ORDER
Per: Justice Anand Pathak The present Writ Appeal under Section 2 (1) of The Madhya Pradesh Uchcha Nyayalaya (Khand Nyaypeeth Ko Appeal) Adhiniyam, 2005 is preferred by the appellant being aggrieved by the order dated 07.07.2026 passed by the learned Writ Court in W.P. No.4750/2026, whereby the petition filed by the appellant as petitioner was disposed of with certain directions.
1
2. Precisely stated facts of the case are that appellant is an Education Officer having entered Government service in the year 1988. He has clean and unblemished track record. On 04.10.2023, appellant was posted as In- charge District Education Officer, Niwari. During his posting, serious complaints regarding large scale financial irregularities and embezzlement involving officers of the Education Department came to light. Pursuant to directions issued by the competent authorities, appellant conducted enquiry and submitted report exposing misappropriation of Government funds running into more than Rs. 16 crores.
3. Acting upon such report, proceedings before the Lokayukt, departmental enquiries and further investigation by the Economic Offences Wing were initiated. Since appellant unearthed the scam of absorption of private school into government fold, he was a material witness and later on became Presenting Officer in departmental proceeding against erring officers, including present respondent no.6. Since he exposed corruption, displeasure of respondent no.5 and other officials (who came under scrutiny) thereby prompted removal of petitioner from the post of D.E.O., Niwari.
4. Earlier transfer order dated 24.12.2024 was successfully challenged and ultimately withdrawn by the Government. Soon thereafter another transfer order dated 29.01.2026, within a short span of time in identical circumstances, was issued for displacement of petitioner. Therefore, petitioner preferred Writ Petition No. 4750/2026 before this Court in which interim order was passed.
5. During the pendency of writ petition, appellant brought certain
2
documents on record including communications dated 17.02.2026, 11.03.2026 and 22.06.2026 as well as documents established that the investigations continued and respondent no.6 failed to act in accordance with departmental directions. Vide impugned order dated 11.02.2026, appellant resumed the charge in compliance with the judicial directions and respondent no.6 was relieved from officiating charge. Said order was challenged by respondent no.6 by filing Writ Appeal No. 628/2026 before a Division Bench but the Division Bench passed a reasoned order dated 18.03.2026 dismissing the appeal while affirming the interim order passed in favour of appellant by learned Single Judge.
6. As submitted, Division Bench observed that respondent no.6 should not be permitted to claim any vested interest on the post of In-charge District Education Officer merely because he was approaching retirement. However, impugned order dated 07.07.2026 was passed and petition preferred by appellant as petitioner got dismissed. Therefore, appellant is before this Court.
7. It is the submission of learned senior counsel for appellant that learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petition solely on the premise that appellant had completed his tenure and had no vested right to continue as In-charge District Education Officer, without adjudicating the principal issues of mala fides, colourable exercise of power and absence of administrative necessity to transfer appellant. It is also submitted that appellant unearthed the big scam in which a private school was absorbed in the Government fold and, as per allegations, certain
3
correspondence/communications of different offices of State Government are being fabricated by vested interest.
8. On such serious allegations, departmental enquiries are conducted against erring officers and a police case has also been registered. In Departmental Enquiry, appellant is working as Presenting Officer, therefore, till enquiry is completed the appellant be permitted to work at Niwari so that he may not put to inconvenience and at the same time, he preserves the record.
9. Counsel for respondents/State opposed the contentions raised by appellant and submits that investigation is going on and Departmental Enquiry is under-way. All erring officers be suitably punished, if they were found guilty. Due to administrative exigency, appellant is posted at transferred place of posting.
10. Counsel for respondent no.5 opposed the contentions raised by appellant and submits that present respondent no.6 Devidayal Dubey is going to retire on 31.07.2026, therefore, he seeks only a week's time to be retained on the post of D.E.O., Niwari, so that he can retire peacefully. In support of his contentions, learned counsel for respondent no.5 has place reliance on the decisions of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the cases of State of M.P. & Another Vs. S.S. Kourav & Others, (1995) 3 SCC 270 and Shilpi Bose (Mrs.) & Others vs. State of Bihar & Others, 1991 Supp(2) SCC 659.
11. Learned senior counsel for respondent no. 6 opposed the contentions raised by appellant and submits that investigation is going on. No case for interference is made out. He prayed for dismissal of appeal.
4
12. Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the impugned order and other documents available on record.
13. This is a case, wherein appellant was working as In-charge District Education Officer at relevant point of time. On 04.10.2023, he unearthed the alleged scam of absorption wherein serious allegations were levelled, pursuant for which, he was removed from the said post. Law in respect of transfer is well settled.
14. Transfer is an incident of service. No one much less petitioner has any vested right to be posted at a particular place of posting. It is well settled in law that employer is the best judge to organize its work force and it is also well settled in law that a transfer order cannot be subjected to judicial review unless and until same is found to be influenced by mala fide or arbitrary exercise of powers. Concept of equality as enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of Constitution of India, has no application to the case of transfer.
15. However, instant case bears peculiar facts and circumstances, in which plea of malice/mala fides (especially malice in law) is apparently visible. Once, transfer order dated 24.12.2024 was successfully challenged by appellant in writ petition and the said transfer order was ultimately withdrawn by State Government, hence, in a short span, issuance of another transfer order on 29.01.2026 does not evoke credence and confidence. If the appellant made complaints against financial irregularities, including fabrication of certain communications made by State Government, then seriousness of the case is amplified. Therefore, it was the duty of the competent authorities at the helm to take care of such complaints and to
5
investigate and inquire the matter further. However, they did not.
16. Be that as it may.
17. Appellant is appointed as Presenting Officer in the Departmental Enquiry and therefore, he has to present the case and keep the record intact and clean so that real facts may come to the fore in Departmental Enquiry. Not only this, earlier respondent no.5 unsuccessfully made an attempt to get the impugned order vacated. Certain observations made by the then Division Bench also reflects the same over the state of affairs.
18. It is equally true that, in normal circumstances, scope of interference is restricted by different pronouncements of Apex Court but, at the same time, exceptions carved out regarding interference on the point of violation of statutory rules or mala fides are apparent on record. Here, it appears that respondents, on account of some vested interest, want to remove appellant from the post of District Education Officer, Niwari, to affect the Departmental Enquiry and investigation.
19. Therefore, in the conspectus of facts and circumstances of case, this Court intends to allow the appeal for a limited purpose. Impugned order stands modified to the extent that respondent no. 6 shall continue to work till 31.07.2026 and shall superannuate from his present place of posting, i.e. D.E.O., Niwari. Immediately thereafter from 01.08.2026, appellant shall resume the post of In-charge D.E.O., Niwari, for next four months so that Departmental Enquiry, in which appellant is Presenting officer be concluded without delay and the report be submitted to the Enquiry Officer. It is made clear that all parties shall have to cooperate in the Departmental Enquiry and
6
(ANAND PATHAK)
JUDGE
(VINAY SARAF)
JUDGE
shall have to conclude the Departmental Enquiry positively within four months.
20. After conclusion of Enquiry, respondents/State shall be at liberty either to continue the appellant as In-charge D.E.O., Niwari or may post him as per administrative exigency to any other place wherever respondents want appellant to perform duty. It is also made clear that if Departmental Enquiry is not concluded within four months' then only two months time shall be given as a grace period for conclusion of enquiry. Respondents may take appropriate steps for day-to-day or week- to-week hearing of departmental enquiry.
21. With the aforesaid modification in impugned order, appeal stands partly allowed and disposed of. Impugned order is modified to this extent. skt
7