Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Football Association Premier League Ltd & Ors v. QC Leisure & Ors

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This judgment follows the resumption of the hearing of the trial of multiple actions concerning alleged copyright infringements by the defendants related to broadcasts of the Football Association Premier League Ltd ("FAPL"). The court had previously decided some issues and referred several questions to the Court of Justice of the European Union, which responded with a judgment. The current hearing addresses a series of issues arising from that judgment and the ongoing proceedings, including whether defendants communicated copyright works contrary to the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 ("CDPA"), the scope of any defences under the CDPA, authorisation of infringement by certain defendants, and remedies including declarations and injunctions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether any of the defendants have communicated any of FAPL's copyright works to the public contrary to section 20 of the CDPA, and if so, whether section 72 provides a defence.
  2. Whether defendants QC Leisure ("QC") and AV Station plc ("AV") have infringed FAPL's copyrights by authorising infringing acts of their customers, including the Madden defendants.
  3. Which works were screened or played by the Madden defendants.
  4. Whether it is appropriate to grant a declaration that the defendants have infringed FAPL's copyrights and the form of such declaration.
  5. Whether it is appropriate to grant an injunction to restrain further infringement and the form of such injunction.
  6. Whether to grant a declaration reflecting the ruling of the Court of Justice on Article 81 EC (now Article 101 TFEU) and the form of such declaration.
  7. Whether to dismiss causes of action which have failed.
  8. Whether to order an inquiry or account and consequential directions.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Claimants)

  • The defendants have infringed FAPL's copyrights by communicating works to the public in public houses via television screens and speakers, contrary to section 20 CDPA as amended by the 2003 Regulations implementing the Copyright Directive.
  • The legislature intended to implement the Copyright Directive correctly, and thus the activities of the publicans fall within the scope of "communication to the public" by electronic transmission.
  • A declaration of infringement is appropriate once infringement is established.
  • Injunctions are necessary to prevent further infringement of copyrights, including film works, artistic works, and the Anthem.
  • Support for a declaration reflecting the Court of Justice ruling on Article 81 EC.

Appellee's Arguments (Defendants)

  • The case is misconceived as the communication to the public under the Satellite and Copyright Directive occurs only in the Member State of transmission, not where the broadcast is received.
  • The phrase "communication to the public by electronic transmission" in section 20 CDPA cannot be interpreted to include receiving a broadcast and showing it publicly on a television set.
  • Section 72 CDPA provides a defence when the public have not paid for admission to the place where the broadcast is shown, exempting such acts from infringement.
  • Directives do not have horizontal direct effect and national courts must interpret domestic law in conformity with directives only "so far as possible" without overriding clear statutory language.
  • The showing or playing of broadcasts in public houses does not constitute infringement under section 20, and the defence under section 72 applies to all copyrights in films included in broadcasts.
  • Concern about the breadth of claims and the need for precision in any injunction or declaration.
  • Support for a declaration regarding the invalidity of contractual restrictions under Article 81 EC.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Case C-306/05 SGAE v Rafael Hoteles [2006] ECR I-11519 Interpretation of "communication to the public" under the Copyright Directive Used to initially consider whether publicans' acts constituted communication to the public; court provisionally preferred defendants' submissions but referred question to CJEU.
Case C-403/08 (Court of Justice judgment of 4 October 2011) Definition and scope of "communication to the public" in Article 3(1) of the Copyright Directive CJEU held that transmission of broadcast works via TV and speakers to customers in public houses constitutes communication to a new public, thus infringement.
Case C-429/08 (Parallel proceedings: Murphy v Media Protection Services Ltd) Related interpretation of communication to the public Referred to by CJEU in its judgment alongside the present case.
Case C-91/92 Faccini Dori [1994] ECR I-3325 Limits of horizontal direct effect of EU directives Confirmed that directives bind Member States but do not create rights enforceable between private parties.
Case C-106/89 Marleasing SA [1990] ECR 4135 Obligation of national courts to interpret national law in conformity with EU directives Applied as a guiding principle for interpreting section 20 CDPA in light of the Copyright Directive.
HMRC v IDT Card Services Ireland Ltd [2006] EWCA Civ 29 Limits and scope of conforming interpretation under EU law and Human Rights Act 1998 Explained the balance between interpretation and law-making, applied to consider limits on interpreting CDPA provisions.
Ghaidan v Godin-Mendoza [2004] UKHL 30 Interpretation of domestic legislation to comply with EU and Human Rights obligations Referenced for principles on the extent of permissible interpretative modifications.
Vodafone 2 v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2009] EWCA Civ 446 Principles governing broad and far-reaching conforming interpretation of domestic law Summarised principles permitting departure from literal statutory meaning to comply with Community law obligations.
Stewart v Engel [2000] 1 WLR 2268 Jurisdiction to revisit and correct judgments Referenced regarding the request to revisit findings on authorisation and infringement.
Robinson v Bird [2003] EWCA Civ 1820 Jurisdiction to revisit and correct judgments Referenced alongside Stewart v Engel for similar purpose.
Financial Services Authority v John Edward Rourke [2002] CP Rep 14 Power of courts to grant declarations under CPR Part 40.20 Explained the court's discretion in granting declarations, applied to scope of copyright infringement declarations.
Case C-145/10 Painer v Standard Verlags GmbH (2011) Equality of copyright works for injunction purposes Referenced in support of injunction claims, emphasizing no "inferior" classes of copyright work.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by considering whether the defendants' acts constituted communication to the public within the meaning of section 20 CDPA and the Copyright Directive. Initially, the court provisionally accepted the defendants' submission that publicans merely received and displayed broadcasts without retransmitting them, thus not constituting communication to a new public. However, the Court of Justice clarified that communication to the public includes transmission of broadcast works via television screens and speakers to customers in public houses, constituting communication to a new public not originally envisaged by the authors.

