Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Certificates) Act, 2012, read with rule 5
  • section 5 of Odisha Scheduled Castes, Scheduled
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Certificates) Act, 2012, read with rule 5
  • section 5 of Odisha Scheduled Castes, Scheduled
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Subham Kumar Dora, applied for a social status certificate asserting his belonging to the 'Kondadora' Scheduled Tribe. The Tahasildar rejected the application by an undated order citing that the applicant's father's caste status was subjudice in W.P.(C) No.15 of 2008. The petitioner challenged this rejection through multiple writ petitions and appeals. Earlier writ petitions were disposed of by co-ordinate Benches of this Court, which found some issues academic or remanded the matter for appeal before the Collector. The appeal filed by the petitioner was pending before the Collector. Subsequently, the writ petition referred to as subjudice was disposed of by an order dated 1st December 2022, which removed the ground for rejection of the petitioner’s application. This petition seeks direction upon the Tahasildar to issue the social status certificate urgently, as the petitioner requires it for the upcoming National Eligibility Entrance Test (NEET) examination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to issuance of a social status certificate as a member of the 'Kondadora' Scheduled Tribe despite previous rejection on the ground of subjudice caste status of the petitioner’s father.
  2. Whether the appeal filed by the petitioner against the Tahasildar’s rejection order should be proceeded with or dismissed as infructuous following the disposal of the writ petition that was earlier subjudice.
  3. Whether the Tahasildar is obliged to dispose of the petitioner’s application for caste certificate within a stipulated time frame.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The petitioner urgently requires the social status certificate to participate in the forthcoming NEET examination.
  • The application was wrongly rejected on the basis that the petitioner’s father's caste status was subjudice in W.P.(C) No.15 of 2008, which has since been disposed of.
  • The petitioner relies on the order dated 1st December 2022 disposing of W.P.(C) No.15 of 2008, which removed the ground of subjudice status.
  • Requests a direction to the Tahasildar to issue the certificate within a time-bound period.

Opposite Parties’ Arguments

  • The State contends that the petitioner’s application was properly rejected because the caste status issue was subjudice in W.P.(C) No.15 of 2008.
  • The petitioner had filed an appeal against the rejection order before the Collector, which was pending and hence no order should be passed on the writ petition.
  • The appeal was instituted as Misc. Certificate Appeal Case No.01/2021 and is subjudice.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P.(C) No.15 of 2008 (Order dated 1st December 2022) Disposal of writ petition concerning caste status; removal of subjudice ground for rejection of caste certificate application. The Court held the question academic and disposed of the writ petition, thus removing the basis for rejecting the petitioner’s application.
W.P.(C) No.11046 of 2021 (Order dated 5th April 2021) Direction to Tahasildar to dispose of caste certificate application in accordance with law. The Court directed the Tahasildar to take effective steps to dispose of the application, establishing procedural compliance.
W.P.(C) No.26447 of 2021 (Order dated 9th September 2021) Recognition of appealability of Tahasildar’s rejection order under the Odisha Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes Act, 2012 and related Rules. The Court disposed of the writ petition allowing filing of appeal before the Collector and acknowledged pending appeal proceedings.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court carefully examined the procedural history, including multiple writ petitions filed by the petitioner challenging the rejection of his caste certificate application. The initial rejection was based on the pendency of a writ petition concerning the petitioner’s father's caste status. The Court noted that the writ petition cited as subjudice was ultimately disposed of on 1st December 2022, rendering the ground of subjudice obsolete. The Court observed that the petitioner had also filed an appeal before the Collector, which was pending, but given the disposal of the earlier writ petition, the appeal was dismissed as infructuous. Consequently, the Court directed the Tahasildar to promptly consider the petitioner’s application and either issue the certificate or provide reasons for rejection within two weeks. This approach aligns with the principles of procedural fairness and timely disposal under the applicable caste certificate rules and statutes.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The Court dismissed the pending appeal as infructuous and directed the Tahasildar to immediately process the petitioner’s application for issuance of the social status certificate within two weeks. The petitioner was also permitted to produce the Court’s order before the examining authority to seek extension of time to submit the certificate. This decision directly benefits the petitioner by removing procedural obstacles and ensuring timely issuance of the caste certificate. No new legal precedent was established; the Court primarily enforced compliance with existing procedural requirements and disposed of the matter on its merits.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    SUBHAM KUMAR DORA v. STATE OF ODISHA

    Page 1 of 5

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK

    W.P.(C) No.8962 of 2023

    (Through Hybrid mode)

    Subham Kumar Dora …. Petitioner

    -versus-

    State of Odisha and others …. Opposite Parties Advocates appeared in this case:

    For Petitioner : Mr. Digambara Mishra, Advocate

    For Opposite Parties : Mr. A. K. Nanda, AGA

    CORAM: JUSTICE ARINDAM SINHA

    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Date of Hearing and judgment : 21.04.2023

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    1. Mr. Mishra, learned advocate appears on behalf of petitioner and submits, his client has urgent requirement for issuance of social status certificate to him. He belongs to 'Kondadora' Scheduled Tribe. Prayer in the petition is for direction upon the Tahasildar, to grant the certificate. On query from Court he submits, the application was rejected by undated order saying that applicant's father's caste status is subjudice in the Hon'ble High Court of Orissa. He draws attention to annexure-8 being order dated 1stDecember, 2012 passed by a co- ordinate Bench in WP(C) no.15 of 2008 and submits, this is the writ

    1

    petition, referred to as subjudice in impugned order. Text of said order is reproduced below.

