HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT
JODHPUR
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 964/2011
1.
The Special Officer Urban Development and Housing Department, Rajasthan, Jaipur
2.
State of Rajasthan through the Deputy Secretary-I, Department of Urban Development, Secretariat, Jaipur.
3.
The District Collector, Pali. ----Appellants
Versus
1.
Kailash, son of Shri Nathuji Kabli Mali, aged 47 years, resident of 39, Venkastesh Marg, Mahadev Mandir Pali.
2.
Ashok son of Shri Nathuji Kabli Mali, since deceased through his legal Heirs.
2.1
Smt. Seema wife of Late Shri Ashok aged about 48 years, resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near Jain Upasara, Pali.
2.2
Kum. Seema daughter of Late Shri Ashok aged about 29 years, resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near Jain Upasara, Pali.
2.3
Jaideep son of Late Shri Ashok aged about 26 years, resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near Jain Upasara, Pali.
2.4
Ginish son of Late Shri Ashok aged about 24 year, resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near Jain Upasara, Pali.
3.
Smt. Sayari Devi wife of Nathuji Kabli Mali resident of 12 Gujarati Katla, Pali.
4.
Anand aged 49 years son of Nathuji Kabli resident of Pursharti Nagar, Sindhi Colony, Pali.
5.
Smt. Leela Devi wife of Shri Hari Singhji Sankhla Mali daughter of Shri Nathuji Milkman Colony, House no.444 Gali no.3, Pal Road, Jodhpur.
6.
Smt. Suraj Devi wife of Shri Narendra Singhji Gehlot daughter of Shri Nathuji care of Shri Santosh Singhji Gehlot, Subhash Chowk, Sursagar, Jodhpur.
7.
Smt. Vijay Laxmi wife of Shri Prakashji parihar daughter of Shri Nathuji resident of 2-A-76, New Housing Board, Pali.
8.
Smt. Manju Devi wife of Shri Balvir Singhji Mali daughter of Shri Nathuji care of Shri Sohan Singhji Parihar resident of
1
Basni Tamboliya, Parihar Nagar, Jodhpur.
9.
Smt. Manisha wife of Shri Balvir Singhji Gehlot daughter of Shri Nathuji care of Shri Megh Singhji Gehlot, Bera Chutrawala, Magra Punjala Jodhpur.
----Respondents
Connected With
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 197/2011
1.
Rajasthan Housing Board, Division Pali Marwar through its Housing Engineer.
2.
State of Rajasthan through the Deputy Secretary-I, Department of Urban Development & Housing, Secretariat, Jaipur.
3.
The District Collector, Pali. ----Appellants
Versus
1.
Smt. Modi Devi, wife of Shri Mishri Malji aged about 40 years (approximately), resident of House no.51, Maliyon ka Bera, Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
2.
The Special Officer (Visheshadhikari) cum Land Acquisition Officer, Urban Development and Housing Department, Jaipur (Rajasthan).
----Respondents
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 963/2011
Rajashtan Housing Board, Division Pali Marwar through its Housing Engineer.
----Appellant
Versus
1.
Smt. Asi Bai wife of Shri Lala Ram aged about 62 years, resident of Maliyon ka Bera, Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
2.
Hazari Lal son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 32 years resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
3.
Dhanna Ram son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 45
2
years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
4.
Ghewar Ram son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 36 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
5.
Sona Ram son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 22 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
6.
Sohan Lal son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 18 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
7.
Kishan Lal son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 16 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
8.
Smt. Bhanwari Devi, wife of Shri Fula Ram daughter of Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 40 years, resident of Village Sumerpur, District Pali.
9.
Smt. Heera Devi, wife of Shri Babu Lalji daughter of Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 38 years, resident of Village Rani Kalan, District Pali.
10.
Smt. Vidya Devi, wife of Shri Jodha Ramji daughter of Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 25 years, resident of Village Rani Kalan, District Pali.
11.
Smt. Indira Devi, wife of Shri Prakash daughter of Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 20 years, resident of Village Salawas, District Pali.
12
Late Shri Pema Ram through its legal representatives
12.1
Soni Bai wife of late Shri Pema Ram aged about 65 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.2
Gheesu Ram son of late Shri Pema Ram aged about 50 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.3
Pappu Singh son of late Shri Pema Ram aged about 35 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.4
Devi Ram son of late Shri Pema Ram aged about 30 years,
resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.5
Gamna Ram son of late Shri Pema Ram aged about 25 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.6
Babu Devi wife of Late Jetha Ram son of late Shri Pema Ram aged about 28 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.7
Vinod son of Late Jetha Ram son of late Shri Pema Ram aged about 12 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.8
Lata Devi daughter of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about aged 40 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
13
Hukma Ram son of Shri Uda Ram aged about 50 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, Village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
14
State of Rajasthan through the Deputy Secretary-I, Department of Urban Development & Housing, Secretariat, Jaipur.
