Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Attorney(S)
Judges

Turnbull v. Warrener

Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Two experienced horsewomen, referred to as Plaintiff and Defendant, were involved in an arrangement whereby Plaintiff regularly rode a horse owned by Defendant. After Defendant ceased riding due to pregnancy, Plaintiff began riding the horse with Defendant's consent. On a particular date, Plaintiff fell from the horse and sustained injuries. Plaintiff initiated proceedings against Defendant in a County Court, alleging negligence and statutory liability under section 2(2) of the Animals Act 1971. The trial judge rejected Plaintiff's negligence claim based on credibility issues and also dismissed the statutory claim, holding that Plaintiff failed to satisfy the statutory conditions and that Defendant was entitled to statutory defences under sections 5(1) and 5(2). Plaintiff appealed, challenging the application of the statutory provisions and defences.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conditions prescribed by section 2(2) of the Animals Act 1971 were satisfied in respect of damage caused by an animal not belonging to a dangerous species.
  2. Whether the statutory defence under section 5(1), excluding liability where damage is wholly due to the fault of the person suffering it, applied.
  3. Whether the defence of voluntary acceptance of risk under section 5(2) was applicable.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Plaintiff contended that the statutory conditions under section 2(2) were met, specifically disputing the trial judge’s conclusions on the likelihood and severity of damage and the presence of abnormal characteristics in the animal.
  • Plaintiff argued that the statutory defence under section 5(1) did not apply because Defendant was not free from fault.
  • Plaintiff challenged the applicability of the voluntary acceptance of risk defence under section 5(2).

Respondent's Arguments

  • Defendant maintained that the trial judge correctly found that the statutory conditions under section 2(2) were not satisfied.
  • Defendant asserted that the statutory defence under section 5(1) applied because the damage was wholly due to Plaintiff’s fault.
  • By way of a Respondent's Notice, Defendant further argued that the defence of voluntary acceptance of risk under section 5(2) should also bar the claim.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mirvahedy v Henley [2003] 2 AC 491 Interpretation of section 2(2) of the Animals Act 1971; liability for damage caused by animals not of a dangerous species. The court relied on the majority and dissenting views to analyze statutory conditions and the meaning of "likely" and "characteristics" under section 2(2).
Welsh v Stokes [2007] EWCA Civ 796 Application of section 2(2)(a) and likelihood of severe injury; voluntary acceptance of risk. Used as authority for the interpretation of "likely" and for the principle that most animal-related damage falls within statutory liability; discussed in relation to expert evidence and likelihood of injury.
Freeman v Higher Park Farm [2008] EWCA Civ 1185 Voluntary acceptance of risk under section 5(2); likelihood of severe injury. Supported the defence of voluntary acceptance of risk and the approach to likelihood of severe injury in horse-related accidents.
Goldsmith v Patchcott Interpretation and criticism of section 2(2)(b); voluntary acceptance of risk. Quoted for the limited content of section 2(2)(b) and for the success of the voluntary acceptance of risk defence.
Clark v Bowlt [2006] EWCA Civ 978 Interpretation of section 2(2)(b). Referenced in criticism of section 2(2)(b) as opaque and of limited practical effect.
Plum v Berry (Preston County Court, 2004) Voluntary acceptance of risk in horse riding accidents. Approved as illustrative of the risk inherent in riding and the acceptance thereof by competent riders.
Flack v Hudson [2001] QB 698 Limits of voluntary acceptance of risk defence. Distinguished where the rider was unaware of specific risk-creating characteristics known to the owner.
Fitzgerald v ED and AD Cooke Bourne (Farms) Ltd [1964] 1 QB 249 Common law strict liability for animals with vicious or dangerous propensities. Referenced in historical context of liability for animals with vicious propensities.
Cummings v Granger [1977] 1 QB 397 Application of scienter rule to dog attacks. Discussed as an example of cases concerning animals with dangerous propensities.
Breeden v Lampard (1985) Application of scienter rule to horse kicking. Used as authority concerning liability for damage caused by horses.
Tomlinson v Congleton BC [2004] 1 AC 46 Principles limiting liability for voluntary risks and public liberties. Quoted to emphasize policy considerations against imposing liability for voluntary risks in recreational activities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed examination of the statutory provisions of the Animals Act 1971, focusing on section 2(2) which governs liability for damage caused by animals not belonging to dangerous species, and the available defences under section 5. The court acknowledged longstanding criticism of the complex drafting of section 2(2).

Regarding section 2(2)(a), the court considered the two limbs: whether the damage was the kind the animal was likely to cause unless restrained, or whether the damage was likely to be severe if caused. The trial judge had rejected the likelihood of severe injury based on expert cross-examination suggesting such injuries were statistically unlikely. The appellate court found this conclusion flawed, emphasizing that "likely" means "reasonably to be expected" and that the judge had not applied this test correctly.

On section 2(2)(b), the court noted the provision's opacity and judicial criticism. The trial judge had failed to consider whether the horse’s failure to respond to the bitless bridle was a characteristic normally found in horses unfamiliar with such equipment. The appellate court found this omission significant and concluded the judge’s finding on this point could not stand.

For section 2(2)(c), the court questioned the trial judge’s finding that Defendant lacked knowledge of the relevant characteristic. Evidence showed Defendant was aware of the risks inherent in new tack and the need for cautious introduction, supporting knowledge of the characteristic in question.

Turning to statutory defences, the court rejected the trial judge’s finding under section 5(1) that the damage was wholly due to Plaintiff's fault, reasoning that if Plaintiff was wholly at fault, Defendant could not simultaneously be found not negligent; thus, the defence could not succeed.

However, the court upheld the defence of voluntary acceptance of risk under section 5(2), finding that Plaintiff, an experienced rider, knowingly accepted the risk of injury in riding the horse with new equipment in untested conditions. This defence was supported by the equivalence of knowledge and experience between the parties and relevant case law.

The concurring judges expressed concerns about the broad interpretation of section 2(2) liability extending to ordinary riding accidents, which was arguably not Parliament’s intention. They also emphasized the complexity and practical difficulties of applying the statutory provisions, particularly section 2(2)(b).

Holding and Implications

The court's final decision was to DISMISS THE APPEAL, thereby affirming the trial court’s dismissal of Plaintiff’s claim.

The direct effect is that Plaintiff’s claim against Defendant for injuries sustained while riding the horse using a bitless bridle fails. The decision confirms the applicability of the voluntary acceptance of risk defence under section 5(2) in similar circumstances involving experienced riders and known risks. The opinion highlights ongoing difficulties and judicial dissatisfaction with the drafting and application of section 2(2) of the Animals Act 1971 but does not establish new precedent altering its interpretation.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

Turnbull v Warrener

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Justice Licence v1.0.

Use AI to get other relevant cases.

Comments

Turnbull v Warrener
(Apr 3, 2012)