Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 21 Rule 64 of CPC.
  • Section Officer, VR Section Madras High Court N. SATHISH KUMAR, J. Page 7 of 8 dhk C.R.P.No.59 of 2025 05.06.2025 Page 8 of 8
  • Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order 21 Rule 64 of CPC.
  • Section Officer, VR Section Madras High Court N. SATHISH KUMAR, J. Page 7 of 8 dhk C.R.P.No.59 of 2025 05.06.2025 Page 8 of 8
  • Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
Smart Summary

Case Summary: C.R.P.No.59 of 2025 (Madras High Court, N. Sathish Kumar, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The original suit (O.S.No.353 of 2004) was filed by a sole plaintiff for recovery of mortgage money. A preliminary decree was passed on 12.01.2007 and, as the decretal amount remained unpaid, a final decree was passed on 08.06.2016 in I.A.No.1372 of 2007. Execution proceedings were instituted by the plaintiff's legal heirs in R.E.P.No.132 of 2019. The executing court recognised the legal heirs (by an application under Section 50 CPC). The petitioners challenged the execution on the grounds that the final decree was passed after the plaintiff's death (the plaintiff died on 27.10.2015), that the decree in favour of a dead person is invalid, that the respondents failed to prove their status as legal heirs, and that the legal heirs were impleaded citing incorrect provisions. The executing court dismissed an application filed under Section 47 CPC; the present Civil Revision Petition under Section 115 CPC challenges that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a decree passed in favour of a person who had died before the date of the decree is a nullity and therefore unenforceable.
  2. Whether impleading legal heirs citing an incorrect provision (e.g., Section 50 CPC) vitiates execution proceedings or divests the legal heirs of the right to pursue execution.
  3. Whether the attachment/sale of property whose market value significantly exceeds the decretal amount is impermissible or requires specific treatment by the executing court.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The final decree (08.06.2016) was passed after the death of the plaintiff (27.10.2015) and therefore cannot be enforced because a decree in favour of a dead person is invalid.
  • The respondents (legal heirs) were impleaded without any formal petition, and incorrect statutory provisions were cited when bringing them on record.
  • The decretal amount sought (Rs.27,50,000) is much less than the value of the property proposed for attachment (about Rs.50 lakhs), which the petitioners contend is impermissible.

Respondents' / Executing Court's Position

  • The executing respondent filed a counter and the executing court held that merely quoting incorrect provisions of law when impleading legal heirs does not vitiate proceedings; such defects are curable at any time.
  • The executing court (and the Trial Court) relied on precedent to hold that a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not a nullity; consequently the final decree is not invalid solely because it was passed after the plaintiff's death.
  • As to the disproportion between property value and decretal amount, the executing court noted that such pleas are to be raised before the executing court, which will follow Order 21 Rule 64 CPC in deciding sale of property (entire property or portion thereof as necessary).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
B.K. Basha v. Mohamed Ali and others, CRP.(NPD).No.771 of 2014 (MP.Nos.1 & 2 of 2014) dated 14.02.2018 Authority for the proposition that a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not a nullity. The Trial Court relied on this decision to hold that the final decree passed after the plaintiff's death was not a nullity.
Abdul Azeez Sahib v. Dhanabagiammal and others, 1981 SCC OnLine Mad 254 Holds that generally a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not a nullity; a decree against a dead person can be a nullity; executing court is not entitled to refuse execution solely because the plaintiff was not alive when the decree was passed. The High Court referred to and quoted this decision to reject the contention that the decree in favour of the deceased plaintiff was void.
Himangshu Bhusan Kar v. Manindra Mohan Baha, AIR 1954 Cal 205 One of the precedents cited for the principle that a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not a nullity. Referred to within Abdul Azeez Sahib; treated as supporting authority for the non-nullity principle relied upon by the court.
Raddulal Bhurmal v. Mahabirprasad Bisesar Kalwar, AIR 1959 Bom 384 Another precedent cited for the same principle that a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not a nullity. Referred to within Abdul Azeez Sahib and relied upon as part of the body of authority supporting the court's conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed the contesting contentions in sequence:

