AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 2(II) of Consumer Protection Act 2019. Simple
  • Consumer Protection Act. Government Hospital
  • section 34 of Kerala
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • section 2(II) of Consumer Protection Act 2019. Simple
  • Consumer Protection Act. Government Hospital
  • section 34 of Kerala
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    FAISAL P K S/o. C M POCKER HAJI v. DR KEBY BASHEER B S/o. BASHEERUDHEEN LABBA

    1

    DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION,

    KASARAGOD

    (Present: Sri. Krishnan K, President Smt. Beena K G, Member)

    Date of filing: 09/04/2025

    Date of Order:30/03/2026 IA. 324/2025 In CC.No.149/2025

    Faisal.P.K S/o C.M. Pocker Haji, Chathangai House, Chembarika, Complainant Chandragiri Post,

    Kasaragod Dist

    Vs

    Dr. Keby Basheer. B,

    Reg.No. 45454 PEN. 946575

    Kalanad FHC/PHC, Kainoth Opposite Party Kalanad Post - 671317

    Kasaragod.

    (Adv: A.Amith & Ganaraja.K)

    ORDER

    By SRI. KRISHNAN K, PRESIDENT

    IA 324/2025 is filed by petitioner/opposite party to hear the issue of maintainability of the complaint.

    2

    Facts of the case is short is that he has been running a friendly help centre for eighteen year in Kalanad village. He went to the clinic where opposite party is working as a doctor in Kalanad for treatment for his two children on 22/08/2024 at 8.45 Am; even after 9 am, two doctors did not report for duty. He contacted District Medical Officer and sent a complaint via mobile phone. Duty doctor came and took exception for calling him and raising the complaint. Petitioner is investigated them personally inimical with him. The complainant seeking compensation for deficiency in service. The Opposite party appeared and filed written version denying the averments in the complaint. Mainly contended that consumer complaint is not maintainable in view of section 34 of Kerala health care service centre persons and health service institution prevention of damage to property act amendment act 2023. Heard both parties.

    Points for consideration:

    a) Whether there is a consumer dispute and case is maintainable in law?

    The opposite party says he is a doctor by profession working under government salary. It is a government hospital. Hospital is not made a party. There is no consumer dispute to be decided by Commission. Crime No 401/24 of Melparamba Police is pending against the complainant and the present complaint is filed as a vengeance.

    Medical service fall within "service" under Consumer Protection Act. Government Hospital provides treatment totally free, a consumer complaint is not maintainable against government hospitals.

    3

    Medical negligence or deficiency in service must be based on clear professional negligence, not personal grievance. But there is no allegation of medical negligence or unproper treatment.

    Consumer jurisdiction requires deficiency in service under section 2(II) of Consumer Protection Act 2019. Simple behavioural dispute with a doctor may not amount to consumer deficiency.

    In the absence of a consumer dispute and deficiency in service, complaint is not maintainable before this Commission.

    A medical professional may be held liable for negligence only when they are not equipped with the requisite qualification or skill or when they fail to exercise reasonable skill in administrating treatment. A doctor can only be held liable if their actions demonstrated a deviation from accepted medical standards due to either lack of skill or failure to apply the skill they possess.

    No such allegations in the complaint. Hence no cause of action or Consumer Dispute in this case, it is held that complaint is not maintainable. In the result complaint is rejected as not maintainable.

    (Dictated to the Confidential Assistant Smt. Praseetha. K.V transcribed and typed by her, corrected by me and pronounced in the open Commission on the 30thday of March

    2026).

    Sd/- Sd/- Beena.K.G, MEMBER Krishnan.K, PRESIDENT Forwarded by Order

    Assistant Registrar

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    FAISAL P K S/o. C M POCKER HAJI v. DR KEBY BASHEER B S/o. BASHEERUDHEEN LABBA
    (Mar 30, 2026)