15
The District Collector, Pali.
16
The Special Officer (Visheshadikari) cum Land Acquisition Officer, Urban Development and Housing Department, Jaipur (Rajasthan).
----Respondents
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 1028/2011
1.
State of Rajasthan through the Deputy Secretary-I, Department of Urban Development & Housing, Secretariat, Jaipur.
2.
The District Collector, Pali. ----Appellants
Versus
1.
Smt. Asi Bai, wife of Shri Lala Ram aged about 62 years, resident of Maliyon Ka Bera, Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
2.
Hazari Lal son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 32 years,
resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
3.
Dhanna Ram son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 45 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
4.
Ghewar Ram son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 36 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
5.
Sona Ram son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 22 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
6.
Sohan Lal son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 18 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
7.
Kishan Lal son of Late Shri Lala Ram aged about 16 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
8.
Smt. Bhanwari Devi, wife of Shri Fula Ram D/o Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 40 years, resident of village Sumerpur, District Pali.
9.
Smt. Heera Devi, wife of Shri Babu Lalji D/o Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 38 years, resident of village Rani Kalan, District Pali.
10.
Smt. Vidya Devi, wife of Shri Jodha Ramji D/o Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 25 years, resident of village Rani Kalan, District Pali.
11.
Smt. Indira Devi, wife of Shri Prakash D/o Late Shri Lala Ramji aged about 20 years, resident of village Salawas, District Pali.
12.1
Soni Bai wife of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 65 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.2
Gheesu Ram son of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 50 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.3
Pappu Singh son of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 35 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak
5
no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.4
Devi Ram son of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 30 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.5
Gamma Ram son of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 25 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.6
Babu Devi wife of Late Jetha Ram son of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 28 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.7
Vinod son of Late Jetha Ram son of Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 12 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
12.8
Lata Devi D/o Late Shri Pema Ram aged about 40 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
13.
Hukma Ram son of Shri Uda Ram aged about 50 years, resident of Near Hanuman Colony, village Pali Chak no.1, Tehsil Pali, District Pali.
14.
Rajasthan Housing Board, Division Pali Marwar through its Housing Engineer.
15.
The Special Officer (Visheshadhikari) cum Land Acquisition Officer, Urban Development and Housing Department, Jaipur (Raj.)
D.B. Special Appeal Writ No. 1029/2011
1.
State of Rajasthan through the Deputy Secretary-I, Department of Urban Development, Secretariat, Jaipur.
2.
The District Collector, Pali. ----Appellants
Versus
1.
Kailash son of Shri Nathuji, Kabli Mali, aged 47 years resident of 39, Venkastesh Marg, Mahadev Mandir Pali.
2.
Ashok son of Shri Nathuji, Kabli Mali, since deceased through his Legal Heirs.
2.1
Smt. Seema wife of Late Shri Ashok aged about 48 years
6
resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near jain Upasara, Pali.
2.2
Kum. Seema daughter of Late Shri Ashok aged about 29 years, resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near jain Upasara, Pali.
2.3
Jaideep son of Late Shri Ashok aged about 26 years, resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near jain Upasara, Pali.
2.4
Ginish son of Late Shri Ashok aged about 24 years, resident of 12, Gujarati katra, near jain Upasara, Pali.
3.
The Special Officer Urban Development and Housing Department, Rajasthan, Jaipur.
4.
Smt. Sayari Devi wife of Nathuji Kabli Mali resident of 12 Gujarati katla, Pali.
5.
Anand aged 49 years son of Nathuji Kabli resident of Purshrti Nagar, Sindhi Colony, Pali.
6.
Smt Leela Devi wife of Shri Hari Singhji Sankhla Mali daughter of Shri Nathuji Milkman Colony, House no. 444 Gali no. 3, Pal road, Jodhpur.
7.
Smt Suraj Devi wife of Shri Narendra Singhji Gehlot daughter of Shri Nathuji care of Shri Santosh Singhji Gehlot, Subhash Chowk, Sursagar, Jodhpur.
8.
