Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Navitaire Inc v. Easyjet Airline Co. & Anor

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This action concerns an allegation of copyright infringement in computer software implementing an airline booking system principally used by low-cost airlines employing 'ticketless' booking. The claimant, referred to as Plaintiff, owns the copyright in the source code of the OpenRes system, a commercially successful airline booking system. The first defendant, Defendant, is a well-known low-cost airline. The second defendant, Company B, is a software developer responsible for writing the code of the allegedly infringing system, called eRes, in consultation with Defendant's IT department.

The Plaintiff alleges infringement primarily by 'non-textual copying'—that is, copying the 'look and feel' of the user interface, the user commands, and certain screen displays and reports—despite no access to the OpenRes source code by Defendant or Company B. The eRes system is internally different but functions similarly and produces similar outputs to OpenRes.

The case also involves claims relating to the copying and migration of databases underlying the systems. The Plaintiff contends that unauthorized interim copies of OpenRes databases were made during data migration and that the database schemas were reproduced in eRes.

Procedurally, the Plaintiff was ordered to provide detailed particulars of similarities relied upon but initially failed to comply, submitting a one-sided expert report focusing only on similarities. The trial involved extensive technical and factual examination of the systems, their components, and source code.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether copyright subsists in the user command sets, either individually or as a compilation, separate from the source code.
  2. Whether the user interfaces, including VT100 terminal displays and GUI screens, constitute copyright works and if they have been infringed.
  3. Whether the concept of 'non-textual copying'—copying the functional behaviour or 'business logic' of software without copying source code—amounts to copyright infringement.
  4. Whether unauthorized copying of the TakeFlight web interface source code and unauthorized modifications constitute infringement.
  5. Whether the copying or use of OpenRes database schemas, data migration copies, and related materials infringe database copyright or software copyright.
  6. Whether certain statutory exceptions, including permitted acts for lawful users and acts necessary for database access, apply to the defendants' conduct.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Exxon Corp v Exxon Insurance Consultants International Ltd [1982] RPC 69 Single words or short phrases do not qualify as literary works for copyright. The court held that individual command names do not have the necessary qualities of literary works.
Ibcos Computers Limited v Barclays Mercantile Highland Finance Limited [1994] FSR 275 Distinction between idea and expression in software copyright and limits on protection. The court relied on this case to reject broad claims of copying based on functional ideas or 'business logic'.
John Richardson Computers v Flanders [1993] FSR 497 Possibility of unconscious copying of expression without access to source code. The court considered whether knowledge of a program’s functioning could amount to infringement; here, the court was cautious and applied the principle narrowly.
Designers Guild Limited v Russell Williams Textiles Ltd [2001] 1 WLR 2416 Clarification of the idea-expression dichotomy and substantiality in copyright. The court used this authority to emphasize that copyright protects expression, not ideas, and substantiality depends on quality, not quantity.
Anderson v Lieber Code Co [1917] 2 KB 469 Compilation copyright in collections involving skill and labour. The court discussed the conditions under which a compilation of codes can be protected.
Kalamazoo (Aust) Pty v Compact Business Systems Ltd (1985) 5 IPR 213 Protection of compilations of business forms involving skill and labour. The court recognized copyright in compilations of functional business forms where skill and labour have been expended.
Farmers' Build v Carrier Bulk Materials [1999] RPC 461 Requirement of reliance for estoppel or acquiescence to bar relief. The court found no reliance by Defendant on any representation, so no estoppel applied.
Sony Computer Entertainment v Paul Owen [2002] EMLR 34 Interpretation of "necessity" in statutory exceptions concerning database access. The court applied this test to determine whether acts were necessary for accessing and using database contents.
Harman Pictures NV v Osborne [1967] 1 WLR 723 Non-textual copying and copyright infringement of expression. Used as an example of infringement by copying expression in a different form.
Kenrick & Co. v Lawrence & Co. (1890) 25 QBD 99 Ideas not protected if they are commonplace or lack originality. The court applied the principle that banal ideas do not constitute substantial parts of copyright works.
L.B. (Plastics) Ltd v Swish Products Ltd [1979] RPC 551 Expression vs idea distinction in copyright. Referenced to support the distinction between idea and expression in software copyright.
Marleasing (Case C-106/89) [1990] ECR I-4135 Interpretation of EU directives in UK law. The court emphasized conformity with EU directives in interpreting UK copyright law.
Excise Commissioners v Century Life plc [2001] STC 38 Interpretation of EU directives in UK law. Supported the application of EU directives in UK copyright law implementation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed technical and legal analysis of the claims. It examined the nature of the OpenRes and eRes systems, focusing on the user interfaces, commands, screen displays, database structures, and the development history.

Regarding the user commands, the court concluded that individual command names and even complex commands do not qualify as literary works because they lack sufficient originality and are essentially computer languages or functional elements exempted from copyright under the Software Directive. The court rejected the claim that the command set as a compilation is entitled to copyright, finding the collection was an accretion without overall design or authorship.

The court distinguished between the source code (which enjoys copyright) and the functional effects or 'business logic' of the software. It rejected the claim that copying the functional behaviour without copying source code constitutes infringement, emphasizing the idea-expression dichotomy and the exclusion of ideas and computer languages from copyright protection.

On the user interfaces, the court found that the VT100 terminal screens, being character-based and largely functional, did not attract copyright protection, but the GUI screens, involving design and artistic elements such as icons and layout, did qualify as artistic works and were infringed by the defendants copying several icons and screen layouts.

The court found that the Plaintiff failed to prove copying of the reports, which were largely specified by third parties and involved trivial layouts, and that the defendants' code for generating reports was different.

Regarding the TakeFlight web interface, the court found that easyJet made unauthorized modifications to the Perl source code supplied, constituting breach of license and infringement. However, there was no copying of TakeFlight source code in the new internet booking system (NIBS).

In respect of the databases, the court examined the complex technical evidence and concluded that while some copying of database structures occurred—specifically the FlightFollowing table and the History table—the majority of the eRes database was independently designed. The court found that the defendants had legitimate access to OpenRes data and maintenance screens, and that database schemas and structures were often derived from screen shots, spreadsheets, and business requirements rather than direct copying of source code or metadata.

The court held that the defendants' acts in making copies of OpenRes data during migration were permissible under statutory exceptions for lawful users accessing database contents as necessary for use.

Overall, the court emphasized the need to distinguish between protectable expression and unprotectable ideas, functional elements, and computer languages, applying both UK law and relevant EU directives. It rejected claims that would extend copyright protection to functional effects or business logic absent copying of source code.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED IN PART AND ALLOWED IN PART

The court dismissed the majority of the Plaintiff's claims, holding that copyright does not subsist in the command sets or their compilation, nor in the VT100 screen displays or reports. The claim of non-textual copying (copying functional behaviour without source code access) failed. The Plaintiff succeeded only in respect of the copying of certain GUI icons and screens, unauthorized modifications to the TakeFlight source code, and limited copying of specific database tables (FlightFollowing and History).

The direct effect is that the Plaintiff is entitled to relief for unauthorized alterations to TakeFlight and for infringement of copyright in certain GUI elements and limited database structures. No broad new precedent was established, and the decision clarifies the limits of copyright protection in computer programs, particularly regarding user interfaces, command sets, and business logic.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Navitaire Inc v Easyjet Airline Co. & Anor

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Navitaire Inc v Easyjet Airline Co. & Anor
(Jul 30, 2004)