The court then assessed whether section 20 CDPA, as amended by the 2003 Regulations, effectively transposed Article 3(1) of the Copyright Directive. It concluded that the phrase "communication to the public by electronic transmission" encompasses the defendants' activities, as televisions and speakers are electronic instruments transmitting works to a new public. The court applied the Marleasing doctrine to interpret section 20 conformingly with the Directive, recognizing limits but finding no conflict with fundamental legislative features.

The court examined the relationship between sections 19 and 72 CDPA, which derive from national law and the Related Rights Directive. It found an overlap between sections 19 and 20 regarding "playing or showing in public" and "communication to the public." Section 72 provides a defence where the public has not paid for admission, exempting infringement of copyright in films included in broadcasts. The court rejected arguments that section 72 applies only to producers' rights or should be read down to avoid conflict, holding that section 72 means what it says and applies as a complete defence to infringement under sections 19 and 20 for films.

Regarding authorisation, the court reaffirmed its earlier conclusion that supplying decoder cards to customers authorises their use for watching programming in public houses, thus authorising infringing acts by the Madden defendants and others.

On the specific works screened or played by the Madden defendants, the court found that they screened certain ART studio and non-studio matches but rejected the claim that the Anthem was played out loud by them in the pleaded matches, declining to revisit the factual findings.

In considering declarations, the court emphasized the need for precision and limitation to specific acts of infringement established against each defendant, rejecting overly broad declarations.

On injunctions, the court noted the importance of preventing further infringements but recognized the defendants' changed circumstances, including undertakings given and businesses ceased, suggesting undertakings might suffice in lieu of injunctions. Any injunction must be precise and allow lawful business continuation.

Regarding a declaration on Article 81 EC (now Article 101 TFEU), the court accepted the defendants' legitimate interest in a formal declaration that contractual restrictions prohibiting supply of certain satellite decoder cards were void as anti-competitive, while preserving FAPL's copyright rights.

On the order dismissing failed causes of action, the court agreed to make such an order alongside one confirming successful causes of action, corresponding to the declarations.

Finally, the court ordered an inquiry or account of profits for damages, transferring the matter to the Patents County Court for management, and declined to order further disclosure at this stage.

Holding and Implications

DECISION: The court held that the defendants have infringed FAPL's copyrights by communicating broadcast works to the public in their public houses via television screens and speakers, constituting communication to the public under section 20 CDPA as construed in conformity with the Copyright Directive and the Court of Justice's ruling.

The defence under section 72 CDPA applies to films included in broadcasts shown to an audience that has not paid for admission, providing a complete defence against infringement claims under sections 19 and 20 for such works.

QC Leisure and AV Station plc authorised infringing acts by supplying decoder cards to publicans.

The court granted a declaration of infringement limited to specific works and defendants, and accepted undertakings in lieu of injunctions to prevent playing the Anthem out loud.

The court granted a formal declaration that contractual restrictions violating Article 81 EC were void to the extent they prohibited supply of certain decoder cards, without prejudicing copyright rights.

An order will be made dismissing causes of action which failed, and an inquiry or account of profits is ordered, to be managed by the Patents County Court.

IMPLICATIONS: The decision clarifies that public display of broadcast works in public houses constitutes communication to the public under copyright law, expanding the scope of infringement beyond original broadcast transmissions. The decision confirms the applicability of statutory defences for free public showing of broadcasts. It also underscores the courts' obligation to interpret domestic law in conformity with EU directives within limits. No new precedent beyond this case's facts is established, but the ruling has significant practical effects on licensing and enforcement of broadcast copyrights in public venues.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Football Association Premier League Ltd & Ors v QC Leisure & Ors

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Football Association Premier League Ltd & Ors v QC Leisure & Ors
(Feb 3, 2012)