  1. On the contention that a decree in favour of a dead person is a nullity, the Court held that such contention has no force. The Court explained the established principle (as repeatedly held by this Court and in Abdul Azeez Sahib) that while a decree against a dead person can be a nullity, a decree passed in favour of a dead person is generally not a nullity; where a decree was made in ignorance of death it may be wrong but must be set aside by appropriate proceedings (appeal, revision or review) and is not automatically void for execution purposes. The Trial Court had already applied this principle and the High Court found no error in that approach.
  2. On the submission that legal heirs were impleaded citing the incorrect provision (Section 50 CPC) and without formal petition, the Court held that merely quoting the wrong provision does not take away the rights of legal heirs to pursue execution; such defect is curable and does not vitiate the proceedings.
  3. Regarding the contention about attaching a property worth much more than the decretal amount, the Court observed that this is a matter to be raised before and considered by the executing court. The Court noted that the executing court will normally follow the procedure under Order 21 Rule 64 CPC and may sell the entire property or a portion thereof as necessary to satisfy the decree. If the petitioner can show that the property's value exceeds the decretal amount, the executing court must consider that and pass appropriate orders under the cited provision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. (The Court stated: "I do not find any merits in this revision and the same stands dismissed. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition stands closed.")

Implications:

  • The executing court's order dismissing the Section 47 application is upheld.
  • No costs were awarded. The connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
  • The decision applies established authority that a decree passed in favour of a deceased person is not, by virtue only of the deceased status, automatically a nullity for execution purposes; challenges remain available by appropriate remedy but do not prevent execution per se. The opinion contains no indication that it creates a new legal principle or expands precedent beyond the authorities it cites; its direct effect is to uphold the executing court's order in this matter.

Decision delivered on: 05.06.2025. Judge: N. Sathish Kumar, J.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    K.RAJAMANICKAM v. P.M.KANAGASABAPATHY (DIED) 1. K.Muthusamy

    CRP.No.59 of 2025

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

    DATED : 05.06.2025

    CORAM:

    THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR

    C.R.P.No.59 of 2025

    and

    C.M.P.No.564 of 2025

    1.K.Rajamanickam 2.R.Kavitha .. Petitioners

    Versus

    P.M.Kanagasabapathy (Died) 1.K.Muthusamy

    2.P.K.Sengottu Velu 3.K.Chandrasekaran 4.K.Muthulakshmi .. Respondents

    Prayer:- Civil Revision Petition filed under Section 115 of Code of Civil Procedure to set aside the fair and decretal order dated 04.10.2024 made in R.E.A.No.5 of 2023 in REP.No.132 of 2019 in O.S.No.353 of 2004 on the file of the II Additional District Judge, Salem.

    For Petitioners : Mr.B.Manimaran

    For Respondents : Mr.K.Sivasubramanian

    for Mr.T.M.Hariharan

    Page 1 of 8

    ORDER

    Challenge has been made to the order passed by the Executing Court dismissing the application filed under Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the present revision has been filed.

    2. The suit has been filed originally by the sole plaintiff as against the defendant in O.S.No.353 of 2004 for recovery of mortgage money. A preliminary decree was passed on 12.01.2007. As the amount has not been piad as directed in the preliminary decree, final decree has been passed on 08.06.2016 in I.A.No.1372 of 2007. To execute the said decree, execution petition has been filed by the legal heirs in R.E.P.No.132 of 2019. The decree has been challenged only on the ground that during the pendency of the final decree proceedings, the plaintiff has died on 27.10.2015, however, the final decree has been passed on 08.06.2016. Therefore, according to the plaintiff decree passed in favour of a dead person is not valid in the eye of law. Further, the respondents have not filed any documents to prove that they are the legal heirs of the deceased plaintiff. An application has been filed by the legal heirs under Section 50 of CPC and they have been recognised by the executing court which is not in accordance with law.

