AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 22-E
  • Services Authorities Act, 1987 by Amending Act 37 of 2002
  • Services Authorities Act, 1987 (in short "the Act, 1987")
  • sub- section (2) of Section 22-C,
  • Section 22-E(1)
  • Sub- section (4) of Section 22-E
  • sub- section (1) of Section 22-C
  • Section 22-C(8),
  • Order 9 Rule 13 of the CPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 22-E
  • Services Authorities Act, 1987 by Amending Act 37 of 2002
  • Services Authorities Act, 1987 (in short "the Act, 1987")
  • sub- section (2) of Section 22-C,
  • Section 22-E(1)
  • Sub- section (4) of Section 22-E
  • sub- section (1) of Section 22-C
  • Section 22-C(8),
  • Order 9 Rule 13 of the CPC
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    BRANCH MANAGER, SHRIRAM TRANSPORT FINANCE COMPNAY LTD., v. ANIL KUMAR KOMRA

    1 / 7

    2024:CGHC:46244

    NAFR

    HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR

    WP227 No. 937 of 2019

    1 - Branch Manager, Shriram Transport Finance Company Ltd., Above H D F C Bank Lattipara Kanker, District North Bastar Kanker Chhattisgarh

    2 - Manager, Shriram Transport Finance Company Ltd., Kota Near Maruti Heights Raipur, Chhattisgarh.

    3 - Manager, Shriram Transport Finance Company Ltd., Branch Office M M Tower Above Axis Bank, Akashvani Road Jagdalpur, District - Bastar Chhattisgarh.

    4 - Branch Manager, Shriram Transport Finance Company Ltd., Above Axis Bank, Akashwani Road, Jagdalpur, District Bastar (C.G. ) Through Shri Santosh Kumar Khan. ( Note - Petitioner No. 1, 2 And 3 ( Mainly Named As Shriram Equipment Finance Company Ltd. ) has been amalgamated with Shriram Transport Finance Company Ltd., vide Scheme of amalgamation Dated 31.03.2016)

    ... Petitioners versus

    1 - Anil Kumar Komra S/o Dayaram Komra, Aged About 35 Years, Caste Gada, R/o Village Tumsanar, Police Station - Amaboda, Tahsil Antagarh, District - North Bastar Kanker Chhattisgarh

    ... Respondents

    For Petitioners : Mr. Anumeh Shrivastava, Advocate For Respondent : Mr. Parag Kotecha, Advocate

    1

    SB.: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Deepak Kumar Tiwari O rder on Board

    26/11/2024

    1. This petition has been filed by the petitioners assailing the order dated 17.5.2018 passed by the Permanent Lok Adalat (PLA), Public Utility Service, Bastar at Jagdalpur in Case No.22/2017 on the ground that the aforesaid order has been passed without jurisdiction.

    2. Necessary facts of the case, in brief, are that the respondent financed a JCB vehicle from the Petitioner-Company and made certain defaults in making payment of installments. As per the terms of the agreement, the Finance Company took possession of the vehicle, against which, the respondent filed an application before the Permanent Lok Adalat for returning the said vehicle. Consequently, the impugned award has been passed.

    3. Learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that the Permanent Lok Adalat (Public Utility Services) constituted under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (in short "the Act, 1987") acted dehors the jurisdiction. He further submits that the similar issue came up before this Court in WP227 No.509 of 2013 (United Insurance Company Ltd. and another Vs. Ashok Lunia and another) {order dated 14.11.2018}, in which, it was observed that the PLA (PUS) has entertained the dispute, which is highly disputed question of facts and law and the same cannot be adjudicated under Section 22C(8) of the Act, 1987 .

    4. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent would support the

    2

    impugned order. He submits that the petitioners have already availed the alternative remedy by filing an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the CPC challenging the said award, which is still pending consideration (as per clause 8.8. of the petition). Further, the petitioners have also participated in the aforesaid proceeding. Hence, he prays for dismissal of the petition.

    5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused the documents annexed with the petition.

    6. Chapter VI-A, which is titled as Pre-Litigation Conciliation and Settlement, was inserted in the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 by Amending Act 37 of 2002 with effect from 11-6-2002 under which Permanent Lok Adalat is to be constituted under Section 22-B of the Act of 1987. The Permanent Lok Adalats shall have jurisdiction in respect of one or more public utility services and for such areas as may be specified in the notification. "Public utility service" is defined in Section 22-A(b) of the Act of 1987 which states as under: -

    "22A(b)"public utility service" means any--

    (i) transport service for the carriage of passengers or goods by air, road or water; or

    (ii) postal, telegraph or telephone service; or

    (iii) supply of power, light or water to the public by any establishment; or

    (iv) system of public conservancy or sanitation; or

    (v) service in hospital or dispensary; or

    (vi) insurance service, and includes any service which the Central Government or the State Government, as the case may be, may, in the public interest, by notification, declare to be a public utility service for the purposes of this Chapter."

