Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Sri Althaf Ahamed, filed a writ petition challenging the mutation entries made in favour of respondent Nos.5 and 6, his two sisters, concerning property bearing Survey No.2 measuring 5 acres 24 guntas at Udugani Village, Shikaripura Taluk, Shivamogga District. The appellant claimed absolute ownership of the property based on a registered Will dated 30.12.2019, alleging that the gift deed obtained by his sisters from their mother was executed by fraud and misrepresentation. The appellant had been residing in Saudi Arabia and upon return, discovered the alleged conspiracy and forced execution of the Will in favour of respondent Nos.5 and 6. The mutation entries in favour of the respondents were upheld by the revenue authorities through dismissal of the appellant's Regular Appeal and subsequent appeals. The writ petition sought to set aside the orders dated 01.07.2021 and 18.07.2022 and to direct the Tahsildar to make Khatha as per the registered Will in favour of the appellant. The Single Judge dismissed the writ petition on 22.05.2023, leading to the present writ appeal under Section 4 of the Karnataka High Court Act, 1961.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ jurisdiction of the High Court can be exercised to adjudicate disputes relating to the validity of a gift deed and a registered Will affecting property rights.
  2. Whether the mutation entries made by the revenue authorities in favour of respondent Nos.5 and 6 can be challenged and set aside by writ petition or require adjudication through civil proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sohan Lal vs. Union of India and Another (AIR 1957 SC 529) Writ courts should not adjudicate disputes involving title to property which require factual and legal determination more appropriate for civil courts. The court relied on this precedent to hold that the dispute over the gift deed and Will involves civil rights and requires evidence and adjudication by a civil court rather than writ jurisdiction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court observed that the core dispute concerns the validity of the gift deed and the registered Will, which implicates the civil rights and titular claims of the parties. The mutation entries made by the revenue authorities in favour of respondent Nos.5 and 6 were based on the gift deed, and the appellant's challenge to these entries had been dismissed through various stages of revenue appeals. The court emphasized the principle that writ jurisdiction is not the appropriate forum to decide disputes involving title to property requiring evidence and detailed adjudication. It referred to the statutory proviso to Section 135 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964, which provides that aggrieved persons may institute civil suits to declare their rights, and the revenue records are to be amended based on such civil court declarations. The court found the Single Judge's view that the appellant must pursue civil remedies to establish ownership to be just and legally sound. Consequently, no error was found in dismissing the writ petition.

Holding and Implications

The writ appeal is dismissed.

The court's decision confirms that disputes over property title involving allegations of fraud and validity of wills or gift deeds fall outside the scope of writ jurisdiction and must be resolved through civil court proceedings. The mutation entries by revenue authorities remain subject to the outcome of such civil suits. This ruling directly affects the parties by upholding the dismissal of the writ petition and requiring the appellant to seek relief through appropriate civil litigation. No new precedent was established beyond reaffirming established principles limiting writ jurisdiction in property disputes.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SRI. ALTHAF AHAMED v. STATE OF KARNATAKA

    - 1 -

    NC: 2024:KHC:9751-DB WA No. 713 of 2023

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

    DATED THIS THE 11TH DAY OF MARCH, 2024

    PRESENT

    THE HON'BLE MR N. V. ANJARIA, CHIEF JUSTICE

    AND

    THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE KRISHNA S DIXIT WRIT APPEAL NO. 713 OF 2023 (KLR-RR/SUR)

    BETWEEN:

    SRI. ALTHAF AHAMED,

    S/O LATE MOHAMMED ASWAK,

    AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,

    UDUGANI VILLAGE MAIN ROAD,

    SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427.

    SHIMOGA DISTRICT.

    …APPELLANT

    (BY SRI. JAGADEESHACHARI.,ADVOCATE)

    AND:

    1. STATE OF KARNATAKA,

    BY ITS SECRETARY,

    REVENUE DEPARTMENT,

    M.S.BUILDING,

    BANGALORE-560 001.

    2. THE THASILDAR,

    SHIKARIPURA TALUK-577 427,

    SHIMOGA DISTRICT.

    3. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER,

    SAGAR SUB-DIVISION, SAGARA, SHIMOGA DISTRICT-577 401.

    4. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,

    SHIMOGA,

    SHIMOGA DISTRICT -577 201.

    - 2 -

    5. SMT. AMBRIN ANJUM,

    W/O MADASHIR ALIKHAN,

    AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,

    NO.2129, TURABALI ROAD,

    1STMAIN ROAD, MANDI MOHALLA,

    MYSORE-570 001.

    6. SMT.ALMAS ANJUM,

    W/O ATHIK BASHA BASHIR,

    AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,

    JABBAR SAB, TIPPUNAGAR EAST,

    4THCROSS, SHIMOGA DISTRICT-577 201. …RESPONDENTS

    (BY SMT.NILOUFER AKBAR., AGA)

    THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE

    KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE

    ORDER DATED 22/05/2023 PASSED IN WP NO.25582/2022 AND

    PERUSE THE SAME BY ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL.

    THIS WRIT APPEAL COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY

    HEARING, THIS DAY, CHIEF JUSTICE DELIVERED THE

    FOLLOWING:

    JUDGMENT

    Heard learned advocate Mr. Jagadeeshachari for the appellant.

    2. The appellant herein is the original petitioner who has preferred this writ appeal under Section 4 of the Karnataka High Court Act, 1961. The challenge in the appeal is addressed to the order dated 22.05.2023 passed by learned Single Judge dismissing the writ petition.