Smt. Vijay Laxmi wife of Shri Prakashji Parihar daughter of Shri Nathuji resident of 2-A-76, New Housing Board, Pali.
9.
Smt. Manju Devi wife of shri Balvir Singhji Mali daughter of Shri Nathuji care of Shri Sohan Singhji Parihar, resident of Basni Taboliya, Parihar Nagar, Jodhpur.
10.
Smt. Manisha wife of shri Balvir Singhji Gehlot daughter of Shri Nathuji care of Shri Megh Singhji Gehlot, Bera Chutrawala, Magra punjala Jodhpur.
----Respondents
For Appellant(s) : Mr. Amit Tatia
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Manoj Bhandari, Sr. Advocate assisted by Mr. Aniket Tater
Mr. Narendra Thanvi
Mr. Anirudh Purohit
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE KULDEEP MATHUR Order
7
25/09/2024
Per, S.Chandrashekhar J:
These Special Appeals have been filed by the Urban Development and Housing Department, Rajasthan, Jaipur and the Rajasthan Housing Board against the common judgment dated 4thJanuary 2011 passed in S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.4111 of 2009 titled "Kailash Kabli & Anr. Vs. State of Rajasthan and Ors."; S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.4216 of 2009 titled "Smt. Modi Devi Vs. State of Rajasthan and Ors." and; S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.4075 of 2009 titled "Smt. Asi Bai & Ors. Vs. State of Rajasthan and Ors."
2. The writ Court held that the notification dated 22ndJanuary 2009 under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (in short, the Act of 1894) was illegal. The writ Court held as under:
"On examination of the record I also found that a very casual mode was adopted while reaching at decision as desired under provisions of Section 5-A of the Act. As already stated earlier the Legal Remembrance made a note on 6.10.2008 on receipt of the report dated 21.8.2008 and that was placed before the Secretary to the Government, Department of Urban Development. The Secretary desired to have a revised plan but no expeditious action was taken. On 2.1.2009 the Legal Remembrance pointed out that the time was moving fast and the limitation was going to expire on 8.1.2008, therefore, a decision at the earliest was necessary. In such circumstances, the file was placed before the Secretary, Principal Secretary and the Minister to the Government of Rajasthan, Department of Urban Development, and all these authorities just by putting their signatures approved the recommendations made by the Special Officer and the Legal Remembrance. The government, as per Section 5-A of the Act is required to take a decision and not to just approve the recommendations made to it. The decision of the government may be the same as recommended but that should be an outcome of a fair process
8
of decision making. Under Section 5 -A of the Act the decision making is a vital component of the land acquisition proceedings, therefore, that should be supported by appropriate application of mind with a foundation of knowledge and sound reasoning. The government while arriving at a decision, as per Section 5 of the Act, is required to analyze and evaluate the need of the acquisition, objections of the persons interested and even the other alternatives if suggested and available. The decision and approval are two different acts. While making decision the competent authority is required to apply its independent mind by taking into consideration every relevant factor relating to the dispute, whereas the approval is an objective permission to act upon the decision taken by some other authority. Under the Act, a final decision is required to be taken by the Government and that could not and cannot be treated as just approval to the recommendations made by the Collector or his appointee. The government officials and executives are supposed to act as per the intention of the Legislature and objects of the law, however, in the case in hand the authorities concerned failed to do so. Their approach to reach at a decision is not in consonance to the spirit and thrust of the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act, but is quite clerical and mechanical. The authorities competent should have given a decision after adhering entire process of decision making and not a mere approval to the recommendations. The process of decision making is conspicuously absent in the present case. As a matter of fact, in the instant matter, it is only the approval by the government to the recommendations made by the Special Officer, and the same is considered as a decision of the government. Such kind of decision is no decision in the eye of law."
