1 / 8
2024:CGHC:41340
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MA No. 79 of 2022
1. Jahusram Awade S/o Chandel Awade Aged About 60 Years
2. Smt. Sewatibai W/o Shri Pahusram, Aged About 55 Years Both the Appellants are R/o Village - Bhoring, P.S. Tumgaon, Tehsil And District Mahasamund Chhattisgarh
... Appellants/Defendants versus
1. Smt. Leena Sahu, W/o Late Shri Santosh Sahu Aged About 39 Years
2. Harsh Sahu S/o Late Shri Santosh Sahu Aged About 16 Years (Now 21 years)
3. Kumari Manasvi Sahu D/o Late Shri Santosh Sahu Aged About 11 Years Minor and is Represented by her Natural Guardian (Mother), i,e. Respondent No. 1 (Smt. Leena Sahu)
4. Sarojini, D/o Shri Bisoha Sahu
5. Meena Bai D/o Shri Bisoha Sahu
6. Smt. Dulari Bai W/o Late Rajulal Sahu All the respondents are R/o Village - Tumgaon (Wrongly typed as Village - Khairjhitti, in the Impugned Order Dated 20.07.2022), Occupation - Agriculturist, P.S. Tumgaon, Tehsil And District Mahasamund Chhattisgarh
... Respondents/Plaintiffs
1
For Appellants/Defendants : Mr. Surfaraj Khan, Advocate For Respondents/Plaintiffs : Mr. V.K. Pandey, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Justice Deepak Kumar Tiwari Order On Board
21/10/2024
1. With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the matter is heard finally.
2. This Appeal arises out of order (wrongly mentioned as judgment) dated 20.07.2022 in Civil Appeal No.H-44-A/2016 passed by the Additional District Judge, Fast Track Court, Mahasamund (C.G.), remanding the case for retrial to the trial Court upon reception of additional evidence rendered in the Appeal.
3. Briefly stated facts of the case are that respondent No.6 (Smt. Dulari Bai), respondent No.4 (Sarojini), respondent No.5 (Meena Bai) & Late Shri Santosh Sahu filed a Civil Suit against the appellants/defendants for permanent injunction, making an averment inter alia that they are holding title in their own names and are in possession of the subject property i.e. Khasra No.863, ad measuring area 0.33 hectare at Village Khairjhitti, Patwari Halka No.7, Revenue Circle Pateva, Tehsil & District Mahasamund (C.G.). It has been alleged that from the past 3 years, the defendants are forcefully harvesting the crops planted in the subject land. In their written statement, the appellants/defendants had stated that defendant No.2 has purchased the said property from one Dular Sahu by way of a registered sale deed dated 19.08.2009 and
2
thereby, they are in possession of the subject property and are having title over it based on the said sale deed. Learned trial Court framed as many as 6 issues. Though, while dealing with issue No.1, the trial Court reached to a conclusion that the respondents/plaintiffs failed to prove their title on the subject property, but subsequently it held that they are in possession of the subject property. Ultimately, the suit was dismissed on the ground that no injunction can be granted against a person, who is having a better title. Against the said order of the trial Court, the respondents/plaintiffs preferred an Appeal. During the proceeding in the Appeal, an interlocutory application under Order 41 Rule 27 of the CPC was filed and to demonstrate the title on the subject land, along with the said application, certain certified copies of the revenue entries were also filed. The Appellate Court allowed the said application and after setting aside the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court, remitted the matter to the trial Court to decide the same afresh after affording opportunity to adduce additional evidence to the parties.
4. Learned counsel for the appellants/defendants submits that the respondents/plaintiffs have filed the Suit for permanent injunction and to decide the said Suit, the remand order is unnecessary. Even if the Appellate Court found that admission of additional evidence is necessary in the interest of justice, instead of wholesale remand of the case, the trial Court ought to have been directed to take such evidence on record and send it to the Appellate Court to decide the Appeal in accordance with law.
3
5. Learned counsel for the respondents/plaintiffs would also not dispute the aforesaid settled legal proposition.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the documents annexed with the petition carefully.
7. In the matter of Udaya Economics Housing & Construction Limited v. Bhula Bai and Others1, while allowing the application under Order 41 Rule 27 of the CPC, the scope of remand order by the Lower Appellate Court has been discussed and it was held that wholesale remand of entire case for fresh trial is unnecessary.