    2.1 What was prayed in the writ petition was to set aside the orders dated 01.07.2021 and 18.07.2022 passed by the

    - 3 -

    respondents concerned. It was next prayed to direct respondent No.2 - Tahsildar, Shikaripura Taluk, to make Khatha as per the registered Will dated 30.12.2019 in favour of the petitioner.

    3. The case of the petitioner in his writ petition was, inter alia, that the property bearing Survey No.2 admeasuring 5 acres 24 guntas situated at Udugani Village, Shikaripura Taluk, Shivamogga District, belonged to him and that he was the absolute owner of the property. The petitioner has two sisters - respondent Nos.5 and 6, it was stated. It was the case that respondent Nos.5 and 6 had obtained a gift deed from the mother and that the gift deed was executed by fraud and misrepresentation.

    3.1 It was the case of the petitioner that the mother of the petitioner had acquired the property in question by gift deed executed by her husband late Mohammad Aswak. It was the further case that the petitioner had been staying in Saudi Arabia and when returned to India, it came to his notice that respondent Nos.5 and 6 conspired and forced the mother to execute a Will in their favour. The Will was a registered Will, it was stated.

    3.2 The petitioner challenged the mutation entry made in favour of respondent Nos.5 and 6 by filing Regular Appeal which was

    - 4 -

    dismissed. Against the said order of dismissal, further appeals were filed by the petitioner which all came to be dismissed leading the petitioner to file the instant writ petition.

    4. Learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition by the impugned order. It was reasoned that the mother of the petitioner and respondent Nos.5 and 6 was the owner of the property who had executed a gift deed transferring the same in favour of respondent Nos.5 and 6. It was reasoned further that whether the gift deed was valid or not and whether respondent Nos.5 and 6 had got valid title over the property was the matter to be established before the civil court.

    4.1 The mutation entries were made by the revenue authorities entering the names of respondent Nos.5 and 6 on the basis of the gift deed. It was observed that if the petitioner was to succeed before the civil court in the proceedings he may institute, revenue entries would remain subject to the outcome of such civil proceedings. The challenge to the mutation entries by the petitioner met with concurrent dismissal before the revenue authorities upto appeal before the Assistant Commissioner and also resulting into dismissal of revision by the Deputy Commissioner.

    - 5 -

    5. The weighty aspect which dissuades the court from exercising the writ jurisdiction is that the dispute between the parties is essentially in relation to validity of the gift deed. This dispute involves civil rights. In the ultimate analysis, what is to be adjudicated is whether respondent Nos.5 and 6 have got valid title over the property or not and whether the Will referred to by the petitioner and alleged to have been executed fraudulently and by misrepresentation is valid or not.

    5.1 It is in light of these aspects that the assertion of the appellant that he is the absolute owner of the property will have to be examined. Decision on all issues would require leading of evidence and determination of civil rights amongst the parties. It involves adjudication into titular rights of the parties. It is trite principle that the dispute regarding property rights cannot be gone into in the writ jurisdiction. The parties have to take recourse to civil court.

    5.2 The contested property rights cannot be dealt with in writ jurisdiction. The writ court can at the best take notice of the property rights of the parties which are already established rights. When a party is claiming under the disputed Will, the writ court would not be able to adjudicate it, for, it is a matter of leading

    - 6 -

    evidence. In the same way when the gift deed is the derivative document, whereunder the parties claim their respective title rights and dispute one another's claims, the adjudication has to be done by the civil court. The remedy before the civil court would be proper remedy in such circumstances.

    5.3 This is reiterated by the Supreme Court in Sohan Lal vs. Union of India and Another (AIR 1957 SC 529) observing thus,

    "We do not propose to enquire into the merits of the rival claims of title to the property in dispute set up by the appellant and Jagan Nath. If we were to do so, we would be entering into a field of investigation which is more appropriate for a Civil Court in a properly constituted suit to do rather than for a Court exercising the prerogative of issuing writs. These are questions of fact and law which are in dispute requiring determination before the respective claims of the parties to this appeal can be decided. Before the property in dispute can be restored to Jagan Nath it will be necessary to declare that he had title in that property and was entitled to recover possession of it. This would in effect amount to passing a decree in his favour. In the circumstances to be mentioned hereafter, it is a matter for serious consideration whether in proceedings under Art. 226 of the Constitution such a declaration ought to be made and restoration of the property to Jagan Nath be ordered."

    (para 5)

    5.4 The above principle has been recognized statutorily in the proviso to Section 135 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964.

    - 7 -

    Section 135 begins with the title "Bar of suits". Proviso contemplates that if any person is aggrieved as to any right of which he is in possession, by an entry made in any of the record or register maintained, he may institute a suit against any person who denies or is interested to deny his title to such right, for declaration of his right. The entry in the record or in the register shall be amended in accordance with such declaration which may be given by the civil court, it is provided.

    6. The reasoning supplied and the view taken by the learned Single Judge to dismiss the petition and further observing that if the petitioner is to succeed before the civil court, the revenue authorities would be bound to change the mutation entries to make in the name of the person who is held to be the owner of the property, is imminently just, proper and legal.

    6.1 No error could be brooked in the impugned order of learned Single Judge.

    7. The challenge in writ appeal is meritless. The same is dismissed.

    - 8 -

    In view of dismissal of the appeal, the interlocutory applications would not survive and they stand accordingly disposed of.

    Sd/-

    CHIEF JUSTICE

    Sd/-

    JUDGE

    THM

    List No.: 1 Sl No.: 49

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SRI. ALTHAF AHAMED v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
    (Mar 11, 2024)