3. Briefly stated, for the acquisition of the land measuring about 120 bighas and 30 biswas a notification under section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (in short, the Act of 1894) was published and the declaration under section 6 was made on 22ndJanuary 2009. Before that, the writ petitioners (hereinafter
9
referred to as the respondents) had raised objections to the proposed acquisition on the ground that the subject land was not fit for housing purpose, the proclaimed public purpose was not genuine and the proposed acquisition was actuated with malafides. After the notification under section 4 was issued, the Special Officer of the Urban Development and Housing Department prepared a report under section 5-A and the Legal Remembrance made a recommendation on 6thOctober 2008 for excluding 3.75 bighas land from the proposed acquisition. Considering the recommendation of the Legal Remembrance which was in tune with the report prepared by the Special Officer, the appropriate Government revised the acquisition proposal on 6thOctober 2008; for acquisition of 109.35 bighas of land. Thereafter, the matter stood still and was placed before the Secretary-I, Principal Secretary and the Minister of Department of Housing and Urban Development only on 7thJanuary 2009 and, that too, pursuant to a note prepared by the Legal Remembrance on 2ndJanuary 2009 whereunder he indicated that the last date for making the declaration under section 6 was 8thJanuary 2009. Where after, the declaration under section 6 was made on 9thJanuary 2009. The writ Court referred to the records produced by the respondent- Housing Board and held that there was no proper service even by way of affixing notices at the public place, and the records of the proceedings were not forwarded by the Special Officer through the forwarding letter dated 21stAugust 2008. The writ Court also found that the records produced before the Court indicated notings by the Government officials and the internal communications by the Government but no record of the
10
land acquisition proceedings was produced before the appropriate Government and thereby the entire process of decision making was vitiated inasmuch as the appropriate Government is required to take the final decision on the basis of the report prepared by the Special Officer/Land Acquisition Officer after hearing the persons interested and the other materials before it. The writ Court therefore held that the property of the writ petitioners was sought to be acquired in a very casual manner and the decision under section 6 was arrived without analyzing and evaluating the need and requirement for acquisition and objections by the persons interested.
4. Mr. Amit Tatia the learned counsel appearing for the appellant-Housing Board makes two-fold submissions viz. (i) the writ petitioners had knowledge of the acquisition proceedings and they had submitted their objections and therefore the declaration under section 6 was legal and valid and not vitiated on account of any procedural violation; (ii) section 5-A of the Act of 1894 was followed and the objections by the persons interested were considered before the declaration under section 6 was made.
5. In the first place, we would indicate that the proposed public purpose falls short of coming within the purview of public purpose. In "Munshi Singh & Ors. v. Union of India" (1973) 2 SCC 337, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that a public purpose of "planned development of the area" was insufficient to convey any idea for specific purpose and quashed the acquisition proceedings. We may also refer to the decision in "Madhya Pradesh Housing Board v. Mohd. Shafi And Ors." (1992) 2 SCC 168 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held the acquisition proceedings bad in law on the
11
ground that the public purpose mentioned as "residential" was vague.
6. Secondly, the substantive right of the persons interested to object and demonstrate that the acquisition in question is not for public purpose cannot be curtailed on the ground that the person interested had knowledge about the proposed acquisition. This is common knowledge that the development of an area for residential purposes takes many years and, therefore, the inquiry under section 5-A is normally not dispensed with. Section 5-A therefore provides a forum for objection to be raised by any person interested in any land notified under section 4 and this is necessary because the intention of the appropriate Government to acquire the property of an individual or a group of individuals is not a simple matter. Sub-section (2) to section 5-A provides that the Collector shall give the objector an opportunity of being heard in person or by any person authorized by him in this behalf or by the pleader and shall after hearing all such objections and after making such further inquiry, if any, as he thinks necessary, either make a report in respect of the land notified under section 4 (1) or make different reports in respect of different portions of such land to be submitted to the appropriate Government. Sub-section (3) further clarifies that a person shall be deemed to be interested in land who would be entitled to claim an interest in compensation. In "Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. v. Darius Shapur Chenai & Ors." (2005) 7 SCC 627, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the hearing given to a person must be effective and not a mere formality. The Hon'ble Supreme Court further observed that where there has been total non-compliance of the provisions of section
12
5-A, the Court cannot fold its hands and refuse to grant relief to the writ petitioners, in particular, when the decision making process itself is vitiated. In "Hindustan Departmental Corporation Ltd." the Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under :-
"16. However, considerations of the objections by the owner of the land and the acceptance of the recommendations by the Government, it is trite, must precede a proper application of mind on the part of the Government. As and when a person aggrieved questions the decision-making process, the court in order to satisfy itself as to whether one or more grounds for judicial review exist, may call for the records whereupon such records must be produced. The writ petition was filed in the year 1989. As noticed hereinbefore, the said writ petition was allowed. This Court, however, interfered with the said order of the High Court and remitted the matter back to it upon giving an opportunity to the parties to raise additional pleadings."