    "1. Heard learned counsel for the Parties.

    2. The Writ Petition involves, the Petitioner getting difficulty for an order taking out his Caste Certificate in duly constituted proceeding under the provisions of the Orissa Caste Certificate for S.C. & S.T. Rules, 1980 in the continuing as Chairman of the Panchayat Samiti. Undisputedly, the term of the Chairman of the Panchayat Samiti is already over.

    3. In the circumstance, this Court finds, the question remains academic and need not be attended at this moment. However, the question involved herein, if raised in future, will be decided in accordance with law."

    (emphasis supplied)

    He submits, the writ petition stood disposed of by above order. In the circumstances, there be direction for issuance of the social status certificate within a time bound period. The National Eligibility Entrance Test (NEET) Examination is to be held soon and the caste certificate is required to be submitted by end of this month.

    2. Mr. Nanda, learned advocate, Additional Government Advocate appears on behalf of State. He draws attention to paragraph 4 in the counter, in particular a passage therein, extracted and reproduced below.

    2

    "Since the order dtd.5.4.2021 has not been carried out, the petitioner filed another writ petition vide W.P.(C) No.26447/2021 the same was disposed of by the Hon'ble Court vide order dtd.09.09.2021 giving liberty to the petitioner to file appeal before the Collector, Balangir as the Tahasildar had already passed order. On the basis of the application of the petitioner, one Misc. Certificate Appeal Case No.01/2021 has been instituted before the Collector and District Magistrate, Balangir which is subjudice."

    (emphasis supplied)

    He submits, no order can be made on this writ petition since petitioner had filed appeal and it is pending.

    3. On perusal of the orders in several writ petitions filed by petitioner, a sequence of events emerges. Petitioner had applied for issuance of social status certificate by application dated 10thJune, 2020. Complaining that the Tahsildar had not acted upon the application, he filed WP(C) no.11046 of 2021, which was disposed of by a co-ordinate Bench on order dated 5thApril, 2021, directing the Tahsildar to take all effective steps to dispose of the case, relating to supply of caste certificate, in accordance with law.

    4. The Tahsildar by aforesaid undated order, rejected the application saying that applicant's father's caste status is subjudice in this Court. It has been ascertained from the parties that the 'subjudice'

    3

    in the rejection order referred to WP(C) no.15 of 2008. On this rejection, petitioner again approached this Court by WP(C) no.26447 of 2021. The second writ petition was disposed of by same co- ordinate Bench on order dated 9thSeptember, 2021, accepting submission made on behalf of State that the undated rejection order of the Tahsildar was appealable under section 5 of Odisha Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes (Regulation of issuance and Verification of Caste Certificates) Act, 2012, read with rule 5 of the 2019 rules. The notification of the Act, erroneously and thereafter on issuance of corrigendum, was noticed by this Bench in a still pending writ petition. Be that as it may, there is no doubt that Odisha Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes (Regulation of Issuance and Verification of Caste Certificates) Rules, 2019 has not been notified or have been notified as draft rules.

    5. Petitioner preferred appeal. Pursuant thereto, aforesaid referred to subjudice WP(C) no.15 of 2008 came to be disposed of by another co-ordinate Bench on said order dated 1stDecember, 2022, reproduced above. It appears, that is why petitioner has now come up with this writ petition, for direction upon the Tahsildar to deal with his client's application for issuance of social status certificate.

    6. By reason of order dated 1stDecember, 2022, disposing of WP(C) no.15 of 2008, ground for rejection of petitioner's application

    4

    stands removed. In molding the relief it is directed that the appeal need not be proceeded with and is dismissed as infructuous. Opposite party no.3 is directed to forthwith deal with petitioner's said application and either issue the certificate or inform him reasons for rejection of the application, within two weeks from date. Learned Additional Government Advocate will forthwith communicate. Petitioner will serve website copy of this order on said opposite party. Petitioner is also at liberty to produce the order before the examining authority, for extension of time to produce the certificate.

    7. The writ petition is disposed of.

    (Arindam Sinha) Judge

    Prasant

    5

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SUBHAM KUMAR DORA v. STATE OF ODISHA
    (Apr 21, 2023)