    3

    7. Cognizance has to be taken by the Permanent Lok Adalat under Section 22-C of the Act of 1987. By virtue of the provision under sub- section (2) of Section 22-C, after an application is made under sub- section (1) to the Permanent Lok Adalat, no party to that application shall invoke jurisdiction of any court in the same dispute. Procedure to be followed in dealing with complaint filed before the Lok Adalat is prescribed in Section 22-D of the Act of 1987 which provides that the Permanent Lok Adalat shall, while conducting conciliation proceedings or deciding a dispute on merit under this Act, be guided by the principles of natural justice, objectivity, fair play, equity and other principles of justice. Section 22-E provides that award of Permanent Lok Adalat to be final. Section 22-E(1) provides that every award of the Permanent Lok Adalat under this Act made either on merit or in terms of a settlement agreement shall be final and binding on all the parties thereto and on persons claiming under them. Sub- section (4) of Section 22-E provides that every award made by the Permanent Lok Adalat under this Act shall be final and shall not be called in question in any original suit, application or execution proceeding, but that finality clause attached with the award of the Permanent Lok Adalat will not exclude the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India, as the statutory provisions contained in the Act of 1987 will not exclude the constitutional remedy available under the provisions of the Constitution of India. The Supreme Court in the matter of Bar Council Of India v. Union Of India . of India1, while considering Section 22-E(1) of the Act of 1987 held in unmistakable terms that party to dispute

    (2012) 8 SCC 243

    1

    before Permanent Lok Adalat can always approach against the award of Permanent Lok Adalat, this Court under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India.

    8. The Supreme Court in the matter of Bar Council of India (supra) has held that where despite efforts of Permanent Lok Adalat settlement between parties is not arrived at, to avoid delay in adjudication of disputes relating to public utility services, Parliament has conferred power of adjudication upon Permanent Lok Adalat as well. It was observed as under:-

    "26. It is necessary to bear in mind that the disputes relating to public utility services have been entrusted to Permanent Lok Adalats only if the process of conciliation and settlement fails. The emphasis is on settlement in respect of disputes concerning public utility services through the medium of Permanent Lok Adalat. It is for this reason that sub- section

    (1) of Section 22-C states in no unambiguous terms that any party to a dispute may before the dispute is brought before any court make an application to the Permanent Lok Adalat for settlement of dispute. Thus, settlement of dispute between the parties in matters of public utility services is the main theme. However, where despite the endeavours and efforts of the Permanent Lok Adalat the settlement between the parties is not through and the parties are required to have their dispute determined and adjudicated, to avoid delay in adjudication of disputes relating to public utility services. Parliament has intervened and conferred power of adjudication upon the Permanent Lok Adalat.

    27. Can the power conferred on Permanent Lok Adalats to adjudicate the disputes between the parties concerning public utility service up to a specific pecuniary limit, if they do not relate to any offence, as provided under Section 22-C(8), be said to be unconstitutional and irrational? We think not. It

    5

    is settled law that an authority empowered to adjudicate the disputes between the parties and act as a tribunal may not necessarily have all the trappings of the court. What is essential is that it must be a creature of statute and should adjudicate the dispute between the parties before it after giving reasonable opportunity to them consistent with the principles of fair play and natural justice. It is not a constitutional right of any person to have the dispute adjudicated by means of a court only. Chapter VI-A has been enacted to provide for an institutional mechanism, through the establishment of Permanent Lok Adalats for settlement of disputes concerning public utility service before the matter is brought to the court and in the event of failure to reach any settlement, empowering the Permanent Lok Adalat to adjudicate such dispute if it does not relate to any offence."

    9. In the matter of State of Punjab and another v. Jalour Singh and others2the Supreme Court while dealing with the award passed by the Lok Adalat held that Lok Adalats have no adjudicatory or judicial function and observed as under:-

    "8. It is evident from the said provisions that Lok Adalats have no adjudicatory or judicial functions. Their functions relates to purely to conciliation. A Lok Adalat determines a reference on the basis of a compromise or settlement between the parties at his instance, and put its seal of confirmation by making an award in terms of the compromise or settlement... …"

    10. This Court speaking through Manindra Mohan Shrivastava, J. in the matter of Superintending Engineer CSEB Bilaspur Division & Another v. Public Utility Permanent Lok Adalat, Bilaspur & Others3 has held that Permanent Lok Adalat do not possess any plenary

    2 2 008 AIR SCW 1196

    3 2011 (4) C.G.L.J. 460

    6

    jurisdiction to adjudicate upon disputes relating to claim based on tortious liability. His Lordship held as under:-

    "20. The upshot of aforesaid discussions is that the Permanent Lok Adalats can exercise the jurisdiction in the matter of disputes arising out of services relating to public utility service and do not possess any plenary jurisdiction to adjudicate upon disputes relating to claim based on tortious liability merely because one of the party to the dispute is one who is engaged in operating a public utility service."

    11.Reverting back to the facts of the present case, in view of the aforesaid settled proposition of law and also considering the nature of dispute involved in the present case, this Court is of the considered view that the subject dispute does not fall within the ambit of Public Utility Service.

    12. Consequently, in my considered opinion, the impugned order passed by the Permanent Lok Adalat (PUS) is patently devoid of jurisdiction and the same deserves to be and is hereby set-aside.

    1 3.With the aforesaid observation/direction, this Petition is disposed of. Sd/- (Deepak Kumar Tiwari) Judge Shyna

    7

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    BRANCH MANAGER, SHRIRAM TRANSPORT FINANCE COMPNAY LTD., v. ANIL KUMAR KOMRA
    (Nov 26, 2024)