7. While section 4 reflects a mere intention of the appropriate Government to acquire a piece of land, section 6 provides that if the appropriate Government after considering the report made by the Collector under sub-section (2) to section 5-A forms its satisfaction that any particular land is needed for a public purpose, then it shall make a declaration to that effect under the signature of the Secretary to the Government or of some officer duly authorized to certify its orders and different declarations may be made from time to time. The provisions under section 5-A indicates that the Collector shall cause inquiry as he may think necessary upon raising of objections from the landholders and submit a report to the appropriate Government. The report so prepared shall contain recommendations and the objections filed by the landholders, and the Collector is required to forward records of the proceedings "held by him" together with the report.
13
In its turn, the State Government is required to take a decision and arrive at its own satisfaction as to whether it is necessary to deprive a citizen of his property. Quite evidently, the action taken by the Collector is distinct and different from the decision taken by the appropriate Government.
8. Mr. Amit Tatia the learned counsel for the appellants referred to the communications between the Collector and the Resident Engineer of the Rajasthan Housing Board at Pali for service of notice on the landholders. The learned counsel has also referred to the communications with the Divisional Commissioner Jodhpur, Deputy Housing Commissioner Jodhpur, Tehsildar at Pali, Panchayat Samiti at Pali, Government School at Pali and the Municipal Council at Pali to lay support to the stand taken by the appellant-Housing Board that the notices were affixed at the notice board of the Government School and Municipal Council so as to make the landholders and persons interested aware about the proposed acquisition. The learned counsel for the appellants referred to "New Okhla Industrial Development Authority v. Darshan Lal Bohra & Ors." 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1690 to fortify the submission that there shall be presumption of service of notice if the records prima-facie reflect publication and service of notice.
9. In "New Okhla Industrial Authority" the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that where the Collector took a specific stand that notices were duly served upon the persons concerned and the records of service of such notices were duly maintained, that can be a situation where a statutory presumption under section 114 of the Evidence Act shall be drawn. However, the Hon'ble Supreme Court further held that in a case where the objector was not
14
served with an advance notice and an opportunity of personal hearing was not accorded in that situation the acquisition process would be liable to be hammered. In the present case, this is not the stand taken by the Housing Board that the writ petitioners were not required to be accorded opportunity of personal hearing under section 5-A. The records of the land acquisition proceedings were produced before the writ Court and a finding has been recorded thereon that there was not even proper and sufficient notice of the proposed land acquisition proceedings to the writ petitioners. In our opinion, the writ Court rightly held that the appropriate Government before making the declaration under section 6 did not apply its mind inasmuch as the records of the proceedings under section 5-A were not produced along with the report submitted by the Special Officer and, therefore, the declaration under section 6 was illegal.
10. Mr. Amit Tatia the learned counsel for the appellants lastly submitted that a liberty may be reserved with the appellants to initiate the land acquisition proceedings under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. The Land Acquisition Act, 1870 (Act X of 1870) was passed by the Governor General-in-Council and had received the assent of the Governor General-in-Council on 1st April 1870. It was a pre-Constitution legislation which was not found entirely effective for the protection either of the persons interested in land or of public interest. The statement of objects and reasons for replacing the Land Acquisition Act, 1870 (Act X of 1870) and enacting a new law for land acquisition indicates that the amendment to the Land Acquisition Act, 1870 had been under
15
consideration for several years by the Government of India particularly in view of the communication with the local Governments. The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 also underwent multiple amendments and the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 was enacted which was published in the Gazette of India on 27thSeptember 2013 and came into force on 1stJanuary
2014.
11. Under sub-sections (b) and (c) to section 6 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 the repeal of any Central Act or Regulation made after the commencement of the Act shall not affect the previous operation of any enactment so repealed or anything duly done or suffered thereunder or affect any right, privilege, obligation or liability acquired, accrued or incurred under any enactment so repealed. Section 24 of the new Act seeks to preserve the continuity of the proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act inasmuch as the provisions of the new Act relating to the determination of compensation shall apply to all cases where no award under section 11 of the old Land Acquisition Act was made. Clause (b), however, provides that where an award under section 11 has been made then such proceedings shall continue under the provisions of the old Land Acquisition Act as if the said Act has not been repealed. However, the declaration under section 6 having been held illegal, there is no pending proceeding for land acquisition under the Act of 1894 and therefore the appellants cannot proceed further with the land acquisition proceedings pursuant to the notification issued under section 4 under the Act of 1894 and they may take a conscious
16
decision whether or not to initiate a fresh proceeding for land acquisition under the new Act.
12. These Special Appeals are accordingly dismissed.
(KULDEEP MATHUR),J (SHREE CHANDRASHEKHAR),J
7-11 ArjunDaiya/AjaySingh/-
17