ORDER
STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION,
HARYANA, PANCHKULA
First Appeal No.590 of 2023 Date of Institution:30.05.2023
Date of Order:13.01.2025 The Managing Director, Car Dekho.Com, 11thFloor, Tower-B, EMAAR Digital Greens, Golf Course Ext., Road, Sector-61,Gurugram, Haryana-122102.
1
…..Appellant Versus
Anil Kumar Datta R/o 943-A, Sector-7, Panchkula, Haryana 134109. ..…Respondent
CORAM: Hon'ble Mr. Justice T.P.S Mann, President. Mr.S.P.Sood, Judicial Member
Mrs.Manjula, Member
Present:- Shri Rahul Makkar, counselfor the appellant. Ms. Amresh Datta, authorized representative of respondent- complainant-Shri Anil Kumar Datta.
O R D E R
T.P.S. MANN J.
Delay of 226days in filing the appeal is condoned for the reasons stated in the application for condonation of delay.
2. Appellant-Opposite Party (OP),has filed the instant appeal under Section 41 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 for challenging the order dated 31.08.2022 passed by learned District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission,Panchkula whereby complaint filed by complainant/respondent herein Shri Anil Kumar Dattawas partly allowed with directions:
"As a sequel to the above discussion, we partly allow the present complaint with the following directions to the OP:-
2
(i) The OP is directed to make the payment of Rs.62,600/- (Rs.6000+21600+35000/-) as paid by the complainant and his friend alongwith interest @ 9% per annum w.e.f. the date of filing of the complaint till its realization.
(ii) The OP is directed to make the payment of Rs.10,000/- to the complainant on account of mental agony and physical harassment suffered by the complainant.
(iii) The OP is further directed to make the payment of Rs.15,000/- as punitive damages to the complainant. Since, the fraudster had succeeded in causing the wrongful loss to the complainant of the sum of Rs.62,600/- only because of the utter negligence and deficient services of the OP.
(iv) The OP is further directed to pay Rs.2500/- on account of litigation charges.
(v) As mentioned above the OP has been found lacking a proper and robust dynamic checking mechanism due to which the fraudster succeeded in getting registration on its website. Therefore, it is imperative to direct the OP to adopt and put in place a sound and dynamic checking mechanism system so as to prevent the entry of fraudster on its website. It is so necessary to prevent the repetition of such foul practice by the fraudster."
3. The brief facts of the case as set out in the complaint are that complainant- Anil Kumar Dattastarted visiting the site cardekho.com for the purchase of a used car. On 20.12.2020, the complainant selected the car with description as Maruti Suzuki Swift, 2015 Model, having 30000 Km old with Chandigarh registration (CH01BC9554). On contacting the verified seller, who claimed to be an army personnel named Lakhwinder Singh,took them into confidence by offering a test
3
drive. The deal was settled at Rs.2,10,000/- and Rs.6000/- was paid to Sh.Lakwinder Singh for booking charges on 21.12.2020 through UPI and within next 20 minutes, he asked for Rs.21,600/- as GST and transport charges which were again paid by him into his UPI Account. On 23.12.2020, Sh.Lakwinder Singh demanded for Rs.30,000/- more amount, who refused to pay because he sensed foul play. The complainant cancelled the deal and asked him to refund the amount paid. The complainant gave a/c of his friend to receive money as the complainant did not have a google linked a/c. He first deposited an amount of Rs.500/- into his friend account and then sent a QR code for scanning and entered his PIN, to see that his friend account was deposited for an amount of Rs.35,000/-. He again tried to withdraw more money but failed due to insufficient funds. Complainant's friend registered a complaint with the bank within one hour of being defrauded but they showed their inability to retrieve money as the fraudster had transferred the amount to a different account. The complainant lodged the complaint on 27thDecember through online mode. The complainant also lodged a complaint-cum-notice with the cardekho.com on 03.01.2021 through mail, which was replied by the OP on 04.01.2021 and OP totally denied to take any responsibility. The complainant received a call from fraudster again on 04.01.2021 to give him account number for depositing the refund to which complainant refused and number was forwarded to the police station. The complainant requested the OP to pay Rs.62,600/-, but, to of no avail. Thus there was unfair trade practices on the part of the OP.
4. OP was proceeded against ex parte vide order dated 10.11.2021.
5. After hearing counsel for the complainant, learned District Consumer Disputes
4
Redressal Commission, Panchkula, partly allowed the complaint vide impugned order dated 31.08.2022 and relevant portion of the order is mentioned in para No.2 of the order.