    Page 2 of 8

    3. The said application has been opposed by the respondent by filing counter. The executing court clearly found that merely quoting wrong provisions of law in bringing the legal heirs will not vitiate the proceedings, the defects is curable and can be cured at any time. As far as the submission that decree in favour of the plaintiff is concerned, the Trial Court has clearly held that decree in favour of a dead person is not nullity as held by B.K.Basha vs. Mohamed Ali and others made in CRP.(NPD).No.771 of 2014 in MP.Nos.1 & 2 of 2014 dated 14.02.2018. Challenging the said order, the present revision has been filed.

    4. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the decree cannot be enforced, since the final decree has been passed after the death of the plaintiff. Similarly, legal heirs have been impleaded without any formal petition and wrong provision has been quoted. Further, it is his contention that the amount sought to be recovered is only Rs.27,50,000/-, whereas, the property sought for attachment is worth about Rs.50 lakhs which is impermissible in the law. Hence, seeks for allowing this revision.

    5. Heard both sides and perused the materials placed on record.

    Page 3 of 8

    6. As far as the first contention that the decree in favour of a dead person is nullity is concerned, such contention has no force for the simple reason that decree against a dead person is construed as nullity and a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not construed as nullity. This proposition has been repeatedly held by this Court time and again. In fact, the Trial Court has also considered the same aspect. Therefore, the contention of the learned counsel in this regard is negated. In this regard, it is useful to refer to an order of this Court in the case of Abdul Azeez Sahib

    v. Dhanabagiammal and others reported in 1981 SCC OnLine Mad 254 , wherein, it is held as follows:

    " 3. The learned counsel for the petitioner relying on the two decisions reported in Himangshu Bhusan Kar v. Manindra Mohan Baha, AIR 1954 Cal 205 and Raddulal Bhurmal v. Mahabirprasad Bisesar Kalwar, AIR 1959 Bom 384, contended that a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not a nullity, and the fact of death not brought to the notice of the Court when it passed the decree is only an irregularity and it cannot have the effect of making the decree void ab initio and the decree is executable. Where the Court proceeds with the case in ignorance of the fact of death of a person and passes a decree, that decree cannot be treated as a nullity. It may, no doubt, be a wrong decree, but it will have to be set aside by taking appropriate proceedings like appeal, revision or review. Generally speaking, a decree passed in favour of a dead person is not a nullity, though a

    Page 4 of 8

    decree passed against a dead person can be construed as a nullity. Even if there is abatement of the suit, that would not make the decree passed in the suit as one without jurisdiction and the executing Court is not entitled to refuse to execute the decree on the ground that the plaintiff was not alive on the date when the decree was passed in his favour."

    Emphasis supplied

    7. Second submission that legal heirs have been impleaded under Section 50 of CPC and it relates to the only judgment debtors not to the decree holders is concerned, this Court is of the view that mere quoting wrong provisions will not take away the rights of the legal heirs of the deceased decree holder to pursue the execution petition. Such contention cannot have force in the eye of law. The other submission that the property sought to be attached is worth about Rs.50 lakhs and the money sought to be recovered is only Rs.27 lakhs is concerned, it is relevant to note that such a plea has to be pleaded only before the Executing Court. Executing Court normally follow the procedure under Order 21 Rule 64 of CPC while selling the property. Further, the Executing Court shall sell the entire property or only a portion of it, as deemed necessary to satisfy the decree. If the petitioner is able to show that the property worth is more than the decretal amount than the value of the amount sought to be recovered, the

    Page 5 of 8

    Executing Court will definitely consider the same and pass appropriate order as contemplated under Order 21 Rule 64 of CPC.

    8. In view of the above, I do not find any merits in this revision and the same stands dismissed. No costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition stands closed.

    05.06.2025

    dhk Internet : Yes Index : Yes/No Speaking order / Nonspeaking order Neutral Citation : Yes/No

    Page 6 of 8

    To

    1. The II Additional District Judge, Salem

    2. The Section Officer, VR Section Madras High Court

    N. SATHISH KUMAR, J.

    Page 7 of 8

    dhk

    C.R.P.No.59 of 2025

    05.06.2025

    Page 8 of 8

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.RAJAMANICKAM v. P.M.KANAGASABAPATHY (DIED) 1. K.Muthusamy
    (Jun 5, 2025)