The arbitration pursuant to the 2000 notice proceeds under the Arbitration Act 1996.

There is no finding of abandonment or repudiatory breach of the arbitration agreement by the claimant. The court’s decision allows both arbitration processes to continue concurrently if necessary, with clear delineation of the applicable arbitration regimes. No new precedent was set beyond the application of existing principles regarding delay, abandonment, and the mutual obligations of parties in arbitration agreements.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Indescon Ltd v Sir Robert Ogden CBE LLD

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Indescon Ltd v Sir Robert Ogden CBE LLD
(Aug 20, 2004)