6. Feeling aggrieved therefrom, OP-appellant has preferred this appeal for setting aside the impugned order.
7. We have heard learned counsel for the appellant as well as learned counsel for the respondent. With their kind assistance the entire record of appeal as well as the record of the District Consumer Commission wasthoroughly perused andexamined.
8. Learned counsel for the appellant has assailed the impugned order dated 31.08.2022 being erroneous on all fronts. Learned District Consumer Commissionhas not analyzed legal and factual aspects in proper perspectives. Learned counsel for the appellant has further argued that the appellant i.e. cardekho.com is an e-platform developed by the Girnar Software Private Limited that helps users buy cars that are right for them. Its website and app carry rich automotive content such as expert reviews, detailed specs and prices, comparisons as well as videos and pictures of all car brands and models available in India. The Company has tie-ups with many auto manufacturers, more than 4000 car dealers and numerous financial institutions to facilitate the purchase of vehicles. The counsel for the appellant further argued that the appellant never received any notice at any relevant point of time from the District consumer Commission in the complaint case bearing No.CC/50/2021. The terms and conditions displayed on the website of the appellant recommend its users to read these terms of use carefully before using
5
or registering on the website or listing any item, accessing any material, information or services, posting any advertisement/information at or through the website and if there was any disagreement with the terms of use, then not to use the website. The complainant who failed in carrying out due diligence at the time of making payment to the seller directly without any physical verification of the vehicle as well as its documents. The complainant wrongly alleged that the seller was verified seller in his complaint. No such category with respect to verified seller was available on the website of the appellant. There was no role/privity of the appellant to monitor the transaction or to access any transaction in random. The complainant was not entitled for any relief as prayed for.
9. Refuting the contentions, learned counsel for respondent /complainant has urged that impugned order dated 31.08.2022passed by learned District Consumer Commission is legally justified on given facts and evidence, warranting no interference in appeal. Counsel for the complainant-respondent argued that online fraud of Rs.62600/- has been committed in the site of OP i.e. Cardekho.com and hence, the complainant-respondent was entitled for the amount as prayed for.
10. It is not disputed that on 20.12.2020, the complainant selected the car with description as Maruti Suzuki Swift, 2015 Model, having 30000 Km old with Chandigarh registration (CH01BC9554) in the OP site i.e. Cardekho.com. It is also not disputed that the deal was settled at Rs.2,10,000/- and Rs.6000/- was paid to Sh.Lakwinder Singh for booking charges on 21.12.2020 through UPI. It is also not disputed that the complainant paid Rs.62,000/- to Sh.Lakhwinder Singh (fraudster). Perusal of the documents placed on the file shows that the online fraud of
6
Rs.62,600/- has been committed in the site of OP i.e. Cardekho.com. To prove the online fraud against complainant-respondent, he placed on record online Receipt of Rs.6000/- Annexure C-2, Rs.21600/- Annexure C-3 and Rs.35,000/- Annexure C-4, which were paid to India Fighting, Mrsuhail Ahmed and Lilu Ram Foji respectively. The transactions were made for the purchase of a car (
https://www.cardekho.com/used-car-details/used-Maruti-Swift-2004-2011-VDI-BSIV- cars Chandigarh_22BA413 C2B72995A260CD 5F93AF3FF6F,htm), which was identified from the cardekho.com. It means that the fraudster registered on the website of the OP. It is also admitted that the OP has immediately removed the advertisement posted by the seller in order to save other buyers from fraudster.It also shows that the appellant company did not prevent the misleading advertisements. It is the prime responsibility of the OP to delete the misleading advertisement in the site and stop the unlawful contents ofits site. The learned District Consumer Commissionhas rightly partly allowed the complaint of the complainant. The State Consumer Commission finds no reason or ground to interfere with the order of learned District Consumer Commission. Hence the appeal being devoid of merit stands dismissed.
11. Statutory amount of Rs.46,000/- was deposited by the appellant at the time of filing of this appeal. This amount is now ordered to be reimbursed to the complainant-Mr.Anil Kumar Dattaagainst proper receipt, identification and verification as per rules and registry of this Commission is accordingly directed.
12. Application(s) pending, if any stand disposed of in terms of the aforesaid judgment.
7
13. A copy of this judgment be provided to all the parties free of cost as mandated by the Consumer Protection Act. The judgment be uploaded forthwith on the website of the Commission for perusal of the parties.
14. File be consigned to record room.
13th January, 2025 Manjula, S.P.Sood T.P. S. Mann Member Judicial Member President
S.K(Pvt. Secy.)
..................J
T P S MANN
PRESIDENT
..................J
S . P . SOOD
JUDICIAL MEMBER
..................J
MANJULA
MEMBER
8