8. Further, in the matter of Jawahar Lal (Dead) through L.Rs. and Another v. Champa Devi and Another2, while dealing with the similar issue, the following was held in para 6 to 10, which read as under:-
"6. Order 41 Rule 23 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (hereinafter called 'the CPC') empowers the Appellate Court to remand the case, which reads as follows:
"23. Remand of case by Appellate Court.— Where the court from whose decree an appeal is preferred has disposed of the suit upon a preliminary point and the decree is reversed in appeal, the Appellate Court may, if it thinks fit, by order remand the case, and may further direct what issue or issues shall be tried in the case so remanded, and shall send a copy of its judgment and order to the court from whose decree the appeal is preferred, with directions to re-admit the suit under its original number in the register of civil suits, and proceed to determine the
4
suit; and the evidence (if any) recorded during the original trial shall, subject to all just exceptions, be evidence during the trial after remand."
7. Order 41 Rule 23 CPC will come into application only when the suit has been disposed of upon preliminary points and the decree is reversed in appeal. If the suit has been disposed of on merits, then Order 41 Rule 23 CPC will not apply. Remand can also be ordered under Order 41 Rule 23- A CPC, which reads as follows:
"23-A. Remand in other cases.—Where the court from whose decree an appeal is preferred has disposed of the case otherwise than on a preliminary point, and the decree is reversed in appeal and a retrial is considered necessary, the Appellate Court shall have the same powers as it has under Rule 23."
8. A bare reading of Order 41 Rule 23A CPC clearly shows that the Court before remanding the case where it has reversed the decree in appeal, must come to a conclusion that re-trial is necessary. In case re-trial is not necessary, then no remand is called for.
9. Order 41 Rule 24 and 25 CPC read as under:
"24. Where evidence on record sufficient, Appellate Court may determine case Anally.— Where the evidence upon the record is sufficient to enable the Appellate Court to pronounce judgment, the Appellate Court may, after resettling the issues, if necessary, finally determine the suit, notwithstanding that the judgment of the court from whose decree the appeal is preferred has proceeded wholly upon some ground other than that on which the Appellate Court proceeds.
5
25. Where Appellate Court may frame issues and refer them for trial to court whose decree appealed from.— where the court from whose decree the appeal is preferred has omitted to frame or try any issue, or to determine any question of fact, which appears to the Appellate Court essential to the right decision of the suit upon the merits, the Appellate Court may, if necessary, frame issues, and refer the same for trial to the court from whose decree the appeal is preferred and in such case shall direct such court to take the additional evidence required; and such court shall proceed to try such issues, and shall return the evidence to the Appellate Court together with its findings thereon and the reasons therefor within such time as may be fixed by the Appellate Court or extended by it from time to time."
10. Order 41 Rule 24 makes it amply clear that where the evidence on record is sufficient to decide all the issues, then the appellate Court may even after re settling the issues, decide all the issues afresh and there is no need in such a case to remand the matter. Order 41 Rule 25 CPC empowers the appellate Court to frame fresh issues and refer them for trial to the Court where the decree is appealed. Therefore, if the appellate Court feels that a fresh issue has to be framed on the basis of the pleadings already on record or on the basis of some amendments in the pleadings, the appellate Court may, if necessary, frame issues and refer the same to the trial Court and where an appeal is preferred, in such case, the trial Court is only required to take additional evidence on the issues so framed or remanded to it and it is thereafter required to only try the issues and return the evidence to the appellate
6
Court alongwith the findings. The purpose behind Order 41 Rule 23 CPC is to ensure speedy and effective trial. This is frustrated by ordering a wholesale remand of the case without even seeing which provision of law is applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case……………….."
9. In view of the aforesaid legal proposition and also considering that the Suit has been filed for permanent injunction and the trial Court has dismissed the Suit only on the ground that no document has been filed with regard to title and subsequently, at the appellate stage, the plaintiffs have filed some necessary documents, this Court is of the view that as per the procedure prescribed under Order 41 Rule 28 of the CPC, the Appellate Court, instead of wholesale remand of the case, ought to have directed the trial Court to take such evidence and sent it to the Appellate Court for deciding the Appeal in accordance with law.
10.Consequently, the impugned order passed by the learned First Appellate Court, so far as it concerns to remand of the case in wholesale manner, is set aside and the matter is remanded to the concerned First Appellate Court with a direction to make earnest endeavour to decide the Appeal itself or if found necessary, direct the trial Court to take such evidence and after collecting such evidence, send the same to the Appellate Court to enable it to decide the Appeal one way or the other.
11.Accordingly, the Appeal is allowed to the extent and in the manner indicated above.
7
12.Both the parties are directed to appear before the Appellate Court on
04.12.2024.
Sd/-
(Deepak Kumar Tiwari)
Judge Priyanka
8